Liberalizing Passenger Rail: The Effect of Competition on Local Unemployment

Badura, Ondrej and Melecky, Ales and Melecky, Martin (2022): Liberalizing Passenger Rail: The Effect of Competition on Local Unemployment.

Abstract

Competitive passenger rail can help workers access new or better jobs. This paper studies the wider economic impacts on local unemployment of the liberalized passenger rail between Ostrava, the third-biggest city in the Czech Republic, and Prague, its capital. The local impacts are estimated at the LAU 1 level (administrative districts) using the difference-in-differences method. The liberalization motivated the entry of two new private providers. The resulting competition in ticket prices, the number of connections, and service quality had a strong beneficial effect on labor market connectivity. It significantly reduced unemployment in the districts along the line compared with the control districts. The effect weakens with the level of urbanization of the treated district. It could partly transmit through higher firm entry and lower firm exit in the local market, as well as better skill matching on the back of higher inward and outward migration.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Competition; difference in differences; districts; liberalization; local labor market; passenger transport; railways; unemployment; urbanization; EU country; OECD country
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers; L - Industrial Organization > L4 - Antitrust Issues and Policies > L40 - General; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R10 - General; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R4 - Transportation Economics > R40 - General

References

Atack, Jeremy, Fred Bateman, Michael Haines, and Robert A. Margo. 2010. “Did railroads induce or follow economic growth? Urbanization and population growth in the American Midwest, 1850–1860.” Social Science History 34(2):171–197.

Asturias, Jose, Manuel García Santana, and Roberto Ramos. 2018. “Competition and the welfare gains from transportation infrastructure: Evidence from the Golden Quadrilateral of India.” Banco de Espana Working Paper No. 1816. DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.3194481

Audretsch, David. B., Diana Heger, and Tobias Veith. 2015. “Infrastructure and entrepreneurship.” Small Business Economics 44: 219–230. DOI: 10.1007%2Fs11187-014-9600-6

Baum-Snow, Nathaniel, Loren Brandt, J. Vernon Henderson, Matthew A. Turner, and Qinghua Zhang, Qinghua. 2017. “Roads, railroads and decentralization of Chinese cities.” Review of Economics and Statistics 99(3): 435–448.

Bošković, Branislav, and Mirjana Bugarinović. 2015. “Why and how to manage the process of liberalization of a regional railway market: South-Eastern European case study.” Transport Policy 41(C): 50-59.

Bougna, Emmanuel, and Yves Crozet. 2016. “Towards a liberalised European rail transport: analysing and modelling the impact of competition on productive efficiency.” Research in Transportation Economics 59 (C), 358–367.

Brunello, G. and Wruuck, P., 2019. Skill shortages and skill mismatch in Europe: A review of the literature. EIB Working Papers 2019/05.

Cantos Sanchez, Pedro, José M. Pastor, and Lorenzo Serrano. 2012. “Evaluating European railway deregulation using different approaches.” Transport Policy 24(C): 67–72.

Cantos Sanchez, Pedro, José M. Pastor, and M. Lorenzo Serrano. 2010. “Vertical and horizontal separation in the European railway sector and its effects on productivity.” Journal of Transport Economics and Policy 44 (2): 139–160.

Carbo, Jose M., Daniel J. Graham, Anupriya, Daniel Casas, and Patricia C. Melo. 2019. “Evaluating the causal economic impacts of transport investments: evidence from the Madrid–Barcelona high speed rail corridor.” Journal of Applied Statistics 46(9): 1714-1723. DOI: 10.1080/02664763.2018.1558188

Chacko, Elizabeth. 2007. “From brain drain to brain gain: reverse migration to Bangalore and Hyderabad, India’s globalizing high tech cities.” GeoJournal 68: 131–140.

Chandra, Amitabh, and Eric Thompson. 2000. “Does public infrastructure affect economic activity? Evidence from the rural interstate highway system.” Regional Science and Urban Economics 30(4): 457-90.

Chassamboulli, A. and Palivos, T. 2014. A search‐equilibrium approach to the effects of immigration on labor market outcomes. International Economic Review, 55(1), pp.111-129.

Chen, Zhenhua, and Kingsley E. Haynes, 2017. “Impact of high-speed rail on regional economic disparity in China.” Journal of Transport Geography 65(C): 80-91.

