Option contracts in a vertical industry

Antelo, Manel and Bru, Lluís (2016): Option contracts in a vertical industry.

Abstract

We examine, in a vertical industry, the strategic role of horizontal subcontracting through option contracts by a downstream dominant firm competing with a competitive fringe. Downstream production requires an input from an upstream component-producing industry composed of imperfectly competitive suppliers. We characterize how the dominant firm may outsource downstream production from fringe firms in order to gain bargaining clout in the upstream input market. It is shown that option contracts are preferred to fixed-quantity forward contracts, because leverage against upstream suppliers is gained at lower contract prices. When there is no market uncertainty option contracts do not alter spot prices beyond that caused by unavoidable market power, whereas they increase price volatility whenever demand is subject to uncertainty.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Option contracts, forward contracts, vertical industry, demand uncertainty
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L10 - General; L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior > L22 - Firm Organization and Market Structure; L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior > L23 - Organization of Production

References

Allaz, B. and J.L. Vila (1993), Cournot competition, forward markets and efficiency. Journal of Economic Theory 59, 1-16.

Antelo, M. and L. Bru (2002), Forward contracts and competition, Spanish Economic Review 4, 281-300.

Antelo, M. and L. Bru (2006), The welfare effects of upstream mergers in the presence of entry barriers, International Economic Review 47, 1269-1294.

Barnes-Schuster, D., Y. Bassok, and R. Anupindi (2002), Coordination and flexibility in supply contracts with options, Manufacturing and Service Operations Management 4, 171–207.

Bolton, P. and M.D. Whinston (1993), Incomplete contracts, vertical integration and supply assurance, Review of Economic Studies 60, 121-148.

Bresnahan, T. (1999), New modes of competition and the future structure of the computer industry, in: Competition, Convergence, and the Microsoft Monopoly, a Progress and Freedom Foundation Volume published by Kluwer Press.

Castellani, M. and M. Mussoni (2005), An Economic Analysis of the Tourism Contracts: Allotment and Free Sale, mimeo, University of Bologna.

Choi, J.P. and C. Davidson (2004), Strategic second sourcing by multinationals, International Economic Review 45, 579-600.

Eppen, G.D. and A.V. Iyer (1997), Backup agreements in the fashion buying – The value of upstream flexibility, Management Science 43, 1469-1484.

Ferreira, J.L. (2003), Strategic interaction between futures and spot markets, Journal of Economic Theory 108, 141-151.

Janeba, E., (2000), Tax competition when government lack commitment: excess capacity as a countervailing threat, American Economic Review 90, 1508-19.

Kamien, M.I., L. Li and D. Samet (1989), Bertrand competition with subcontracting, Rand Journal of Economics, 20: 553-567

Newbery, D.M.G. (1984), Manipulation of futures markets by a dominant producer, in Anderson, R. (ed.) The Industrial Organization of Futures Markets, Lexington Books, Lexington Mass.

Newbery, D.M.G. (1987), Futures markets, hedging and speculation, in Eatwell et al. (eds.) The New Palgrave: a Dictionary in Economics, The MacMillan Press Limited, London

Nöldeke, G. and K. Schmidt (1995), Option contracts and renegotiation: a solution to the hold-up problem, Rand Journal of Economics 26, 163-179.

Nöldeke, G. and K. Schmidt (1998), Sequential investments and options to own, Rand Journal of Economics 29, 633-653.

Rey, P. and J. Tirole (1999), A theory of foreclosure. In: The Handbook of Industrial Organization, vol. 3, North-Holland, Amsterdam (in preparation)

Segal, I. and M. D. Whinston (2002), The Mirrlees approach to mechanism design with renegotiation (with applications to hold-up and risk sharing), Econometrica 70, 1-45.

Shy, O. and R. Stenbacka (2003), Strategic outsourcing. Journal of Economic and Behavior & Organization, 50: 203-224.

Shy, O. and R. Stenbacka (2012), Efficient organization production: Nested versus horizontal outsourcing, Economics Letters 116, 593–596.

Slade, M.E. and H. Thille (2004), Commodity spot prices: an exploratory assessment of market-structure and forward-trading effects, Economica 73, 229-256.

Spiegel, Y. (1993), Horizontal Subcontracting, Rand Journal of Economics 24, 570-590.

Taymaz, E. and Y. Kilicaslam (2005), Determinants of subcontracting and regional development: an empirical study on Turkish textile and engineering industries, Regional Studies 39, 633-645.

Wang, X. and L. Liu (2007), Coordination in a retailer-led supply chain through option contract, International Journal of Production Economics 110, 115-127.