From financial crisis to revolution: Russia 1899-1905

Lychakov, Nikita (2019): From financial crisis to revolution: Russia 1899-1905.

Abstract

What are the channels by which financial crises lead to social unrest? This paper examines the period between the major Russian financial crisis of 1899-1902 and the Russian Revolution of 1905. Using newly-constructed aggregate-level data and narrative evidence, this paper finds that in response to the crisis, the Russian government and industry transferred income and wealth from ordinary workers to industrialists and investors. The recipients of transfers weathered the crisis well and profited during the recovery, while employees’ wages and wealth fell behind. The evidence also suggests that businesses required their staff to work more intensively. Ultimately, the distributional effect of the response to the crisis seems to have contributed to the occurrence of labour strikes which culminated in the revolution.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: financial crises, social unrest, businesses, labour, Russia
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N0 - General > N00 - General

References

Algan, Y., Guriev, S., Papaioannou, E., & Passar, E. (2017). The European trust crisis and the rise of populism. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 2017, 48(2), 309-400.

Annaert, J., Buelens, F., & Cuyvers, L. (2019). Returns on foreign investment during the pre-1914 era: the case of Russia. European Review of Economic History, 23(1), 72-96.

Bernanke, B. (1983). Nonmonetary effects of the financial crisis in the propagation of the great depression. American Economic Review, 73(3), 257-276.

Bovykin, V. (1984). Formirovanie finansovogo kapitala v Rossii konec XIX v. - 1908 g. [The formation of financial capital in Russia. The end of the XIX century to 1908]. Moscow: Nauka.

Brender, A. & Drazen, A. (2008). How do budget deficits and economic growth affect reelection prospects? Evidence from a large panel of countries. American Economic Review, 98(5): 2203-2220.

De Bromhead, A., Eichengreen, B, & O'Rourke, K. (2013). Political extremism in the 1920s and 1930s: Do German lessons generalize? The Journal of Economic History, 73(2), 371-406.

DiPasquale, D. & Glaeser, E. (1998). The Los Angeles riot and the economics of urban unrest. Journal of Urban Economics 43(1), 52-78.

Fisher, I. (1933). The debt-deflation theory of Great Depressions. Econometrica, 1, 337-357.

Franklin, J., Rostom, M., & Thwaites, G. (2015). The banks that said no: banking relationships, credit supply and productivity in the United Kingdom (Bank of England working paper No. 557).

Friedman, M., & Schwartz, A. (1963). A Monetary History of the United States, 1867‐1960. Princeton: Princeton.

Funke, M., Schularick, M., & Trebesch, C. (2016). Going to extremes: Politics after financial crises, 1870-2014. European Economic Review, 88(1), 227-260.

Gapon, G. (1905). Peticija rabochih i zhitelej Sankt-Peterburga [The petition of workers and residents of St. Petersburg].

Gefter, M. (1953). Carizm i monopolisticheskij kapital v metallurgii Juga Rossii do pervoj mirovoj vojny [Tsarism and monopoly capital in the metallurgy of the South of Russia before the First World War]. Istoricheskie zapiski [Historical notes], 43, 70-130. Moscow: The USSR Academy of Sciences.

Gefter, M. (1955). Jekonomicheskie predposylki pervoj russkoj revoljucii [The economic preconditions for the First Russian Revolution]. Doklady i soobshhenija [Reports and messages], 6, 3-26.

Goetzmann, W., Cabolis, C., & Radchenko, P. (n. d.a). St. Petersburg Stock Exchange Index. SPSE and NYSE comparison [Data set]. Retrieved from http://som.yale.edu/sites/default/files/files/SPSENYSE18651917ind.xls

Goetzmann, W., Cabolis, C., & Radchenko, P. (n. d.b). St. Petersburg Stock Exchange Index. Individual securities data [Data set]. Retrieved from http://som.yale.edu/sites/default/files/files/St_%20Petersburg%20data%20Revised%20082010%281%29.xlsx

Gindin, I. (1948). Russkie kommercheskie banki. Iz istorii finansovogo kapitala v Rossii [Russian commercial banks. Based on the history of financial capital in Russia]. Moscow.

Gindin, I. (1950). Neustavnye ssudy Gosudarstvennogo banka i ekonomiceskaja politika carskogo pravitelstva [Extraordinary loans of the Bank and the economic policy of the Tsarist government]. Istoricheskie zapiski [Historical Notes], 35, 87-126. Moscow: The USSR Academy of Sciences.

