The long-term effects of development aid - Empirical studies in rural West Africa.

Bierschenk, Thomas and Elwert, Georg and Kohnert, Dirk (1991): The long-term effects of development aid - Empirical studies in rural West Africa. Published in: Economics, Biannual Journal of the Institute for Scientific Co-operation, Tübingen , Vol. 47, No. 1 (1993): pp. 83-111.

Abstract

This article is based on field studies in rural West Africa. It concentrates on the socio-structural effects of development aid in the long run, in contrast to numerous available evaluation reports on the short-run effects of development projects. The study reveals that superficial generalisations or condemnations of development projects, like the big farmers benefit at the expense of the smaller ones, or the men benefit at the expense of the women, do not hold up to verification. Quite to the contrary one observes a wide range of specific adapted forms by which the target groups react to the demands and offers of development projects, and thereby transform their own social structure. In short, one observes a great diversity of social self-organisation. The bureaucratic structures of the development administration do, however, unfortunately - more often than not - ignore the social dynamic of their target groups which they nevertheless sustain unconsciously. Development aid has become an important political and economic factor in most African countries. Its financial impact often exceeds that of the national budget. It contributes, therefore, significantly to the development of a bureaucratic class and of its clients: the project development degenerates into a project nationalization / bureaucratization. This contrasts vividly with the strategies of the peasants. Men and women at village level do not accept any longer the paternalistic development approach. They just select what they need out of the packages of solutions that are offered to them, while they develop their own solutions, like a variety of seeds adapted to their specific resource endowments, diversified sources of income, different strategies of accumulation and risk prevention. All this allows for a gradual evolution by variation and selection. The dynamic of the rural society is to a large extent due to a competition of different (strategic) groups, opposed to one another, about the partitioning of the cake of development aid. Normally this struggle between different vested interests is covered up by the rhetoric of development planning. Planned development has up to now proven to be to rigid, to be able to take account of the complex and subtle fabric of self organisation. Aid sometimes appears to be a second best substitute for a vision of a democratic society. This is due to the fact that the structures we are aiming for in the long run - which are to allow for open markets, an orientation of the producers at the resources and needs of the nation, and last not least, the growth of indigenous structures of self-help - would require a responsible and democratic government, as well as the guarantee of civil rights, accountability, an independent judiciary, freedom of the press, etc.; up to now, however, all these elements are still oppressed by the commando state itself, well nourished by the various forms of technical and financial aid.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: GIGA - German Institute of Global and Area Studies / Institute of African Affairs
• Language: English
• Keywords: development cooperation; ODA; evaluation; Africa; social structure
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N1 - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics ; Industrial Structure ; Growth ; Fluctuations > N17 - Africa ; Oceania; F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance > F35 - Foreign Aid; A - General Economics and Teaching > A1 - General Economics > A14 - Sociology of Economics; Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R5 - Regional Government Analysis > R58 - Regional Development Planning and Policy; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O2 - Development Planning and Policy > O22 - Project Analysis; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O5 - Economywide Country Studies > O55 - Africa; P - Economic Systems > P5 - Comparative Economic Systems > P52 - Comparative Studies of Particular Economies; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O17 - Formal and Informal Sectors ; Shadow Economy ; Institutional Arrangements

References

AGOSSOU, CHRISTIAN (1987): Differentiation intrafamiliale et systeme de production - Le cas du District rural de Kpomasse, Province de 1'Atlanti-que, Rep. du Benin, unpublished project report, Inst. f. Ethnologic, FU Berlin.

AHOHOUNKPANZON, MlCHA£L: Ausbildung zur Arbeitsmigration: Der Jungbauernverein von Ayou, ein Vorführprojekt in Dahomey/Benin, in: Bierschenk/Elwert (in print).

ALTHEIM, F. (1962): Entwicklungshilfe im Altertum. Die grossen Reiche und ihre Nachbarn, Reinbek 1962.

AMSELLE, JEAN L. (1988): Le developpement vu du village, in: Elwert/ Bierschenk; pp. 176-181.

ASCH, SUSAN (1983): L'Eglise du Prophete Kimbangu. De ses Origines a son Role Actuel au Zaire, 1921-1981, Paris, Karthala.

ATHAWET, GERVAIS (1987): Monetarisation des rapports sociaux et develop¬pement rural dans une communaute semi-lacustre du bas-Benin, unpub¬lished project report, Institute of Ethnology, FU-Berlin.

BATES, R. H. (1983): Essays on the Political Economy of Rural Africa, Cambridge.

BAYART, JEAN F. (1989): L'etat en Afrique, Paris.

