How better monetary statistics could have signaled the financial crisis

Barnett, William A. and Chauvet, Marcelle (2010): How better monetary statistics could have signaled the financial crisis.

Abstract

This paper explores the disconnect of Federal Reserve data from index number theory. A consequence could have been the decreased systemic-risk misperceptions that contributed to excess risk taking prior to the housing bust. We find that most recessions in the past 50 years were preceded by more contractionary monetary policy than indicated by simple-sum monetary data. Divisia monetary aggregate growth rates were generally lower than simple-sum aggregate growth rates in the period preceding the Great Moderation, and higher since the mid 1980s. Monetary policy was more contractionary than likely intended before the 2001 recession and more expansionary than likely intended during the subsequent recovery.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Measurement error, monetary aggregation, Divisia index, aggregation, monetary policy, index number theory, financial crisis, great moderation, Federal Reserve.
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C4 - Econometric and Statistical Methods: Special Topics > C43 - Index Numbers and Aggregation; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E32 - Business Fluctuations ; Cycles; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E58 - Central Banks and Their Policies; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E52 - Monetary Policy; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E4 - Money and Interest Rates > E40 - General

References

Barnett, W.A., 1978, The User Cost of Money. Economics Letter 1, 145-149. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and A. Serletis, (Eds.), 2000, The Theory of Monetary Aggregation, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 1, pp. 6-10.

Barnett, W.A., 1980, Economic Monetary Aggregates: An Application of Aggregation and Index Number Theory. Journal of Econometrics 14, 11-48. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and A. Serletis, (Eds.), 2000, The Theory of Monetary Aggregation, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 1, pp. 6-10.

Barnett, W.A., 1982, The Optimal level of Monetary Aggregation. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 14, 687-710. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and A. Serletis, (Eds.), 2000, The Theory of Monetary Aggregation, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 7, pp. 125-149.

Barnett, W.A., 1983, Understanding the New Divisia Monetary Aggregate. Review of Public Data Use 11, 349-355. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and A. Serletis, (Eds.), 2000, The Theory of Monetary Aggregation, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 4, pp. 100-108.

Barnett, W.A., 1984, Recent Monetary Policy and the Divisia Monetary Aggregates. American Statistician 38, 162-172. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and A. Serletis, (Eds.), 2000, The Theory of Monetary Aggregation, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 23, pp. 563-576.

Barnett, W.A., 1987, The Microeconomic Theory of Monetary Aggregation, in W.A. Barnett and Kenneth Singleton, (Eds.), New Approaches to Monetary Economics, Cambridge U. Press. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and A. Serletis, (Eds.), 2000, The Theory of Monetary Aggregation, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 3, pp. 49-99.

Barnett, W.A., 1997, Which Road Leads to Stable Money Demand? The Economic Journal 107, 1171-1185. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and A. Serletis, (Eds.), 2000, The Theory of Monetary Aggregation, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 24, pp. 577-592.

Barnett, W.A., 2000, A Reply to Julio J. Rotemberg. In: Belongia, M.T. (ed) Monetary policy on the 75th Anniversary of the Federal Reserve System. Boston: Kluwer Academic, 232-244 (1991). Reprinted in: Barnett, W.A., A. Serletis, (Eds.) The Theory of Monetary Aggregation. Amsterdam: North Holland, chapter 14, pp. 296-30.

Barnett, W.A., 2007, Multilateral Aggregation-Theoretic Monetary Aggregation over Heterogeneous Countries. Journal of Econometrics 136, 2, 457-482.

Barnett, W. A., 2009, Who’s Looking at the Fed’s Books? , New York Times, October 22, 2009, p. A35.

Barnett, W. A, 2011, Getting It Wrong: How Faulty Monetary Statistics Undermine the Fed, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, forthcoming.

Barnett, W. A. and M. Chauvet, 2010, Financial Aggregation and Index Number Theory: A Survey, World Scientific, Singapore, forthcoming.

Barnett, W.A. and J.H. Hahm, 1994, Financial Firm Production of Monetary Services: A Generalized Symmetric Barnett Variable Profit Function Approach. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 12, 33-46. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and J. Binner, (Eds.), 2004, Functional Structure and Approximation in Econometrics, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 15, pp. 351-380.

