Allocating Capital to Time: Introducing Credit Migration for Measuring Time-Related Risks

Albrecher, Hansjörg and Dacorogna, Michel M (2024): Allocating Capital to Time: Introducing Credit Migration for Measuring Time-Related Risks.

Abstract

Assessing time-related risks in long-tailed insurance is challenging. Regulatory capital allocation rules may underestimate credit deterioration risk by not requiring insurers to hold solvency capital early, while actuarial practices often allocate capital sooner than mandated. We propose a framework to quantify these time-associated risks and evaluate capital allocation strategies based on time to ultimate, aiming to manage long-tail business effectively. By modeling the impact of exogenous credit migration risk, we evaluate six strategies, including costs associated with potential company bankruptcy until long-term claims are settled. Using a numerical example of a future heavy-tailed insurance risk, we estimate a Markov chain credit migration model with insurance market data and analyze liability values from various capital management strategies. Our findings show that early capital raising is costly, even with penalties for avoided credit risk, unless the company's initial credit rating is poor. In such cases, purchasing protection through a credit derivative may be more efficient, if available.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Insurance, solvency capital requirement, credit risk, bankruptcy, regulation
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G22 - Insurance ; Insurance Companies ; Actuarial Studies; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G28 - Government Policy and Regulation; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G32 - Financing Policy ; Financial Risk and Risk Management ; Capital and Ownership Structure ; Value of Firms ; Goodwill

References

Albrecher, H., Bauer, D., Embrechts, P., Filipovi´c, D., Koch-Medina, P., Korn, R., Loisel, S., Pelsser, A., Schiller, F., Schmeiser, H., and Wagner, J. (2018). Asset liability management for long-term insurance business. European Actuarial Journal, 8:9–25.

Albrecher, H., Eisele, K.-T., Steffensen, M., and W¨uthrich, M. V. (2022). On the cost of capital rate under incomplete market valuation. Journal of Risk and Insurance, 89(4):1139–1158.

Artzner, P., Eisele, K.-T., and Schmidt, T. (2024). Insurance-finance arbitrage. Mathematical Finance, in press.

Barigou, K., Bignozzi, V., and Tsanakas, A. (2022). Insurance valuation: A two-step generalised regression approach. ASTIN Bulletin, 52(1):211–245.

Barigou, K. and Dhaene, J. (2019). Fair valuation of insurance liabilities via mean-variance hedging in a multi-period setting. Scandinavian Actuarial Journal, 2019(2):163–187.

Bauer, D. and Zanjani, G. (2021). Economic capital and RAROC in a dynamic model. Journal of Banking and Finance, 125:106071.

Belkin, B., Suchower, S., and Forest, L. (1998). A one-parameter representation of credit risk and transition matrices. CreditMetrics Monitor, 1(3):46–56.

Bohn, J. G. and Hall, B. (1998). The costs of insurance company failures. In The Economics of Property-Casualty Insurance, pages 139–166. University of Chicago Press.

Chen, Z., Chen, B., Dhaene, J., and Yang, T. (2021). Fair dynamic valuation of insurance liabilities via convex hedging. Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 98:1–13.

Dacorogna, M. (2018). A change of paradigm for the insurance industry. Annals of Actuarial Science, 12(2):211–232.

Dacorogna, M., Albrecher, H., Moller, M., and Sahiti, S. (2013). Equalization reserves for natural catastrophes and shareholder value: a simulation study. European Actuarial Journal, 3(1):1–21.

de Finetti, B. (1940). Ii problema dei pieni. Giornale dell’Istituto Italiano degli Attuari, 11(1):1–88.

Delong, L., Dhaene, J., and Barigou, K. (2019a). Fair valuation of insurance liability cash-flow streams in continuous time: Applications. ASTIN Bulletin, 49(2):299–333.

Delong, L., Dhaene, J., and Barigou, K. (2019b). Fair valuation of insurance liability cash-flow streams in continuous time: Theory. Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 88:196–208.

Denneberg, D. and Kaplan, D. (1988). 14. die methode der verzerrten wahrscheinlichkeiten in der lebens- und rentenversicherung. Bl¨atter der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Versicherungsmathematik, 23:473–478.

Denzler, S. M., Dacorogna, M. M., Müller, U. A., and McNeil, A. J. (2006). From default probabilities to credit spreads: Credit risk models do explain market prices. Finance Research Letters, 3(2):79–95.