BECK, KURT: Entwicklungshilfe als Beute, in: Orient, 31.1991.4; pp. 583-601.

BIERSCHENK, THOMAS: (1984): Weltmarkt, Stammesgesellschaft und Staatsformation in Südostarabien, Saarbrücken.

BIERSCHENK, THOMAS: Baumwollanbau und gesellschaftliche Entwicklung in Benin, in: Sociologus 37.1987; pp. 155-174.

BIERSCHENK, THOMAS (1988): Development projects as arenas of negotiation of strategic groups. A case study from Benin, in Elwert/Bierschenk.

BIERSCHENK, THOMAS (1989):Vorwärts mit der Tradition der Fulbe. Zur Genese einer ethnisch-politischen Bewegung unter den Fulbe Nord-Benins, in: Sozialanthropologische Arbeitspapiere, No. 20, FU Berlin.

BIERSCHENK, THOMAS: Les projets et les politiques de developpement, font-ils des preoccupations legitimes de Panthropologie? Bulletin de 1'Associa-tion Euro-Africaine pour 1'Anthropologie du Changement Sociale et du Developpement (ADAP), 1. June 1991; pp. 12-14.

BIERSCHENK, THOMAS: Rational Herdsmen. Economic strategies of the agro-pastoral Fulani of Northern Benin, in: Applied Geography and Develop¬ment (in publication).

BIERSCHENK, T. - R. FORSTER: Die gesellschaftliche Organisation der Fulbe im östlichen Atakora / V. R. Benin, in: Sozialanthropologische Arbeitspapiere, No. 3, Berlin 1987, Publisher: "Das arabische Buch".

BIERSCHENK. T. - P. SAUER - H. SCHAFFT (1989): Planspiel zur entwicklungspolitischen Projektpraxis. Ein Beitrag zur Entdämonisierung der Entwicklungshilfe, in: Sozialanthropologische Arbeitspapiere, No. 23, FU Berlin.

BIERSCHENK, T. - G. ELWERT (Eds.): Folgen der Entwicklungshilfe im ländlichen Afrika, Frankfurt, in preparation, Campus.

BOIRAL, P. - J. F. LANTERI - J. P. OLF/IER DE SARDON (Eds.) (1985): Paysans, experts et chercheurs en Afrique noire: sciences et developpement rural, Paris Karthala.

CERNEA, MICHAEL (Ed.) (1985): Putting people first. Sociological variables in rural development. Oxford (2nd edn. 1991).

CHAUVEAU, JEAN-PIERRE: L'avenir d'une illusion: histoire de la production et des politiques vivrieres en Cote d'lvoire, in: Etudes rurales, 99/100.1985; pp. 281-325.

CREHAN, KATE - ACHIM V. OPPEN (1988): Understandings of Development: An Arena of Struggle. The Story of a Development Project in Zambia, in: Elwert/Bierschenk 1988; pp. 113-145.

EGA (1989): African Alternative Framework to Structural Adjustment: Programmes for Socio-Economic Recovery and Transformation. UN Economic Recovery and Transformation. UN Economic Commission for Africa (EGA), Addis Abeba.

EIU (1990): Country Reports, The Economist Intelligence Unit, London 1990.

ELWERT, GEORG (1983a): Bauern und Staat in Westafrika, Frankfurt, Campus.

ELWERT, GEORG (1983b): Der entwicklungssoziologische Mythos vom Traditionalismus, in: GOETZE, D./H. WEILAND (Eds.), Soziokulturelle Implikationen technoiogischer Wandlungsprozesse, Saarbriicken

ELWERT, GEORG (1989): Nationalisms und Ethnizitat iiber die Bildung von Wir-Gruppen, in: Kolner Zeitschrift fur Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, 41; pp. 417-439.

ELWERT, GEORG (1990): Der Kommandostaat und seine Bauern, Paper given at the Congress of the European Society for Rural Sociology, Giessen July 1990.

ELWERT, G. - T. BIERSCHENK (1988b): Development aid as intervention into dynamic systems: An Introduction, in: ELWERT/BIERSCHENK.

ELWERT, G. - T. BIERSCHENK (Eds.) (1988b): Aid and Development, in: Sociologia Ruralis, 37, 2/3.

ELWERT G. - K. ELWERT-KRETSCHMER (1991): Mit den Augen der Beniner-Eine andere Evaluation von 25 Jahren,DED in Benin, DED Berlin.

ELWERT, G. - D. KOHNERT (1983): Sozio-strukturelle Auswirkungen von Entwicklungsprojekten im ländlichen Raum Westafrikas, Working Paper No. 35, Centre of development planning, University of Bielefeld.

