Taxing cross-border intercompany transactions: are financing activities fungible?

Kayis-Kumar, Ann (2015): Taxing cross-border intercompany transactions: are financing activities fungible? Published in: AUSTRALIAN TAX FORUM , Vol. 3, No. 30 (2015): pp. 627-661.

Abstract

The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (‘OECD’) is currently considering best practice approaches to designing rules to prevent base erosion and profit shifting (‘BEPS’) by multinational enterprises (‘MNEs’). However, the OECD makes a distinction between combating BEPS and reducing distortions between the tax treatment of various methods of financing. Yet, an unequal tax treatment can create distortions, which incentivises tax planning behaviour. Accordingly, this paper aims to improve the tax design of anti-avoidance rules governing MNEs’ cross-border intercompany deductions by introducing the concept of the tax-induced cross-border funding bias. To date, the literature has focussed on the debt bias, which arises from the distortion in the tax treatment between debt and equity financing. On the other hand, the funding bias also includes licensing and leasing activities in addition to debt and equity financing. This presents a novel contribution to the literature. This paper examines the conceptual case for why is might be appropriate and feasible to restrict the tax deductibility of cross-border intercompany interest, dividends, royalties and lease payments given their mobility and fungibility. Specifically, it examines whether it is preferable for MNEs to be subject to economic rent taxation, as is attained through reform proposals such as the Allowance for Corporate Equity (‘ACE’), in this context. This presents a novel proposal for taxing cross-border intercompany economic rents which aligns with the main aim of corporate tax harmonisation; namely: to reduce, if not remove, distortions relating to the taxation of cross-border intercompany activities.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: OECD, BEPS, Transfer pricing, Multinational, Economic rent taxation
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C6 - Mathematical Methods ; Programming Models ; Mathematical and Simulation Modeling; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C6 - Mathematical Methods ; Programming Models ; Mathematical and Simulation Modeling > C61 - Optimization Techniques ; Programming Models ; Dynamic Analysis; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H20 - General; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H25 - Business Taxes and Subsidies; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H26 - Tax Evasion and Avoidance; K - Law and Economics > K0 - General; K - Law and Economics > K0 - General > K00 - General

References

Caves RE, Multinational Enterprise and Economic Analysis (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2nd ed, 1996).

Altshuler R and Ackerman J, ‘International Aspects of Recommendations from the President’s Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform’ (International Tax Policy Forum Presentation, 2 December 2005).

Auerbach AJ, Devereux MP and Simpson HD, ‘Taxing Corporate Income’ (NBER Working Paper No. 14494, November 2008).

Auerbach AJ, Devereux MP and Simpson HD, ‘Taxing Corporate Income’, Chapter 9, in: Mirrlees J et al (eds.) Dimensions of Tax Design: The Mirrlees Review (Oxford University Press, 2010).

Australian Government, Australian Accounting Standards Board, AASB 124: Related Party Disclosures (December 2009); available at: http://www.aasb.gov.au/admin/file/content105/c9/AASB124_12-09.pdf.

Australian Government, Department of the Treasury, ‘Australia’s Future Tax System: Report to the Treasurer’, December 2009 (‘Henry Review’), Chapter B.

Australian Government, Department of the Treasury, Tax Integrity: Multinational Anti-avoidance Law (12 May 2015), available at: http://www.treasury.gov.au/ConsultationsandReviews/Consultations/2015/Tax-Integrity-Law.

Australian Government, Senate Committee on Corporate Tax Avoidance: available at: http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Economics/Corporate_Tax_Avoidance/Submissions.

Avi-Yonah RS and Clausing KA, ‘A Proposal to Adopt Formulary Apportionment for Corporate Income Taxation’, (Law & Economics Working Paper Art 70, University of Michigan Law School, 2007).

Avi-Yonah RS, ‘Globalization and tax competition: implications for developing countries’ [August 2001] 74 CEPAL Review 59, 60-61; and references cited therein.

Avi-Yonah RS, ‘Globalization, Tax Competition and the Fiscal Crisis of the Welfare State’ (2000) 113(7) Harvard Law Review 1575.

Avi-Yonah RS, Clausing KA and Durst MC, ‘Allocating Business Profits for Tax Purposes: A Proposal to Adopt a Formulary Profit Split’ (2009) 9(5) Florida Tax Review 497, 503.

