The Economics of Student Attendance

Pipergias Analytis, Pantelis and Ramachandran, Rajesh and Rauh, Chris and Willis, Jack (2008): The Economics of Student Attendance.

Abstract

The most common method of education remains that of the student teacher relationship in the classroom. Within this framework, although the student has the final choice on attendance, the educational institution can affect his relevant incentives. At the two extremes, full attendance can be mandatory for completion of the course, or attendance can be entirely optional. This article begins with a theoretical model showing that under the assumptions of rational individuals, no externalities, and “perfect evaluation methods”, optional attendance is optimal. The three central assumptions of the model are then relaxed to show that under certain conditions, assuming a high social value of education, institutional intervention can be justified economically. The approach is enriched with many practical examples, and the efficiency of numerous attendance rules is discussed. The article concludes with the deduction of policy recommendations for educational institutions

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: attendance laws, time allocation,educational production funtions, screening, mandatory attendance
• Subjects: A - General Economics and Teaching > A2 - Economic Education and Teaching of Economics > A20 - General; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I21 - Analysis of Education; D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D82 - Asymmetric and Private Information ; Mechanism Design

References

1. Acemoglu D Angrist J (2000), “How large are Human Capital Externalities? Evidence from Compulsory schooling laws” in NBER Macroeconomics Annual 9-59

2. Acemoglu D (1996), “A microfoundation for social increasing returns in human capital accumulation”, Quarterly Journal of Economics 111(3):779-804.

3. Altonji, J. (1993), “The demand for and return to education when outcomes are uncertain”, Journal of Labor Economics 11:48-83

4. Altonji, J., and C. Pierret (1997), “Employer learnings and the signaling value of education”, in: I. Ohashi and T. Tachibanaki, eds., Industrial Relations, Incentives and Employment, Macmillan Press Ltd., London.

5. Alchian AA Desmetz H (1975) “Production, Information Costs and Economic Orginisation”, Engineering Management Review, 3:21-41

6. Arrow KJ (1973), “Higher education as a filter”, Journal of Public Economics 193:216

7. Bauer T, Zimmerman KF (1998) ,“Learning Efficiency of Economic Students”, IZA Discussion Paper no 23

8. Becker GS (1965), “A theory of Allocation of Time”, Economic Journal, 75:493-517

9. Becker GS (1993), Human Capital: A theoretical and empirical analysis, with special reference to education, The University of Chicago Press

10. Becker GS (1991), A treatise of Family, Harvard University Press: New York

11. Becker WE J (1982) “The educational process and student achievement given uncertainty in measurement”, The American economic review, 72:229-336

12. Becker WE J (1997) “Teaching Economics to Undergraduates” Journal of Economic Literature 35:1347-1373

13. Becker WE J (1975), “ The University Professor as a utility maximizer”, The Journal of Human resources, 10:107-115

14. Bolton P, Dewatripont M (2005), Contract Theory , MIT Press:Boston

15. Bowles S (2004), Microeconomics, Behaviour, Institutions and Evolution, Princeton University Press: Priceton

16. Bratti M, Staffolani S (2002), “Student Time Allocation and education production functions” Quaderni di Ricerca

17. Bransford J, Brown A, Cocking R (2000), How do people learn, Brain, Mind, Experience and School, National Academy Press:Washington

18. Brown BW, Saks DH (1987), “microeconomics of the Allocation of Teachers time and student Learning”,Economics of Education Review, 6:319-332

19. Chizmar JF, Zak TA (1983) “Modeling Multiple outputs in educational production functions”,The American Economic Review,73:18-22

20. Chon E, Johnson E (2006), “Class Attendance and Performance in Principles of Education”, Education Economics ,14:211-23

21. Devadoss S, Foltz J (1996), “Evaluation of Factors influencing student attendance and performance”,American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 78:499-507

22. Dolton P, Marcevanno OD, Navarro L (2003),“The effective use of student time a stohastic frontier production function case study” Economics of Education Review,22 547-560

23. Durden GC, Elis LV (1995), “The effects of attendance on student learning in Principles of Economics”, The American Economic Review, 85:343-346

24. Elster J (1998), “Emotions and Economic Theory”, Journal of Economic Literature, 36:47-74

25. Elster J (1989),Ulysses and the Sirens, Cambridge University Press

26. Gambetta D (1987) ,Where they pushed would they jump? Individual decision mechanism in Education, Cambridge University Press: Cambridge

27. Hanushek EA (1979) “Conceptual and Empirical Issues in the Estimation of Educational Production Functions”, The Journal of Human Resources, 14:351-388

28. Hanushek EA (1986), “The Economics of Schooling: Production and Efficiency in Public schools”, Journal of Economic Literature, 24:1141-1177

29. Hanushek EA (1996), ''School resources and student performance'', in Does Money Matter edited by Gary Burtless, Brooking Institution Press

