Temporary employment and wage gap with permanent jobs: evidence from quantile regression

Bosio, Giulio (2009): Temporary employment and wage gap with permanent jobs: evidence from quantile regression.

Abstract

Previous research on wage penalty for temporary workers has focused on the conditional mean model. This paper uses micro data from the 2006 wave of the Survey of Italian Households’ Income and Wealth (SHIW) to examine the wage gap between temporary and permanent workers across the whole wage distribution. I apply a quantile regression models to understand whether there are glass ceiling or sticky floor for fixed-term workers and to test the hypothesis of polarization of wage profile by contract status. I also exploit a counterfactual decomposition analysis to investigate whether the gap is attributed to differences in characteristics or to differences in coefficients effect. A possible source of misspecification may arise, the endogenous selection in temporary status. In order to address the selectivity bias, I adopt an IV specification and a variant of the traditional Heckman (1978) dummy endogenous variable for the quantile framework. The main finding is a sticky floor effect, in the sense that the wage penalty for temporary workers is wider at the bottom of earnings distribution and in particular the decomposition method shows how the coefficients effect is decreasing in the upper half of wage profile. The analysis by educational level and by sector confirms the sticky floor effect. Finally correcting for endogenous self-selection in temporary contract slightly modifies the magnitude of wage gap, without changing the main patterns evidenced in the standard quantile regression.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: temporary employment, quantile regression, wage gap decomposition, endogenous selection
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J0 - General > J08 - Labor Economics Policies; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J3 - Wages, Compensation, and Labor Costs > J31 - Wage Level and Structure ; Wage Differentials; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J4 - Particular Labor Markets > J42 - Monopsony ; Segmented Labor Markets

References

Abadie A., Angrist J. and G. Imbens (2002), “Instrumental variable estimates of the effect of subsidized training on the quantile of trainee earnings”, Econometrica, Vol. 70, n°1, pp. 91-117;

Amemiya T. (1982), “Two-Stage Least Absolute Deviations Estimators”, Econometrica, 50, pp.689-711;

Amuedo-Dorantes C. e R. Serrano-Padial (2006), “Wage Growth Implications of Fixed-Term Employment: An Analysis by Contract Duration and Job Mobilty”, Labour Economics 14, pp. 829-847;

Arias O., Sosa-Escudero W. And K. Hallock (2001), “Individual heterogeneity in the returns to schooling: Instrumental Variables Quantile Reregression Using Twins Data”, Empirical Economics, 26 (1), pp.7-40;

Arulampalam W., Booth A. and M. Bryan (2007), “Is There a Glass Ceiling over Europe? Explaining the Gender Pay Gap across the Wages Distribution”, Industrial and Labour Relations Review, 60, pp. 163-186;

Arumpalam W., Manquilef A. and J. Smith (2006), “Quantile Regression Analysis of Union Wage Premia in the United Kingdom, 1991-2003”, unpublished mimeo;

Autor D., Katz L. and M. Kearney (2006), “The Polarization of the US Labour Market”, American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings, 95(2), pp. 440-446;

Azevedo J. P. (2004), “GRQREG: Stata module to graph coefficients of a quantile regression”, Statistical Software Components, Boston College, Department of Economics, http://ideas.repec.org/c/boc/bocode/s437001.html;

Beblo M., D. Beninger, A. Heinze and F. Laisney (2003), ”Measuring Selectivity-Corrected Gender Wage Gaps in the EU”,unpublished mimeo;

Berton F. (2008), “The (long) run out of unemployment are temporary jobs the shortest way?”, LABOR working paper no. 76;

Blàzquez M. (2006), “The probability of leaving a low-paid job in Spain: The importance of switching into permanent employment”, Revista de Economia Laboral n.3, pp. 58-86;

Booth A. L., Francesconi M. And J. Frank (2002), “Labour as a Buffer: Do temporary workers suffer?” ISER Working Papers,.n°29;

Brown S. and J. G. Sessions (2005), “Employee Attitudes, Earning and Fixed-Term Contracts: International Evidence”, Review of World Economics, Springer, vol. 127(2), pages 296-317;

Buchinsky M. (1998), “Recent Advances in Quantile Regression Models: A Practical Guideline for Empirical Research”, Journal of Human Resources, 33, pp. 88-126;

Buchinsky M. (2001), “Quantile regression with sample selection: Estimating women’s return to education in the U.S.”, Empirical Economics, 26, pp. 87-113;

Cai L. and A. Y. C. Liu (2007), “Union Wage Effects in Australia: Are There Variations in Distribution?”, Melbourne Institute Working Paper, n°17;

Chernozhukov V. and C. Hansen (2005), “An IV Model of Quantile Treatment Effect”, Econometrica, 71, pp.254-261;

Costantini M. e S. De Nardis (2007), “Estimates of Structural Change in the Wage Equation: Some Evidence for Italy”, ISAE working paper, n°86;

Davia M. A. and V. Hernanz (2004), “Temporary employment and segmentation in the Spanish labour market: An empirical analysis through the study of wage differentials”, Spanish economic review, n°6, pp. 291-318;

