On the Spatial Allocation of College Seats: Human Capital Production and the Distribution of Skilled Labor

Yang, Yu (Alan) (2024): On the Spatial Allocation of College Seats: Human Capital Production and the Distribution of Skilled Labor.

Abstract

How to allocate college seats across regions is an important yet largely neglected issue. It may imply a policy tradeoff between efficiency in aggregate human capital production and equality of opportunities for people growing up in different places. Furthermore, the flow of college attendance, resulting from the geography of college seats, also impacts the spatial distribution of skilled workers through post-college migration and regional inequality in future development. This paper studies this tradeoff between efficiency and multidimensional inequality in the spatial allocation of college seats by focusing on the province-based college admission quotas in China, the largest college market in the world. Combining national administrative data and surveys, I estimate a structural model of college and migration choice under quota constraints, together with a measurement model that can recover the nationally comparable distribution of pre-college human capital in each province. There are substantial skill gaps between college applicants across provinces, but this disparity is not well reflected in the allocated admission quotas. A purely merit-based nationwide admission increases aggregate human capital at the cost of worse college opportunities and substantially more severe brain drain in less developed regions, while equalized admission leads to the opposite outcome. Comparing the current quota system against the efficiency-equality frontier suggests that China places a larger policy weight toward a more equalized spatial supply of skilled labor.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Place-based college admission, human capital, spatial sorting, regional inequality
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I23 - Higher Education ; Research Institutions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I24 - Education and Inequality; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J24 - Human Capital ; Skills ; Occupational Choice ; Labor Productivity; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility ; Immigrant Workers; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R2 - Household Analysis > R23 - Regional Migration ; Regional Labor Markets ; Population ; Neighborhood Characteristics

References

Abowd, John M., Francis Kramarz, and David N. Margolis, “High Wage Workers and High Wage Firms,” Econometrica, 1999, 67 (2), 251–333.

Adamopoulos, Tasso, Loren Brandt, Jessica Leight, and Diego Restuccia, “Misallocation, Selection, and Productivity: A Quantitative Analysis With Panel Data From China,” Econometrica, 2022, 90 (3), 1261–1282.

Agarwal, Nikhil and Paulo Somaini, “Revealed Preference Analysis of School Choice Models,” Annual Review of Economics, 2020, 12, 471–501.

Anstreicher, Garrett, “Spatial Influences in Upward Mobility,” Journal of Political Economy, 2024, 132 (1), 149–199.

Arcidiacono, Peter, “Affirmative Action in Higher Education: How do Admission and Financial Aid Rules Affect Future Earnings?,” Econometrica, 2005, 73 (5), 1477–1524.

Arcidiacono, Peter and Michael Lovenheim, “Affirmative Action and the Quality-Fit Trade-off,” Journal of Economic Literature, 2016, 54 (1), 3–51.

Bai, Chong-En, Ruixue Jia, Hongbin Li, and Xin Wang, “Entrepreneurial Reluctance: Talent and Firm Creation in China,” NBER Working Paper Series, 2021, 28865, 1–49.

Baird, Matthew D., John Engberg, and Isaac M. Opper, “Optimal Allocation of Seats in the Presence of Peer Effects: Evidence from a Job Training Program,” Journal of Labor Economics, 2023, 41 (2), 479–509.

Barrow, Lisa, Lauren Sartain, and Marisa de la Torre, “Increasing Access to Selective High Schools through Place-Based Affirmative Action: Unintended Consequences,” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 2020, 12 (4), 135–163.

Bleemer, Zachary, “Affirmative Action, Mismatch, and Economic Mobility after California’s Proposition 209,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2022, 137 (1), 115–160.

Blouri, Yashar and Maximilian V. Ehrlich, “On the optimal design of place-based policies: A structural evaluation of EU regional transfers,” Journal of International Economics, 2020, 125, 103319.

Bo, Shiyu, Jing Liu, Ji-Liang Shiu, Yan Song, and Sen Zhou, “Admission Mechanisms and the Mismatch between Colleges and Students: Evidence from a Large Administrative Dataset from China,” Economics of Education Review, 2019, 68, 27–37.

Brotherhood, Luiz, Bernard Herskovic, and João Ramos, “Income-Based Affirmative Action in College Admissions,” The Economic Journal, 2023, 133 (653), 1810–1845.

Busso, Matias, Jesse Gregory, and Patrick Kline, “Assessing the Incidence and Efficiency of a Prominent Place Based Policy,” American Economic Review, 2013, 103 (2), 897–947.

Calsamiglia, Caterina, Chao Fu, and Maia Guell, “Structural Estimation of a Model of School Choices: the Boston Mechanism vs. Its Alternatives,” Journal of Political Economy, 2020, 128 (2), 642–680.

Carr, Michael D. and Emily E. Wiemers, “The decline in long-term earnings mobility in the U.S.: Evidence from survey-linked administrative data,” Labour Economics, 2022, 78, 102170.

Chan, Jimmy, Zhi Wang, and Shunyi Zhao, “The Institution of Merit: A Chinese Case Study,” Working paper, 2019.

