Improving prevention compliance through appropriate incentives

Schneider, Udo and Zerth, Jürgen (2008): Improving prevention compliance through appropriate incentives.

Abstract

This paper theoretically and empirically explores the effects of insurance parameters and a complementary information environment on patient´s primary prevention activity in the context of a managed care organisation. The theoretical model is based on a principal-agent setting in which the patient is acting as an agent in deciding about his preventive effort. Both for the patient and for the insurer the information distribution about prevention efforts is diluted. Hence, the theoretical results reflect the impact of insurance parameters as well as complementary information settings. The empirical investigation sheds the light on the patient´s prevention decision in the case of smoking. This depends on age effects, education, working time and health status. The research also stresses the relationship between monetary incentive schemes and individual behaviour as well as the influence of additional information schemes. In addition to the theoretical results, there is an evidence that changes in health behaviour depend on education and individual health assessment, too.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Incentives in Prevention; Information distribution
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I12 - Health Behavior; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C2 - Single Equation Models ; Single Variables > C23 - Panel Data Models ; Spatio-temporal Models; D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D82 - Asymmetric and Private Information ; Mechanism Design

References

Barigozzi, F. (2004), Reimbursing Preventive Care., in: The Geneva Papers on Risk and In-surance Theory 29, 165-186.

Becker, G. and K. Murphy (1988), A Theory of Rational Addiction, in: Journal of Political Economy 26, 675-700.

Breyer, F. and S. Felder (2006), Life Expectancy and Health Care Expenditures: A new calcu-lation for Germany using the costs of dying, in: Health Policy, Vol. 75, 178-186.

Brocas, I. and J. Carillo (2000), The Value of Information when Preferences are Dynamically Inconsistent, in: European Economic Review 44, 1104-1115.

Chandra, A., J. Gruber and R. McKnight (2007), Patient cost-sharing, Hospitalisation Offsets and the Design of Optimal Health Insurance for the Elderly, in: NBER Working Paper 12972, Cambridge/Mass.

Cohen, D. and G. Mooney (1984), Prevention Goods and Hazards Goods – a Taxonomy, in: Scottish Journal of Political Economy 31, 92-99.

Cohen, A. and L. Einav (2007), Estimating Risk Preferences from Deductible Choice, in: American Economic Review 97, 745-788.

Contoyannis, P. und A. M. Jones (2004), Socio-Economic Status, Health and Lifestyle, in: Journal of Health Economics 23, 965-995.

Cowell, A. J. (2006), The Relationship between Education and Health Behavior: Some Em-pirical Evidence, in: Health Economics 15, 125-146.

De Fraja, G. (2000), Contracts for Health Care and Asymmetric Information, in: Journal of Health Economics 19, 663-677.

Disney. R., Emmerson, C. and M. Wakefield (2006), Ill Health and Retirement in Britain: A Panel Data-based Analysis, in: Journal of Health Economics 25, 621-649.

Dracup, A and A. J. Meleis (1982); Compliance: an Interactional Approach, in: Nursing Re-search 31, 31-36.

Ellis, R. P., and T. G. McGuire (1990), Optimal Payment Systems for Health Services, in: Journal of Health Economics 9, 375-396.

Evans, R. (1988), Economic Barriers to Preventive Services – Clinical Obstacle of Fiscal De-fense, in: American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 4 (Suppl), 111-120.

Forster, M. und A. M. Jones (2001), The Role of Tobacco Taxes in Starting and Quitting Smoking, in: Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, Statistics in Society 164, 517-547.

Garber, A. M. and C. E. Phelps (1997), Economic Foundations of Cost-Effectiveness Analy-sis, in: Journal of Health Economics 16, 1-31.

Giveon, S. and E. Kahan (2000), Patient Adherence to Family Practitions’ Recommendations for Breast Cancer Screening: a Historical Cohort Study, in: Family practice 17, 42-45.

Greenlund, K, Keenan N, Anderson, L., Mandelson, M., Newton, C. and A LaCroix (2000): Does Provider Prevention Orientation Influence Female Patients’ Practices?, in: American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 19, 104-110.

Hagan, R., Jones, A. M. and N. Rice (2006), Health and Retirement in Europe, HEDG Working Paper 06/10, Uni-versity of York.

Hart, O. and B. Holmstrom (1987), The Theory of Contracts, in: Bewley, T. (ed.). Advances in Economic Theory, Cambridge, 71-115.

Haynes, R. B. (1978); Introduction, in: Haynes, R.B., D. Sackett and D. Taylor (eds.): Com-pliance in Health Care, John Hopkins Press, Baltimore, 1-18.

Haynes R. B.; H. McDonald, A. X. Garg and P. Montagque (2002): Interventions for Helping Patients to Follow Prescriptions for Medications, in: The Cochrane Database of Syste-matic Reviews, Issue 2.

Hernández-Quevo, C., Jones, A. M. and N. Rice (2005), Reporting Bias and Heterogeneity in Selfassessed Health. Evidence from the British Household Panel Survey, HEDG Working Paper 05/04, University of York.