De La Rica S. (2004), “Wage gaps between workers with indefinite and fixed-term contracts: The impact of firm and occupational segregation”, MONEDA Y CREDITO, n° 219, pp. 43-69;

De la Rica S. and Felgueroso F. (1999), “Wage differentials between permanent and temporal workers: Further evidence”, unpublished mimeo;

Diàz M. A. and R. Sànchez (2005), “Wage gap and temporality in Spain”, University of Valencia, unpublished mimeo;

Frolich M. and B. Melly (2008), “Unconditional quantile treatment effects under endogeneity”, IZA discussion paper, n° 3288;

Frolich M. and B. Melly (2008), “Estimation of quantile treatment effects with STATA”, unpublished mimeo;

Graaf-Zijl M. D. (2005), “Compensation of On-Call and Fixed-Term Employment: The role of uncertainty”, Technical Report 120/3, Tinberg Institute, University of Amsterdam;

Hagen T. (2002), “Do Temporary Workers Receive Risk-Premiums? Assessing the Wage Effects of Fixed-Term Contracts in West-Germany by Matching Estimators Compared with Parametric Approaches”, Labour, 16, pp. 667-705;

Heckman J. J. (1978), “Dummy Endogenous Variables in a Simultaneous Equation System”, Econometrica, 46 (4), pp. 931-959;

Heckman J. J. (1979), “Sample Selection Bias As a Specification Error”, Econometrica, 47 (1), pp. 153-162;

Heinze A. (2007), “Going behind the gender wage gap: Are women less educated or are they in worse firms?”, EALE conferences, unpublished;

Hevenstone D. (2008), “European Labour Institutions and the Fixed Term Wage Gap”, unpublished mimeo;

Hu Y. and K. Tijdens (2003), “Fixed-term contracts in the Netherlands: who took them, how were they paid? The analysis using the linked employee-employer data”, unpublished mimeo;

Isae (2007), “Regimi di Protezione all’Impiego ed Effetti sul Mercato del Lavoro: L’evoluzione della Flessibilità in Italia”, in Rapporto ISAE, “Priorità nazionali, Ambiente normativo, Imprese, Competitività”, a cura di M. Mancini;

Janh E. J. (2008), “Reassessing the Wage Penalty for Temps in Germany”, IZA discussion paper, n°3663;

Jimeno J. F. and L. Toharia (1993), “The Effects of Fixed-term Employment on Wages: Theory and Evidence from Spain”, Investigaciones Economicas, Vol. XVII(3), pp. 475-494;

Koenker R and G. Basset (1978), “Regression Quantiles”, Econometrica, 46 (1), pp.33-50; Lopez-Nicolas A., Garcia J. and P. J. Hernandez (2001), “How wide is the gap? An investigation of gender wage differences using quantile regression”, Empirical Economics, 26 (1), pp. 149-167;

Machado J. and J. Mata (2005), “Counterfactual decomposition of changes in wage distributions using quantile regression”, Journal of Applied Econometrics, 20, pp. 445-465;

Melly B. (2005), “Decomposition of differences in distribution using quantile regression”, Labour Economics 12, pp. 577-590;

Melly B. (2005), “Public-private sector wage differentials in Germany: Evidence from quantile regression”, Empirical Economics, 30, pp. 505-520;

Melly B. (2006), “Public and private sector wage distributions controlling for endogenous sector choice”, unpublished mimeo;

Melly B. (2007), “Rqdeco: A Stata module to decompose difference in distribution”, mimeo, University of St. Gallen, http://www.alexandria.unisg.ch/Publikationen/40161

Mertens A. and F. McGinnity (2003), “A “Two-Tier” Labour Market for Fixed-Term Jobs? Evaluating Evidence from West Germany Using Quantile Regression” Working Paper n°1,project “Employment Relationship at Risk”;

Mertens A., Gash V. and F. McGinnity (2007), “The Cost of Flexibility at the Margin. Comparing the Wage Penalty for Fixed-term Contracts in Germany and Spain using Quantile Regression”, Labour 21 (4/5), pp. 637-666;

Naticchioni P., Ricci A. and E. Rustichelli (2008), “Wage Inequality, Employment Structure and Skill-biased Change in Italy”, Labour, 22 (special issue), pp. 27-51;

Picchio M. (2006), “Wage Differentials and Temporary Jobs in Italy”, Departement des Sciences Economiques, UCL Discussion Paper No. 33;

Picchio M. (2006), “Wage Differentials between Temporary and Pemanent Workers in Italy”, Quaderni di Ricerca No. 257, Università Politecnica delle Marche, Dipartimento di Economia;

Tanda P. and S. Rossetti (2007), “Flessibilità, contratti di lavoro e differenziali salariali”, Politica Economica, n°1;

Van der Wiel K. (2008), “Better Protected, Better Paid: Evidence on How Employment Protection Affects Wages”, IZA Discussion Paper, No. 3352;