Public versus Private Sector Wage Gap in Egypt: Evidence from Quantile Regression on Panel Data

Tansel, Aysit and Keskin, Halil Ibrahim and Ozdemir, Zeynel Abidin (2008): Public versus Private Sector Wage Gap in Egypt: Evidence from Quantile Regression on Panel Data.

Abstract

This paper considers the public and private sector wage earners in Egypt and examines their wage distribution during 1998-2012 using Egyptian Labor Market Panel Survey. We estimate the public-private sector wage gap with Mincer wage equations both at the mean and at different quantiles of the wage distribution. In this process we take into account observable and unobservable characteristics of the individuals using the panel feature of the data with a fixed effects model. We address sector of employment selection issue for both males and females. We find that there is very little evidence of sample selection in our data. Therefore, we present both the selection corrected results and the results with no selection correction. We find a persistent public sector wage penalty for males and public sector wage premium for females in the face of extensive sensitivity checks. They are larger when unobserved heterogeneity is taken into account for males but insignificant for females. They are similar across the quantiles for males but, smaller at the top than at the bottom of the conditional wage distribution for females. We further examine the public sector wage gap over time and in different sub-groups according to age and education. The public sector wage penalty for males has decreased recently over time and is larger for the better educated and younger. We also find substantial regional differences in public sector wage gap for males.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Public Sector, Private Sector, Wage Gap, Gender, Sample Selection, Quantile Regression, Panel Data, Egypt
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C2 - Single Equation Models ; Single Variables > C21 - Cross-Sectional Models ; Spatial Models ; Treatment Effect Models ; Quantile Regressions; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C2 - Single Equation Models ; Single Variables > C23 - Panel Data Models ; Spatio-temporal Models; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J16 - Economics of Gender ; Non-labor Discrimination; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J3 - Wages, Compensation, and Labor Costs > J31 - Wage Level and Structure ; Wage Differentials; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J4 - Particular Labor Markets > J45 - Public Sector Labor Markets

References

Amin, G. (2014) “Egypt Country Report Policies and Mechanisms for Integration into the Workforce and Job Creation”, Egypt Country Report for the 2014 Ministerial Conference on Youth Employment, How to Improve, Trough Skills Development and Job Creation, Access of Africa’s Youth to the World of Work, Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire, 21-23 July, 2014.

Angel-Urdinola, D. F. and Kuddo, A. (2011) “Key Characteristics of Employment Regulations in the Middle East and North Africa”, World Bank, Washington, D.C.: World Bank. https://openknowledge.worldbank.com/handle/10986/10893.

Assaad, R. (1997) “The Effects of Public Sector Hiring and Compensation Policies on the Egyptian Labor Market”, The World Bank Economic Review, 11(1), 85–118.

Assaad, R. (2009) “Labor Supply, Employment and Unemployment in the Egyptian Economy, 1988-2006”, In: Assaad R (ed) The Egyptian Labor Market Revisited. Cairo, Egypt: American University in Cairo Press with Economic Research Forum, (pp.1–52).

Assaad, R. and Krafft, C. (2013) “The Evolution of Labor Supply and Unemployment in the Egyptian Economy: 1988-2012”, Cairo, Egypt: Economic Research Forum (ERF), Working Paper No: 806.

Bargain, O. and Melly, B., (2008) “Public sector pay gap in France: new evidence using panel data”, IZA Discussion Paper 3427.

Bargain, O. and Kwenda, P. (2014) “The Informal Sector Wage Gap: New Evidence Using Quantile Estimations on Panel Data“, Economic Development and Cultural Change, 63(1), 117-153.

Bender, K. A. (1998) “The central government‐private sector wage differential”, Journal of Economic Surveys, 12(2), 177-220.

Bender, K. A. (2003) “Examining equality between public‐and private‐sector wage distributions”, Economic Inquiry, 41(1), 62-79.

Birch, E. R. (2006) “The public-private sector earnings gap in Australia: a quantile regression approach”, Australian Journal of Labour Economics, 9(2), 99-123.

Borland, J., Hirschberg, J., and Lye, J. (1998) “Earnings of public sector and private sector employees in Australia: is there a difference?”, Economic Record, 74(224), 36-53.

Botelho, F., and Ponczek, V. (2011) “Segmentation in the Brazilian Labor Market”, Economic Development and Cultural Change, 59(2), 437–63.

Buchinsky, M. (1998): “The dynamics of changes in the female wage distribution in the USA: A quantile regression approach,” Journal of Applied Econometrics, 13, 1–30.

Buchinsky, M., and Hunt, J., (1999) “Wage mobility in the United States”, The Review of Economic Studies, 81 (3), 351–368.

