Lights, Camera, What Action? The Nascent Literature on the Economics of US State Film Incentives

Rickman, Dan and Wang, Hongbo (2020): Lights, Camera, What Action? The Nascent Literature on the Economics of US State Film Incentives.

Abstract

The widespread proliferation of US state incentives for film and television production led to a large number of evaluations of their economic impacts. The common assumption by economic impact studies that state and film production would not occur without the incentives has spurred interest in the academic literature. We review the academic empirical studies on the nexus between state incentives and economic activity in the film and television sector. We identify areas of strengths and weakness in the empirical literature and perform additional analysis of numerous states using the synthetic control method to fill in gaps of knowledge. An added contribution of the study is discussion of the economics of the empirical results that mostly is missing in the film incentive literature.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Film; Incentives; Synthetic Control Method
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H25 - Business Taxes and Subsidies; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H71 - State and Local Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R12 - Size and Spatial Distributions of Regional Economic Activity; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R5 - Regional Government Analysis > R58 - Regional Development Planning and Policy

References

Abadie, Alberto, Alexis Diamond and Jens Hainmueller, 2010. “Synthetic control methods for comparative case studies: Estimating the effect of California's tobacco control program,” Journal of the American Statistical Association 105 (490), 493-505.

Adkisson, Richard V., 2013. “Policy convergence, state film-production incentives, and employment: A brief case study,” Journal of Economic Issues 47, 445–54.

Bartik, Timothy J., 2018. "But for" percentages for economic development incentives: What percentage estimates are plausible based on the research literature? Upjohn Institute working paper 18-289, https://research.upjohn.org/up_workingpapers/289/.

_____, 2019a. Costs and Benefits of a Revised Foxconn Project. Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.

_____, 2019b. Making sense of incentives: Taming business incentives to promote prosperity. Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.

Bartik, Timothy J., Stephen C.Y. Biddle, Brad J. Hershbein and Nathan D. Sotherland, 2018. WholeData: Unsuppressed County Business Patterns Data: Version 1.0 [dataset]. Kalamazoo: W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.

Berck, Peter, Elise Golan, and Bruce Smith, 1997. “State tax policy, labor, and tax revenue feedbacks.” Industrial Relations 36(4), 399-418.

Bradbury, John C., 2019. “Can movie production incentives grow the economy? Evidence from Georgia and North Carolina,” https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3432035.

_____, 2020a. “Do movie production incentives generate economic development?” Contemporary Economic Policy 38(2), 327-342.

_____, 2020b. Do incentive programs promote economic activity? A comment on O’Brien and Lane,” Econ Journal Watch 17(1), 56-65.

Button, Patrick, 2018. “Can tax incentives create a local film industry? Evidence from Louisiana and New Mexico,” Journal of Urban Affairs doi:10.1080/07352166.2018.1530570.

_____, 2019. “Do tax incentives affect business location and economic development? Evidence from state film incentives,” Regional Science and Urban Economics 77, 315-339.

Cain, Carol, 2020. “New Michigan film incentives could bring back Hollywood, jobs and cash,” Detroit Free Press, February 29, https://www.freep.com/story/money/2020/02/29/michigan-film-incentives-hollywood-michigan/4907143002/.

Camoin Associates, 2020. Economic and fiscal impact of Louisiana entertainment tax credits. https://louisianaentertainment.gov/docs/default-source/default-library/2019-economic-fiscal-impact-of-louisiana-entertainment-tax-credits.pdf

Christopherson, Susan and Ned Rightor, 2010. “The creative economy as ‘Big Business’: Evaluating state strategies to lure filmmakers,” Journal of Planning Education and Research 29(3), 336-352.

Coates, Dennis and Brad R. Humphreys, 2008. “Do economists reach a conclusion on subsidies for sports franchises, stadiums, and mega-events?” Econ Journal Watch 5(3), 294-315. Dorfman, Jeffrey, Partridge, Mark D., Galloway, Hamilton, 2011. “Are high-tech employment and natural amenities linked: answers from a smoothed Bayesian spatial model,” Spatial Economic Analysis 6, 397–422.

George, Bradley, 2020. Florida's film incentives: The Next Hollywood reboot? WUSF Public Media, January 21st. https://wusfnews.wusf.usf.edu/post/floridas-film-incentives-next-hollywood-reboot.

IO-Snap, 2019. Input-output state and national analysis program. https://www.io-snap.com/.

Karlin, Sam, 2019. Film tax break costs Louisiana millions, new study shows; supporters rally at entertainment summit. The Advocate. March 28, https://www.theadvocate.com/baton_rouge/news/business/article_c1d98d48-5193-11e9-b6a0-7bc2825afed3.html

KPM Film, 2020. Incentives by State. http://kpmfilm.com/film-tax-credits-by-state-map/

Leiser, Stephanie, 2017. “The diffusion of state film incentives: A mixed-methods case study,” Economic Development Quarterly 31(3), 255-267.

Lester, John, 2013. “Tax credits for foreign location shooting of films: No net benefit for Canada,” Canadian Public Policy 39(3), 451-472.