30. Hanushek EA, Kain JF, Rivkin VG (1998), “Teachers Schools and Academic Achievement” NBER working papers

31. Hanushek E et al (2003) ,“Does peer ability affect student achievement, Journal of Applied Economics 18:527-544

32. Haveman RH Wolfe BL (1984) ,“Schooling and Economic well-being the role of No-Market Effects”, The Journal of Human Resources, 19:377-407

33. Juster FT, Stafford FP (1991), “The Allocation of Time: Empirical Findings, Behavioural Models and Problems of Measurement”, Journal of Economic Literature 29:471-522

34. Kahneman D (2003), “Maps of Bounded Rationality: Psychology for Behavioural Economics”, The American Economic Review 93:1449-1475

35. Kelley AC (1975), “The student as a utility maximizer”, The journal of Economic Education 6:82-92

36. Krohn GA, O'Connor CM (2006), “Student effort and performance over the semester”, The Journal of Economic Education, 36:3-28

37. Krueger AB, M Lindahl (2001) "Education and Growth: Why and for Whom" Journal of Economic Literature, 39:1101-1136

38. Lancaster K (1966) ,''A new approach to consumer theory '' Journal of Political Economy, 74:132-57

39. Layard, R., and G. Psacharopoulos, (1974) ,“The screening hypothesis and the returns to education”, Journal of Political Economy 82:985-998

40. Lazear (1977), “Education : Production or Consumption” The Journal of Political Economy, 85:569-598

41. Lazear EP (2000) ,“Economic Imperialism”,The Quarterly Journal of Economics 115:99-146

42. Lazear EP (2001) ,“Educational Production”, The quarterly journal of Economics 116:777-803

43. Levin HM, ChangMC (1987) , “The economics of Student Time”, Economics of Education Review, 6:356-364

44. Marburger DR (2001) ,“Absenteeism and Economic Exam Performance”, The Journal of Economic Education 32:99-109

45. Mas-Collel A, Whinston M.D and Green J (1995) ,Microeconomic Theory, Oxford University Press

46. Mill JS (1873) , Autobiography , utilitarianism.com/millauto/

47. Millot B, Lane J (2002) “The efficient use of Time in education” Education Economics,10:209-228

48. North DC (1990), Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance, Harvard University Press

49. Papandreou AA (1998) ,Externalities and Institutions, Oxford University Press

50. Plant EA et Al (2005) “Why Study time does not predict grade point average amongacross college students: Implications of Deliberate practice for academic performance”Contemporary Educational Psychology 30:96-116

51. Pritchett L, Filmer D (1999) ,“What educational Production really show: A positive theory of Education Expenditures”, Economics of Education Review, 18:223-239

52. Psacharopoulos G (1987), Economics of Education: Research and Studies, Pergamon Press

53. Psacharopoulos G, Partinos HA (2004) “Returns to Investment in Education, A Further Update Educational Economics” World Bank Policy Research Working Papers, 12:111-134

54. Rabin M (1998) , “Psychology and Economics” Journal of Economic Literature 36:11-46

55. Riley J. (1979), “Testing the educational screening hypothesis”, Journal of Political Economy 227-252.

56. Riley J. (2001) ,“Silver signal – twenty five years of screening and signaling”, Journal of Economics Literature ,39: 432-478.

57. Rodgers JR (2002) "Encouraging Tutorial Attendance did not improve performance" Australian Economic Papers 41:255-266

58. Romer D (1993) ,“Do students go to class? Should they” The Journal of Economic Perspectives,7:167-174

59. Rosen S (1987) ,“Some Economics of Teaching”,Journal of Labor Economics, 5:561-575

60. Sabot R Wakeman-Linn J (1991),“Grade Inflation and Course Choice”,The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 5:159-170

61. Schmidt RM (1983), “Who maximises what? A study of student time allocation”, The American Economic Review, 73:23-28

62. Schultz T (1963) ,The Economic Value of Education ,Columbia University Press

63. Simon HA (1986) ''Rationality in Psychology and Economics", Journal of Business,59:209-24

64. Simon HA (1988) "Rationality as a process and a product of thought" in Bell DE, Raiffa H and Trevsky, A Decision Making Descriptive Normative and Prescriptive Interactions, pp56-78 65. Simon HA (1997), Models of Bounded Rationality, MIT Press:Boston

66. Spence AM (1973) “Job Market Signaling”, The Quarterly Journal of Economics 87:355-374

67. Stanca L (2006) , “The effects of Attendance on Academic Performance: Panel Data Evidence for Introductory Microeconomics” The Journal of Economic Education, 37:251-266

68. Stiglitz J (1975) “The Theory of Screening, Education and the distribution of income”, The American economic review, 65 283-300

69. Taubman PJ, Wales TJ (1973) ,“Higher education mental ability and screening” Journal of Political Economy, 81:28-55

70. Todd PE, Wolpin K (2003) “On the specification and estimation of the production function for cognitive achievement”, Economic Journal 113:3-33

71. Weiss A (1995) ,“Human Capital vs. Signaling explanations on wages”, The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9:133-154

72. Wolpin K. (1977), “Education and screening”, American Economics Review 67:949-958