Buchinsky, M. (2001). “Quantile regression with sample selection: Estimating women’s return to education in the US”, Empirical Economics, 26(1), 87-113.

Cai, L., and Liu, A. Y. (2011) “Public–private sector wage gap in Australia: variation along the distribution”, British Journal of Industrial Relations, 49(2), 362-390.

Campos, M. M., and Centeno, M. (2012) “Public-private wage gaps in the period prior to the adoption of the euro: an application based on longitudinal data”, Banco de Portugal, WP, 1, 2012.

Canay, I. A. (2011) “A Simple Approach to Quantile Regression for Panel Data”, The Econometrics Journal, 14(3), 368–386.

Cappellari, L., (2002) “Earnings dynamics and uncertainty in Italy: how do they differ between the private and public sectors?”, Labour Economics, 9, 477–496.

Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics (CAPMAS) (2014) Statistical Year Book of A.R.E., Cairo, Egypt.

Christofides, L. N., & Michael, M. (2013) “Exploring the public-private sector wage gap in European countries”, IZA Journal of European Labor Studies, 2(1), 15.

Christopoulou, R., and Monastiriotis, V. (2014) “The Greek public sector wage premium before the crisis: size, selection and relative valuation of characteristics”, British Journal of Industrial Relations, 52(3), 579-602.

Coelho, D., Soares, F., & Veszteg, R. (2008, October). “Quantile Regression with Sample Selection: Estimating Married Women´s Return of Education and Racial Wage Differential in Brazil”, In XXX Meeting of the Brazilian Econometric Society.

Dell'Aringa, C., Lucifora, C., and Origo, F. (2007) “Public sector pay and regional competitiveness. A first look at regional public–private wage differentials in Italy”, The Manchester School, 75(4), 445-478.

Depalo, D., Giordano, R., and Papapetrou, E. (2015) “Public–private wage differentials in euro-area countries: evidence from quantile decomposition analysis”, Empirical Economics, 49(3), 985-1015.

Disney, R. and Gosling, A., (2003) “A new method for estimating public sector pay premia: evidence from Britain in the 1990s”, CEPR Discussion Paper 3787.

Dustmann, C. and van Soest, A., (1998) “Public and private sector wages of male workers in Germany”, European Economic Review, 42, 1417–1441.

Garcia-Perez, J. I., and Jimeno, J. F. (2007) “Public sector wage gaps in Spanish regions”, The Manchester School, 75(4), 501-531.

Gatti R., D. Angel-Urdinola, J. Silva, and A. Bodor, 2014. “Striving for Better Jobs. The Challenges of Informality in Middle East and North Africa Region”. Washington, DC: World Bank, Directions in Development, No: 90271.

Ghinetti, P., & Lucifora, C. (2008). “Public sector pay gaps and skill levels: a cross-country comparison”, (No. 118).

Giordano, R., Domenico Depalo, M., Coutinho Pereira, B., Papapetrou, E., Perez, J.,Reiss, L., Roter, M., (2011) “The public sector pay gap in a selection of euro area countries”, European Central Bank Working Paper Series, no. 1406.

Gregory, R. G. and Borland, J., (1999) “Recent developments in public sector labour markets”, In: Ashenfelter O, Card D (eds) Handbook of Labor Economics, 3c. Elsevier, 3573–3630.

Hartog, J. and Oosterbeek, H., (1993) “Public and private sector wages in the Netherlands”, European Economic Review, 37, 97–114.

Heckman, J. (1979). “Sample selection bias as a specification error”, Econometrica, 47: 153-161.

Heitmuller, A. (2006) “Public-private sector pay differentials in a devolved Scotland”, Journal of Applied Economics, 9(2), 295-323.

Heitmueller, A., and Mavromaras, K. G. (2007) “On the post-unification development of public and private pay in Germany”, The Manchester School, 75(4), 422-444.

Hou, J. W. (1993) “Public-private wage comparison: A case study of Taiwan”, Journal of Asian Economics, 4(2), 347-362.

Hospido, L., and Moral-Benito, E. (2016) “The public sector wage premium in Spain: evidence from longitudinal administrative data”, Labour Economics, 42, 101-122.

Huber, M., & Melly, B. (2011). Quantile regression in the presence of sample selection. School of Economics and Political Science, Department of Economics, University of St. Gallen.

Koenker, R. (2004) “Quantile Regression for Longitudinal Data”, Journal of Multivariate Analysis, 91(1), 74–89.

Ichimura, H. (1993). “Semiparametric least squares (SLS) and weighted SLS estimation of single-index models”, Journal of Econometrics, 58(1-2), 71–120.

