“Bad rebounds” and the Environment: Bottled water and plastic collection behavior using cross-sectional Italian data

D'Amato, Alessio and De Simone, Marco and Dileo, Ivano and Marzano, Elisabetta (2025): “Bad rebounds” and the Environment: Bottled water and plastic collection behavior using cross-sectional Italian data.

Abstract

The multidimensional nature of environmental problems is increasingly recognized, as different relevant behaviors may be mutually reinforcing or in a trade-off relationship. This is particularly relevant when the use of resources is tightly linked to their packaging, as in the case of bottled water consumption. This paper aims at using Italian data to assess whether plastic related separated collection and bottled water consumption are complements or substitutes in consumers’ behaviors. Using Cross-sectional Italian data, we provide evidence of a challenging “rebound” effect: individuals more engaged in recycling are also those producing more plastic waste related to bottled water consumption. This has important consequences for policy analysis, since the rebound effect appears to be related to the availability of waste infrastructures: better infrastructure, namely door to door collection, inflate the consumption of (plastic packaged) bottled water. We also provide robustness analysis for our results, specifically addressing the role of endogeneity issues.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: bottled water, environmental concern; recycling waste; rebound effect
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C2 - Single Equation Models ; Single Variables > C21 - Cross-Sectional Models ; Spatial Models ; Treatment Effect Models ; Quantile Regressions; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q2 - Renewable Resources and Conservation > Q25 - Water; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q53 - Air Pollution ; Water Pollution ; Noise ; Hazardous Waste ; Solid Waste ; Recycling

References

Amicarelli, V., Rana, R. L., Lombardi, M., Fellner, J., Tricase, C., & Bux, C. (2024). Material flow analysis and carbon footprint of water-packaging waste management. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 106, 107517.

Andreoni, J., 1990. Impure altruism and donations to public goods: a theory of warm glow giving. Economic Journal 100 (401), 464–477.

Ballantine, P., Ozanne, L., & Bayfield, R. (2019). Why buy free? exploring perceptions of bottled water consumption and its environmental consequences. Sustainability, 11, 757.

Beaumais, O., & Crastes dit Sourd, R. (2024). Modeling Quality and Price Perception in the Choice of Drinking Water in France: A Hybrid Choice Model Approach. Water Resources Research, 60(2), e2023WR034803.

Benöhr, I. (2023). The right to water and sustainable consumption in EU Law. Journal of Consumer Policy, 46(1), 53-77.

Brekke, K.A., Kverndokk, S., Nyborg, K., 2003. An economic model of moral motivation. Journal of Public Economics 87, 1967–1983

Bruchmann, K., Chue, S., Dillon, K., Lucas, J., Neumann, K., & Parque, C. (2021). Social comparison information influences intentions to reduce single-use plastic water bottle consumption. Frontiers in Psychology, 12, 29 september 2021

Carlucci, D., De Gennaro, B., & Roselli, L. (2016). What is the value of bottled water? Empirical evidence from the Italian retail market. Water Resources and Economics, 15, 57-66.

Castellucci, L. & D'Amato, A. (2006). An Exercise on the Optimal Use of Groundwater Resources. Rivista Internazionale di Scienze Sociali.114 (4), 545-560.

Castro, C. G., Trevisan, A. H., Pigosso, D. C., & Mascarenhas, J. (2022). The rebound effect of circular economy: Definitions, mechanisms and a research agenda. Journal of Cleaner Production, 345, 131136.

D'Amato, A., Mancinelli, S., & Zoli, M. (2016). Complementarity vs substitutability in waste management behaviors. Ecological Economics, 123, 84-94.

De Marchi, E., Pigliafreddo, S., Banterle, A., Parolini, M., & Cavaliere, A. (2020). Plastic packaging goes sustainable: An analysis of consumer preferences for plastic water bottles. Environmental Science & Policy, 114, 305-311.

De Simone, M., Dileo, I., & Marzano, E. (2024). Fattori socioeconomici e divari nel consumo di acqua in bottiglia tra il Nord e il Sud Italia. Rivista Economica del Mezzogiorno, 38(1-2), 209-240.

Dorigoni, A., & Bonini, N. (2023). Water bottles or tap water? A descriptive-social-norm based intervention to increase a pro-environmental behavior in a restaurant. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 86, 101971.

Garfí, M., Requejo-Castro, D., & Villanueva, C. M. (2025). Social life cycle assessment of drinking water: Tap water, bottled mineral water and tap water treated with domestic filters. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 112, 107815.

Garfí, M., Cadena, E., Sanchez-Ramos, D., & Ferrer, I. (2016). Life cycle assessment of drinking water: Comparing conventional water treatment, reverse osmosis and mineral water in glass and plastic bottles. Journal of Cleaner Production, 137, 997-1003.

Geerts, R., Vandermoere, F., Van Winckel, T., Halet, D., Joos, P., Van Den Steen, K., ... & Vlaeminck, S. E. (2020). Bottle or tap? Toward an integrated approach to water type consumption. Water research, 173, 115578.

Gillingham, K., Rapson, D., & Wagner, G. (2016). The Rebound effect and energy efficiency policy. Review of Environmental Economics and Policy. 10. 68-88.

Legambiente (2018). Acque in bottiglia 2018. Un’anomalia tutta italiana”, available on: https://www.legambiente.it/wp-content/uploads/dossier-acque_in_bottiglia_2018.pdf. (Accessed on 29th January, 2024).

Margetts, E. A., & Kashima, Y. (2017). Spillover between pro-environmental behaviours: The role of resources and perceived similarity. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 49, 30-42.

Moncur, J. E., & Pollock, R. L. (2018). Scarcity rents for water: A valuation and pricing model. In Economics of Water Resources (pp. 39-49). Routledge

Orset, C., Barret, N., & Lemaire, A. (2017). How consumers of plastic water bottles are responding to environmental policies?. Waste management, 61, 13-27.

Peter, P. and Honea, H. (2012). Targeting social messages with emotions of change: the call for optimism. Journal of Public Policy and Marketing, 31, 269-283.

Qian, N. (2018). Bottled water or tap water? A comparative study of drinking water choices on University Campuses. Water, 10(1), 59.

Tosun, J., Scherer, U., Schaub, S., & Horn, H. (2020). Making Europe go from bottles to the tap: Political and societal attempts to induce behavioral change. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Water, 7(3), e1435.

Tsironi, T. N., Chatzidakis, S. M., & Stoforos, N. G. (2022). The future of polyethylene terephthalate bottles: Challenges and sustainability. Packaging Technology and Science, 35(4), 317-325.

Viscusi, W., Huber, J., & Bell, J. (2014). The private rationality of bottled water drinking. Contemporary Economic Policy, 33, 450-467

Zvěřinová, I., Otáhal, J., & Ščasný, M. (2024). Bottled or tap water? factors explaining consumption and measures to promote tap water.. https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202407.0349.v1