Donaldson, Dave. 2018. “Railroads of the raj: Estimating the impact of transportation infrastructure.” American Economic Review 108(4-5): 899–934. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20101199

Donaldson, Dave, and Richard Hornbeck. 2016. “Railroads and American economic growth: A ‘market access’ approach.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 131(2): 799–858. doi:10.1093/qje/qjw002.

Faber, Benjamin. 2014. “Trade integration, market size, and industrialization: Evidence from China's national trunk highway system.” Review of Economic Studies 81(3): 1046–1070. https://doi.org/10.1093/restud/rdu010

Friebel, Guido, Marc Ivaldi, and Catherine Vibes. 2010. “Railway (de) regulation: A European efficiency comparison.” Economica 77 (305): 77–91.

Friebel, Guido, Sergei Guriev, Russell Pittman, Elizaveta Shevyakhova, and Anna Tomová. 2007. “Railroad restructuring in Russia and Central and Eastern Europe: One solution for all problems?” Transport Reviews 27(3): 251–271.

Green, David A., René Morissette, Ben M. Sand, and Iain Snoddy 2019. “Economy-Wide Spillovers from Booms: Long-Distance Commuting and the Spread of Wage Effects.” Journal of Labor Economics 37(S2): S643–S687.

Hazans, Mihails. 2004. “Does Commuting Reduce Wage Disparities?” Growth and Change 35(3): 360-390.

He, Guojun, Yang Xie, and Bing Zhang. 2020. “Expressways, GDP, and the environment: The case of China.” Journal of Development Economics 145(C): 1-16. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0304387820300602?via%3Dihub

Herzog, Ian, 2021. "National transportation networks, market access, and regional economic growth." Journal of Urban Economics 122(C), 103316. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jue.2020.103316.

Holl, Adelheid. 2016. “Highways and productivity in manufacturing firms.” Journal of Urban Economics 93, May: 131-151. DOI: 10.1016/j.jue.2016.04.002

ICF Consulting Services. 2018. “Study on the movement of skilled labour: Final report, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg,” accessed October 5, 2021, https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=738&langId=en&pubId=8156&furtherPubs=yes.

Iammarino, S., Rodríguez-Pose, A. and Storper, M. 2019. Regional inequality in Europe: evidence, theory and policy implications. Journal of Economic Geography, 19(2), pp.273-298.

Jandová, Monika, and Tomáš Paleta. 2019. “Impact of on-track competition on public finances: The case of the Czech Republic.” Journal of Rail Transport Planning & Management 12(12): 1–13.

Jandová, Monika, and Václav Rederer. 2013. “Milníky vývoje na dopravním rameni Praha–Ostrava” (Milestones of Development on the Railway Route Prague–Ostrava). In: Kvizda, Tomeš. Regulovaná a neregulovaná konkurence na kolejích. Brno: Masarykova univerzita MuniPress: 77-93. ISBN 978-80-210-6425-6.

Kaplanis, Ioannis. 2010. “Local human capital and its impact on local employment chances in Britain.” Spatial Economics Research Centre Working Paper 40.

Khan, Habibullah, and M. Shahidul Islam. 2006. “Outsourcing, Migration, and Brain Drain in the Global Economy: Issues and Evidence.” U21Global Working Paper No. 004/2006.

Lee, Neil, and Stephen Clarke. 2019. “Do low-skilled workers gain from high-tech employment growth? High-technology multipliers, employment and wages in Britain.” Research Policy 48(9): 1-11.

Leunig, Tim. 2006. “Time is money: a re-assessment of the passenger social savings from Victorian British railways.” Journal of Economic History 66(3): 635-673. DOI: 10.1017/S0022050706000283

Lin, Yatang. 2017. “Travel costs and urban specialization patterns: Evidence from China’s high speed railway system.” Journal of Urban Economics 98: 98-123, DOI: 10.1016/j.jue.2016.11.002.

Lindgren, Erik, Per Pettersson-Lidbom, and Björn Tyrefors. 2021. “The Causal Effect of Transport Infrastructure: Evidence from a New Historical Database”. IFN Working Paper No. 1407. Stockholm: Research Institute of Industrial Economics (IFN).

Lui, Chong, Wei Wang, and Qunfeng Wu. 2019. “Transportation infrastructure, competition and productivity: Theory and evidence from China.” Economics Letters 174(2019): 74-77. DOI: 10.1016/j.econlet.2018.10.023

Liu, Liwen, and Ming Zhang. 2018. “High-speed rail impacts on travel times, accessibility, and economic productivity: A benchmarking analysis in city-cluster regions of China.” Journal of Transport Geography 73(December): 25-40.

