Retail pricing format and rigidity of regular prices

Ray, Sourav and Snir, Avichai and Levy, Daniel (2023): Retail pricing format and rigidity of regular prices. Forthcoming in: Economica No. Forthcoming

Abstract

We study the price rigidity of regular and sale prices, and how it is affected by pricing formats (i.e., pricing strategies). We use data from three large Canadian stores with different pricing formats (Every-Day-Low-Price, Hi-Lo, and Hybrid) that are located within a 1 km radius of each other. Our data contains both the actual transaction prices and actual regular prices as displayed on the store shelves. We combine these data with two “generated” regular price series (filtered prices and reference prices) and study their rigidity. Regular price rigidity varies with store formats because different format stores treat sale prices differently, and consequently define regular prices differently. Correspondingly, the meanings of price cuts and sale prices vary across store formats. To interpret the findings, we consider the store pricing format distribution across the US.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Price Rigidity; Sticky Prices; Regular Prices; Sale Prices; Filtered Prices; Reference Prices; Temporary Price Changes; Transaction Prices; Price Cuts; Pricing Format; Pricing Strategy; Every-Day-Low-Price (EDLP); Hi-Lo; Hybrid
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D22 - Firm Behavior: Empirical Analysis; D - Microeconomics > D4 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design > D40 - General; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E31 - Price Level ; Inflation ; Deflation; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E52 - Monetary Policy; L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L11 - Production, Pricing, and Market Structure ; Size Distribution of Firms; L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L16 - Industrial Organization and Macroeconomics: Industrial Structure and Structural Change ; Industrial Price Indices; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M3 - Marketing and Advertising > M30 - General; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M3 - Marketing and Advertising > M31 - Marketing

References

ÁLVAREZ, F., LE BIHAN, H. and LIPPI, F. (2016). The real effects of monetary shocks in sticky price models: a sufficient statistic approach. American Economic Review, 106 (10), 2817–2851.

ANDERSON, E., JAIMOVICH, N. and SIMESTER, D. (2015). Price stickiness: empirical evidence of the menu cost channel. Review of Economics and Statistics, 97 (4), 813–826.

ANDERSON, E., MALIN, B., NAKAMURA, E., SIMESTER, D. and STEINSSON, J. (2017). Informational rigidities and the stickiness of temporary sales. Journal of Monetary Economics, 90, 64–83.

ANGELONI, I. and EHRMANN, M. (2007). Euro area inflation differentials. B.E. Journal of Macroeconomics, 7 (1).

BALEY, I. and BLANCO, A. (2021). Aggregate dynamics in lumpy economics. Econometrica, 89 (3), 1235–1264.

BARSKY, R., BERGEN, M., DUTTA, S. and LEVY, D. (2003). What can the price gap between branded and private label products tell us about markups? In R. Feenstra and M. Shapiro (eds), Scanner Data and Price Indexes (pp. 165–225). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

BARRO, R. (1972). A theory of monopolistic price adjustment. Review of Economic Studies, 39 (1), 17–26.

BELL, D.R. and LATTIN, J.M. (1998). Shopping behavior and consumer preference for store price format: why ‘large basket’ shoppers prefer EDLP. Marketing Science, 17 (1), 66–88.

BERADI, B., GAUTIER, E. and LE BIHAN, H. (2015). More facts about prices: France before and during the great recession. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 47 (8), 1465–1502.

BILS, M. and KLENOW, P. (2004). Some evidence on the importance of sticky prices. Journal of Political Economy, 112, 947–985.

BOLTON, R. N. and SHANKAR, V. (2003). An empirically derived taxonomy of retailer pricing and promotion strategies. Journal of Retailing, 79 (4), 213–224.

CABALLERO, R.J. and ENGEL, E.M.R.A. (2007). Price stickiness in s, S models: new interpretations of old results. Journal of Monetary Economics, 54, 100–121.

CAMPBELL, J. and EDEN, B. (2014). Rigid Prices: evidence from U.S. scanner data. International Economic Review, 55 (2), 423–442.

CARLTON, D. (1986). The rigidity of prices. American Economic Review, 76, 637–658.

CARVALHO, C. (2006). Heterogeneity in price stickiness and the real effects of monetary shocks. Frontiers of Macroeconomics, 2 (1).

CAVALLO, A. (2018). Scraped data and sticky prices. Review of Economics and Statistics, 100 (1), 105–119.

CECCHETTI, S. (1986). The frequency of price adjustment: a study of the newsstand prices of magazines. Journal of Econometrics, 31, 255–274.

CHAHROUR, R. (2011). Sales and price spikes in retail price data. Economics Letters, 110, 143–146.

CHEN, H.A., LEVY, D., RAY, S. and BERGEN, M. (2008). Asymmetric price adjustment in the small. Journal of Monetary Economics, 55, 728–737.

CHEVALIER, J. and KASHYAP, A. (2019). Best prices: price discrimination and consumer substitution. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 11 (1), 126–159.

COIBION, O., GORODNICHENKO, Y. and HONG, G.H. (2015). The cyclicality of sales, regular and effective prices: business cycle and policy implications. American Economic Review, 105 (3), 993–1029.