Barnett, W.A. and P. Peretti, 2008, A Necessary and Sufficient Stochastic Semi-Nonparametric Test for Weak Separability. Macroeconomic Dynamics, pp. 317-334.

Barnett, W.A. and A. Serletis (eds), 2000, The Theory of Monetary Aggregation, Contributions to Economic Analysis Monograph Series, Elsevier, Amsterdam.

Barnett, W.A. and S. Wu, 2005, On user costs of risky monetary assets. Annals of Finance 1, 35-50.

Barnett, W.A. and H. Xu, 1998, Stochastic Volatility in Interest Rates and Nonlinearity in Velocity. International Journal of Systems Science 29, 1189-1201.

Barnett, W.A. and G. Zhou, 1994a, Partition of M2+ as a Joint Product: Commentary, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review 76, 53-62.

Barnett, W.A. and G. Zhou, 1994b, Financial Firm’s Production and Supply-Side Monetary Aggregation under Dynamic Uncertainty. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review, March/April, 133-165. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and J. Binner, (Eds.), 2004, Functional Structure and Approximation in Econometrics, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 16, pp. 381-427.

Barnett, W.A., U. Chae, and J. Keating, 2006, The Discounted Economic Stock of Money with VAR Forecasting. Annals of Finance 2, 2, 229-258.

Barnett, William A, M. Chauvet, and H.L.R. Tierney, 2009, Measurement Error in Monetary Aggregates: A Markov Switching Factor Approach, Macroeconomic Dynamics 13, Supplement 2, 381-412.

Barnett, W.A, M.J. Hinich, and W.E. Weber, 1986, The Regulatory Wedge between the Demand-Side and Supply-Side Aggregation-Theoretic Monetary Aggregates. Journal of Econometrics 33, 165-185. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and A. Serletis, (Eds.), 2000, The Theory of Monetary Aggregation, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 19, pp. 433-453.

Barnett, W., Fisher, D. and A. Serletis, 1992, Consumer Theory and the Demand for Money. Journal of Economic Literature 30, 2086–119. Reprinted in Barnett and Serletis (2000, ch. 18, pp. 389-427).

Barnett, W.A., Y. Liu, and M. Jensen, 1997, “CAPM Risk Adjustment for Exact Aggregation over Financial Assets,” Macroeconomic Dynamics 1, 485–512.

Barnett, W.A., E.K. Offenbacher, and P.A. Spindt, 1984, The New Divisia Monetary Aggregates. Journal of Political Economy 92, 1049-1085. Reprinted in W.A. Barnett and A. Serletis (eds.), 2000, The Theory of Monetary Aggregation, North Holland, Amsterdam, ch. 17, pp. 360-388.

Batchelor, R., 1989. A Monetary Services Index for the UK, Mimeo, Department of Economics, City University, London.

Belongia, M., 1996, Measurement Matters: Recent Results from Monetary Economics Reexamined. Journal of Political Economy 104, 5, 1065-1083.

Belongia, M. and J. Binner, (Eds), 2000, Divisia Monetary Aggregates: Theory and Practice. Basingstoke: Palgrave.

Belongia, M. and A. Chrystal, 1991, An Admissible Monetary Aggregate for the United Kingdom. Review of Economics and Statistics 73, 497-503.

Belongia, M. and P. Ireland, 2006, The Own-Price of Money and the Channels of Monetary Transmission. Journal of Money Credit and Banking 38, 2, 429-445.

Belongia, M. and P. Ireland, 2010, The Barnett Critique After Three Decades: A New Keynesian Analysis, Journal of Econometrics, forthcoming.

Bernanke, B., 2006, Monetary Aggregates and Monetary Policy at the Federal Reserve: A Historical Perspective, Speech at the Fourth ECB Central Banking Conference, Frankfurt, Germany, November.

Chauvet, M., 1998, An Econometric Characterization of Business Cycle Dynamics with Factor Structure and Regime Switches. International Economic Review 39, 4, 969-96.

Chauvet, M., 2001, A Monthly Indicator of Brazilian GDP. Brazilian Review of Econometrics 21, 1, 1-15.

Chauvet, M. and J. Piger, 2008, A Comparison of the Real-Time Performance of Business Cycle Dating Methods. Journal of Business Economics and Statistics 26, 1, 42-49.

Chetty, K. V., 1969, On Measuring the Nearness of Near-Moneys. American Economic Review 59, 270-281.

