Which are the "best" schools in Ireland? Analysing feeder school performance using student destination data

Borooah, Vani and Dineen, Donal and Lynch, Nicola (2009): Which are the "best" schools in Ireland? Analysing feeder school performance using student destination data. Published in: Irish Educational Studies , Vol. 29, No. 2 (2010): pp. 107-130.

Abstract

This paper represents an investigation of the broad factors which underpin the success of feeder schools in terms of the proportion of their “sits” who proceed to third-level education and, also, in terms of the “quality” of their educational destinations. It distinguishes between three school types: public (non-fee paying, English language) private (fee paying, English language), and Gaelscoil (non-fee paying, Irish language). Both private schools and the Gaelscoileanna reported much better results than public schools. From this, the paper disentangles the nature of this advantage by investigating the extent to which private school and Gaelscoil advantage over public schools was predicated on better circumstances and/or on better responses to circumstances. Our results show that private schools and the Gaelscoileanna had a response advantage over public schools: if private schools and the Gaelscoileanna were constrained to responding to their circumstances in the manner in which public schools responded to theirs, the performance of private schools and the Gaelscoileanna would suffer. By constraining the coefficient responses of all three types of schools to be that of public schools, we arrive at a revised list of the "best performing" twenty five feeder schools in Ireland. This is different from, but not dissimilar to, a ranking of the best performing twenty five schools based on their raw performance.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Schools Ireland Performance Student Destination
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I21 - Analysis of Education

References

Adab P., A.M., Rouse, M.A., Mohammed, and T. Marshall (2002) Performance league tables: the NHS deserves better, BMJ, 324: 95-98.

Brown R. (2006) League tables – do we have to live with them? Perspectives: policy and practice in higher education, 10 (2): 33-38.

Buchanan N.K., R. Fox (2008) Every school a school of choice: school choice in Ireland as viewed through American eyes, Irish Educational Studies, 27 (3): 267-279.

Caldas S.J., C. Bankston III (1997) Effect of school population socioeconomic status on individual academic achievement, The Journal of Educational research, 90 (5): 269-277.

Garner C.L., S.W. Raudenbush (1991) neighbourhood effects on educational attainment: a multilevel analysis, Sociology of Education, 64: 251-262.

Hallgarten J. (2001) School league tables: Have they outlived their usefulness? New Economy, 8 (4): 189-196.

Hannan D.F., E. Smyth, J. McCullagh, R. O’Leary, D. McMahon (1996) Coeducation and gender equality: exam performance, stress and personal development, Dublin: Oak Tree Press as quoted in, Lynch K., M. Moran (2006) Markets, schools and the convertibility of economic capital: the complex dynamics of class choice, British Journal of Sociology of Education, 27 (2): 221-235.

Independent (2006), All but teachers love league tables, Sunday November 05th 2006: http://www.independent.ie/national-news/all-but-teachers-love-league-tables-136655.html.

Irish Examiner (2008), League tables are for football – not for schools, Saturday December 27th, 2008: http://archives.tcm.ie/irishexaminer/2008/12/27/story80740.asp.

Lynch K., M. Moran (2006) Markets, schools and the convertibility of economic capital: the complex dynamics of class choice, British Journal of Sociology of Education, 27 (2): 221-235.

Marks G.N., J. Creswell, J. Ainley (2006) Explaining socioeconomic inequalities in student achievement: The role of home and school factors, Educational Research and Evaluation, 12 (2): 105-128.

O'Shea, M. (2006), Education as a means of effecting life change and achieving a state of self-autonomy, Irish Educational Studies, 25: 63-74.

Stakelum, M. (2008), Primary music education: the misrepresentation of the ideals of curricula in research, Irish Educational Studies, 27: 281-293.

Sykes B., H. Kuyper (2009) Neighbourhood effects on youth educational achievement in the Netherlands: can effects be identified and do they vary by student background characteristics, Environment and Planning A, 41: 2417-2436.

Thomas S. (1998) Value-added measures of school effectiveness in the United Kingdom, Prospects, 28(1), pp. 91–108.

Webber R., T. Butler (2007) Classifying pupils by where they live: how well does this predict variations in their GCSE results? Urban Studies, 44(7): 1229-1253.

West A., H. Pennell (2000) Publishing school examination results in England: incentives and consequences, Educational Studies, 26(4): 423-436.

Yang Y., J.E. Gustafsson (2004) Measuring Socioeconomic status at individual and collective levels, Educational research and evaluation, 10 (3): 259-288.