Economic and environmental impact assessment of proposed bark-free requirements for wood pallets in international trade

Ray, Charles and Janowiak, John and Michael, Judd and Bachev, Hrabrin (2007): Economic and environmental impact assessment of proposed bark-free requirements for wood pallets in international trade. Published in: Journal of Forest Products Business Research , Vol. 4, No. 6 (2007): pp. 1-25.

Abstract

In 2004 the European Commission issued Directive 2004/102/EC which, among other things, introduced the concept of requiring wood packaging materials to be “debarked.” While previous research has established that as many as one in five North American wood pallets contain at least one occurrence of bark, the process changes required to eliminate or segregate barky defects from pallets have not been adequately defined or quantified. Simulation-based findings as described in this paper indicate that the proposed EC regulation could add $2.7 billion over 10 years to the cost of U.S. pallets alone as they enter international trade markets, and depending on the degree of universal adoption of bark-free regulation, could result in as much as 16 billion additional board feet of lumber being consumed, again in U.S. pallet production alone. Labor, administration, and environmental costs dwarf the capital costs required to make this process transition. The largest potential cost, however, may come in the form of product substitution, as product manufacturers convert to alternative shipping platforms to avoid potential quarantine and return-of-product risk.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: pallets, phytosanitary regulation, bark-free, EU policies, transaction costs
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business; F - International Economics > F4 - Macroeconomic Aspects of International Trade and Finance; F - International Economics > F4 - Macroeconomic Aspects of International Trade and Finance > F42 - International Policy Coordination and Transmission; F - International Economics > F5 - International Relations, National Security, and International Political Economy; F - International Economics > F5 - International Relations, National Security, and International Political Economy > F53 - International Agreements and Observance ; International Organizations

References

Araman, P.A., M.F. Winn, M.F. Kabir, X. Torcheux, and G. Loizeaud. 2003. Unsound defect volume in hardwood pallet cants. Forest Prod. J. 53(2): 45-49.

Bachev, H. 2004. Efficiency of agrarian organizations. In: Farm Management and Rural Planning. Kyushu University, Fukuoka, Japan. 5:135-150.

Brindley, E. and C. Brindley. 2004. Pallet material costs climb: Pallet prices can’t hold pat for long. Pallet Profile Weekly, Special Report. Industrial Reporting, Ashland, VA. 4 pp.

Bush, R.J., R.A. Araman, and V.S. Reddy. 1997. Pallet recycling and material substitution: How will hardwood markets be affected? In: Proceedings Eastern Hardwoods: Resources, Technologies, and Markets. J. Wiedenbeck, Ed. Forest Products Society, Madison, WI pp. 67-73.

Christoforo, J.C., R.J. Bush, and W.G. Luppold. 1994. A profile of the U.S. pallet and container industry. Forest Prod. J. 44(2): 9-14.

Dasgupta. P. 1996. The economics of the environment. In: Proceedings of the British Academy, 90:165-221. www.britac.ac.uk/pubs/src/keynes95/01conten.html.

European Union (EU). 2004. Commission Directive 2004/102/EC. Official Journal of the European Union. http://europa.eu.int/comm/food/plant/organisms/imports/special_en.htm.

European Union (EU). 2006. An overview of EU rules on wood packaging material. http://europa.eu.int/comm/food/plant/organisms/imports/overview_eu_rules.pdf.

Fraser, R.F., W.W. Johnson, and P.R. Blankenhorn. 1990. A description of the 1986 pallet manufacturing industry in Pennsylvania. Forest Prod. J. 40(6): 43-47.

Haake, R.A., T.R. Petrice, P. Nzokou, and D.P. Kamdem. 2006. Do insects infest wood packing material with bark following heat treatment? 4th Meeting of the International Forestry Quarantine Research Group. Rome, IT. 3 pp.

Interim Commission on Phytosanitary Measures (ICPM). 2002. International Standards for Phytosanitary Measures Publication No. 15: Guidelines for Regulating Wood Packaging Material in International Trade. Secretariat of the International Plant Protection Convention, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome, IT. 15 pp.

IFQRG. 2005. 3rd Meeting of the International Forestry Quarantine Research Group. Rome, IT. 11 pp. www.forestryquarantine.org/Dec-2005-Report_e.pdf.

IFQRG. 2006. 4th Meeting of the International Forestry Quarantine Research Group. Rome, IT. 12 pp. www.forestryquarantine.org/Oct06/CFIA_ACIA-IFQRG_Meeting_Report_Official.pdf.

IUFRO. 2006. Alien invasive species and international trade. International Union of Forestry Research Organizations, Working Group 7.03.12. Radom, Poland. www.forestresearch.gov.uk/fr/infd-6j7fhc. IPPC. 2007.

IPPC survey on bark of ISPM No. 15 marked wood packaging. International Plant Protection Convention. Posted on the International Phytosanitary Portal 1/26/2007. www.ippc.int/servlet/CDSServlet?status=ND0xNzE0NTEmNj1lbiYzMz0qJjM3PWtvcw~~.

Kuenzi, T. 2002. The effects of wane allowance, kerf, and target size reduction on sawmill optimization. Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR. 29 pp. www.lsize.com/ftp/literature/kuenzi_report.pdf.

Luppold, W. 1996. Structural changes in the central Appalachian hardwood sawmilling industry. Wood and Fiber Sci. 28(3): 346-355.

