Understanding Why Fiscal Stimulus Can Fail through the Lens of the Survey of Professional Forecasters

Kim, Hyeongwoo and Zhang, Shuwei (2018): Understanding Why Fiscal Stimulus Can Fail through the Lens of the Survey of Professional Forecasters.

Abstract

This paper shows that fiscal policy in the U.S. has become ineffective due to lack of coordination between monetary and fiscal policy. We present a New Keynesian model that generates strong output effects of government spending shocks only when monetary policy coordinates well with fiscal policy. Employing the post-war U.S. data, we report strong stimulus effects of fiscal policy during the pre-Volcker era, which rapidly dissipate when we shift the sample period to the post-Volcker era. Finding a negligible role of the real interest rate in the propagation of government spending shocks, we propose an alternative explanation using a consumer sentiment channel. Employing the Survey of Professional Forecasters data, we show that forecasters tend to systematically over-estimate real GDP growth in response to positive innovations in government spending when policies coordinate well with each other. On the other hand, they are likely to formulate pessimistic forecasts when the monetary authority maintains a hawkish stance that conflicts with the fiscal stimulus. The fiscal stimulus, under such circumstances, may generate consumer pessimism, which decreases private spending and ultimately weakens the output effects of fiscal policy. We also provide statistical evidence that confirms an important role of the sentiment channel under different regimes of policy coordination.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Fiscal Policy; Time-varying Effectiveness; Policy Coordination; Consumer Sentiment; Survey of Professional Forecasters
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E32 - Business Fluctuations ; Cycles; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E61 - Policy Objectives ; Policy Designs and Consistency ; Policy Coordination; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E62 - Fiscal Policy

References

S. Rao Aiyagari, Lawrence J. Christiano, and Martin Eichenbaum. The output, employment, and interest rate e¤ects of government consumption. Journal of Monetary Economics, 30(1):73-86, October 1992.

Steve Ambler and Alain Paquet. Fiscal spending shocks, endogenous government spending, and real business cycles. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 20(1-3):237-256, 1996.

Donald W K Andrews. Tests for parameter instability and structural change with unknown change point. Econometrica, 61(4):821-856, July 1993.

Donald W K Andrews and Werner Ploberger. Optimal tests when a nuisance parameter is present only under the alternative. Econometrica, 62(6):1383-1414, November 1994.

Alan J. Auerbach and Yuriy Gorodnichenko. Fiscal multipliers in recession and expansion. In Fiscal Policy after the Financial Crisis, NBER Chapters, pages 63-98. National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc, April 2012.

Rüdiger Bachmann and Eric R. Sims. Confidence and the transmission of government spending shocks. Journal of Monetary Economics, 59(3):235-249, 2012.

Paul Beaudry and Franck Portier. Stock prices, news, and economic fluctuations. American Economic Review, 96(4):1293-1307, September 2006.

Paul Beaudry and Franck Portier. When can changes in expectations cause business cycle fluctuations in neo-classical settings? Journal of Economic Theory, 135(1):458-477, July 2007.

Florin O. Bilbiie, André Meier, and Gernot J. Müller. What accounts for the changes in u.s. fiscal policy transmission? Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 40(7):1439-1470, October 2008.

Olivier Blanchard and Roberto Perotti. An empirical characterization of the dynamic effects of changes in government spending and taxes on output. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 117(4):1329-1368, 2002.

Olivier Jean Blanchard. Consumption and the recession of 1990-1991. American Economic Review, 83(2):270-274, May 1993.

Craig Burnside, Martin Eichenbaum, and Jonas D. M. Fisher. Fiscal shocks and their consequences. Journal of Economic Theory, 115(1):89-117, March 2004.

Guillermo A. Calvo. Staggered prices in a utility-maximizing framework. Journal of Monetary Economics, 12(3):383-398, September 1983.

Eduardo A. Cavallo. Trade, gravity and sudden stops: On how commercial trade can increase the stability of capital flows. Research Department Publications 4491, Inter-American Development Bank, Research Department, December 2006.

Lawrence Christiano, Martin Eichenbaum, and Sergio Rebelo. When is the government spending multiplier large? Journal of Political Economy, 119(1):78-121, 2011.

Lawrence J Christiano and Martin Eichenbaum. Current real-business-cycle theories and aggregate labor market fluctuations. American Economic Review, 82(3):430-450, June 1992.

Lawrence J Christiano, Martin Eichenbaum, and Charles L Evans. Monetary policy shocks: What have we learned and to what end? Handbook of Macroeconomics, 1:65-148, 1999.

Lawrence J. Christiano, Martin Eichenbaum, and Charles L. Evans. Nominal rigidities and the dynamic effects of a shock to monetary policy. Journal of Political Economy, 113(1):1-45, February 2005.

Richard Clarida, Jordi Galí, and Mark Gertler. Monetary policy rules and macroeconomic stability: Evidence and some theory. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 115(1):147-180, 2000.

John H. Cochrane. Shocks. Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, 41(1):295-364, December 1994.