Gindin, I. (1964). Balansy akcionernyh predprijatij kak istoricheskij istochkik [Balance sheets of joint-stock companies as a historical source]. In Alexey Novoselsky (Ed.), Maloissledovannye istochniki po istorii SSSR XIX-XX vv.: Istochnikovedcheskij analiz [Scarcely-researched sources on the history of the USSR in the XIX-XX centuries]. Moscow: Nauka.

Gindin, I. (1980). Antikrizisnoe finansirovanie predprijatij tjazheloj promyshlennosti (konec XIX - nachalo XX v.) [Anti-crisis financing of companies in the heavy industry (the end of XIX – beginning of XX century]. Istoricheskie zapiski [Historical Notes], 105, 105-149. Moscow: The USSR Academy of Sciences.

Gindin, I. (1996). Jekonomicheskij krizis 1900-1903 goda i antikrizisnaja politika pravitelstva [The economic crisis of 1900-1903 and the state anti-crisis policy]. Iz istorii jekonomicheskoj mysli i narodnogo hozjajstva Rossii [From the history of economic thought and the economy of Russia], 2, 1-153. Moscow: The Russian Academy of Sciences.

Gindin, I. (2007a). Gosudarstvo i jekonomika v gody upravlenija S. Ju. Witte [The state and economy in the years of S. U. Witte’s governance]. Voprosy Istorii [Questions of History], 7, 64-93.

Gindin, I. (2007b). Gosudarstvo i jekonomika v gody upravlenija S. Ju. Witte [The state and economy in the years of S. U. Witte’s governance]. Voprosy Istorii [Questions of History], 9, 62-96.

Gregory, P. (1982). Russian national income, 1885-1913. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Gregory, P. (1994). Before command: An economic history of Russia from emancipation to the first five-year plan. Princeton: Princeton.

Halac, M. & Schmukler, S. (2004). Distributional effects of crises: The financial channel. Economia, 5(1), 1-67.

Hilt, E. (2017). Banks, Insider Connections, and Industry in New England: Evidence from the Panic of 1873. Working paper.

Izmesteva T. (1998). Dinamika rossijskoj promyshlennosti za 1887-1913 [The dynamics of the Russian industry 1887-1913]. Retrieved from http://www.hist.msu.ru/Labs/Ecohist/DBASES/INDUSTRY/index.htm.

Izmesteva T. (2011). Dinamika razvitija dobyvajushhej promyshlennosti Rossii v 1887-1914 gg. [The dynamics of development of the mining industry of Russia during 1887-1914]. Retrieved from http://www.hist.msu.ru/Dynamics/08_min.htm

Jayadev, A. (2013). Distribution and crisis: reviewing some of the linkages. In Wolfson, M. & Epstein, G. (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of the political economy of financial crises. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Kafengauz, L. (1994). Jevoljucija promyshlennogo proizvodstva Rossii (poslednjaja tret XIX v. – 30-e gody XX v.) [The evolution of industrial production in Russia (the last third of the 19th century to the 1930s). Moscow: Epiphany.

Kirjanov, U. (1979). Zhiznennyj uroven rabochih Rossii (konec XIX - nachalo XX v.) [The living standard of workers in Russia (late XIX - early XX century)]. Moscow: Nauka.

Korelin, A., Pushkareva, I., Koroleva, N., Tyutyukin, S., Khristoforov, I. (2005). Pervaja revoljucija v Rossii. Vzgljad cherez stoletie [The first revolution in Russia. A look through the century]. Moscow: Pamjantniki Istoricheskoj Mysli.

Lenin, V. (1963). Polnoe sobranie sochinenij. Tom 6. Janvar – Avgust 1902 [Collected works. Volume 6. January – August 1902]. Moscow: Gospolitizdat.

Lenin, V. (1967). Polnoe sobranie sochinenij. Tom 5. Maj – Dekabr 1901 [Collected works. Volume 5. May – December 1901]. Moscow: Gospolitizdat.

Lenin, V. (1969). Polnoe sobranie sochinenij. Tom 26. Ijul 1914 – Avgust 1915 [Collected works. Volume 26. July 1914 – August 1915]. Moscow: Gospolitizdat.

Lenin, V. (1972). Polnoe sobranie sochinenij. Tom 15. Fevral – Ijun 1907 [Collected works. Volume 15. February – June 1907]. Moscow: Gospolitizdat.

Lindert, P. & Nafziger, S. (2014). Russian Inequality on the Eve of Revolution. Journal of Economic History, 74(3), 767-798.

Lindgren, K. & Vernby, K. (2016). The electoral impact of the financial crisis: Evidence using district-level data. Electoral Studies, 44(6), 214-224.

