Fiscal Decentralization and Health Care Access and Quality: Evidence from Local Governments Around the World

Kyriacou, Andreas and Roca-Sagalés, Oriol (2023): Fiscal Decentralization and Health Care Access and Quality: Evidence from Local Governments Around the World.

Abstract

In this article we consider the impact on health care access and quality when decentralizing health spending down to local governments, based on data from 49 countries around the world over the period 1996 to 2015. Our empirical results, after controlling for a range of potentially confounding variables, indicate that decentralizing health spending is inimical to timely and effective health care. We moreover explore the role of two specific channels through which fiscal decentralization can undermine health outcomes namely, externalities and foregone economies of scale. We find that decentralizing health expenditure down to the local level may generate externalities to the detriment of health outcomes when it is accompanied by locally elected municipal politicians who are not subject to national parties. Our results also suggest that fiscal decentralization can improve health access and quality when two-thirds or more of the people in a country live in localities with more than 300,000 inhabitants, implying that below this threshold economies of scale may be foregone.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: fiscal decentralization; health decentralization; health care access and quality; local governments; economies of scale; externalities
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H1 - Structure and Scope of Government > H11 - Structure, Scope, and Performance of Government; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H72 - State and Local Budget and Expenditures; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I18 - Government Policy ; Regulation ; Public Health

References

Adam, A., Delis, M., Kammas P. 2014. Fiscal decentralization and public sector efficiency: evidence from OECD countries. Economics of Governance 15(1), 17–49.

Alesina, A., Baqir, R., Easterly, W. 1999. Public goods and ethnic divisions’, Quarterly Journal of Economics 114(4), 1243–1284.

Alesina, A., Devleeschauwer, A., Easterly, W., Kurlat, S, Wacziarg, R. 2003. Fractionalization. Journal of Economic Growth 8, 155–194.

Alesina, A., Spolaore, E. 2003. The Size of Nations. Cambridge MA, London: MIT Press.

Anyanwu. J., Erhijakpor A. 2009. Health expenditures and health outcomes in Africa. Afr Dev Rev 21, 400–433.

Arends, H. 2017. More with less? Fiscal decentralisation, public health spending and health sector performance’, Swiss Political Science Review 23(2), 144–174.

Arzaghi M., Henderson V. 2005. Why countries are fiscally decentralizing. Journal of Public Economics 89, 1157–1189.

Arze del Granado, F.J., Martinez-Vazquez J. and McNab R. M. 2018. Decentralized governance, expenditure composition, and preferences for public goods’, Public Finance Review 46(3), 359–388.

Beazley, I., Dougherty, D., James, C., Penn, C., Phillips, L. 2019. Decentralisation and performance measurement systems in healthcare. OECD Working Papers on Fiscal Federalism, April 2019 No. 28.

Bankauskaite, V., Saltman, R. 2007. Central issues in the decentralization debate. In Saltman, R., Bankauskaite, V., Vranbaek, K. (eds). Decentralization in Health Care. Strategies and outcomes. Berkshire: Open University Press. pp. 9–21.

Besley, T., Case, A. 1995. Incumbent behavior: vote-seeking, tax-setting, and yardstick competition. Am Econ Rev 85(1), 25–45.

Brennan, G., Buchanan, J.M. 1980. The Power to Tax: Analytical Foundations of a Fiscal Constitution. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Cantarero, D., Pascual, M. 2008. Analysing the impact of fiscal decentralization on health outcomes: empirical evidence from Spain. Applied Economic Letters 15 (2): 109–111.

Cavalieri, M., Ferrante, L. 2016. Does fiscal decentralization improve health outcomes? Evidence from infant mortality in Italy. Social Science & Medicine 164, 74–88.

Collins. C., Green A. 1994. Decentralization and primary health care: some negative implications in developing countries. Int J Health Serv. 24(3), 459–475.

Costa-i-Font, J. 2012. Fiscal Federalism and European Health System Decentralization: A Perspective, LEQS Paper No. 55/2012 December.

