Real time estimation of potential output and output gap for theeuro-area: comparing production function with unobserved componentsand SVAR approaches

Lemoine, Matthieu and Mazzi, Gian Luigi and Monperrus-Veroni, Paola and Reynes, Frédéric (2008): Real time estimation of potential output and output gap for theeuro-area: comparing production function with unobserved componentsand SVAR approaches. Published in: Document de travail de l'OFCE , Vol. 34, (November 2008): pp. 1-44.

Abstract

We develop a new version of the production function (PF) approach usually used for estimating the output gap of the euro area. Our version does not call for any (often imprecise) measure of the capital stock and improves the estimation of the trend total factor productivity. We asses this approach by comparing it with two other multivariate methods mostly used for output gap estimates, a multivariate unobserved components (MUC) model and a Structural Vector Auto-Regressive (SVAR) model. The comparison is conducted by relying on assessment criteria such as the concordance of the turning points chronology with a reference one, the inflation forecasting power and the real-time consistency of the estimates. Two contributions are achieved. Firstly, we take into account data revisions and their impact on the output gap estimates by using vintage datasets coming from the Euro Area Business Cycle (EABCN) Real-Time Data-Base (RTDB). Secondly, the PF approach, generally employed by policy-makers despite of its difficult implementation, is assessed. We thus improve on previous papers which limited their assessment on other multivariate methods, e.g. MUC or SVAR models. The different methods show different ranks in relation to the three criteria. This new PF estimate appears highly concordant with the reference chronology. Its forecasting power appears favourable only for the shortest horizon (1 month). Finally, the SVAR model appears more consistent in real-time.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: potential output, production function, state-space models, structural VARs
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C3 - Multiple or Simultaneous Equation Models ; Multiple Variables > C32 - Time-Series Models ; Dynamic Quantile Regressions ; Dynamic Treatment Effect Models ; Diffusion Processes ; State Space Models; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E32 - Business Fluctuations ; Cycles

References

ANAS J., M. BILLIO, L. FERRARA and G. L. MAZZI, 2008, “A system for dating and detecting turning points in the euro area”, The Manchester School, forthcoming.

APEL M., P. JANSSON, 1999, “A theory-consistent system approach for estimating potential output and the NAIRU”, Economics Letters 64, 271-275.

ARROW K. J., H. B CHENERY, B. S. MINHAS and R. M. SOLOW, 1961, “Capital- Labor Substitution and Economic Efficiency”, Review of Economics and Statistics 43(3), 225-250.

BANQUE DE FRANCE, 2002: “Croissance potentielle, positionnement de l’économie dans le cycle et tensions inflationnistes", Bulletin de la Banque de France n°103, juillet.

BEFFY P.-O., P. OLLIVAUD, P RICHARDSON., F. SÉDILLOT, 2007, “New OECD method for supply-side and medium-term assessments: a capital services approach”, OECD Economics Department Working Papers 482

BJØRNLAND H., L. BRUBAKK and A. S. JORE, 2007, “Forecasting inflation with uncertain output gaps”, Empirical Economics, forthcoming.

BLANCHARD O. J. and L. H. SUMMERS, 1986, “Hysteresis and the European Unemployment”, in: Fischer S. (Eds.), NBER Macroeconomics Annual, Fall, MIT Press, Cambridge, 15-78.

BLANCHARD O. J. and L. F.KATZ, 1999, “Wage Dynamic: Reconciling Theory and Evidence”, American Economic Review 89(2), 69-74.

BLANCHARD O. J. and D. QUAH, 1993, ''The Dynamic Effect of Aggregate Demand and Supply Disturbances: Reply'', American Economic Review, 83, pp. 653-58.

BLANCHARD O. J. et L. H. SUMMERS, 1987, « Hysteresis and the European Unemployment Problem », NBER working paper, N° 1950.

