Interprovincial Barriers to Internal Trade in Goods, Services and Flows of Capital: Policy, Knowledge Gaps and Research Issues

Macmillan, Kathleen and Grady, Patrick (2007): Interprovincial Barriers to Internal Trade in Goods, Services and Flows of Capital: Policy, Knowledge Gaps and Research Issues.

Abstract

This paper summarizes the state of knowledge on internal barriers to trade in goods, services and flows of capital, examines their cost to the economy, and presents some options for addressing the important barriers that remain. A companion paper examines barriers to labour mobility in Canada (Grady and Macmillan, 2007). The paper finds that there is no single overriding research methodology that is most appealing, and suggests employing a methodology most suitable for the use to which the estimates would be put. Researchers could measure the cost of barriers with a case study approach because of its usefulness in focussing attention on specific barriers deserving of attention; update the 1983 and 1995 work of John Whalley, and others; or use computable general equilibrium models to test empirically the gains from increased trade. The study suggests that whether significant progress in dismantling barriers is achieved might well depend on factors such as whether parties abandon or stay with the current Agreement to Internal Trade (AIT) negotiating model. Good progress could also be made with the creation of bilateral and plurilateral agreements such as the Alberta-B.C. Trade, Investment and Labour Mobility Agreement and the recent Interim Agreement on agriculture as it allows like-minded parties to side-step the AIT’s requirement for unanimous consensus. The study also concludes that economic events, such as labour shortages, may well drive the internal trade agenda in the next decade.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: trade, trade barriers, internal trade
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N7 - Transport, Trade, Energy, Technology, and Other Services > N72 - U.S. ; Canada: 1913-; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F15 - Economic Integration; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F14 - Empirical Studies of Trade

References

Australia, Productivity Commission (2003) Evaluation of the Mutual Recognition Schemes, Research Report, Canberra, p. xv.

Beaulieu, Eugene, Jim Gaisford and Jim Higginson (2003) Interprovincial Trade Barriers in Canada: How Far Have We Come? Where Should We Go? Van Horne Institute for International Transportation and Regulatory Affairs.

Bonsor, Norman C. (1994) “Big Wheels Stalling: How Bad are Barriers to Commercial Transportation Between the Provinces?” In Filip Palda (ed.) Provincial Trade Wars: Why the Blockade Must End. The Fraser Institute, Vancouver.

Brown, Douglas (2001) “Comparing Economic Union Reform: Canada, Australia and the European Union,” in Strengthening Canada: Challenges for Internal Trade and Mobility, Conference sponsored by the Internal Trade Secretariat. http://www.ait-aci.ca/index_en/initiatives.htm

Canada West Foundation (2006) Coming up Next: The Transformation of Western Canada ’s Economy.

Canadian Chamber of Commerce (2004) Obstacles to Free Trade in Canada: A Study on Internal Trade Barriers, November. http: //www. chamber. ca/cmslib/general/InternalTrade041108.pdf

Canadian Chamber of Commerce (2004) Examples of Existing Internal Trade Barriers in Canada. (January).

Charles River Associates (2003) “Securities Enforcement in Canada: The Effect of Multiple Regulators, ” Research Study Prepared for the Wise Persons’ Committee, October 21. http://www.wise-averties.ca/reports/WPC_10.pdf

COMPAS (2004) Inter -provincial Trade Barriers: Seriously Damaging to the Economy and Standard of Living and Almost as Harmful as Canada-U.S Trade Barriers, BDO Dunwoody/Chamber Weekly CEO/Business Leader Poll, published in Financial Post, September 13 .

Conference Board of Canada (2005) An Impact Assessment of the British Columbia/Alberta Trade, Investment and Labour Mobility Agreement. September.

Conference Board of Canada (2006) Death by a Thousand Paper Cuts: The Effect of Barriers to Competition on Canadian Productivity, May.

Copeland, Brian R. (1998) Interprovincial Barriers to Trade: A Review of the Evidence, Paper prepared for BC Ministry of Employment and Investment, January.

Copenhagen Economics (2005) Economic Assessment of the Barriers to the Internal Market for Services, January.

Council of the Federation (2006) Progress Report Letter Following CIT Meeting, October 3, www. councilofthefederation. c a.

Engel, Charles and John H. Rogers (1996) “How Wide is the Border?” American Economic Review, 86: pp. 1112-25.

Flaherty, Jim (2006) Speech by the Minister of Finance to the Halifax Chamber of Commerce, June 19, . http://www.fin.gc.ca/news06/06-025_2e.html

Foreign Affairs and International Trade Canada (2007) State Procurement Preferences. http ://www. dfait-maeci. gc. ca/can-am/sell2usgov/statelawsreg-en. asp.

Goodman Richard M. and John M. Frost (2000) International Economic Agreements and the Constitution, Institute for International Economics (February). http : //www. iie. com/publications/wp/00-2.pdf

Grady, Patrick and Kathleen Macmillan (1998) “Why is Interprovincial Trade Down and International Trade Up?” Canadian Business Economics (Summer) pp 1-10.

Grady, Patrick and Kathleen Macmillan (2007) “Inter-provincial Barriers to Labour Mobility in Canada: Policy, Knowledge Gaps and Research Issues”, paper prepared for Industry Canada and Human Resources and Social Development Canada, February 6.

Helliwell, John F (1996) “Do National Borders Matter for Quebec’s Trade?” Canadian Journal of Economics, 29: pp. 507-22.

Helliwell, John F., Frank C. Lee and Hans Messinger (1999) Effects of the Canada-United States Free Trade Agreement on Interprovincial Trade, Paper Number 5 in Industry Canada Research Publications Program: Perspectives on North American Free Trade, April.

Internal Trade Secretariat (2002) Report on Public Consultations Project, Spring , p. 9. http://www.ait-aci.ca/index_en/initiatives.htm

Internal Trade Secretariat (2007b), Progress to Date, http://www.ait-aci.ca/index_en/progress.htm.

International Monetary Fund (2005) Canada: Selected Issues, Country Report No. 05/116, March.

Manitoba, Department of Finance (2006) The 2006 Manitoba Budget. http://www. gov.mb.ca/finance/budget06/modern/modern08.html

MARCAN (2006) Summary of Procurement Reported, June 5. http://www.marcan.net/index_en/procure.htm

McCallum, John (1995) “National Borders Matter: Canada-U.S. Regional Trade Patterns” American Economic Review, 85 615-23.

Ontario Ministry of Economic Development and Trade (2005) Canadian Internal Trade Initiative: Harmonizing Provincial Technical Regulations, A Targeted Approach. (May 11).

Rutley, Todd (1991) “‘Canada 1993’: A Plan for the Creation of a Single Economic Market in Canada,” Canadian Manufacturers’ Association Report on Interprovincial Trade.

Sinclair, Scott (2001) “Canada’s Internal Market: A Report Card” in Strengthening Canada: Challenges for Internal Trade and Mobility, Conference sponsored by the Internal Trade Secretariat. http://www.ait-aci.ca/index_en/initiatives.htm

Whalley, John (1983) “Induced Distortions of Interprovincial Activity: An Overview of Issues” and “The Impact of Federal Policies on Interprovincial Activity,” in M.J. Trebilcock et al. (eds.), Federalism and the Canadian Economic Union. Ontario Economic Council.

Whalley, John (1995) Interprovincial Barriers to Trade and Endogenous Growth Considerations, Paper for Industry Canada Conference on Endogenous Growth and Policy Design, March.