Lausev, J. (2014) “What has 20 years of public–private pay gap literature told us? Eastern European transitioning vs. developed economies”, Journal of Economic Surveys, 28(3), 516-550.

Lassibille, G., (1998) “Wage gaps between the public and private sectors in Spain”, Economics of Education Review, 17 (1), 83–92.

Lohmann, T. (2010) “Labor Regulation and Female Labor Market Participation A Country Study of Egypt”, Regional Programme Economic Integration of Women-MENA, EconoWin,

Lucifora, C., and Meurs, D., (2006) “The public sector pay gap in France, Great Britain and Italy”, Review of Income and wealth, 52 (1), 43–59.

Kanellopoulos, C. N. (1997) “Public-private wage differentials in Greece”, Applied Economics, 29(8), 1023-1032.

Lucifora, C., and Meurs, D. (2006) “The public sector pay gap in France, Great Britain and Italy”, Review of Income and wealth, 52(1), 43-59.

Mahuteau, S., Mavromaras, K., Richardson, S., and Zhu, R. (2017) “Public–Private Sector Wage Differentials in Australia”, Economic Record, 93, 105–121.

Melly, B., (2005) “Public–private sector wage differentials in Germany: evidence from quantile regression”, Empirical Economics, 30, 505–520.

Mueller, R. E. (1998) “Public–private sector wage differentials in Canada: evidence from quantile regressions”, Economics Letters, 60(2), 229-235.

Newey, W. (1999) “Two step series estimation of sample selection model”, MIT. Working Paper No: 99-04.

Nguyen, H.C., Nordman, C.J. and Roubaud, F. (2013) “Who Suffers the Penalty? A Panel Data Analysis of Earnings Gaps in Vietnam”, The Journal of Development Studies, 49(12), 1694–1710.

Nikolic, J. (2014) “The effect of large-scale privatization on public sector pay gap in a transition economy”, Economics of Transition, 22(4), 759-781.

Nordman, C. J., Rakotomanana, F. and Roubaud, F. (2016) “Informal versus Formal: A Panel Data Analysis of Earnings Gaps in Madagaskar”, World Development, 86, 1-17, doi:10.1016/j.worlddev.2016.05.006.

Tannuri-Pianto, M. and Pianto, D. (2002) "Informal Employment in Brazil A Choice at the Top and Segmentation at the Bottom: A Quantile Approach", Serie de Textos para Discussao No. 236, Universidade de Brasilia.

Postel-Vinay, F. and Turon, H., (2007) “The public pay gap in Britain: small differences that (don't?) matter”, The Economic Journal, 117, 1460–1503.

Said, M. (2009) “The Fall and Rise of Earnings and Inequality in Egypt: New Evidence from the Egypt Labor Market Panel survey 2006”, In: Assaad R (ed) The Egyptian Labor Market Revisited. Cairo, Egypt: American University in Cairo Press with Economic Research Forum, (pp. 53–85).

Said, M. (2015). “Wages and inequality in the Egyptian labor market in an era of financial crisis and revolution”, The Egyptian Labor Market in an Era of Revolution, 52-69.

Siminski, P. (2013) “Are low-skill public sector workers really overpaid? A quasi-differenced panel data analysis”, Applied Economics, 45(14), 1915-1929.

Tansel, A. (2005) “Public-Private Employment Choice, Wage Differentials and Gender in Turkey”, Economic Development and Cultural Change, 53(2): 453-477.

Tansel, A. and Kan, E.O. (2012) “The Formal/Informal Employment Earnings Gap: Evidence from Turkey”, Bonn, Germany: Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA) Discussion Paper No. 6556. http://ftp.iza.org/dp6556.pdf.

Tansel, A. and Ozdemir, Z. A. (2014) “Determinant of Transitions Across Formal/Informal Sectors in Egypt”, Bonn, Germany: Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA) Discussion Paper No. 8773. http://ftp.iza.org/dp8773.pdf

Tansel, A., Keskin, H. I. and Ozdemir, Z. A. (2015) “Is There an Informal Employment Wage Penalty in Egypt,” October, 2015, IZA Discussion Paper No. 9359. ERF Working Paper No: 976.

Van Ophem, H., (1993) “A modified switching regression model for earnings differentials between the public and private sectors in the Netherlands”, The Review of Economics and Statistics, 75 (2), 215–224.

Wahba, J. and Assaad, R. (2015) “Flexible Labor Regulations and Informality in Egypt”, Cairo, Egypt: Economic Research Forum (ERF), Working Paper No: 915.

World Bank (2014) Arab Republic of Egypt: More Jobs Better Jobs: A Priority of Egypt. Washington D.C.: Report no: 88447-EG, Poverty Reduction and Economic Management Department Middle East and North Africa Region. The World Bank.