FÖRSTER, TILL (1988): Islam als sozio-kultureller Faktor des Entwicklungs-zusammenhanges in der Republik Niger, Research Report for the BMZ, Bayreuth.

EVERS, HANS-DlETER - TlLMAN SCHIEL (1988): Strategische Gruppen. Ver-gleichende Studien zu Staat, Biirokratie und Klassenbildung in der Dntten Welt, Berlin, Reimer.

FRIEDRICH, BRUNO (1991): Die kleinstadtische Beamtenfamilie in Guinea-Bissau, in: Der Überblick, 2; pp. 98-99.

GESCHIERE, PETER - JOS KLEI (1986): African peasants against the state: Popular modes of political action and their implication for development projects, unpublished paper from the 13th European Congress on Rural Sociology, Braga, Portugal.

GRIFFIN, KEITH (1991): Foreign Aid after the Cold War, in: Development and Change, 22 4; pp. 645-686.

HOGENDORN, J. S. (1966): The Origins of the Groundnut Trade in Northern Nigeria, PhD thesis, Univ. of London.

KREMER, GABRIELE (1987): Auswirkungen von Entwicklungshilfemassnahmen und staatlichen Entwicklungsprojekten auf die Kultur der Viehzüchter-Fulbe in Niger, am Beispiel der Wodaalae, unpublished project report, FU-Berlin.

KOHNERT, DIRK (1982): Klassenbildung im ländlichen Nigeria, Arbeiten aus dem Institut fur Afrika-Kunde. No. 42, Hamburg.

KOHNERT, DIRK (1983): Indicators of social and political conflict in African societies: On the articulation of witchcraft among the Nupe, Northern Nigeria, Working Paper No. 32, Center of development sociology, Univ. of Bielefeld.

KOHNERT, DIRK (1988): Socialism without liberation. Land reclamation projects in Guinea-Bissau, in: Sociologia Ruralis 2/3; pp. 161-175.

KOHNERT, DIRK (1990): Drill statt Beratung? - Zum Aufstieg und Fall des training und visit-Systems im landwirtschaftlichen Beratungsdienst Westafrikas, in: Entwicklung und ländlicher Raum 4; pp. 26-28.

KOHNERT, D. - H. J. A. PREUSS (1990): ZOPP in der Projektpraxis, in: Sozialanthropologische Arbeitspapiere, No. 25, FU-Berlin

LAABS, JOHANNES (1987): Regenzeit gleich Hungerzeit? - Zum Wandel reproduktiver Strategien von Reisproduzenten in Marainpa, Sierra Leone, Sociology Degree Thesis, Univ. of Bielefeld.

LACHENMANN, GUDRUN (1988): Development policy and survival strategies in the zone lacustre in Mali, in: Sociologia Ruralis 2/3; pp. 182-197.

LENTZ, CAROLA (1988): Why the most incompetent are on the village council. Development projects in an Indian village in Ecuador, in: Sociologia Ruralis 2/3; pp. 199-215.

LILLEY, S. (1973): Technical progress and the Industrial Revolution, 1700-1914, in: C. M. Cipolla, The Industrial Revolution (The Fontana Economic History of Europe. 3), London; pp. 187-254.

LONG, NORMAN: Handlung, Struktur und Schnittstelle: Theoretische Reflec-rionen, in: Bierschenk/Elwert, in preparation.

LONG, NORMAN (Ed.) (1990): Encounters at the Interface. A perspective on social discontinuities in rural development, Wageningen Sociological Studies, No. 22, Wageningen.

LÜHE, NIKO V. D. (1991): Transfer of technology or barter trade? - The rural extension service in the Atlantic Province of Benin as a market for negotiating resources, in: Quarterly Journal of Intern. Agriculture, 30 3; pp. 248-263.

MEISSNER, RICARDA (1990): Plantagenarbeit, Cash-Crop-Anbau und Kor-ruption. Beobachtungen auf einer Baumwollplantage in Nordbenin, unpubl. Master's thesis, Institute of Ethnology, FU-Berlin.

METZ, VOLKER (1986): Nutzung traditioneller und neuer Agrartechnologie in 30 Distrikten von Sierra Leone, unpublished project report, Univ. of Bielefeld.

MÖNIKES, VOLKER (1988): Die Planung von Entwicklung und die Entwick-lung der Verplanten - Schichten - und kulturspezifische Auswirkungen von Entwicklungsprojekten in Benue-State, Nigeria. Thesis, Univ. of Bielefeld, Faculty of Sociology, Centre of development planning.

