Measuring the Immeasurable: A Survey of Sustainability Indices

Böhringer, Christoph and Jochem, Patrick (2007): Measuring the Immeasurable: A Survey of Sustainability Indices. Published in: Ecological economics , Vol. 63, No. 1 (2007): pp. 1-8.

Abstract

Sustainability indices for countries provide a one-dimensional metric to valuate country-specific information on the three dimensions of sustainable development: economic, environmental, and social conditions. At the policy level, they suggest an unambiguous yardstick against which a country’s development can be measured and even a cross-country comparison can be performed. This paper reviews the explanatory power of various sustainability indices applied in policy practice. We show that these indices fail to fulfill fundamental scientific requirements making them rather useless if not misleading with respect to policy advice.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Sustainability Indices, Composite Indicators, Sustainability, Indices
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C4 - Econometric and Statistical Methods: Special Topics > C43 - Index Numbers and Aggregation; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O10 - General

References

Alberti, M. and J.D. Parker, 1991. Indices of Environmental Quality: the Search for Credible Measures. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 11 (2): 95-101.

Asheim, G.B., W. Buchholz, and C. Withagen, 2003. The Hartwick Rule: Myths and Facts. Environmental and Resource Economics, 25 (2): 129-150.

Atkinson, G., W.R. Dubourg, K. Hamilton, M. Munasinghe, D.W. Pearce, and C.E.F. Young, 1997. Measuring Sustainable Development: Macroeconomics and Environment. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.

Booysen, F., 2002. An Overview and Evaluation of Composite Indices of Development. Social Indicators Research, 59: 115-151.

Cash, D.W., W. Clark, F. Alcock, N.M. Dickson, N. Eckley, and J. Jaeger, forthcoming. Salience, Credibility, Legitimacy and Boundaries: Linking Research, Assessment and Decision Making. Policy Sciences.

Chambers, N. and K. Lewis, 2001. Ecological Footprint Analysis: Towards a Sustainability Indicator for Business. ACCA Research Paper, 65, Glasgow.

Cobb, C.W., 1989. The Index for Sustainable Economic Welfare. In: H. Daly and J.B. Cobb (Editors), For the Common Good – Redirecting the Economy toward Community, the Environment, and a Sustainable Future. Beacon Press, Boston, pp. 401-457.

Cobb, C., T. Halstead, and J. Rowe, 1995. The Genuine Progress Indicator: Summary of Data and Methodology, Redefining Progress, Washington DC.

Cobb, C.W. and J.B. Cobb, 1994. The Green National Product: a Proposed Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare. University Press of America, Maryland.

Dalal-Clayton, B. and S. Bass (Editors), 2002. Sustainable Development Strategies: A Resource Book. Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development, Paris.

Diefenbacher, H., 1995. Der “Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare” – eine Fallstudie für die BRD 1950-1992. Texte und Materialien der FEST, B 24, Heidelberg.

Dunteman, G.H., 1989. Principal Component Analysis. Sage University Paper Series on Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences, No. 07-069, Newbury Park, CA.

Ebert, U. and H. Welsch, 2004. Meaningful Environmental Indices: a Social Choice Approach. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 47: 270-283.

ESI (Environmental Sustainability Index), 2002. 2002 Environmental Sustainability Index. Yale Center for Environmental Law & Policy, New Haven.

ESI (Environmental Sustainability Index), 2001. 2001 Environmental Sustainability Index. Yale Center for Environmental Law & Policy, New Haven.

Esty, D. C., M.A. Levy, T. Srebotnjak, A. de Sherbinin, Ch. H. Kim, and B. Anderson, 2006. Pilot 2006 Environmental Performance Index. Yale Center for Environmental Law & Policy, New Haven.

Esty, D.C., M.A. Levy, T. Srebotnjak, and A. de Sherbinin, 2005. 2005 Environmental Sustainability Index: Benchmarking National Environmental Stewardship. Yale Center for Environmental Law & Policy, New Haven.

Freudenberg, M., 2003. Composite Indicators of Country Performance: A Critical Assessment. STI Working Paper 2003/16, Paris.

Guenno, G. and S. Tizzi, 1998. The Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare (ISEW) for Italy. Nota Di Lavoro, No. 5.98.

Gassner, J. and M. Narodoslawsky, 2004. Sustainable Economy and their application to Austria. International Journal of Environment and Sustainable Development, 3 (2): 120-144.

Hamilton, C., 1999. The Genuine Progress Indicator Methodologiacl developments and results from Australia. Ecological Economics, 30: 13-28.

Hamilton, K., G. Atkinson, and D.W. Pearce, 1997. Genuine Savings as an Indicator of Sustainability. CSERGE Working Paper GEC97-03, Norwich.

Hammond, A., A. Adriaanse, E. Rodenburg, D. Brryant, and R. Woodward, 1995. Environmental Indicators: A Systematic Approach to Measuring and Reporting on Environmental Policy Performance in the Context of Sustainable Development. World Resource Institute, Washington DC.

Hanley, N., 2000. Macroeconomic Measures of ‘Sustainability’. Journal of Economic Surveys, 14 (1): 1-30. Hartwick, J.M., 1977. Intergenerational Equity and the Investing of Rents from Exhaustible Resources. American Economic Review, 67 (5): 972-974.

Hochreiter, H., B. Obermayr, K. Steiner, and E. Stockhammer, 1995. Der Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare (ISEW) – eine empirische Studie zur Wohlstandsentwicklung in Österreich von 1955 bis 1992. Interdisziplinäres Institut für Umwelt und Wirtschaft, Wien.

