Does Financial Tranquility Call for More Stringent Regulation?

Basak, Deepal and Murray, Alexander and Zhao, Yunhui (2017): Does Financial Tranquility Call for More Stringent Regulation?

Abstract

Consistent with the Minsky hypothesis and the “volatility paradox” (Brunnermeier and Sannikov, 2014), recent empirical evidence suggests that financial crises tend to follow prolonged periods of financial stability and investor optimism. But does financial tranquility always call for more stringent regulation? We examine this question using a simple portfolio choice model that features the interaction between learning and externality. We evaluate the potential of a macroprudential policy in the form of a capital income tax to restore efficiency, and highlight a key challenge faced by regulators: whether the stringency of prudential policy should rise or fall over time depends on the resilience of the financial system, which is difficult to know and thus may lead to inefficient regulation. Our paper provides a simple framework to shed light on the current regulation debates, such as the ongoing debates on the financial deregulation initiatives in the U.S. (as evident in the August 2017 Jackson Hole meeting), and the discussions on how to regulate the rapidly-developing online finance industry in China.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Financial stability, Financial regulation, Learning, Externality, Macroprudential
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G0 - General > G01 - Financial Crises; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G18 - Government Policy and Regulation; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G28 - Government Policy and Regulation

References

[1] Acemoglu, D., Ozdaglar, A., Tahbaz-Salehi, A., 2013. Systemic Risk and Stability in Financial Networks. Technical report, National Bureau of Economic Research.

[2] Acharya, V.V., 2009. A theory of systemic risk and design of prudential bank regulation. Journal of Financial Stability, 5, 224–255.

[3] Acharya, V., Pedersen, L., Philippon, T., Richardson, M.P., 2009. Regulating Systemic Risk. In Restoring Financial Stability: How to Repair a Failed System, edited by Acharya, V.V., Richardson, M.P.. John Wiley & Sons: Hoboken, NJ.

[4] Acharya, V., Pedersen, L., Philippon, T., Richardson, M.P., 2010. Taxing Systemic Risk. In Regulating Wall Street: The Dodd-Frank Act and the New Architecture of Global Finance, edited by Acharya, V.V., Cooley, T., Richardson, M.P., Walter, I.. John Wiley & Sons: Hoboken, NJ.

[5] Acharya, V.V., Richardson, M., Van Nieuwerburgh, S., White, L., 2011. Guaranteed to Fail: Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the Debacle of Mortgage Finance. Princeton University Press.

[6] Acharya, V.V., Iyer, A.M., Sundaram, R.K., 2016. Risk-Sharing and the Creation of Systemic Risk. Working Paper.

[7] Adam, K., Beutel, J., Marcet, A., Merkel, S., 2015. Can a financial transaction tax prevent stock price booms? Journal of Monetary Economics, 76, S90–S109.

[8] Adrian, T., Brunnermeier, M., 2016. CoVaR. American Economic Review, 106(7): 1705–1741.

[9] Auerbach, A., 2013. Capital Income Taxation, Corporate Taxation, Wealth Transfer Taxes and Consumption Tax Reforms. Working Paper, University of California Berkeley.

[10] Axelson, U., Bond, P., Wall Street Occupations. 2015. Journal of Finance, 70 (5), 1949–1996.

[11] Bank for International Settlements, 2010. 80th Annual Report. BIS.

[12] Barberis, N., Greenwood, R., Jin, L., Shleifer, A., 2015. X-CAPM: An Extrapolative Capital Asset Pricing Model. Journal of Financial Economics, 115 (1), 1–24.

[13] Barberis, N., Greenwood, R., Jin, L., Shleifer, A. Extrapolation and Bubbles. Journal of Financial Economics, Forthcoming.

[14] Baron, M., Xiong, W., 2014. Credit Expansion and Neglected Crash Risk. Working Paper.

[15] Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, July 2010. Countercyclical Capital Buffer Proposal.