Lyashchenko, P. (1956). Istorija narodnogo hozjajstva SSSR. Tom 2 [The history of the national economy of the USSR. Volume 2]. Moscow: Politicheskaja literatura.

Malik, H. (2018). Bankers and Bolsheviks: international finance and the Russian Revolution. Princeton: Princeton.

Mikhailovsky, V. (1921). Urozhai v Rossii 1801-1914 gg. [Harvests in Russia in 1801-1914]. Bjulleten Centralnogo Statisticheskogo Upravlenija [Bulletin of the Central Statistical Bureau], 50, 4.

Moyer, F., Jones, G., & Wrenn, V. (1952). Injury experience in coal mining, 1948: Detailed analysis of factors influencing mine safety and related employment, production, and productivity data (Bulletin 509). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.

Nevsky, V. (1922). Janvarskie dni v Peterburge 1905 goda [January days of 1905 in St. Petersburg]. Krasnaja Letopis [The Red Chronicle], 1, 13-74.

Ol, P. (1925). Inostrannye kapitaly v narodnom hozjajstve dovoennoj Rossii [Foreign capital in the economy of pre-war Russia]. Leningrad: Press of the All-Union Academy of Sciences.

Owen, T. (2013). Measuring business cycles in the Russian Empire. The Economic History Review, 66(3), 895-916.

Ozerov, I. (1905). Jekonomicheskaja Rossija i ejo finansovaja politika na ishode XIX i v nachale XX veka [Economic Russia and her financial policy at the turn of the XIX and early XX century]. Moscow: Kushnereva & Co.

Piketty, T. (2014). Capital in the twenty-first century. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi Imperii [The complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire] (1885), collection 3, vol. 5, law 2961. Retrieved from http://www.nlr.ru/e-res/law_r/search.php

Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi Imperii [The complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire] (1902a), collection 3, vol. 19. Retrieved from http://www.nlr.ru/e-res/law_r/search.php

Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi Imperii [The complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire] (1902b), collection 3, vol. 20. Retrieved from http://www.nlr.ru/e-res/law_r/search.php

Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi Imperii [The complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire] (1903), collection 3, vol. 21. Retrieved from http://www.nlr.ru/e-res/law_r/search.php

Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi Imperii [The complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire] (1904), collection 3, vol. 22. Retrieved from http://www.nlr.ru/e-res/law_r/search.php

Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi Imperii [The complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire] (1905), collection 3, vol. 23. Retrieved from http://www.nlr.ru/e-res/law_r/search.php

Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi Imperii [The complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire] (1907), collection 3, vol. 24. Retrieved from http://www.nlr.ru/e-res/law_r/search.php

Ponticelli, J. & Voth, H. (2011). Austerity and anarchy: Budget cuts and social unrest in Europe, 1919-2008. Working paper.

Pushkareva, I., Zheltova, B., Dodonov, B., Kalmykov, S., Michailov, N., Popolov, S., & Rusakova, M. (2005). Rabochee dvizhenie v Rossii. 1895 - Fevral 1917. Hronika. Vypusk 9. God 1903 [The labor movement in Russia. 1895 - February 1917. Chronicle. Issue 9. Year 1903]. Moscow: The Russian Academy of Sciences.

Pushkareva, I., Zheltova, B., Dodonov, B., Kalmykov, S., Michailov, N., Popolov, S., & Rusakova, M. (2008). Rabochee dvizhenie v Rossii. 1895 - Fevral 1917. Hronika. Vypusk 10. God 1904 [The labor movement in Russia. 1895 - February 1917. Chronicle. Issue 10. Year 1904]. Moscow: The Russian Academy of Sciences.

Pushkareva, I., Borodkin, L., Glazunov, S., Novikov, A., Potolov, S., & Shilnikova, I. (2011). Trudovye konflikty i rabochee dvizhenie v Rossii na rubezhe XIX–XX vv. [Labor conflicts and the labor movement in Russia at the turn of the XIX-XX centuries]. St. Petersburg: Aletheia.

Rubakin, N. (1912). Rossija v cifrah. Strana. Narod. Soslovija. Klassy. [Russia in figures. A country. People. Сlasses]. St. Petersburg: Bitner.

Shilnikova, I. (2012). Jekonomicheskie aspekty trudovyh konfliktov v promyshlennosti [Economic aspects of labor conflicts in industry]. Industrialnaja istorija [Industrial history], 2(17), 13-25.