DELLAVIGNA, S. and GENTZKOW, M. (2019). Uniform pricing in US retail chains. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134 (4), 2011–2084.

DUTTA, S., BERGEN, M., LEVY, D. and VENABLE, R. (1999). Menu costs, posted prices, and multi-product retailers. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, 31, 683–703.

DUTTA, S., LEVY, D. and BERGEN, M. (2002). Price flexibility in channels of distribution. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 26, 1845–1900.

EDEN, B. (2018). Price dispersion and demand uncertainty: evidence from U.S. scanner data. International Economic Review, 59 (3), 1035–1075.

EICHENBAUM, M., JAIMOVICH, N. and REBELO, S. (2011). Reference prices, costs and nominal rigidities. American Economic Review, 101 (1), 234–262.

ELLICKSON, P. and MISRA, S. (2008). Supermarket pricing strategies. Marketing Science, 27 (5), 811–828.

FISHER, T.C.G and KONIECZNY, J.D. (2000). Synchronization of price changes by multiproduct firms: evidence from Canadian newspaper prices. Economics Letters, 68, 271–277.

FOX, K.J and SYED, I.A. (2016). Price discounts and the measurement of inflation. Journal of Econometrics, 191, 398–406.

FRANCIS, N., OWYANG, M. and SEKHPOSYAN, T. (2012). The local effects of monetary policy. The B.E. Journal of Macroeconomics, 12 (2), 1–38.

GALATA, G., RANDOLPH, E., BUCKLIN, R. and HANSSENS, D. (1999). On the stability of store format choice. Working Paper, Anderson School, UCLA.

GAURI, D.K., TRIVEDI, M. and GREWAL, D. (2008). Understanding the determinants of retail strategy: an empirical analysis. Journal of Retailing, 84 (3), 256–267.

GLANDON, P.J. (2018). Sales and the (mis)measurement of price level fluctuations. Journal of Macroeconomics, 58, 60–77.

GOLOSOV, M. and LUCAS, R.E. (2007). Menu costs and Philips curves. Journal of Political Economy, 115 (2), 171–199.

GORDON, R.J. (1981). Output fluctuation and gradual price adjustment. Journal of Economic Literature, 19, 492–530.

GORDON, R.J. (1990). What is New-Keynesian economics? Journal of Economic Literature, 28, 1115–1171.

GORODNICHENKO, Y. and TALAVERA, O. (2017). Price setting in online markets: basic facts, international comparisons, and cross-border integration. American Economic Review, 107 (1), 249–282.

GUIMARAES, B. and SHEEDY, K. (2011). Sales and monetary policy. American Economic Review, 101, 844–876.

HE, G., LAFRANCE, J.T., PERLOFF, J.M. and VOLPE, R. (2023). How do every-day-low-price supermarkets adjust their prices? Manuscript.

HENDEL, I. and NEVO, A. (2013). intertemporal price discrimination in storable goods markets. American Economic Review, 103 (7), 2722–2751.

HOCH, S.J., DRÈZE, X. and PURK, M.E. (1994). EDLP, Hi-Lo, and margin arithmetic. Journal of Marketing, 50, 16–27.

KASHYAP, A. (1995). Sticky prices: new evidence from retail catalogues. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110, 245–274.

KEHOE, P. and MIDRIGAN, V. (2015). Prices are sticky after all. Journal of Monetary Economics, 75, 35–53.

KLENOW, P. and WILLIS, J. (2007). Sticky information and sticky prices. Journal of Monetary Economics, 54, 79–99.

KLENOW, P. and MALIN, B. (2011). Microeconomic evidence on price setting. In B. Friedman and M. Woodford (eds.), Handbook of Monetary Economics, Volume 3A. New York, NY: North Holland.

KNOTEK, E. II (2019). The roles of price points and menu costs in price rigidity. Working Paper No. 19-23, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland.

KONIECZNY, J. and RUMLER, F. (2006). Regular adjustment: theory and evidence. Working Paper No. 669, European Central Bank.

KONIECZNY, J. and SKRZYPACZ, A. (2005). Inflation and price setting: evidence from a natural experiment. Journal of Monetary Economics, 52, 621–632.

KRYVTSOV, O. and VINCENT, N. (2021). The cyclicality of sales and aggregate price flexibility. Review of Economic Studies, 88, 334–377.

LAL, R. and RAO, R. (1997). Supermarket competition: the case of everyday low pricing. Marketing Science, 16, 60–80.

LACH, S. and TSIDDON, D. (1992). The behavior of prices and inflation: an empirical analysis of disaggregated data. Journal of Political Economy, 100, 349–389.

LACH, S. and TSIDDON, D. (1996). Staggering and synchronization in price setting: evidence from multiproduct firms. American Economic Review, 86, 1175–1196.

LEAHY, J. (2011). A survey of New Keynesian theories of aggregate supply and their relation to industrial organization. Journal of Money Credit & Banking, 43, 87–110.

