The Oil Price Crash in 2014/15: Was There a (Negative) Financial Bubble?

Fantazzini, Dean (2016): The Oil Price Crash in 2014/15: Was There a (Negative) Financial Bubble? Forthcoming in: Energy Policy (2016)

Abstract

This paper suggests that there was a negative bubble in oil prices in 2014/15, which decreased them beyond the level justified by economic fundamentals. This proposition is corroborated by two sets of bubble detection strategies: the first set consists of tests for financial bubbles, while the second set consists of the log-periodic power law (LPPL) model for negative financial bubbles. Despite the methodological differences between these detection methods, they provided the same outcome: the oil price experienced a statistically significant negative financial bubble in the last months of 2014 and at the beginning of 2015. These results also hold after several robustness checks which consider the effect of conditional heteroskedasticity, model set-ups with additional restrictions, longer data samples, tests with lower frequency data and with an alternative proxy variable to measure the fundamental value of oil.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Oil, WTI, Brent, Generalized sup ADF test, LPPL, Bubble
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General > C15 - Statistical Simulation Methods: General; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C2 - Single Equation Models ; Single Variables > C22 - Time-Series Models ; Dynamic Quantile Regressions ; Dynamic Treatment Effect Models ; Diffusion Processes; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C5 - Econometric Modeling > C51 - Model Construction and Estimation; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C5 - Econometric Modeling > C53 - Forecasting and Prediction Methods ; Simulation Methods; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G17 - Financial Forecasting and Simulation; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O13 - Agriculture ; Natural Resources ; Energy ; Environment ; Other Primary Products; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy > Q47 - Energy Forecasting

References

Areal, F. J., K. Balcombe, and G. Rapsomanikis (2013): Testing for bubbles in agriculture com modity markets, Discussion paper, ESA Working Papers. 14.

Arezki, R., and O. Blanchard (2014): Seven Questions about the Recent Oil Price Slump, IMFdirect - The IMF Blog, December 22, 2014.

Arouri, M. E. H., and D. K. Nguyen (2010): Oil prices, stock markets and portfolio investment: evidence from sector analysis in Europe over the last decade, Energy Policy, 38(8), 4528–4539.

Awartani, B., and A. I. Maghyereh (2013): Dynamic spillovers between oil and stock markets in the Gulf Cooperation Council Countries, Energy Economics, 36, 28–42.

Baffes, J., M. Kose, F. Ohnsorge, and M. Stocker (2015): The great plunge in oil prices: Causes, consequences, and policy responses. World Bank Group, Development Economics.

Barsky, R. B., and L. Kilian (2002): Do we really know that oil caused the great stagflation? A monetary alternative, in NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2001, Volume 16, pp. 137–198. MIT Press.

Baumeister, C., and L. Kilian (2016): Understanding the Decline in the Price of Oil since June 2014, Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists, forthcoming.

Bhattacharya, U., N. Galpin, R. Ray, and X. Yu (2009): The role of the media in the internet IPO bubble, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 44(03), 657–682.

Bothmer, H.-C. G. v., and C. Meister (2003): Predicting critical crashes? A new restriction for the free variables, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its pplications, 320, 539–547.

Case, K. E., and R. J. Shiller (2003): Is there a bubble in the housing market?, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 2003(2), 299–362.

Caspi, I., N. Katzke, and R. Gupta (2015): Date stamping historical periods of oil price explosivity: 1876–2014, Energy Economics, forthcoming.

Collins, D. (2010): CFTC steps up on limits. Futures: news, analysis & strategies for futures, Option Derivatives Traders, 39(2), 14.

Corsi, F., and D. Sornette (2014): Follow the money: The monetary roots of bubbles and crashes, International Review of Financial Analysis, 32, 47–59.

Cosgrove, M. (2009): Banishing energy speculators is not the solution, FOW: Global Derivatives Management, 454, 39.

Creti, A., M. Joe¨ts, and V. Mignon (2013): On the links between stock and commodity markets’ volatility, Energy Economics, 37, 16–28.

Diebold, F. X., and K. Yilmaz (2012): Better to give than to receive: Predictive directional measure- ment of volatility spillovers, International Journal of forecasting, 28(1), 57–66.

Domanski, D., J. Kearns, M. J. Lombardi, and H. S. Shin (2015): Oil and Debt, BIS Quarterly Review, March, 55–65.

Dutt, H. R., and L. E. Harris (2005): Position limits for cash-settled derivative contracts, Journal of Futures Markets, 25(10), 945–965.