Diaz-Serrano, L., Rodríguez-Pose, A. 2015. Decentralization and the welfare state: what do citizens perceive? Social Indicators Research 120(2), 411–435.

Enikolopov R., Zhuravskaya E. 2007. Decentralization and political institutions. Journal of Public Economics 91, 2261–2290.

Espasa M., Esteller-Moré, A., Mora, T. 2017. Is decentralization really welfare enhancing? Empirical evidence from survey data (1994-2011). Kyklos 70(2), 189–219.

Faguet, J.-P., Sánchez, F. 2014. Decentralization and access to social services in Colombia’, Public Choice 160(1–2): 227–249.

Filmer, D., Pritchett, L. 1999. The impact of public spending on health: does money matter? Soc Sci Med. 49(10), 1309–23.

Gerring, J., Thacker, S., Alfaro, R. 2012. Democracy and human development. The Journal of Politics 74(1), 1–17.

Gupta. S., Davoodi, H., Tiongson, E. 2002. Corruption and the provision of health care and education services. In: Abed GT,

Gupta S, (eds). Governance, Corruption, and Economic Performance. Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund, pp. 245–72.

Habibi, N., Huang, C., Miranda, D., Murillo, V., Ranis, G., Sarkar, M. and Stewart, F. 2003. Decentralization and human development in Argentina. Journal of Human Development 4(1), 73–101.

Hankla, C., Martinez-Vazquez, J., Ponce-Rodriguez, Raúl. 2019. Local Accountability and National Coordination in Fiscal Federalism. A Fine Balance. Cheltenham, UK and Northampton, MA, USA: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Hayek, F. 1937. Economics and knowledge. Economica 4, pp. 33–54

Hurley, J., Birch, S., Eyles, J. 1995. Geographically-decentralized planning and management in health care: some informational issues and their implications for efficiency. Social Science and Medicine 41(1): 3–11.

Ivanyna, M., & Shah, A. 2014. How close is your government to its people? Worldwide indicators on localization and decentralization. Economics: The Open-Access, Open-Assessment E-Journal, 8(2014–3), 1–62.

James, C., Beazley, I., Penn, P., Philips, L., Dougherty, S. 2019. Decentralisation in the health sector and responsibilities across levels of government: Impact on spending decisions and the budget. OECD Journal of Budgeting, Vol 2019/3 - SPECIAL ISSUE ON HEALTH.

Jiménez-Rubio, D. 2011a. The impact of decentralization of health services on health outcomes: Evidence from Canada. Applied Economics 43(26), 3907–3917.

Jiménez-Rubio, D. 2011b. The impact of fiscal decentralization on infant mortality rates: Evidence from OECD countries. Social Science & Medicine 73(9): 1401–1407.

Kaufmann, D., Kraay, A., Mastruzzi, M. 2011. The worldwide governance indicators: Methodology and analytical issues. Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 3, 220–246.

Keen, M., Marchand M. 1997. Fiscal competition and the pattern of public spending. Journal of Public Economics 66, 33–53.

Kyriacou, A., Roca Sagalés, O. 2019. Local decentralization and the quality of public services in Europe, Social Indicators Research 145(2), 755–776.

La Porta, R., Lopez-de-Silanes, F., Shleifer, A., Vishny, R. 1999. The quality of government. Journal of Law Economics and Organization 15(1), 222–279.

Ladner, A., Keuffer, N., Baldersheim, H. 2016. Measuring local autonomy in 39 countries (1990–2014). Regional & Federal Studies, 26(3), 321–357.

Lewer, D; Bibby, J. 2021. Cuts to local government funding and stalling life expectancy. The Lancet 6, e623–e624.

Li, Q., An, L., Xu, J., Baliamoune-Lutz, M. 2018. Corruption costs lives: evidence from a cross-country study. European Journal of Health Economics 19(1), 153–165.

Lledó, V., Ncuti, C., Kabanda, M., Hu, C., Xiang, Y. 2018. The IMF Fiscal Decentralization Dataset: A Primer, Washington D.C, International Monetary Fund

Marshall, M. 2020. Polity V Project: Political Regime Characteristics and Transitions, 1800–2018 – Dataset User’s Manual. Center for Systemic Peace.