Bärsch SE, Taxation of Hybrid Financial Instruments and the Remuneration Derived Therefrom in an International and Cross-border Context: Issues and Options for Reform (Germany: Springer, 2013).

Benshalom I, ‘Rethinking the Source of the Arm’s Length Transfer Pricing Problem’ (2013) 32(3) Virginia Tax Review 425.

Benshalom I, ‘Sourcing the “Unsourceable”: The Cost Sharing Regulations and the Sourcing of Affiliated Intangible-Related Transactions’ (2007) 26 Virginia Tax Review 631

Benshalom I, ‘Taxing the Financial Income of Multinational Enterprises by Employing a Hybrid Formulary and Arm’s Length Allocation Method’ (2009) 28 Virginia Tax Review 619.

Benshalom I, ‘The Quest to Tax Financial Income in a Global Economy: Emerging to an Allocation Phase’ (2008) 28 Virginia Tax Review 165.

Bird RM and Brean DJS, ‘The interjurisdictional allocation of income and the unitary taxation debate’ (1986) 34(6) Canadian Tax Journal 1377, 1388.

Bird RM, ‘Why Tax Corporations?’ (Working Paper No 96-2, Technical Committee on Business Taxation, December 1996).

Blessing PH, ‘The Debt-Equity Conundrum – A Prequel’ (2012) 66(4-5) Bulletin for International Taxation 198.

Boadway RW and Bruce NDB, ‘A general proposition on the design of a neutral business tax’ (1984) 24(2) Journal of Public Economics 231.

Bond S, ‘Corporate Tax’ (Paper presented at the Royal Economic Society Special Session on the Mirrlees Review, Coventry: University of Warwick, 17 March 2008).

Bond SR and Devereux MP, ‘On the design of a neutral business tax under uncertainty’ (1995) 85(1) Journal of Public Economics 57.

Burnett C, ‘Intra-Group Debt at the Crossroads: Stand-Alone versus Worldwide Approach’ (2014) 6(1) World Tax Journal 40.

Butler B and Wilkins G, ‘Singapore, Ireland top havens for multinational tax dodgers’, Sydney Morning Herald (online), 1 May 2014; available at: http://www.smh.com.au/business/singapore-ireland-top-havens-for-multinational-tax-dodgers-20140430-37hzi.html.

Chaudhry SM, Mullineux AW and Agarwal N, ‘Balancing Bank Regulation and Taxation’ (4 February 2014), available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1141090.

Chen D, Lee FC and Mintz JM, ‘Taxation, SMEs and Entrepreneurship’ (OECD Science, Technology and Industry Working Papers 2002/09, OECD Publishing, August 2002).

Cooper GS, ‘Implementing an allowance for corporate equity’ (2012) 27 Australian Tax Forum 241.

De Mooij R and Devereux MP, ‘Alternative Systems of Business Tax in Europe: An applied analysis of ACE and CBIT reforms’ (European Union Taxation Papers, Working Paper No 17, 2009).

De Mooij RA and Devereux MP, ‘An applied analysis of ACE and CBIT reforms in the EU’ (2011) 18(1) International Tax and Public Finance 93.

de Mooij RA and Ederveen S, ‘Corporate tax elasticities: a reader's guide to empirical findings’ (2008) 24(4) Oxford Review of Economic Policy 680-697; Altshuler R and Grubert H, ‘Governments and multinational corporations in the race to the bottom’ (2006) 41(5) Tax Notes International 459.

De Mooij RA, ‘Tax Biases to Debt Finance: Assessing the Problem, Finding Solutions’ (IMF Staff Discussion Note SDN/11/11, 3 May 2011).

Devereux M and Freeman H, ‘A general neutral profits tax’ (1991) 12(3) Fiscal Studies 1.

Devereux MP and Hubbard RG, ‘Taxing Multinationals’ (2003) 10 International Tax and Public Finance 469.

Devereux MP, ‘Some Optimal Tax Rules for International Portfolio and Direct Investment’ (2004) 60(1) Finanzarchiv 1.

Devereux MP, ‘Trade-offs in the Design of Taxes on Corporate Profit’ (Paper presented at the Oxford Sydney Conference, Ross Parsons Centre: The University of Sydney, 30-31 March 2012).

Devereux MP, Mokkas S, Pennock J and Wharrad P, ‘Interest Deductibility for UK Corporation Tax’, (Working Paper, Oxford University Centre for Business Taxation, December 2006).