Giancarlo Corsetti, André Meier, and Gernot J. Müller. What determines government spending multipliers? Economic Policy, 27(72):521-565, October 2012.

Michael B Devereux, Allen C Head, and Beverly J Lapham. Monopolistic competition, increasing returns, and the e¤ects of government spending. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 28(2): 233-254, May 1996.

Avinash K Dixit and Joseph E Stiglitz. Monopolistic competition and optimum product diversity. American Economic Review, 67(3):297-308, June 1977.

Wendy Edelberg, Martin Eichenbaum, and Jonas D.M. Fisher. Understanding the effects of a shock to government purchases. Review of Economic Dynamics, 2(1):166-206, January 1999.

Christopher J. Erceg, Dale W. Henderson, and Andrew T. Levin. Optimal monetary policy with staggered wage and price contracts. Journal of Monetary Economics, 46(2):281-313, October 2000.

Antonio Fatás and Ilian Mihov. The effects of fiscal policy on consumption and employment: Theory and evidence. CEPR Discussion Papers 2760, Center for Economics and Policy Research, 2001.

Steven M Fazzari, James Morley, and Irina Panovska. State-dependent e¤ects of fiscal policy. Studies in Nonlinear Dynamics & Econometrics, 19(3):285-315, 2015.

Mary G Finn. Cyclical effects of government's employment and goods purchases. International Economic Review, pages 635-657, 1998.

Mario Forni and Luca Gambetti. Government spending shocks in open economy vars. Journal of International Economics, 99(C):68-84, 2016.

Jordi Galí, J. David López-Salido, and Javier Vallés. Understanding the e¤ects of government spending on consumption. Journal of the European Economic Association, 5(1):227-270, March 2007.

Robert E. Hall. The role of consumption in economic fluctuations. In The American Business Cycle: Continuity and Change, NBER Chapters, pages 237-266. National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc, April 1986.

Robert E Hall. Macro theory and the recession of 1990-1991. American Economic Review, 83(2): 275-279, May 1993.

Robert E. Hall. By how much does gdp rise if the government buys more output? Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 40(2):183-249, 2009.

Bruce E Hansen. Approximate asymptotic p values for structural change tests. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 15(1):60-67, January 1997.

Bruce E. Hansen. The new econometrics of structural change: Dating breaks in u.s. labour productivity. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15(4):117-128, Fall 2001.

Gary D Hansen. Indivisible labor and the business cycle. Journal of Monetary Economics, 16(3):309-327, 1985.

Ethan Ilzetzki, Enrique G. Mendoza, and Carlos A. Végh. How big (small?) are fiscal multipliers? Journal of Monetary Economics, 60(2):239-254, 2013.

Hyeongwoo Kim and Bijie Jia. Government spending shocks and private activity: The role of sentiments. Auburn Economics Working Paper Series auwp2017-08, Department of Economics, Auburn University, December 2017.

Eric M. Leeper, Nora Traum, and Todd B. Walker. Clearing up the fiscal multiplier morass. American Economic Review, 107(8):2409-2454, August 2017.

Ludger Linnemann and Andreas Schabert. Can fiscal spending stimulate private consumption? Economics Letters, 82(2):173-179, February 2004.

Stefan Mittnik and Willi Semmler. Regime dependence of the fiscal multiplier. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 83(3):502-522, 2012.

Andrew Mountford and Harald Uhlig. What are the effects of fiscal policy shocks? Journal of Applied Econometrics, 24(6):960-992, 2009.

Michael T. Owyang, Valerie A. Ramey, and Sarah Zubairy. Are government spending multipliers greater during periods of slack? evidence from twentieth-century historical data. American Economic Review, 103(3):129-134, May 2013.

Roberto Perotti. Estimating the effects of fiscal policy in oecd countries. Proceedings, 2005.

Roberto Perotti. Expectations and fiscal policy: An empirical investigation. Technical report, 2011. Manuscript.

Valerie A. Ramey. Identification government spending shocks: It's all in the timing. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 126(1):1-50, 2011.

Valerie A. Ramey. Government spending and private activity. NBER Working Papers 17787, National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc, January 2012.

Valerie A. Ramey and Matthew D. Shapiro. Costly capital reallocation and the e¤ects of government spending. Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, 48(1):145-194, June 1998.

Valerie A Ramey and Sarah Zubairy. Government spending multipliers in good times and in bad: Evidence from us historical data. Journal of Political Economy, 126(2):850-901, 2018.

Julio J Rotemberg and Michael Woodford. Oligopolistic pricing and the effects of aggregate demand on economic activity. Journal of Political Economy, 100(6):1153-1207, December 1992.

Christopher A Sims. Solving linear rational expectations models. Computational Economics, 20(1-2):1-20, October 2002.

Frank Smets and Rafael Wouters. Shocks and frictions in us business cycles: A bayesian dsge approach. American Economic Review, 97(3):586-606, 2007.

Tack Yun. Nominal price rigidity, money supply endogeneity, and business cycles. Journal of Monetary Economics, 37(2-3):345-370, April 1996.