Dyck, A., and L. Zingales (2003): The bubble and the media, in Corporate governance and capital flows in a global economy, ed. by P. Cornelius, and B. Kogut, pp. 83–104. Oxford University Press.

EIA (2015): STEO, http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/steo/.

Fantazzini, D. (2010): THE HANDBOOK OF TRADING,chap. Modelling bubbles and anti-bubbles in bear markets: a medium-term trading analysis, pp. 365–388. McGraw-Hill Finance and Investing.

Figuerola-Ferretti, I., C. Gilbert, and J. Mccrorie (2016): Testing For Mild Explosivity And Bubbles In LME Non-Ferrous Metals Prices, Journal of Time Series Analysis, forthcoming.

Figuerola-Ferretti, I., and J. Gonzalo (2010): Modelling and measuring price discovery in com- modity markets, Journal of Econometrics, 158(1), 95–107.

Filimonov, V., and D. Sornette (2013): A stable and robust calibration scheme of the log-periodic power law model, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 392(17), 3698–3707.

Filis, G., S. Degiannakis, and C. Floros (2011): Dynamic correlation between stock market and oil prices: The case of oil-importing and oil-exporting countries, International Review of Financial Analysis, 20(3), 152–164.

Geraskin, P., and D. Fantazzini (2013): Everything you always wanted to know about log-periodic power laws for bubble modeling but were afraid to ask, The European Journal of Finance, 19(5),366–391.

Gilbert, C. L. (2010): Speculative influence on commodity prices 2006–08, Discussion paper, Discussion Paper 197, United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), Geneva.

Gomes, M., and A. Chaibi (2014): Volatility Spillovers Between Oil Prices And Stock Returns: A Focus On Frontier Markets, Journal of Applied Business Research, 30(2), 509–526. 23

Hamilton, J. D. (2009a): Causes and Consequences of the Oil Shock of 2007-08, Discussion paper, National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No. 15002.

Hamilton, J. D (2009b): Understanding crude oil prices, Energy Journal, 30(2), 179–206.

Hamilton, J. D (2011): Historical oil shocks, Discussion paper, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Hamilton, J. D (2014): Oil prices as an indicator of global economic conditions, Econbrowser Blog entry, December 14, 2014.

Harvey, D. I., S. J. Leybourne, R. Sollis, and A. R. Taylor (2016): Tests for Explosive Financial Bubbles in the Presence of Non-stationary Volatility, Journal of Empirical Finance, forthcoming.

Homm, U., and J. Breitung (2012): Testing for speculative bubbles in stock markets: a comparison of alternative methods, Journal of Financial Econometrics, 10(1), 198–231.

Ji, Q., and Y. Fan (2012): How does oil price volatility affect non-energy commodity markets?, Applied Energy, 89(1), 273–280.

Jiang, Z.-Q., W.-X. Zhou, D. Sornette, R. Woodard, K. Bastiaensen, and P. Cauwels (2010): Bubble diagnosis and prediction of the 2005–2007 and 2008–2009 Chinese stock market bubbles, Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 74(3), 149–162.

Johansen, A. (2003): Characterization of large price variations in financial markets, Physica A: Statis- tical Mechanics and its Applications, 324(1), 157–166.

Johansen, A., O. Ledoit, and D. Sornette (2000): Crashes as critical points, International Journal of Theoretical and Applied Finance, 3(2), 219–255.

Johansen, A., D. Sornette, and O. Ledoit (1999): Predicting Financial Crashes Using Discrete Scale Invariance, Journal of Risk, 1(4), 5–32.

Khalfaoui, R., M. Boutahar, and H. Boubaker (2015): Analyzing volatility spillovers and hedging between oil and stock markets: Evidence from wavelet analysis, Energy Economics, 49, 540–549.

Khan, M. S. (2009): The 2008 Oil Price Bubble, Discussion paper, Peterson Institute for International Economics Policy Brief, Washington, DC.

Kilian, L. (2008): The Economic Effects of Energy Price Shocks, Journal of Economic Literature, 46(4), 871–909.

Kilian, L., and D. Murphy (2014): The role of inventories and speculative trading in the global market for crude oil, Journal of Applied Econometrics, 29, 454–478.

Kumar, S., S. Managi, and A. Matsuda (2012): Stock prices of clean energy firms, oil and carbon markets: A vector autoregressive analysis, Energy Economics, 34(1), 215–226.