Eden L, Taxing Multinationals: Transfer Pricing and Corporate Income Taxation in North America (Toronto, Canada: University of Toronto Press, 1998), 32.

European Commission, ‘Tax reforms in EU member states 2013: Tax policy challenges for economic growth and fiscal sustainability: 2013 Report’, European Economy 5 (Brussels: European Commission, DG ECFIN and DG TAXUD, October 2013).

Fatica S, Hemmelgarn T and Nicodème G, ‘The Debt-Equity Tax Bias: consequences and solution’ (Taxation Papers Working Paper No 33, European Commission, July 2012).

Federici D and Parisi V, ‘Do corporate taxes reduce investments? Evidence from Italian firm-level panel data’ [February 2015] 3 Cogent Economics & Finance 1012435.

Financial Accounting Standards Board of the Financial Accounting Foundation, Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 57: Related Party Disclosures (March 1982); available at: http://www.fasb.org/jsp/FASB/Document_C/DocumentPage?cid=1218220127001&acceptedDisclaimer=true.

Gammie M, ‘Corporate tax harmonization: an “ACE” proposal: harmonizing European corporate taxation through an allowance for corporate equity’ (1991) 31(8) European Taxation Journal 238.

Gérard M and Princen S, ‘Investment and Financing Strategy of a Multinational Enterprise under Alternative Tax Designs’ (CESifo Working Paper No 3838, June 2012).

Graetz MJ, ‘A Multilateral Solution for the Income Tax Treatment of Interest Expenses’ [November 2008] Bulletin for International Taxation 486.

Grubert H and Altshuler R, ‘Corporate Taxes in the World Economy: Reforming the Taxation of Cross-Border Income’, in: Diamond J and Zodrow G (eds.) Fundamental Tax Reform: Issues, Choices, and Implications (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2008).

Grubert H and Altshuler R, ‘Fixing the System: An Analysis of Alternative Proposals for the Reform of International Tax’ (2013) 66(3) National Tax Journal 671.

Hanlon D, ‘Thin Capitalisation Legislation and the Australia/United States Double Tax Convention: Can They Work Together?’ (2000) 3(1) Journal of Australian Taxation 4.

Henry K, Harmer J, Piggott J, Ridout H and Smith G, Australia’s Future Tax System: Report to the Treasurer, Commonwealth of Australia, December 2009, Part 2, Chapter B1–4, available at: http://taxreview.treasury.gov.au/content/FinalReport.aspx?doc=html/publications/Papers/Final_Report_Part_2/chapter_b1-4.htm.

Herman D, Taxing Portfolio Income in Global Financial Markets (Amsterdam, The Netherlands: IBFD, 2002).

Hirshleifer J, ‘On the Economics of Transfer Pricing’ (1956) Journal of Business 172.

Huang H, International Securities Markets: Insider Trading Law in China (The Netherlands: Kluwer Law International, 2006).

ICC Commission on Taxation and the ICC Committee on Customs and Trade Regulations, ‘Transfer pricing and customs value’ Policy Statement, Document No. 180/103-6-521, February 2012.

ICC Commission on Taxation, ‘Limitations of deductions of interest payments’ (International Chamber of Commerce Policy Statement No 180-520, February 2012).

IMF Committee On Balance Of Payments Statistics and OECD Workshop On International Investment Statistics, Direct Investment Technical Expert Group, ‘FDI – Other Capital (with focus on short-term)’ (Issue Paper No. 22, November 2004).

IMF Fiscal Affairs Department, ‘Debt Bias and Other Distortions: Crisis-related Issues in Tax Policy’ (International Monetary Fund Study, 12 June 2009).

IMF, ‘A Fair and Substantial Contribution by the Financial Sector: Final Report for the G-20’ (June 2010), available at: http://www.imf.org/external/np/g20/pdf/062710b.pdf.

Inotai A, ‘Macroeconomic Impacts of the 2008–09 Crisis in Europe’, in: DeBardeleben J and Viju C, Economic Crisis in Europe: What it Means for the EU and Russia (Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire; New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013).

Institute for Fiscal Studies, Equity for Companies: A Corporation Tax for the 1990S, Fourth report of the IFS Capital Taxes Group, Commentary No 26 (Chameleon Press: 1991), available at: http://www.ifs.org.uk/comms/comm26.pdf.