Loren C. Scott & Associates, Inc., 2017. The economic impact of Louisiana’s entertainment tax credit programs for film, live performance & sound recording. Louisiana Economic Development Website. Available online at https://louisianaentertainment.gov/docs/default-source/default-library/2017-entertainment-impact-study.pdf

McDonald, Adrian, 2011. “Down the Rabbit Hole: The madness of state film incentives as a "solution" to runaway production,” Journal of Business Law 14, 85-165. Available online at: https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/jbl/vol14/iss1/2.

Meares, Wesley, Aaron Hutton, Savannah Brown, and Rachel Morris, 2020. “Show Me the Money: An Analysis of Georgia’s State Film Tax Credit Program,” Questions in Politics 7, 40-55.

MNP LLP, 2014. New Mexico film production tax incentive study: Phase I report. July 21, https://nmfilm.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/Phase-1-Report-Final-Report-July-21-2014.pdf

Morehead, Andrea, 2020. “Indiana missing out on film opportunities due to lack of tax incentive,” WTHR, January 19th, https://www.wthr.com/article/indiana-missing-out-film-opportunities-due-lack-tax-incentive.

Munasib, Abdul and Dan S. Rickman, 2015. "Regional economic impacts of the shale gas and tight oil boom: A synthetic control analysis," Regional Science and Urban Economics 50, 1-17.

National Conference of State Legislatures, 2018. State Film Production Incentives and Programs. Accessed June 4, 2020 at https://www.ncsl.org/research/fiscal-policy/state-film-production-incentives-and-programs.aspx

North American Industrial Classification System, 2017. United States Office of Management and Budget. https://www.census.gov/eos/www/naics/

O’Brien, Nina F. and Christianne J. Lane, 2018. “Effects of economic incentives in the American film industry: an ecological approach,” Regional Studies 52(6), 865-875.

Owens, Mark F. and Adam D. Rennhoff, 2020. “Motion picture production incentives and filming location decisions: a discrete choice approach,” Journal of Economic Geography 20(3), 679-709.

Oxford Economics, 2017. Lights, camera but no action? A critical assessment of the methodological approach. https://www.oxfordeconomics.com/recent-releases/lights-camera-but-no-action

Popp, Anthony and James Peach, 2008. The film industry in New Mexico and the provision of tax incentives. https://arrowheadcenter.nmsu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/filmindustryfinal.pdf

Reed, W. Robert, 2009. “The determinants of US state economic growth: A less extreme bounds analysis, Economic Inquiry 47, 685-700.

Reich, Michael, Sylvia Allegretto and Anna Godoey, 2017. Seattle’s minimum wage experience 2015-16. Center on Wage and Employment Dynamics Policy Brief. June, https://irle.berkeley.edu/files/2017/Seattles-Minimum-Wage-Experiences-2015-16.pdf

Rickman, Dan S. and Hongbo Wang, 2018. "Two tales of two US states: Regional fiscal austerity and economic performance," Regional Science and Urban Economics 68, 46-55.

_____, 2020. "US state and local fiscal policy and economic activity: Do we know more now?" Journal of Economic Surveys 34(2), 424-465.

Seworder and Sjoquist, 2016. “Lights, camera, action: The adoption of state film tax credits,” Public Budgeting and Finance 36(2), 5-25.

Skorup, Jarrett, 2017. “Michigan was right to end film incentives: New report backs up legislators,” Mackinanc Center for Public Policy, November 15.

Swenson, Charles W., 2017. “Preliminary evidence on film production and state incentives,” Economic Development Quarterly 31, 65–80.

Tannenwald, Robert, 2010. State film subsidies: Not much bang for too many bucks. Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, December 9. https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-film-subsidies-not-much-bang-for-too-many-bucks

The Public Affairs Research Council of Louisiana, 2015. “Louisiana’s Film Industry Incentives,” Policy Brief, March 15.

Thom, Michael, 2018a. “Time to Yell “Cut?” An evaluation of the California film and production tax credit for the motion picture industry,” https://escholarship.org/uc/item/3rf6v988.

_____, 2018b. “Lights, camera, but no action? Tax and economic development lessons from state motion picture incentive programs,” The American Review of Public Administration 48(1), 33-51.

_____, 2019. “Do state corporate tax incentives create jobs? Quasi-experimental evidence from the entertainment industry,” State and Local Government Review 51(2), 92-103.

Thom, Michael, and Brian An, 2017. “Fade to black? Exploring policy enactment and termination, through the rise and fall of state tax incentives for the motion picture industry,” American Politics Research 45, 85–108.

Thompson, Megan, 2019. “Should Arizona bring back incentives for filmmakers?” WTXL, February 25th, https://www.wtxl.com/entertainment/arizona-tax-incentive-film-projects-return

Urban Land Institute, 2020. State and local finance data. https://state-local-finance-data.taxpolicycenter.org/pages.cfm

Verrier, Richard, 2011. “Iowa film tax credit program racked by scandal,” Los Angeles Times, January 19. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2011-jan-19-la-fi-ct-onlocation-20110119-story.html

Weiner, Jennifer, 2009. State business tax incentives: Examining evidence of their effectiveness. New England Public Policy Center Discussion Paper 09-3.