French legal origins: A Tocquevilian view

Crettez, Bertrand and Deffains, Bruno and Musy, Olivier (2016): French legal origins: A Tocquevilian view.

Abstract

We provide an alternative explanation of French legal centralization. To do this we develop a rational choice model of the legal architecture around 1789 and the French Revolution. Following Tocqueville we propose to analyze the French movement towards legal centralization as the result of an increase in the aversion to inequality before the law. We show that legal centralization can be preferred to the "Ancien Régime" situation or intermediate legal decentralization if the aversion to legal differences is sufficiently strong. In addition, we show that when the legal system is centralized it is always optimal to allow some degree of judicial discretion. This result is consistent with the historical evidence that the Napoleonic codification, i.e., the culmination of French legal centralization, was associated with a higher degree of judicial discretion than at the beginning of the Revolution. This view contrasts with the interpretation of the Napoleonic codification as a means of transforming judges into automata.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Aversion to inequality before the law, Codification, Legal origins, Legal centralization, French Revolution
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K4 - Legal Procedure, the Legal System, and Illegal Behavior > K40 - General; N - Economic History > N4 - Government, War, Law, International Relations, and Regulation > N40 - General, International, or Comparative

References

Alfange Jr, Dean (1969). "Jeremy Bentham and the Codification of Law". Cornell L. Rev. 55.1-3, pp. 58-77.

Allison, John W. F. (2000). A Continental Distinction in the Common Law: A Historical and Comparative Perspective on English Public Law. Oxford University Press.

Amson, Daniel (2010). Histoire Constitutionnelle Française de la Prise de la Bastille à Waterloo. L.G.D.J. Lextenso Editions.

Armour, John, Simon Deakin, Priya Lele, and Mathias M. Siems (2009). "How do Legal Rules Evolve ? Evidence From a Cross-Country Comparison of Shareholder, Creditor and Worker Protection". American Journal of Comparative Law 57, pp. 579-629.

Arrunada, Benito and Veneta Andonova (2005). "Market Institutions and Judicial Rulemaking". In: Handbook of New Institutional Economics. Ed. by Claude Menard and Mary M. Shirley. Springer, pp. 229-250.

Balas, Aron, Rafael La Porta, Florencio Lopez-De-Silanes, and Andrei Shleifer (2008). "The Divergence of Legal Procedures". American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 1.2, pp. 138-162.

Barbiche, Bernard (2001). Les Institutions de la Monarchie Francaise a l' Epoque Moderne. Presses Universitaires de France.

Besley, Timothy and Torsten Persson (2011). Pillars of Prosperity: The Political Economics of Development Clusters. Princeton University Press.

Biard, Michel (2010). "Quelle Centralisation Jacobine ?" In: La Revolution Francaise. Une Histoire Toujours Vivante. Ed. by Michel Biard. Tallandier. Biard, Michel and Pascal Dupuy (2014). La Revolution Francaise. 2nd Edition. Armand Collin.

Carbasse, Jean-Marie (2014). Manuel d'Introduction Historique au Droit. 5th Edition. Presses Universitaires de France.

Chevallier, Jean-Jacques (2001). Histoire des Institutions et des Regimes Politiques de la France de 1789 a 1958. 9th Edition. Dalloz.

Clere, Jean-Jacques (2005). "L'Abolition des Droits Feodaux en France". Cahiers d'histoire. Revue d'histoire critique 94-95, pp. 135-157.

Crettez, Bertrand, Bruno Deffains, Guillaume Leyte, and Laurent Pfister (2011). "On the Law and Economics of the origin of the French Civil Code". In: Does Law Matter ? Ed. by Michael Faure and Jan M. Smits. Intersentia.

Crettez, Bertrand, Bruno Deffains, and Olivier Musy (2014). "Legal Harmonization with Endogenous Preferences". International Review of Law and Economics 39, pp. 20-27.

Darnton, Robert (1973). "The Encyclopedie Wars of Prerevolutionary France". The American Historical Review 78.5, pp. 1331-1352. Dawson, John P. (1960). A History of Lay Judges. Harvard University Press.

Dawson, John P. (1968). The Oracles of the Law. The University of Michigan Law School.

Glaeser, Edward L and Andrei Shleifer (2002). "Legal origins". Quarterly Journal of Economics 117.4, pp. 1193-1229.

Johnson, Noel D and Mark Koyama (2014). "Taxes, lawyers, and the decline of witch trials in France". Journal of Law and Economics 57.1, pp. 77-112.

Klerman, Daniel (2015). "Economics of Legal History". In: Oxford Handbook of Law and Economics. Ed. by Francesco Parisi. Oxford University Press.

Klerman, Daniel and Paul G. Mahoney (2007). "Legal Origin?" Journal of Comparative Economics 35, pp. 278-293.

La Porta, Rafael, Florencio Lopez-de-Silanes, and Andrei Shleifer (2008). "The Economic Consequences of Legal Origins". Journal of Economic Literature 46.2, pp. 285-332.

Lagarde, Xavier (2009). Juste Capitalisme. Litec.

Le Bris, David (2015). "Testing Legal Origins Theory within France: Customary Laws versus Roman Code". Working Paper.

Loeper, Antoine (2011). "Coordination in Heterogeneous Federal Systems". Journal of Public Economics 95.7, pp. 900-912.

Lovisi, Claire (2011). Introduction Historique au Droit. 4th. Dalloz.

Montaigne, Michel de (1595 (2009)). Essais. Pocket Classiques.

Ozouf, Mona (1984). "La revolution Francaise et la Perception de l'Espace National: Federations, Federalisme et Stereotypes regionaux". In: L'ecole de la France. Ed. by Mona Ozouf. Gallimard.

Pittz, Steven (2011). "Providential Partners? Tocqueville's Take on Equality and Centralization". The Journal of Politics 73.03, pp. 797-807.

Portalis, Jean-Etienne Marie (1820). "De l'Usage Et de l'Abus de l'Esprit Philosophique Durant le XVIIIe Siecle".

Siems, Mathias M. (2011). "Measuring the Immeasurable: How to Turn Law into Numbers". In: Does Law Matter? Ed. by Michael Faure and Jan Smits. Intersentia, pp. 115-136.

Tocqueville, Alexis (de) (1835). De la Democratie en Amérique. (1981). Flammarion.

Tocqueville, Alexis (de) (1856). L'Ancien Régime et la Revolution. (1988). Flammarion.

Ubrecht, Georges (1933 (1969)). "Montaigne, Juriste". In: Conférences a l'occasion du quatrième centenaire de la mort de Montaigne. Slatkine Reprints, Geneva.

Voltaire, Franccois-Marie (1765). Dictionnaire philosophique. Collection Ideales, edition 2005.

Voltaire, Francois-Marie (1819). Dialogues et entretiens philosophiques. In: Oeuvres completes de Voltaire. Antoine-Augustin Renouard.

Von Mehren, Arthur T. (1957). The Civil Law System. Prentice Hall.