Arbitrage bots in experimental asset markets

Angerer, Martin and Neugebauer, Tibor and Shachat, Jason (2019): Arbitrage bots in experimental asset markets.

Abstract

While algorithmic trading robots are a proliferating presence in asset markets, there is no consensus whether their presence improves market quality or benefits individual investors. We examine the impact of robots seeking arbitrage in experimental laboratory markets. We find that the presence of algorithmic arbitrageurs generally enhances market quality. However, the wealth of human traders suffers from the presence of algorithmic traders. These social costs can be mitigated as we find high latency algorithms harm investors less than low latency algorithms; while the improvements in market quality are indistinguishable between algorithm latency levels and whether they provide liquidity or not.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: asset market experiment, arbitrage, algorithmic trading
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments > C92 - Laboratory, Group Behavior; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G12 - Asset Pricing ; Trading Volume ; Bond Interest Rates

References

Aldrich, E. M., & Friedman, D. (2017). Order protection through delayed messaging. https://cloudfront.escholarship.org/dist/prd/content/qt4938f518/qt4938f518.pdf

Aldrich, E. M., and López Vargas, K. (Forthcoming). Experiments in High-Frequency Trading: Testing the Frequent Batch Auction, Experimental Economics.

Andersen, T. G., Bondarenko, O., Kyle, A. S., & Obizhaeva, A. A. (2016). Intraday trading invariance in the E-mini S&P 500 futures market. http://pages.nes.ru/aobizhaeva/ABKO-intradayinv.pdf

Asparouhova, Elena, Peter Bossaerts, Kristian Rotaru, Tingxuan Wang, Nitin Yadav and Wenhao Yang (2019), Humans in Charge of Trading Robots: The First Experiment. http://uleef.business.utah.edu/newsite/pubs/PilotStudyAsparouhova.pdf

Baron, M., Brogaard, J., Hagströmer, B., & Kirilenko, A. (2018). Risk and return in high-frequency trading. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 1-32.

Biais, B., Foucault, T., & Moinas, S. (2015). Equilibrium fast trading. Journal of Financial Economics, 116(2), 292-313.

Bossaerts, P., Shachat, J., Xie, K. (2018). Arbitrage Opportunities: Anatomy and Remediation, Working Paper

Brogaard, J., Hendershott, T., Riordian, R. (2014). High-Frequency Trading and Price Discovery. The Review of Financial Studies. 27(8), 2267-2306

Brogaard, J., & Garriott, C. (forthcoming). High-Frequency Trading Competition. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis. doi:10.1017/S0022109018001175

Budish, E., Cramton, P., & Shim, J. (2015). The high-frequency trading arms race: Frequent batch auctions as a market design response. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 130(4), 1547-1621.

Carrion, A. (2013). Very Fast Money: High-frequency trading on the NASDAQ. Journal of Financial Markets. 16(4), 680-711

Chaboud, A., P., Chiquoine, B., Hjalmarsson, E., Vega, C. (2014). Rise of the Machines: Algorithmic Trading in the Foreign Exchange Market. The Journal of Finance. 69(5), 2045-2084

Charness, G., & Neugebauer, T. (2019). A Test of the Modigliani‐Miller Invariance Theorem and Arbitrage in Experimental Asset Markets. The Journal of Finance, 74(1), 493-529.

Charness, Gary and Uri Gneezy, 2010. Portfolio choice and risk attitudes: An experiment. Economic Inquiry 48(1), 133-146.

Clark-Joseph, A. (2014). Exploratory trading. Unpublished job market paper. Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.

Easley, D., Lopez de Prado, M.M., O´Hara, M. (2011). The Microstructure of the Flash Crash: Flow toxicity, liquidity crashes and the Probability of Informed Trading. Journal of Portfolio Management. 39(1), 19-29.

Easley, D., Lopez de Prado, M.M., O´Hara, M. (2012a). The Volume Clock: Insights into the High- Frequency Paradigm. Journal of Portfolio Management. 39(1), 19-29

Easley, D., Lopez de Prado, M.M., O´Hara, M. (2012b). Flow Toxicity and Liquidity in a High- frequency World. The Review of Financial Studies. 25(5), 1457-1493

Farjam, Mike, and Oliver Kirchkamp, 2017. Bubbles in hybrid markets: How expectations about algorithmic trading affect human trading, Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 146, 248-269.