Hodge, R.A. and P. Hardi, 1997. The Need for Guidelines: The Rationale Underlying the Bellagio Principles for Assessment. In: P. Hardi and T. Zdan (Editors), Assessing Sustainable Development: Principles in Practice. International Institute for Sustainable Development, Winnipeg, pp. 7-20.

IMSA (Instituut voor Milieu- en Sastemanalyse), 1995: A Pilot ISEW for the Netherlands. IMSA, Amsterdam.

Jackson, T. and N. Marks, 1994. Measuring Sustainable Economic Welfare – A Pilot Index: 1950 –1990. Stockholm Environment Institute, Stockholm.

Jesinghaus, J., 1999. Indicators for Decision Making, European Commission. European Commission, Ispra, http://esl.jrc.it/envind/idm/idm_e_.htm. Jespersen, J., 1994. Et Velfærdsindeks for Danmark, 1965 – 1990, Roskilde.

Kuik, O.J. and A.J. Gilbert, 1999. Indicators of Sustainable Development. In: J.C.J.M. Van den Bergh,(Editor), Handbook of Environmental and Resource Economics, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp.722-730.

Moldan, B., T. Hák, J. Kovanda, M. Havránek, and P. Kušková, 2004. Composite indicators of environmental sustainability. Invited paper to ‘Statistics, Knowledge and Policy: OECD World Forum on Key Indicators’, Palermo Italy, 10-13 November 2004.

Nardo, M., M. Saisana, A. Saltelli, and S. Tarantola, 2005. Tools for Composite Indicators Building. European Comission, Ispra.

Narodoslawsky, M. and Ch. Krotscheck, 2004. What can we learn from ecological valuation of processes with the sustainable process index (SPI) – the case study of energy production systems. Journal of Cleaner Production, 12: 111-115.

Nordhaus, W. and J. Tobin, 1971. Is Growth Obsolete?. Cowles Foundation, Yale University, Cowles Discussion Papers: 319, New Haven.

OECD (Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development), 1994. Environmental Indicators. OECD, Paris.

Osberg, L., 1985. The Measurement of Economic Welfare. In: D. Laidler (Editor), Approaches to Economic Well-Being, 26. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, pp. 49-87.

Ott, W., 1978. Environmental Indices: Theory and Practice. Ann Arbor Science, Ann Arbor.

Parris, T.M. and R.W. Kates, 2003. Characterizing and Measuring Sustainable Development. Annual Review of Environmental Resources, 28 (13): 1-28.

Pearce, D.W. and G. Atkinson, 1993. Capital Theory and the Measurement of Sustainable Development: An Indicator of Weak Sustainability. Ecological Economics, 8. 103-108.

Pezzey, J., 1992. Sustainable Development Concepts – An Economic Analysis. World Bank, Washington DC.

Prescott-Allen, R., 2001. The Wellbeing of Nations. Island Press, Washington DC.

Radke, V., 1999. Nachhaltige Entwicklung. Springer, Heidelberg.

Ramachandran, N., 2000. Monitoring Sustainability: Indices and Techniques of Analysis. Concept Publishing Company, New Delhi.

Schmidt-Bleek, F., 1994. Wieviel Umwelt braucht der Mensch? MIPS, dass Maß für ökologisches Wirtschaften. Birkhäuser Verlag, Berlin.

SOPAC (South Pacific Applied Geoscience Commission), 2005. Building Resilience in SIDS. The Environmental Vulnerability Index (EVI) 2005. SOPAC Technical Report, Suva, Fiji Islands.

SRU (Rat von Sachverständigen für Umweltfragen), 1994. Umweltgutachten 1994 – für eine dauerhaft umweltgerechte Entwicklung. Metzler-Poeschel, Stuttgart.

Stehling, F., 1988. Environmental Quality Indices: Problems, Concepts, Examples. In: W. Eichhorn,(Editor). Measurement in Economics. Physica-Verlag, Heidelberg, pp. 349-369.

UN (United Nations), European Commission, IMF (International Monetary Fund), OECD(Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development), and World Bank (Editors), 2003. Handbook of National Accounting – Integrated Environmental and Economic Accounting. Studies in Methods, Series F, No.61, Rev.1. UN, New York.

UNCHS (United Nations Centre for Human Settlements), 2001. The State of the Worlds Cities 2001.UN, Nairobi.

UNCED (The United Nations Conference on Environment and Development, Earth Summit), 1992.Rio Declaration on Environment and Development, Rio de Janeiro, 3.–14.6.1992.

UNDP (United Nations Development Programme), 2005. Human Development Report 2005. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

UNEP (United Nations Environmental Programme), 2000. Integrated Environmental and Economic Accounting – An Operational Manual. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Wackernagel, M. and W. Rees, 1997. Unser ökologischer Fußabdruck, Birkhäuser Verlag, Basel.

Welsch, H., 2005. Constructing Meaningful Sustainability Indices. In: C. Böhringer and A. Lange(Editors), Applied Research in Environmental Economics. Physica Verlag, Heidelberg, pp. 7-22.

World Bank, 2005. The Little Green Databook 2005. World Bank Publication, Washington DC.

WWF (World Wildlife Fund), 2004. Living Planet Report 2004. WWF, Gland.

WWF (World Wildlife Fund), 1998. Living Planet Report 1998. WWF, Gland.

Zolotas, X., 1981. Economic Growth and Declining Social Welfare. New York University Press, New York.