[16] Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, December 2010. Guidance for National Authorities Operating the Countercyclical Capital Buffer.

[17] Berk, J., Green, R., 2004. Mutual fund flows and performance in rational markets. Journal of Political Economy, 112, 1269–95.

[18] Bernanke, B.S., 2011. Implementing a macroprudential approach to supervision and regulation. In: Speech delivered at the 47th Annual Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Chicago, IL.

[19] Bhattacharya, S., Goodhart, C.A.E., Tsomocos, D., Vardoulakis, A., 2015. A Reconsideration of Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 47 (5), August, 931–973.

[20] Biais, B., Rochet, J.C., Woolley, J., 2015. Dynamics of Innovation and Risk. Review of Financial Studies, 28 (5), 1353–1380.

[21] Bianchi, J., 2011. Overborrowing and Systemic Externalities in the Business Cycle. American Economic Review, 101 (7), 3400–3426.

[22] Bianchi, J., Boz, E., Mendoza E., 2012. Macro-prudential Policy in a Fisherian Model of Financial Innovation. IMF Economic Review, 60 (2), 223–269.

[23] Bolton, P., Santos, T., Scheinkman, J.A., 2016. Cream-Skimming in Financial Markets. Journal of Finance, 71 (2), 709–736.

[24] Borio, C., 2011. Rediscovering the macroeconomic roots of financial stabilitypolicy: journey, challenges, and a way forward. Annual Review of Financial Economics, 3, 87–117.

[25] Borio, C., 2012. The Financial Cycle and Macroeconomics: What have we Learnt? BIS Working Paper No. 395, December. http://www.bis.org/publ/work395.pdf.

[26] Boz, E., Mendoza, E.G., 2014. Financial innovation, the discovery of risk, and the U.S. credit crisis. Journal of Monetary Economics, 62, 1–22.

[27] Brownlees, C.T., Engle, R.F., 2012. Volatility, correlation and tails for systemic risk measurement. SSRN Working Paper 1611229.

[28] Brunnermeier, M., Crocket, A., Persaud, A.D., Shin, H., 2009. The fundamental principles of financial regulation. Geneva Reports on the World Economy 11.

[29] Brunnermeier, M., Sannikov, Y., 2014. A Macroeconomic Model with a Financial Sector. American Economic Review, 104 (2), 379–421.

[30] Celerier, C., Vallee, B., 2015. Returns to Talent and the Finance Wage Premium. Working Paper.

[31] Danielsson, J., Valenzuela, 2016. Learning from History: Volatility and Financial Crises. Working Paper.

[32] Dell’Ariccia, G., Igan, D., Laeven, L., Tong, H., Bakker, B., Vandenbussche, J., 2012. Policies for Macrofinancial Stability: How to Deal with Credit Booms. IMF Staff Discussion Note.

[33] Drehmann, M., Borio, C., Gambacorta, L., Jiménez, G., Trucharte, C., 2010. Countercyclical capital buffers: exploring options. BIS Working Paper No. 137.

[34] Drehmann, M., Borio, C., Tsatsaronis, K., 2012. Characterising the Financial Cycle: Don’t Lose Sight of the Medium Term! BIS Working Paper No. 380, June. http://www.bis.org/publ/work380.pdf.

[35] Farhi, E., Werning, I., 2016. A Theory of Macroprudential Policies in the Presence of Nominal Rigidities. Econometrica, 84 (5), 1645–1704.

[36] Fernandez de Lis, S., Garcia-Herrero, A., 2012. Dynamic provisioning: a bufferrather than a countercyclical tool? Working Paper. BBVA Bank, EconomicResearch Department.

[37] Gauthier, C., Lehar, A., Souissi, M., 2012. Macroprudential capital requirementsand systemic risk. Journal of Financial Intermediation, 21, 594–618.

[38] Gertler, M., Kiyotaki, N., 2015. Banking, Liquidity, and Bank Runs in an Infinite Horizon Economy. American Economic Review, 105 (7), 2011–2043.