Holmström, B. (1979), Moral Hazard and Observability, in: Bell Journal of Economics 10, 74-91.

Hsu, J; M. Price; j. Huang; R. Brand, V. Fung; R Hui, B Fireman; J. Newhouse and J. Selby. (2006), Unintended Consequences of Caps on Medicare Drug Benefits, in: New Eng-land Journal of Medicine 354, 2349-2359.

Jenkins, S. P. (1995), Easy Estimation Methods for Discrete-Time Duration Models, in: Ox-ford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 57, 129-138.

Jenkins, S. P. (1997), Discrete Time Proportional Hazards Regression, in: The Stata Technical Bulletin Reprints 7, 109-121.

Jones, A. M. (2007), Panel Data Methods and Applications to Health Economics, HEDG Working Paper 07/18, University of York.

Kan, K. (2007) Cigarette Smoking and Self-control, in; Journal of Health Economics 26, 61-81.

Kenkel, D. S. (1991), Health Behavior, Health Knowledge, and Schooling, in: The Journal of Political Economy 99, 287-305.

Kenkel, D. S. (2001) Prevention, in: A. J. Culyer und J. P. Newhouse (Hrsg.), Handbook of Health Economics Volume 1B, Elsevier, Amsterdam et al.; 1675-1720.

Kenkel, D. S., D. Lillard and A. Mathios (2006), The roles of high school completion and GED receipt in smoking and obesity, in: Journal of Labor Economics . 24, 635-660.

Macho-Stadler, I. and J. D. Pérez-Castrillo (2001), An Introduction to the Economcis of In-formation: Incentives and Contracts, 2nd edition, Oxford 2001.

Mas-Colell, A.; M. Whinston and J. Green (1995), Microeconomic Theory, Oxford.

Miceli, T. J., and D. Heffley (2002), Do HMOs Encourage Prevention?: An Analysis of Al-ternative Health Care Plans, in: Contemporary Economic Policy 20, 429-439.

Mullahy, J. (1997), Instrumental-Variable Estimation of Count Data Models: Applications to Models of Cigarette Smoking Behavior, in: Review of Economics and Statistics 79, 586-593.

Oberender, P. and J. Zerth (2007), The Search for Good Compliance: Economic Aspects of a Conveyed Combination Pharmaco-Therapy, Exemplified by an Osteoporosis Therapy, in: European Journal of Health Economics, published online 20th April 2007.

Rasmusen, E. (1989), Games and Information: An Introduction to Game Theory, Oxford.

Rees, R. (1985), The Theory of Principal and Agent: Part 1, in: Bulletin of Economic Re-search 37, 3-26.

Schneider, U. (2004), Asymmetric Information and the Demand for Health Care - the Case of Double Moral Hazard, in: Journal of Applied Social Science Studies 124, 233-256.

Shavell, S. (1979), On Moral Hazard and Insurance, in: Quarterly Journal of Economics 93, 541-562.

Stewart, J. (1994), The Welfare Implications of Moral Hazard and Adverse Selection in Com-petitive Insurance Markets, in: Economic Inquiry 32, 193-208.

Treadwell, J. R. and L. A. Lenert (1999), Health Values and Prospect Theory, in: Medical Decision Making 19, 344-352.

van Deuverden, K. (2004), Die Erhöhung der Tabaksteuer zur Finanzierung versicherungs-fremder Leistungen in der gesetzlichen Krankenversicherung (The Increase of To-bacco Taxes to Finance Extraneous Insurance Benefits in the German SHI), in: Dis-cussion Paper 187, Halle Institute for Economic Research.

Winter, L., Lawton, M. P. and K. Ruckdeschel (2003), Preferences of Prolonging Life: A Prospect Theory Approach, in: International Journal of Aging and Human Development 56, 155-170.

Wooldridge, J. M. (2002), Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data, MIT Press, Cambridge et al.

Yaniv, G. (2006), Rational Health-Compromising Behavior and Economic Intervention, in: Altmann, M. (ed.). Handbook of Contemporary Behavioural Economics, 560-585.

Zweifel, P. (1994), Eine Charakterisierung von Gesundheitssystemen: Welche sind von Vor-teil bei welchen Herausforderungen? (A Characterisation of Health Care Systems. Ad-vantages and Challenges), in: P. Oberender (Eds), Probleme der Transformation im Gesundheitswesen. Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft, Baden-Baden.1994.

Zweifel, P., Lehmann, H., and L. Steinmann. (2002). Patching up the Physician-Patient Rela-tionship: Insurers vs. Governments as Complementary Agents, in: B. Lindgren (Eds), Individual Decisions for Health, Routledge, London et al., 207-233.

Zweifel, P., Felder, S., and A. Werblow (2004), Population Ageing and Health Care Expendi-ture: New Evidence on the Red Herring, in: The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance 29 (4), 652-666.