Luppold, W. 2003. Is the hardwood market entering a new era? Part II. Hardwood Market Report 81(42): 11-13.

Luppold, W. 2005. The number of hardwood sawmills continues to decrease – Is that bad? 2004: The Year at a Glance. Hardwood Market Report, Special Issue (Feb.). pp. 80-84.

McCurdy, D.R. and J.E. Phelps. 1996. The pallet industry in the United States: 1980, 1985, 1990, and 1995. Department of Forestry, Southern Illinois University at Carbondale, Carbondale, IL. 16 pp.

McCurdy, D.R., J.T. Ewers, F.H. Kung, and D.B. McKeever. 1988. A study of lumber use in pallets manufactured in the United States: 1982 and 1985. Forest Prod. J. 38(2): 11-15.

Michael, J.H. 1997. A characterization of the Texas pallet industry. Forest Prod. J. 47(2): 27-30.

Molina-Murillo, S., T. Smith, M. Reichenbach, and R. Smith. 2005. Impact of international phytosanitary standards on wood packaging materials end users: Pre-implementation assessment. Forest Prod. J. 55(9): 24-26.

Mumford, J.D. 2002. Economic issues related to quarantine in international trade. European Review of Agricultural Economics. 29(3): 329-348.

NWPCA. 2005a. Environmentalists are lobbying to eliminate wood packaging. Pallet Central (June). The National Wooden Pallet and Container Association, Alexandria, VA.

JNWPCA. 2005b. Wood packaging – A grassroots lobby success. Pallet Central (July-August). The National Wooden Pallet and Container Association, Alexandria, VA. p. 12.

NWPCA. 2006. NWPCA meets with top E.U. regulators to discuss next steps. Pallet Central (Feb.). The National Wooden Pallet and Container Association, Alexandria, VA. p. 1.

Parker, P.M. 2004. The world market for wood pallets, box pallets, and other load boards: A 2005 global trade perspective. INSEAD, France. The ICON Group, www.icongrouponline.com. 124 pp.

Pease, D.A., T. Blackman, and J.A. Sowle. 1996. 1996–97 North American Factbook. Miller Freeman, Inc., San Francisco, CA.

Portman, R. 2005. Official communication from the Executive Office of the President of the United States to Markos Kyprianou, Commissioner for Health and Consumer Protection, European Commission. 9/19/2005. Washington, DC. 2 pp.

Raballand, G. and E. Aldaz-Carroll. 2005. How do differing standards increase trade costs? The case of pallets. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 3519. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=665064.

Rao, P.K. 2003. The Economics of Transaction Costs. Palgrave-MacMillan, NY, NY. 197 pp.

Ray, C.D. 1998. Forest products industry applications of systems simulation. In: Proceedings of the 32nd International Particleboard/Composite Materials Symposium. Washington State University, Pullman, WA. pp. 89-93.

Ray, C.D. 2006. An examination of inspection and enforcement issues related to bark-free specifications for wood pallets and containers. IUFRO Working Party 7.03.12, “Alien Invasive Species and International Trade”. Radom, Poland. http://woodpro.cas.psu.edu/IUFRO-Poland7-4re-record.ppt.

Ray, C.D. and E. Deomano. 2007. Bark occurrence in U.S. and Canadian wood pallets. Forest Prod. J. 57(3): 84-88.

Ray, C.D., J.H. Michael, and B.N. Scholnick. 2006. Supply-chain system costs of alternative grocery industry pallet systems. Forest Prod. J. 56(10): 52-57.

Reddy, V.S., R.J. Bush, M.S. Bumgardner, J.L. Chamberlain, and P.A. Araman. 1997. Wood use in the U.S. pallet and container industry: 1995. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA. 17 pp.

Scheerer, C.E., R.J. Bush, and C.D. West. 1996. The use of substitute material pallets for grocery distribution. Forest Prod. J. 46(2): 29-36.

Skog, K.E. and G. A. Nicholson. 2000. Carbon sequestration in wood and paper products. USDA Forest Service Gen. Tech. Rep. RMRS-GTR-59. pp. 79-88.

Smith, P.M. 1991. The Washington State wood pallet industry. Forest Prod. J. 41(5): 39-44.

Stratis. 2006. Estimation of plastic pallet price increases under mass replacement of wood pallets for export. Personal communication with Jay Skinner, Feb. 2006. Plastic Pallet Sales Manager, Stratis Pallets, Indianapolis, IN.

Spence, A.M. 1974. Blue whales and optimal control theory. In: Systems Approaches and Environmental Problems. H. Göttinger, Ed. Göttingen: Vandenhoek and Ruprecht.

Steele, P. 1984. Factors determining lumber recovery in sawmilling. USDA Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory, Gen. Tech. Rept. FPL-39. 8 pp. www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/fplgtr/fplgtr39.pdf.

Tait, P. 2005. Personal communication, 11-25-05. National Association of Pallet Distributors, UK.

USNR. 2005. Estimation of sawmills operating without debarking equipment, from USNR’s database. Personal communication with Keith Fulmer, Sept. 2005. USNR Debarker Sales Manager. Hot Springs, AR.

Wenger, K.F., Ed. 1984. Forestry Handbook, 2nd ed. John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY. 1,335 pp.

White, M. and P. Hamner. 2005. Pallets move the world: The case for developing system-based designs for unit loads. Forest Prod. J. 55(3): 8-16.