Chen, Yan and Onur Kesten, “Chinese College Admissions and School Choice Reforms: A Theoretical 39Analysis,” Journal of Political Economy, 2017, 125 (1), 99–139.

Chetty, Raj, John N Friedman, Emmanuel Saez, Nicholas Turner, and Danny Yagan, “Income Segregation and Intergenerational Mobility Across Colleges in the United States,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2020, 135 (3), 1567–1633.

Chetty, Raj, Nathaniel Hendren, Patrick Kline, and Emmanuel Saez, “Where is the Land of Opportunity? The Geography of Intergenerational Mobility in the United States,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2014, 129 (4), 1553–1623.

Clark, Derek J. and Christian Riis, “Influence and the Discretionary Allocation of Several Prizes,” Euro- pean Journal of Political Economy, 1998, 14 (4), 605–625.

Colas, Mark and Suqin Ge, “Transformations in China’s Internal Labor Migration and Hukou System,” Journal of Labor Research, 2019, 40 (3), 296–331.

Cunha, Flavio and James J. Heckman, “Formulating, Identifying and Estimating the Technology of Cognitive and Noncognitive Skill Formation,” Journal of Human Resources, 2008, 43 (4), 738–782.

Cunha, Flavio, James J. Heckman, and Susanne M. Schennach, “Estimating the Technology of Cognitive and Noncognitive Skill Formation,” Econometrica, 2010, 78 (3), 883–931.

Diamond, Rebecca, “The Determinants and Welfare Implications of US Workers’ Diverging Location Choices by Skill: 1980-2000,” American Economic Review, 2016, 106 (3), 479–524.

Diamond, Rebecca and Cecile Gaubert, “Spatial Sorting and Inequality,” Annual Review of Economics, 2022, 14 (1), 795– 819.

Diao, Chenglei, Chenyuan Liu, and Xiaohan Zhong, “Improving Equality in China’s College Admissions: Estimation and Policy Interventions,” Working paper, 2022.

Dillon, Eleanor W. and Jeffrey A. Smith, “Determinants of the Match between Student Ability and College Quality,” Journal of Labor Economics, 2017, 35 (1), 45–66.

Dillon, Eleanor W. and Jeffrey A. Smith, “The Consequences of Academic Match between Students and Colleges,” Journal of Human Resources, 2020, 55 (3), 767–808.

Fabre, Anaıs, “The Geography of Higher Education and Spatial Inequalities,” Working paper, 2023.

Fack, Gabrielle, Julien Grenet, and Yinghua He, “Beyond Truth-Telling: Preference Estimation with Centralized School Choice and College Admissions,” American Economic Review, 2019, 109 (4), 1486– 1529.

Fajgelbaum, Pablo D. and Cecile Gaubert, “Optimal Spatial Policies, Geography, and Sorting,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2020, 135 (2), 959–1036.

Fang, Hanming and Xincheng Qiu, ““Golden Ages”: A Tale of the Labor Markets in China and the United States,” Journal of Political Economy: Macroeconomics, 2023, 1 (4), 665–706.

Feng, Shuaizhang and Xiaoyu Xia, “Heterogeneous firm responses to increases in high-skilled workers: Evidence from China’s college enrollment expansion,” China Economic Review, 2022, 73, 101791.

Fleisher, Belton M., Haizheng Li, and Min Qiang Zhao, “Human Capital, Economic Growth, and Re- gional Inequality in China,” Journal of Development Economics, 2010, 92 (2), 215–231.

Fu, Chao, Junjie Guo, Adam J. Smith, and Alan Sorensen, “Students’ heterogeneous preferences and the uneven spatial distribution of colleges,” Journal of Monetary Economics, 2022, 129, 49–64.

Gaubert, Cecile, Patrick Kline, and Danny Yagan, “Place-Based Redistribution,” NBER Working Paper Series, 2021, w28337.

Ge, Teng and Tao Wu, “Search, Migration, and Social Connections: Solving the Migration Puzzle to Beijing,” China Economic Review, 2020, 62, 1–11.

Glaeser, Edward L. and Joshua Gottlieb, “The Economics of Place-Making Policies,” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 2008, 39, 155–253.

Gourieroux, C., A. Monfort, and E. Renault, “Indirect inference,” Journal of Applied Econometrics, 1993, 8 (S1), S85–S118.

Groen, Jeffrey A., “The Effect of College Location on Migration of College-Educated Labor,” Journal of Econometrics, 2004, 121, 125–142.

Guo, Lina, Prashant Loyalka, and Xiaoyang Ye, “Are Regional Quotas Fair? Simulating Merit-Based College Admissions Using Unique Student-Level Data from China,” Working paper, 2018.

Heckman, James J., Lance Lochner, and Christopher Taber, “General-Equilibrium Treatment Effects: A Study of Tuition Policy,” American Economic Review, 1998, 88 (2), 381–386.

Hendricks, Lutz, Tatyana Koreshkova, and Oksana Leukhina, “Causes and Consequences of Student-College Mismatch,” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Working Paper, 2022, 026.