Dhaene, J., Stassen, B., Barigou, K., Linders, D., and Chen, Z. (2017). Fair valuation of insurance liabilities: Merging actuarial judgement and market-consistency. Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 76:14–27.

Eisele, K.-T. and Artzner, P. (2011). Multiperiod insurance supervision: top-down models. European Actuarial Journal, 1:107–130.

Eling, M., Gatzert, N., and Schmeiser, H. (2008). The Swiss Solvency Test and its market implications. The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance: Issues and Practice, 33:418–439.

Engler, N. and Lindskog, F. (2023). Approximations of multi-period liability values by simple formulas. arXiv preprint arXiv:2301.09450.

Engsner, H., Lindensj¨o, K., and Lindskog, F. (2020). The value of a liability cash flow in discrete time subject to capital requirements. Finance and Stochastics, 24:125–167.

Engsner, H., Lindskog, F., and Thøgersen, J. (2023). Multiple-prior valuation of cash flows subject to capital requirements. Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 111:41–56.

European Union (2009). Directive 2009/138/EC (Solvency II). Official Journal of European Union, 335.

Federal Office of Private Insurance (2006). Technisches Dokument zum Swiss Solvency Test. Available at: https://www.finma.ch/FinmaArchiv/bpv/download/d/SST_technischesDokument_061002.pdf

Filipovic, D., Kremslehner, R., and Muermann, A. (2015). Optimal investment and premium policies under risk shifting and solvency regulation. Journal of Risk and Insurance, 82(2):261–288.

Floreani, A. (2011). Risk margin estimation through the cost of capital approach: Some conceptual issues. The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance: Issues and Practice, 36:226–253.

Froot, K. A. and Stein, J. C. (1998). Risk management, capital budgeting, and capital structure policy for financial institutions: an integrated approach. Journal of financial economics, 47(1):55–82.

Guo, Q., Bauer, D., and Zanjani, G. H. (2021). Capital allocation techniques: Review and comparison. Variance, 14(2).

Guo, Q., Bauer, D., and Zanjani, G. H. (2023). Dynamic capital allocation in general insurance. Preprint.

Hansen, L. P. and Renault, E. (2010). Pricing kernels. Encyclopedia of Quantitative Finance.

Jones, H. (2023). EU agrees to ease capital rules for insurers to boost investment. Available at: https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/eu-agrees-ease-capital-rules-insurers-boost-investment-2023-12-13/.

Klaassen, P. and Van Eeghen, I. (2009). Economic capital: How it works, and what every manager needs to know. Elsevier, North Holland.

Koch-Medina, P. and Munari, C. (2020). Market-Consistent Prices. Springer,

Heidelberg. Korn, R. and Stahl, G. (2024). A first look back: model performance under Solvency II. European Actuarial Journal, in press.

Nick W Kraemer, S&P (2021). Default, transition, and recovery: 2020 annual global corporate default and rating transition study. Available at: https://www.spglobal.com/ratings/en/research/articles/210407-default-transition-and-recovery-2020-annual-global-corporate-default-and-rating-transition-stu dy-11900573.

Pelkiewicz, A., Ahmed, S., Fulcher, P., Johnson, K., Reynolds, S., Schneider, R., and Scott, A. (2020). A review of the risk margin – Solvency II and beyond. British Actuarial Journal, 25(e1):1–72.

Pflug, G. C. and Roemisch, W. (2007). Modeling, measuring and managing risk. World Scientific, Singapore.

Salahnejhad Ghalehjooghi, A. and Pelsser, A. (2023). A market-and time-consistent extension for the eiopa risk-margin. European Actuarial Journal, 13(2):517–539.

Schmutz, M., Moehr, C., and Dudok de Wit, L. (2023). The risk margin and market risks. Oberwolfach Reports 2023/44, pages 18–21.

Vedani, J., El Karoui, N., Loisel, S., and Prigent, J.-L. (2017). Market inconsistencies of market-consistent European life insurance economic valuations: pitfalls and practical solutions. European Actuarial Journal, 7:1–28.

Wang, S. (1996). Premium calculation by transforming the layer premium density. ASTIN Bulletin: The Journal of the IAA, 26(1):71–92.

Wilson, T. (2015). Value and Capital Management: A Handbook for the Finance and Risk Functions of Financial Institutions. Wiley.