Institute for Fiscal Studies, The Structure and Reform of Direct Taxation: Report of a Committee chaired by Professor JE Meade (London, George Allen & Unwin: 1978); available at: http://www.ifs.org.uk/docs/meade.pdf.

Kayis-Kumar A, ‘Thin capitalisation rules: A second-best solution to the cross-border debt bias?’ (2015) 30(2) Australian Tax Forum 363-394.

Keen M and King J, ‘The Croatian profit tax: an ACE in practice’ (2002) 23(3) Institute for Fiscal Studies 401.

Keen M and King J, ‘The Croatian profit tax: an ACE in practice’ (2002) 23(3) Institute for Fiscal Studies 401.

Keen M and Piekkola H, ‘Simple Rules for the Optimal Taxation of International Capital Income’ 99(3) The Scandinavian Journal of Economics (1997) 447.

Keen M, Krelove R and Norregaard J, ‘The Financial Activities Tax’, Chapter 7 in: Claessens S, Keen M, Pazarbasioglu C (eds.), Financial Sector Taxation: The IMF’s Report to the G-20 and Background Material (IMF, September 2010).

Kleinbard ED, ‘Rehabilitating the business income tax’ (The Hamilton Project Discussion Paper 2007-09, The Brookings Institution, June 2007).

Kleinbard ED, ‘Stateless Income’s Challenge to Tax Policy, Part 2’ (2012) [November] Tax Notes International 671, 750–52.

Klemm AD, ‘Allowances for Corporate Equity in Practice’ (CESifo Economic Studies, Volume 53, 2/2007, 12 June 2007) 229.

Kozlow R, ‘Multinational enterprises, foreign direct investment and related income flows’, Chapter 3, in: UNECE, The Impact Of Globalization On National Accounts, (New York and Geneva: UN, 2011).

Marres O and Weber D, Tax Treatment of Interest for Corporations (The Netherlands: IBFD, 2013).

Mintz J, ‘The Corporation Tax: A Survey’ (1995) 16(4) Fiscal Studies 23.

Mintz JM and Weichenrieder AJ, The Indirect Side of Direct Investment: Multinational Company Finance and Taxation (Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 2010).

Morse SC, ‘The Transfer Pricing Regs Need a Good Edit’ (2013) 40 Pepperdine Law Review 1415, 1427–1428.

Musgrave PB, ‘Combining fiscal sovereignty and coordination: National taxation in a globalising world’, in: Kaul I and Conceicao P (eds.), The New Public Finance: Responding to Global Challenges (Oxford University Press, 2006).

OECD Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital, available at: http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/taxation/model-tax-convention-on-income-and-on-capital-2010_9789264175181-en;jsessionid=4naiu3f38brmg.x-oecd-live-02.

OECD, ‘BEPS Action 4: Interest deductions and other financial payments’ (Public Discussion Draft, 18 December 2014).

OECD, ‘Review of Comparability and of Profit Methods: Revision Of Chapters I-III of the Transfer Pricing Guidelines’, 22 July 2010.

OECD, ‘The Arm's Length Principle’, in: OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations 2009 (OECD Publishing).

OECD, Action Plan on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (Paris: OECD Publishing, 2013).

OECD, BEPS Action 15: A Mandate for the Development of a Multilateral Insturment on Tax Treaty Measures to Tackle BEPS, 16 September 2014, available at: http://www.oecd.org/ctp/beps-action-15-mandate-for-development-of-multilateral-instrument.pdf.

OECD, Explanatory Statement: 2014 Deliverables, OECD/G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Project (OECD Publishing, 2014).

OECD, Public Discussion Draft, BEPS Action 8, 9 and 10: Discussion draft on revisions to Chapter I of the Transfer Pricing Guidelines (including risk, recharacterisation and special measures), 1 December 2014 – 6 February 2015.

Picciotto S, ‘The International Crisis of Income Taxation: Combating tax havens, capital flight and corruption’ (Paper presented at the Critical Legal Conference, Kent, UK, February 2007).

Picciotto S, ‘The U.K.’s Diverted Profits Tax: An Admission of Defeat or a Pre-Emptive Strike?’ [19 January 2015] Tax Notes International 239.

Princen S, ‘Taxes do Affect Corporate Financing Decisions: The Case of Belgian ACE’ (CESifo Working Paper Series No 3713, January 2012).

Principles and Policy (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2011).