Foucault, T., Hombert, J., Rosu, I. (2016). News Trading and Speed. Journal of Finance. 71(1), 335- 382

Frederick, Shane, 2005. Cognitive Reflection and Decision Making. Journal of Economic Perspectives. 19(4), 25-42.

Glantz, Morton and Robert Kissell. Multi-Asset Risk Modeling: Techniques for a Global Economy in an Electronic and Algorithmic Trading Era. Chapter Academic Press, 2013, p. 258.

Gomber, P., Gomber, P., & Haferkorn, M. (2015). High frequency trading. In Encyclopedia of Information Science and Technology, Third Edition, IGI Global, 1-9.

Hagströmer, B., Nordén, L. (2013). The diversity of high-frequency traders. Journal of Financial Markets. 16(4), 741-770

Harrison, J. M., & Kreps, D. M. (1979). Martingales and arbitrage in multiperiod securities markets. Journal of Economic Theory, 20(3), 381-408.

Hasbrouck, J. & Saar, G. (2013). Low-latency trading. Journal of Financial Markets. 16(4), 646–679

Hendershott, T. & Riordan, R. (2013). Algorithmic Trading and the Market for Liquidity. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis. 48(4), 1001-1024

Hendershott, T., Jones, C., M., Menkveld, A., J. (2011). Does Algorithmic Trading Improve Liquidity? The Journal of Finance. 66(1), 1-33

Jarrow, R. A., & Protter, P. (2012). A dysfunctional role of high frequency trading in electronic markets. International Journal of Theoretical and Applied Finance. 15(03), 1250022.

Jarrow, R., & Protter, P. (2015). Liquidity suppliers and high frequency trading. SIAM Journal on Financial Mathematics. 6(1), 189-200.

Kirilenko, A., Lo, A. (2013). Moore's Law versus Murphy's Law: Algorithmic Trading and Its Discontents. The Journal of Economic Perspectives. 27(2), 51-72

Kirilenko, A., Kyle, A. S., Samadi, M., & Tuzun, T. (2017). The flash crash: High‐frequency trading in an electronic market. The Journal of Finance, 72(3), 967-998.

Leal, Jacob Sandrine and Nobuyuki Hanaki. Algorithmic Trading, What if it is just an Illusion? Evidence from Experimental Financial Markets. No. 2018-31. Groupe de Recherche en Droit, Economie, Gestion (GREDEG CNRS), University of Nice Sophia Antipolis, 2018.

Menkveld, A.J., 2013. High frequency trading and the new market makers. Journal of Financial Markets. 712–740.

Menkveld, A.J., Yueshen, B., (Forthcoming) The Flash Crash: A Cautionary Tale About Highly Fragmented Markets. Management Science.

O`Hara, M. (2014). High-Frequency Trading and Its Impact on Markets. Financial Analysts Journal. 70(3), 18-27

O`Hara, M. (2015). High frequency market microstructure. Journal of Financial Economics. 116(2), 257-270

Rietz, Thomas A., 2005. Behavioral Mis-pricing and Arbitrage in Experimental Asset Markets, Working Paper, University of Iowa.

Shleifer 2000, Inefficient Markets An Introduction to Behavioral Finance. Clarendon Lectures in Economics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Smith, Vernon L., Gerry L. Suchanek and Arlington W. Williams, 1988. Bubbles, Crashes, and Endogenous Expectations in Experimental Spot Asset Markets. Econometrica. 56(5), 1119-1151.

Stöckl, Thomas, Jürgen Huber, and Michael Kirchler, 2010, Bubble measures in experimental asset markets. Experimental Economics. 13(3), 284-298.

Wah, E. (2016). How prevalent and profitable are latency arbitrage opportunities on US stock exchanges?. SSRN 2729109, http://www.smallake.kr/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/SSRN-id2729109.pdf

Zhang, S., & Riordan, R. (2011). Technology and market quality: the case of high frequency trading. ECIS 2011 proceedings.