Shilnikova, I. (2013a). Statisticheskie svedenija o neschastnyh sluchajah s rabochimi na gornozavodskih i promyslovyh rabotah v Rossii po rajonam i po rodam promyshlennosti, 1893-1903 gg. [Statistical data on worker accidents at mining and manufacturing operations in Russia by region and by industry. Years 1893-1903]. [Data set]. Retrieved from http://www.hist.msu.ru/Strikes_factors/data/03_04.xls

Shilnikova, I. (2013b). Statisticheskie svedenija o neschastnyh sluchajah s rabochimi na kamennougolnyh kopjah Doneckogo bassejna, 1893-1903 gg. [Statistical data on worker accidents in coal mines of the Donetsk basin. Years 1893-1903]. [Data set]. Retrieved from http://www.hist.msu.ru/Strikes_factors/data/03_05.xls

Shpolyanski, D. (1953). Monopolii ugolno-matallurgicheskoj promyshlennosti juga Rossii v nachale XX veka (k voprosu o soobnoshenii monopolii i konkurencii) [Monopoly of the metallurgical industry in the south of Russia at the beginning of the 20th century]. Moscow: Academy of Sciences.

Siegel, J. (2015). For Peace and Money: French and British finance in the service of tsars and commissars. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Stalin, J. (1952). Jekonomicheskie problemy socializma v SSSR [The economic problems of socialism in the USSR]. Moscow: State Publishing House of Political Literature.

Stiglitz, J. (2013). The price of inequality: How today's divided society endangers our future. New York, NY: W. W. Norton & Company.

Strumilin, S. (1960). Ocherki jekonomicheskoj istorii Rossii i SSSR [Essays on the economic history of Russia and the USSR]. Moscow: Nauka.

The Economist (newspaper). (1901, May). The financial and commercial crisis in Russia.

Trigari, A. & Rotemberg, J. (2006). Cyclical wages in a search-and-bargaining model with large firms. NBER International Seminar on Macroeconomics, 3, 65-114.

Valetov, T. (2017). Denezhnye obemy jeksporta «glavnejshih» tovarov i tovarnyh grupp. 1802-1915 [Monetary volumes of exports of ‘major’ goods and commodity groups. 1802-1915]. [Data file]. Retrieved from http://www.hist.msu.ru/Dynamics/data/10_001.xls

Vvedensky, B. (1952). Devjatoe janvarja 1905 [The ninth of January 1905]. In Bolshaja sovetskaja jenciklopedija [The Great Soviet Encyclopedia]. (Vol. 13, pp. 539-540). Moscow: Bolshaja Sovetskaja Jenciklopedija.

Vvedensky, B. (1955). Revoljucija 1905-07 v Rossii [Revolution of 1905-07 in Russia]. In Bolshaja sovetskaja jenciklopedija [The Great Soviet Encyclopedia]. (Vol. 36, pp. 199-205). Moscow: Bolshaja Sovetskaja Jenciklopedija.

Vvedensky, B. (1956). Sobranija Russkih Fabrichno-zavodskih rabochih g. S.-Peterburga [Meetings of the Russian Factory Workers of the city of St. Petersburg]. In Bolshaja sovetskaja jenciklopedija [The Great Soviet Encyclopedia]. (Vol. 39, pp. 463-464). Moscow: Bolshaja Sovetskaja Jenciklopedija.

Official publications

Ministry of Finance. (1900-1907a). Ezhegodnik Ministerstva Finansov. Vypusk 1899, 1900, 1901, 1902, 1903, 1904, 1905, 1906-1907 [The Yearbook of the Ministry of Finance. Issue 1899, 1900, 1901, 1902, 1903, 1904, 1905, 1906-1907]. St. Petersburg: Kirschbaum.

Ministry of Finance. (1899-1906b). Obshhaja gosudarstvennaja rospis dohodov i rashodov na 1898, 1899, 1900, 1901, 1902, 1903, 1904, 1905, 1906 god [Government revenues and expenditures for the year 1898, 1899, 1900, 1901, 1902, 1903, 1904, 1905, 1906]. St. Petersburg.

Ministry of Finance. (1903-1907с). Svod otchetov fabrichnyh inspektorov za 1901, 1902, 1903, 1904 [Summary of factory inspector reports for 1901, 1902, 1903, 1904]. St. Petersburg.

Russian State Historical Archive. Collection 587, inventory 56, file 296, pp. 10-11: State Bank (12 November, 1899), O sodejstvii realizacii obligacij vypuskov solidnyz promyshlennyh predprijatij [On the assistance of the sale of bonds of sound industrial enterprises]. St. Petersburg.

State Bank of the Russian Empire. (1899-1903). Otchet gosudarstvennogo banka za 1898, 1899, 1900, 1901, 1902 god [The report of the State Bank for the year 1898, 1899, 1900, 1901, 1902]. St. Petersburg: State Bank.