Kwiatkowski, D., P. Phillips, P. Schmidt, and Y. Shin (1992): Testing the null of stationarity against the alternative of a unit root: how sure are we that the economic time series have a unit root?, Journal of Econometrics, 54, 159–178.

Lammerding, M., P. Stephan, M. Trede, and B. Wilfling (2013): Speculative bubbles in recent oil price dynamics: Evidence from a Bayesian Markov-switching state-space approach, Energy Economics, 36, 491–502.

Lin, L., R. Ren, and D. Sornette (2014): The volatility-confined LPPL model: A consistent model of explosivefinancial bubbles with mean-reverting residuals, International Review of Financial Analysis, 33, 210–225.

Lombardi, M. J., and I. Van Robays (2011): Do financial investors destabilize the oil price?, Discus- sion paper, Working Paper Series No. 1346. European Central Bank, Frankfurt/Main.

Maugeri, L. (2010): Beyond the age of oil: the myths, realities, and future of fossil fuels and their alternatives. Praeger.

Phillips, P., and S. Shi (2014): Financial bubble implosion, Discussion paper.

Phillips, P., S. Shi, and J. Yu (2014): Specification Sensitivity in Right-Tailed Unit Root Testing for Explosive Behaviour, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 76(3), 315–333.

Phillips, P., S. Shi, and J. Yu (2015): Testing for Multiple Bubbles: Historical Episodes of Exuberance and Collapse in the SP500, International Economic Review, forthcoming.

Phillips, P., S. Shi, and J. Yu (2016): Testing for multiple bubbles: limit theory of real time detectors, International Economic Review, forthcoming.

Phillips, P., Y. Wu, and J. Yu (2011): Explosive Behavior In The 1990S Nasdaq: When Did Exuberance Escalate Asset Values?, International Economic Review, 52(1), 201–226.

Phillips, P., and J. Yu (2011): Dating the timeline of financial bubbles during the subprime crisis, Quantitative Economics, 2(3), 455–491.

Pindyck, R. S. (1992): The present value model of rational commodity pricing, Discussion paper, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Shi, S., and V. Arora (2012): An application of models of speculative behaviour to oil prices, Eco- nomics Letters, 115(3), 469–472.

Shiller, R. J. (2000): Irrational exuberance. Princeton University Press.

Shiller, R. J. (2002): Bubbles, human judgment, and expert opinion, Financial Analysts Journal, 58(3),18–26.

Sornette, D. (2003): Why stock markets crash: critical events in complex financial systems. Princeton University Press.

Sornette, D., A. Johansen, et al. (2001): Significance of log-periodic precursors to financial crashes, Quantitative Finance, 1(4), 452–471.

Sornette, D., O. Ledoit, and A. Johansen (1999): Critical crashes, Risk Magazine, 12(1), 91–95.

Sornette, D., R. Woodard, and W.-X. Zhou (2009): The 2006–2008 oil bubble: Evidence of specu- lation, and prediction, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 388(8), 1571–1576.

Sornette, D., and W.-X. Zhou (2006): Predictability of large future changes in major financial indices, International Journal of Forecasting, 22(1), 153–168.

Tokic, D. (2010): The 2008 oil bubble: Causes and consequences, Energy Policy, 38(10), 6009–6015.

Tokic, D (2015): The 2014 oil bust: Causes and consequences, Energy Policy, 85, 162–169.

Veldkamp, L. L. (2006): Media frenzies in markets for financial information, The American Economic Review, 96(3), 577–601.

Yan, W., R. Woodard, and D. Sornette (2012): Diagnosis and prediction of rebounds in financial markets, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 391(4), 1361–1380.

Yiu, M., J. Yu, and J. Lu (2013): Detecting bubbles in Hong Kong residential property, Journal of Asian Economics, 28, 115–124.

Zhou, W.-X., and D. Sornette (2003): 2000–2003 real estate bubble in the UK but not in the USA, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 329(1), 249–263.

Zhou, W.-X., and D. Sornette (2006): Is there a real-estate bubble in the US?, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 361(1), 297–308.

Zhou, W.-X., and D. Sornette (2008): Analysis of the real estate market in Las Vegas: Bubble, seasonal patterns, and prediction of the CSW indices, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 387(1), 243–260.

Zhou, W.-X., and D. Sornette (2009): A case study of speculative financial bubbles in the South African stock market 2003–2006, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 388(6), 869–880.