Hillman, Nicholas W., “Geography of College Opportunity: The Case of Education Deserts,” American Educational Research Journal, 2016, 53 (4), 987–1021.

Howard, Greg and Hansen Shao, “The Dynamics of Internal Migration: A New Fact and its Implications,” Working paper, 2023.

Hsieh, Chang-Tai and Peter J Klenow, “Misallocation and Manufacturing TFP in China and India,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2009, 124 (4), 1403–1448.

Hsieh, Chang-Tai , Erik Hurst, Charles I. Jones, and Peter J. Klenow, “The Allocation of Talent and U.S. Economic Growth,” Econometrica, 2019, 87 (5), 1439–1474.

Huang, Mian, Chunbing Xing, and Xiaoyong Cui, “Does College Location Affect the Location Choice of New College Graduates? Evidence from China,” China & World Economy, 2022, 30 (3), 135–160.

Ishimaru, Shoya, “Geographic Mobility of Youth and Spatial Gaps in Local College and Labor Market Opportunities,” Working paper, 2023.

Jia, Ruixue and Hongbin Li, “Just Above the Exam Cutoff Score: Elite College Admission and Wages in China,” Journal of Public Economics, 2021, 196, 104371.

Kanbur, Ravi and Xiaobo Zhang, “Fifty Years of Regional Inequality in China: A Journey through Central Planning, Reform, and Openness,” Review of Development Economics, 2005, 9 (1), 87–106.

Kang, Ning, Institutional Innovation in Higher Education Resource Distribution in a Transitional Economy, Educational Science Publishing House, 2005.

Kennan, John, “Spatial Variation in Higher Education Financing and the Supply of College Graduates,” Working paper, 2021.

Kennan, John and James R. Walker, “The Effect of Expected Income on Individual Migration Decisions,” Econometrica, 2011, 79 (1), 211–251.

Kline, Patrick and Enrico Moretti, “Local Economic Development, Agglomeration Economies, and the Big Push: 100 Years of Evidence from the Tennessee Valley Authority,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2014, 129 (1), 275–331.

Knight, Brian and Nathan Schiff, “The Out-of-State Tuition Distortion,” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 2019, 11, 317–350.

Lu, Yi, Jin Wang, and Lianming Zhu, “Place-Based Policies, Creation, and Agglomeration Economies: Evidence from China’s Economic Zone Program,” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 2019, 11 (3), 325–360.

Luflade, Margaux, “The Value of Information in Centralized School Choice Systems,” Working paper, 2017.

McFadden, Daniel D, “Conditional Logit Analysis of Qualitative Choice Behavior,” in Paul Zarembka, ed., Frontiers in Econometrics, Academic Press, 1974, pp. 105–142.

Mello, Ursula, “Centralized Admissions, Affirmative Action, and Access of Low-Income Students to Higher Education,” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 2022, 14 (3), 166–197.

Ministry of Education, “Regular Institutions of Higher Education,” http://www.moe.gov.cn/srcsite/A03/moe_634/ 201104/t20110427_119480.html, 2011.

Moretti, Enrico, “Human Capital Externalities in Cities,” Handbook of Regional and Urban Economics, 2004, 4, 2243–2291.

Pan, Kunfeng and Sheng Cui, “Local Government Competition on Human Capital and the Enrollment Strategy of Provincial Universities,” China Economics of Education, 2017, 2 (6), 31–50.

Pu, Yun, “College Admission in Three Chinese Provinces: Province-Specific versus Pooling Quotas,” China Economic Review, 2020, 60, 1–9.

Rust, John P., “Structural Estimation of Markov Decision Processes,” in R.F. Engle and D.L. McFad- den, eds., Handbook of Econometrics, Amsterdam, New York, Oxford: Elsevier Science, North-Holland, 1994, pp. 3081–3143.

Si, Ruichao, “Unexpected pressure? The effect of a curriculum reform on household educational investments and student outcomes,” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2021, 190, 730–746.

Sjoquist, David L. and John V. Winters, “Merit Aid and Post-College Retention in the State,” Journal of Urban Economics, 2014, 80, 39–40.

Song, Yang, “What should economists know about the current Chinese hukou system?,” China Economic Review, 2014, 29, 200–212.

Tombe, By Trevor and Xiaodong Zhu, “Trade, Migration, and Productivity: A Quantitative Analysis of China,” American Economic Review, 2019, 109 (5), 1843–1872.

Wei, Shang Jin, Xiaobo Zhang, and Yin Liu, “Home Ownership as Status Competition: Some Theory and Evidence,” Journal of Development Economics, 2017, 127, 169–186.

Xu, Chenggang, “The Fundamental Institutions of China’s Reforms and Development,” Journal of Economic Literature, 2011, 49 (4), 1076–1151.

Ye, Xiaoyang, “Improving College Choice for the Poorest Students: Results from Randomized Experiments in Centralized Admissions,” Education Finance and Policy, 2023, pp. 1–33.

Zhang, Jipeng, Ru Wang, and Chong Lu, “A Quantitative Analysis of Hukou Reform in Chinese Cities: 2000-2016,” Growth and Change, 2019, 50 (1), 201–221.