Martinez-Vazquez, J., Lago-Peñas, S. and Sacchi, A. 2017. The impact of decentralization: A survey. Journal of Economic Surveys 31: 1095–1129.

Mills, A. 1994. Decentralization and accountability in the health sector from an international perspective: what are the choices? Public Administration and Development, 14, 281–92.

Murray, C. et al. 2017. Healthcare Access and Quality Index based on mortality from causes amenable to personal health care in 195 countries and territories, 1990–2015: a novel analysis from the Global Burden of Disease Study 2015. Lancet 390: 231–66.

Nixon, J., Ulmann, P. 2006. The relationship between health care expenditure and health outcomes: Evidence and caveats for a causal link. Eur J Health Econ 7, 7–18.

Novignon, J., Olakojo, S., Nonvignon, J. (2012). The effects of public and private health care expenditure on health status in sub-Saharan Africa: new evidence from panel data analysis. Health Econ Rev 2, 1–8.

Oates, W. 1972. Fiscal Federalism. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.

Oates W. 1999. An essay on fiscal federalism. Journal of Economic Literature 37, 1120–1149.

Panizza U. 1999. On the determinants of fiscal centralization: Theory and evidence. Journal of Public Economics 74, 97–139.

Pieters, H., Curzi, D., Olper, A., Swinnen, J. 2016. Effect of democratic reforms on child mortality: A synthetic control analysis. The Lancet Global Health, 4(9), e627–e632.

Pickett, K., Wilkinson, R. 2009. The Spirit Level: Why Greater Equality Makes Societies Stronger. New York: Bloomsbury Press.

Pritchett L, Summers L. 1996. Wealthier is Healthier. J Hum Resour 31(4), 841–868.

Porcelli, F. 2014. Electoral accountability and local government efficiency: Quasi-experimental evidence from the Italian health care sector reforms.’Economics of Governance 15(3), 221–251.

Prud’homme R. 1995. The dangers of decentralization. The World Bank Research Observer 10, 201–20.

Riker, W. 1964. Federalism: Origins, Operation, Significance. Little, Brown and Co, Boston, MA.

Robalino, D., Picazo O., Voetberg A. 2001. Does fiscal decentralization improve health outcomes? Evidence from a cross-country analysis. Washington D.C.: World Bank.

Solt, F. 2020. Measuring income inequality across countries and over time: The standardized world income inequality database. Social Science Quarterly 101, 1183–1199.

Soto, V., Farfan, M., Lorant I. 2012. Fiscal decentralisation and infant mortality rate: The Colombian case. Social Science & Medicine 74(9), 1426–1434.

Salmon P. 1987. Decentralization as an incentive scheme. Oxford Review of Economic Policy 3, 24–43

Seabright, P. 1996. Accountability and decentralization in government: an incomplete contracts model. European Economic Review 40, 61–89.

Sumah, A., Baatiema, L., Abimbola, S. 2016. The impacts of decentralisation on health-related equity: A systematic review of the evidence. Health Policy 120 (10), 1183-1192.

Tiebout, C. 1956. A pure theory of local expenditures. The Journal of Political Economy 64, 416–424.

Uchimura, H., Jutting, J. 2009. Fiscal decentralization, Chinese style: good for health outcomes? World Development 37 (12), 1924-1936.

UN. 2018. World Urbanization Prospects: The 2018 Revision. Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division.

Wang, Y., Mechkova, V., Andersson, F. 2019. Does democracy enhance health? New empirical evidence 1900–2012. Political Research Quarterly, 72(3), 554–569.

Wigley, S., Akkoyunlu-Wigley, A. (2017). The impact of democracy and media freedom on under-5 mortality, 1961–2011. Social Science & Medicine, 190, 237–246.

WHO. 1988. The Challenge of Implementation. The challenge of implementation: district health systems for primary health care. WHO/SHS/DHS/88.1, Rev 1. Unpublished 71 p.