NEUBERT, DIETER (1990): Von der traditionellen Solidaritat zur Nicht-Regierungs-Organisation. Eine Steuerungstheoretische Analyse von For-men der Solidaritat in Kenya, in: Kohl, K. H. et al. (Eds.), Die Vielfalt der Kultur. Ethnologische Aspekte von Verwandtschaft, Kunst und Weltauffassung, Berlin; pp. 548-571.

NORRIS, E. G.: Die Unfahigkeit der Entwicklungshilfe, aus ihrer eigenen Geschichte zu lernen: Die vergessenen Erfahrungen der deutschen kolonia-len Ackerbauschule in Togo, in: Bierschenk/Elwert, in preparation.

OBBELODE, MARITA (1988): Der weisse Fluss und was aus ihm geworden ist. Soziostrukturelle Auswirkungen eines Entwicklungsprojektes im Senufo-Land, unpublished project report, Institute of Ethnology, FU-Berlin.

OLIVIER DE SARDAN, JEAN-PIERRE (1985): Paysans, experts et chercheurs en Afrique Noire, Sciences sociales et developpement rurale, Paris.

OLIVIER DE SARDAN, JEAN-PIERRE (1991): L'ethnologie du changement social et du developpement comme ambition theonque, in: Bulletin de I'ADAP 1; pp. 7-11.

OLIVIER DE SARDAN, JEAN-PIERRE: Bauerliche Logiken und die Logiken der Entwicklungshilfe, in: Bierschenk/Elwert, in preparation

PETERS, UWE (1987): Wandel der Strategien des Erwerbes von Reichtum und Status bei den Temne in Sierra Leone, Sociology Degree Thesis, Univ. of Bielefeld.

RAUCH, THEO: Der Zynismus in der Entwicklungspolitik - Macht und Ohnmacht des Entwicklungsplaners, in: Bierschenk/Elwert, in preparation.

RIBEIRO, R. - C. CARDOSO (1988): Bemerkungen zu den sozialökonomischen Strukturen der Agrargesellschaften in Guinea-Bissau und ihrem historischen Wandel - eine Fallstudie, in: Meyns, P. (Ed.), Agrargesellschaften im portugiesisch-sprachigen Afrika, Breitenbach, Saarbrücken; pp. 155-176.

RICHARDS, PAUL (1985): Indigenous Agricultural Revolution: Ecology and Food Production in West Africa, London.

RICHARDS, PAUL (1986): Coping with' Hunger: Hazard and Experiment in an African Rice Farming System, London.

RICHARDS, PAUL: Die Vielseitigkeit der Armen. Einheimische Feuchdandbe-wirtschaftung in Sierra Leone, in: Bierschenk/Elwert, in print.

SCHERLER, CRISTINA (1987): Auswirkungen der Entwicklungshilfe auf sozioökonomische Strukturen kleinbäuerlicher Haushalte am Beispiel Sierra Leones, unpublished project report, FU-Berlin.

SCOTT, JAMES C. (1976): The moral economy of the peasant. Rebellion and Subsistence in Southeast Asia, New Haven/London.

SIMSHAUSER, ULLA - ELISABETH FOURN (1990): Avec le secouriste c'est la securite - über Sinn.und Unsinn von Dorfgesundheitshelfern, in: Sozialan-thropologische Arbeitspapiere, No. 23, Berlin, "Arabisches Buch".

SPITTLER, GERD (1982): Verwaltung in einem afrikanischen Bauernstaat, Wiesbaden.

SPITTLER, GERD: Handeln in Diirren und Hungerkrisen. Die Kel Ewey Tuareg: Opfer der Akteure, in: Bierschenk/Elwert, in print.

STREIFFELER, FRIEDHELM - M. MBAYA: Endogene Entwicklungsvorstellun-gen in Zaire, in: Bierschenk/Elwert, in print.

UNDP (1991): The Human Development Report 1991, OUP, Oxford.

WALSH, V. - H. GRAM (1980): Classical and neoclassical Theories of General Equilibrium — Historical Origins and Mathematical Structures, OUP, Oxford.

WHITEMAN, KAYE (1991): Lords, Samaritans and Gangsters, in: West Africa; pp. 1402-1403.

WORLD BANK (1991): World Development Report 1991, IBRD/World Bank, Washington.

ZITELMANN, THOMAS (1988): "We have nobody in the agencies". Somali and Oromo response to relief aid in refugee camps [Hiraan region/Somali Democratic Republic], in: Sozialanthropologische Arbeitspapiere, No. 17, FU-Berlin.

ZITELMANN, THOMAS (1989): Soziostrukturelle Auswirkungen der Enrwick-lungshilfe im landlichen Raum Westafnkas, (unpublished) final report to the Volkswagen Foundation on the research project of the Institute of Ethno¬logy at the Free University, Berlin.