Raboy DG and Wiggins SN, ‘Intangible capital, hedonic pricing, and international transfer prices’ (1997) 25(4) Public Finance Review 347.

Radulescu DM and Stimmelmayr M, ‘ACE vs. CBIT: Which is Better for Investment and Welfare?’ (CESifo Working Paper No. 1850, January 2006).

Rectenwald G, ‘A Proposed Framework For Resolving The Transfer Pricing Problem: Allocating The Tax Base Of Multi-national Entities Based On Real Economic Indicators Of Benefit And Burden’ (2102) 23 Duke Journal Of Comparative & International Law 425, 427-428.

Ring DM, ’Risk-Shifting Within a Multinational Corporation: The Incoherence of the U.S. Tax Regime’ (1997) 4(4) Boston College Law Review 667.

Rosenbloom HD, ‘Banes of an Income Tax: Legal Fictions, Elections, Hypothetical Determinations, Related Party Debt’ (2004) 26 Sydney Law Review 17.

Rumble T, Synthetic equity and franked debt: Capital markets savings cures (PhD Thesis, UNSW 1998).

Schepens G, ‘Taxes and bank capital structure’ (Working paper, Department of Financial Economics, University of Ghent, October 2013).

Schmalenbach E, ‘Über Verrechnungspreise’ (1908/09) 3 Zeitschrift für betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung 165.

Schön W, ‘Transfer Pricing – Business Incentives, International Taxation and Corporate Law’ (Max Planck Institute for Tax Law and Public Finance, Working Paper 2011 – 05, January 2011).

Schön W, ‘Transfer Pricing, the Arm’s Length Standard and European Union Law’, in: Richelle I, Schön W and Traversa E (eds.) Allocating Taxing Powers Within the European Union (2013).

See further: Brabazon ML, ‘The Attribution Of Profits and Capital Structure To A Permanent Establishment Under The OECD Model Tax Treaty’ (2003) 18 Australian Tax Forum 347.

Shapiro AC and Balbirer SD, Modern Corporate Finance: An Interdisciplinary Approach to Value Creation (Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1999), Topic F4 ‘The Multinational Financial System’; available at: http://www.prenhall.com/divisions/bp/app/finflash/html/onlinehtml/topicf/topicf4.html.

Sørensen PB and Johnson S, Chapter 9: Taxing Capital Income – Options for Reform in Australia, Melbourne Institute, Australia’s Future Tax and Transfer Policy Conference, June 2009.

Sørensen PB, ‘Issues in the Theory of International Tax Coordination’ (Bank of Finland Discussion Papers No 4/90, 20 February 1990).

Sørensen PB, ‘Swedish Tax Policy: Recent Trends and Future Challenges’, Report to the Expert Group on Public Economics, Swedish Ministry of Finance, May 2010.

Sørensen PB, ‘Taxation of Shareholder Income and the Cost of Capital in an Open Economy: Theory and Applications to the Nordic Countries’ (2005) Danish Journal of Economics 143.

Staderini A, ‘Tax reforms to influence corporate financial policy: the case of the Italian business tax reform of 1997-98’ (Banca D’Italia No 423, 2001).

Steeds P, ‘Transfer pricing considerations including guarantees’ (Conference paper presented at Second IBA/CIOT Conference, London: Holdon Bars, 12 February 2013.

Stewart M, Moore A, Whiteford P and Grafton RQ, ‘A Stocktake Of The Tax System And Directions For Reform: Five Years After The Henry Review’ (Tax and Transfer Policy Institute, February 2015).

Strudler and Orts, ‘Moral Principle in the Law of Insider Trading’ (1999) 78 Texas Law Review 375.

Taylor W, ‘Testimony before the President’s Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform, March 31, 2005’ Tax Notes (4 April 2005), Doc 2005-6654.

United States Government, Department of the Treasury, ‘Report of the Department of the Treasury on Integration of the Individual and Corporate Tax Systems: Taxing Business Income Once’, January 1992.

US Treasury Regulation § 1.482-1(b)(1) (2012).

Vann R and Burnett C, ‘Re: BEPS Action 4 Discussion Draft dated 18 December 2014’ (Comment received on Public Discussion Draft, BEPS Action 4: Interest deductions and other financial payments, 6 February 2015).

Vann RJ, ‘Taxing International Business Income: Hard-Boiled Wonderland and the End of the World’ (2010) 2(3) World Tax Journal 291.