Chrystal, A. and R. MacDonald, 1994, Empirical Evidence on the Recent Behaviour and Usefulness of Simple-Sum and Weighted Measures of the Money Stock. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review 76, 73–109.

Cockerline, J. and J. Murray, 1981, A Comparison of Alternative Methods for Monetary Aggregation: Some Preliminary Evidence. Technical Report #28, Bank of Canada.

Deaton, A. and J. N. Muellbauer, 1980, Economics and Consumer Behavior. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Diewert, W. E., 1974, Intertemporal Consumer Theory and the Demand for Durables. Econometrica 42, 497–516.

Diewert, W. E., 1976, Exact and Superlative Index Numbers. Journal of Econometrics, 4, 115–45.

Diewert, W. E., 1978, Superlative Index Numbers and Consistency in Aggregation. Econometrica 46, 883-900.

Divisia, F., 1925, L’Indice monétaire et la théorie de la monnaie. Revue d’Economie Politique 39, 980–1008.

Donovan, D., 1978, Modeling the Demand for Liquid Assets: An Application to Canada. IMF Staff Papers, 25, 676-704.

Drake, L., 1992. The Substitutability of Financial Assets in the U.K. and the Implication for Monetary Aggregation. Manchester School of Economics and Social Studies 60, 221-248.

Fase, M., 1985. Monetary Control: The Dutch Experience: Some Reflections on the Liquidity Ratio, in: Monetary Conditions for Economic Recovery, C. van Ewijk and J. J. Klant, (Eds.), Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff, pp. 95-125. Feenstra, Robert C., 1986, Functional Equivalence between Liquidity Costs and the Utility of Money. Journal of Monetary Economics 17:2, 271-291.

Fisher, I., 1922, The Making of Index Numbers: A Study of their Varieties, Tests, and Reliability, Boston: Houghton Mifflin.

Friedman, M. and A. Schwartz, 1970, Monetary Statistics of the United States: Estimation, Sources, Methods, and Data, Columbia University Press, New York.

Goldfeld, S.M., 1973, The Demand for Money Revisited. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 3, 577-638.

Hancock, D., 1985a, Bank Profitability, Interest Rates, and Monetary Policy. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 17, 189-202.

Hancock, D., 1985b, The Financial Firm: Production with Monetary and Nonmonetary Goods. Journal of Political Economy 93, 859-80.

Hancock, D., A Theory of Production for the Financial Firm. Norwell, Massachusetts: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1991.

Hicks, J.R., 1946, Value and Capital, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Hoa, T.V, 1985, A Divisia System Approach to Modelling Monetary Aggregates. Economics Letters 17, 365-368.

Hutt, W. H, 1963, Keynesianism – Retrospect and Prospect. Regnery, Chicago.

International Monetary Fund, Monetary and Financial Statistics: Compilation Guide. International Monetary Fund Publication Services, Washington, DC, 2008, 183-184.

Ishida, K., 1984. Divisia Monetary Aggregates and the Demand for Money: A Japanese Case. Bank of Japan Monetary and Economic Studies 2, 49-80.

Jones, B., D. Dutkowsky, and T. Elger, 2005, Sweep Programs and Optimal Monetary Aggregation. Journal of Banking and Finance 29, 483–508.

Lucas, R.E., 2000, Inflation and Welfare. Econometrica 68, 62, 247-274.

Rotemberg, J. J., J. C. Driscoll, and J. M. Poterba, 1995, Money, Output, and Prices: Evidence from a New Monetary Aggregate. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 13, 67-83.

Rayton, B. A. and K. Pavlyk, 2010, On the Recent Divergence between Measures of the Money Supply in the UK. Economics Letter 108, August, 159-162.

Serletis, A. (ed.), 2006, Money and the Economy, World Scientific.

Schunk, D., 2001, The Relative Forecasting Performance of the Divisia and Simple Sum Monetary Aggregates. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 33, 2, 272-283.

Swamy, P.A.V.B. and P. Tinsley, 1980, Linear Prediction and Estimation Methods for Regression Models with Stationary Stochastic Coefficients. Journal of Econometrics 12, 103-42.

Yue, P. and R. Fluri, 1991, Divisia Monetary Services Indexes for Switzerland: Are They Useful for Monetary Targeting? Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review 73, 19-33.