[39] Gordon, R., Kalambokidis, L., Slemrod, J., 2004. Do we now collect any revenue from taxing capital income? Journal of Public Economics, 88, 981–1009.

[40] Gordy, M.B., 2009. First, do no harm: a hippocratic approach to procyclicality in Basel II. In: Paper presented at the Conference Procyclicality in the Financial System, jointly organised by the Netherlands Bank and the Bretton Woods Committee, 9–10 February.

[41] Gordy, M.B., Howells, B., 2006. Procyclicality in Basel II: can we treat the disease without killing the patient? Journal of Financial Intermediation, 15, 395–417.

[42] Huang, X., Zhou, H., Zhu, H., 2012. Systemic risk contributions. Journal of Financial Services Research, 42(1–2), 55–83.

[43] International Monetary Fund, April 2017. Getting the Policy Mix Right. Global Financial Stability Report, Chapter 1.

[44] Jeanne, O., Korinek, A., 2010. Excessive Volatility in Capital Flows: A Pigouvian Taxation Approach. American Economic Review: Papers & Proceedings, 100 (2), 403–407.

[45] Jiménez, G., Ongena, S., Peydró, J.-L., Saurina, J., 2017. Macroprudential policy, countercyclical bank capital buffers and credit supply: evidence from the Spanish dynamic provisioning experiments. Journal of Political Economy (forthcoming).

[46] Kahou, M.E., Lehar, A.. Macroprudential Policy: A Review. Journal of Financial Stability, Forthcoming, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jfs.2016.12.005.

[47] Krznar, I., Morsink, J., 2014. With great power comes great responsibility: macroprudential tools at work in Canada. IMF Working Paper No. 14/83.

[48] Laeven, L., Valencia, F., 2010. Resolution of Banking Crises: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly. International Monetary Fund.

[49] Masciandaro, D., Passarelli, F., 2013. Financial systemic risk: Taxation or regulation? Journal of Banking and Finance, 37(2), 587–596.

[50] Minsky, H.P., 1992. The financial instability hypothesis. Working Paper 74, Jerome Levy Economics Institute.

[51] Morris, S., Shin, H.S., 2008. Financial regulation in a system context. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. 2008, 229–274.

[52] Nijathaworn, B., 2009. Rethinking procyclicality – what is it now and what can bedone? In: Speech delivered at the Bank for International Settlements/Financial Stability Institute-Executives’ Meeting of East Asia-Pacific Central Banks (BIS/FSI-EMEAP) High Level Meeting on “Lessons Learned from the FinancialCrisis – An International and Asian Perspective”, Tokyo, 30 November.

[53] Packer, F., Zhu, H., 2012. Loan loss provisioning practices of Asian banks. BIS Working Paper No. 375.

[54] Poledna, S., Thurner, S., 2016. Elimination of systemic risk in financial networks by means of a systemic risk transaction tax. Quantitative Finance, 16, 10, 1599–1613.

[55] Reinhart, C.M., Rogoff, K., 2009. This Time Is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.

[56] Saurina, J., Jimenez, G., 2006. Credit cycles, credit risk, and prudential regulation. International Journal of Central Banking, 2, 65–98.

[57] Segoviano, M., 2006. Consistent information multivariate density optimizing methodology. Financial Markets Group, London School of Economics and Political Science.

[58] Shirakawa, M., 2009. Opening speech delivered at 2010 International Conference hosted by the Institute for Monetary and Economic Studies, the Bank of Japan.

[59] Smaghi, L.B., 2009. Macro-prudential supervision. In: Speech delivered at the CEPR/ESI 13th Annual Conference on “Financial Supervision in an Uncertain World”. European Banking Center at Venice International University, Venice, 25–26 September 2009. Squam Lake Working Group.

[60] Zlatic, V., Gabbi, G., Abraham, H., 2014. Reduction of systemic risk by means of Pigouvian taxation. arXiv preprint arXiv:1406.5817.