LEVY, D., BERGEN, M., DUTTA, S. and VENABLE, R. (1997). The magnitude of menu costs: direct evidence from large U.S. supermarket chains. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112, 791–825.

LEVY, D., DUTTA, S. and BERGEN, M. (2002). Heterogeneity in price rigidity: evidence from primary micro-level data. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, 34, 197–220.

LEVY, D., DUTTA, S., BERGEN, M. and VENABLE, R. (1998). Price adjustment at multiproduct retailers. Managerial and Decision Economics, 19, 81–120.

LEVY, D., MÜLLER, G., DUTTA, S. and BERGEN, M. (2010) Holiday price rigidity and the cost of price adjustment. Economica, 77 (305), 172–198.

LEVY, D., SNIR, A., GOTLER, A. and CHEN, H.A. (2020). Not all price endings are created equal: price points and asymmetric price rigidity. Journal of Monetary Economics, 110 (April), 33–49.

LEVY D., LEE, D., CHEN, H.A., KAUFFMAN, R.J. and BERGEN, M. (2011). Price points and price rigidity. Review of Economics and Statistics, 93, 1417–1431.

MANKIW, N. G. (1985). Small menu costs and large business cycles: a macroeconomic model of monopoly. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 100, 529–539.

MIDRIGAN, V. (2011). Menu costs, multiproduct firms, and aggregate fluctuations. Econometrica, 79 (4), 1139–1180.

MONROE, K. (2002). Pricing: Making Profitable Decisions. New York, NY: McGraw Hill.

NAGLE, T. and MÜLLER, G. (2017). The Strategy and Tactics of Pricing: A Guide to Growing More Profitably. New York, NY: Routledge.

NAKAMURA, E. (2008). Pass-through in retail and wholesale. American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings, 98 (2), 430–437.

NAKAMURA, E. and STEINSSON, J. (2008). Five facts about prices: a reevaluation of menu cost models. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 123 (4), 1415–1464.

NAKAMURA, E. and STEINSSON, J. (2013). Price rigidity: microeconomic evidence and macroeconomic implications. Annual Review of Economics, 5 (1), 133–163.

NAKAMURA, E., STEINSSON, J., SUN, P. and VILLAR, D. (2018). The elusive costs of inflation: price dispersion during the US great inflation. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 133 (4), 1933–1980.

RAY, S., CHEN, H., BERGEN, M. and LEVY, D. (2006). Asymmetric wholesale pricing: theory and evidence. Marketing Science, 25, 131–154.

ROMER, D. (1993). The New Keynesian Synthesis. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 7, 5–22.

RONDAN-CATALUÑA, F.J., SÁNCHEZ-FRANCO, M.J. and VILLAREJO-RAMOS, Á.F. (2005). Are hypermarket prices different from discount store prices? Journal of Product and Brand Management, 14 (5), 330–337.

SHANKAR, V. (1996). Relating price sensitivity to retailer promotional variables and pricing policy: an empirical analysis. Journal of Retailing, 72 (3), 249–272.

SHESHINSKI, E. and WEISS, Y. (1977). Inflation and costs of price adjustment. Review of Economic Studies, 44 (2), 287–303.

SNIR, A., CHEN, H.A. and LEVY, D. (2022). Zero-ending prices, cognitive convenience, and price rigidity. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 203, 519–542.

SNIR, A. and LEVY, D. (2021). If you think 9-ending prices are low, think again. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, 6 (1), 33–47.

STATISTICS CANADA (2016). Census profile, 2016 census, Notre-Dame-de-Grâce-Westmount, Quebec, https://goo.gl/HNoqnk, accessed January 27, 2018.

SYED, I. (2015). Sale spotter: an algorithm to identify sale prices in point-of-sale data. UNSW Business School Research Paper No. 2015 ECON 13.

TAYLOR, J. (1999). Staggered price and wage setting in macroeconomics. In: J. Taylor and M. Woodford (eds.), Handbook of Macroeconomics. New York, NY: Elsevier.

VOLPE, R.J. and LI, C. (2012). On the frequency, depth, and duration of sales at high-low pricing supermarkets. Agribusiness, 28 (2), 222–238.

VOSS, G. B. and SEIDERS, K. (2003). Exploring the effect of retail sector and firm characteristics on retail price promotion strategy. Journal of Retailing, 79 (1), 37–52.

WARNER, E. and BARSKY, R. (1995). The timing and magnitude of retail store markdowns: evidence from weekends and holidays. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110 (2), 321–352.

WEISS, Y. (1993). Inflation and price adjustment: a survey of findings from micro-data. In E. Sheshinski and Y. Weiss (eds.), Optimal Pricing, Inflation, and the Cost of Price Adjustment. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, pp. 3–17.

WILLIS, J. (2003). Implications of structural changes in the U.S. economy for pricing behavior and inflation dynamics. Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City Economic Review, (1st quarter), 5–26.

WOLMAN, A. (2007). The frequency and costs of individual price adjustment: a survey. Managerial and Decision Economics, 28 (6), 531–552.

WU, W. (2022). Sales of durable goods and the real effects of monetary policy. Review of Economic Dynamics, 43, 80–92.