McCullough, Gerard. 2006. “The liberalization of European rail transport: An American view.” Intereconomics 41(6), 311-313.

Mejia-Dorantes, Lucia, Antonio Paez, and Jose Manuel Vassallo. 2012. “Transportation infrastructure impacts on firm location: the effect of a new metro line in the suburbs of Madrid.” Journal of Transport Geography 22: 236-250. DOI: 10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2011.09.006

Mendes, R., Van Den Berg, G.J. and Lindeboom, M., 2010. An empirical assessment of assortative matching in the labor market. Labour Economics, 17(6), pp.919-929.

Melecky, Martin, Mark Roberts, and Siddharth Sharma. 2019. “The wider economic benefits of transport corridors: A policy framework and illustrative application to the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor.” Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 12(1), 17–44. https://doi.org/10.1093/cjres/rsy033

Meng, Xuechen, Shanlang Lin, and Xiaochuan Zhu. 2018. “The resource redistribution effect of high-speed rail stations on the economic growth of neighbouring regions: Evidence from China.” Transport Policy 68(C): 178-191.

Meyer, Jean-Baptiste. 2008. “Network Approach versus Brain Drain: Lessons from the Diaspora.” International Migration 39(5): 91-110.

Michaels, Guy. 2008. “The effect of trade on the demand for skill: Evidence from the interstate highway system.” Review of Economics and Statistics 90(4): 683-701.

Nash, Chris A., Andrew S.J. Smith, Didier van de Velde, Fumitoshi Mizutani, and Shuji Uranish. 2014. “Structural reforms in the railways: Incentive misalignment and cost implications.” Research in Transportation Economics 48(C): 16-23.

Moretti, Enrico. 2010. “Local Multipliers.” American Economic Review 100(2): 373-77.

Moretti, Enrico. 2013. The New Geography of Jobs. New York: Mariner.

Moretti, Enrico, and Per Thulin. 2013. “Local multipliers and human capital in the United States and Sweden.” Industrial and Corporate Change 22(1): 339-362.

Mulalic, Ismir, Jos N. Van Ommeren, and Ninette Pilegaard. 2014. “Wages and Commuting: Quasi‐natural Experiments' Evidence from Firms that Relocate.” Economic Journal 124(579): 1086–1105.

Nash, Chris. 2010. “European rail reform and passenger services: The next steps.” Research in Transportation Economics 29(1): 204-211.

Pradhan, Rudra P. 2019. “Investigating the causal relationship between transportation infrastructure, financial penetration and economic growth in G-20 countries.” Research in Transportation Economics 78(100766): 1-10.

Preston, John, Gerard Whelan, and Mark Wardman. 1999. “An analysis of the potential for on-track competition in the British passenger rail industry.” Journal of Transport Economics and Policy 33(1): 77-94.

Redding, Stephen J., and Matthew A. Turner. 2015. “Transportation costs and the spatial organization of economic activity.” Handbook of Regional and Urban Economics 5, 1339–1398.

Roberts, Mark, Martin Melecky, Théophile Bougna, and Yan (Sarah) Xu. 2020. “Transport corridors and their wider economic benefits: A quantitative review of the literature.” Journal of Regional Science 60(2): 207-248, March.

Tomeš, Zdeněk. 2017. “Do European reforms increase modal shares of railways?” Transport Policy 60(C), 143-151.

Tomeš, Zdeněk, and Hana Fitzová. 2019. “Does the incumbent have an advantage in open access passenger rail competition? A case study on the Prague–Brno line.” Journal of Rail Transport Planning & Management 12(12): 1-11.

Tomeš, Zdeněk, and Monika Jandová. 2016. “Approaches to Czech passenger railway market liberalisation.” Acta Oeconomica Pragensia 24(1): 68–81.

Tomeš, Zdeněk, Martin Kvizda, Monika Jandová, and Václav Rederer. 2016. “Open access passenger rail competition in the Czech Republic.” Transport Policy 47(2016): 203–211.

Tomeš, Zdeněk, Martin Kvizda, Tomáš Nigrin, and Daniel Seidenglanz. 2014. “Competition in the railway passenger market in the Czech Republic.” Research in Transportation Economics 48(2014): 270-276.

Wang, Yang, and Binzhen Wu. 2015. “Railways and the local economy: Evidence from Qingzang Railway.” Economic Development and Cultural Change 63(3): 551-588.