BLOCH L., P.-Y. HENIN, O. MARCHAND, F. MEUNIER, C. THELOT, 1986, “Analyse macroéconomique des taux d’activité et flexion conjoncturelle”, Economie Appliquée 1986 (4).

BULLARD J. B. and J. W. KEATING, 1995, "The Long-Run Relationship between Inflation and Output in Postwar Economies ", Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol. 36, Issue 3, 477-496.

BUTTER F. A. G. and S. J. KOOPMAN, 2001, "Interaction Between Structural Employment and Cyclical Shocks in Production and Employment", Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, Vol. 137, 273-296.

CAHN C. and A. SAINT-GUILHEM, 2007, “Potential output growth in several Industrialised country. A comparison”, ECB Working Paper 828, November.

CAMBA-MENDEZ G. and D. RODRIGUEZ-PALENZUELA, 2003, “Assessment criteria for output gap estimates”, Economic modelling, pp. 529-562.

COTIS J.-P., J. ELMESKOV and A. MOUROUGANE, 2005, “Estimates of potential output: benefits and pitfalls from a policy perspective”, in L. Reichlin (ed.), Euro area business cycle: stylised facts and measurement issues, CEPR.

CEPII, 1997, “Croissance potentielle et écart de production”, Economie internationale 69, 1er trimestre.

CHAGNY O., J. DÖPKE, M. PLANE, R. SCHMIDT, 2001, “Labour Supply and Labour Force Participation in Europe – A Discussion of Some Recent Developments and Projections”, Kiel Working Paper 1049, May.

CHAGNY O. and M. LEMOINE, 2004, “An estimation of the euro area potential output with a semi-structural multivariate Hodrick-Prescott filter”, OFCE working paper No 2004-14, December.

CHAGNY O., M. LEMOINE and F. PELGRIN, 2004, “An assessment of multivariate output gap estimates in the euro area”, Working papers and studies, Eurostat.

CHAGNY O., F. REYNES and H. STERDYNIAK, 2002, « Le taux de chômage d’équilibre: discussion théorique et évaluation empirique», Revue de l’OFCE n°81, April.

CHAUVIN V. and M. PLANE, 2001, “2000-2040 : Population active et croissance”, Revue de l’OFCE 79, octobre.

De BANDT O. and P. ROUSSEAUX, 2002 : “Estimation du PIB potentiel et de l’écart par la méthode « structurelle »”, Note d’études et de recherche de la Banque de France, No. 89.

DENIS C., D. GRENOUILLEAU, K. MC MORROW and W. RÖGER, 2006, “Calculating potential growth rates and output gaps - A revised production function approach”, European Economy No 247.

DENIS C., K. Mc MORROW and W. RÖGER, 2001 : ''Production function approach to calculating potential growth and output gaps – estimates for the EU Member States and the US'', European Commission Economic Papers No 150.

DERNBURG T. and K. STRAND, 1966, “Hidden Unemployment 1953-62: A Quantitative Analysis by Age and Sex” American Economic Review 56(1), 71-95

DESERRES, A. and A.GUAY, 1995, “Selection of the Truncation Lag in Structural VARs (or VECMs) with Long-Run Restrictions” Bank of Canada, Working Paper 95-9.

DIEBOLD F. X. and R. S. MARIANO, 1995, ''Comparing Predictive Accuracy'', Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, Vol..13, No.3, pp. 253-63

DURBIN J. and S.J. KOOPMAN, 2001, Time Series Analysis by Space State Methods, Oxford University Press.

FABIANI, S. and S. MESTRE, 2001, “A System Approach for Measuring the Euro Area NAIRU”, European Central Bank Working Paper, 65.

FAUST, J., LEEPER, E.M., 1997, “When Do Long-Run Identifying Restrictions Give Reliable Results?”Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, 15(3), 345-353.

FILATRIAU O., 2007, “Estimation de l'impact du taux de chômage sur le taux d'activité dans les pays de l'OCDE”, Mimeo.

FOURNIER J.-Y. and P.GIVORD, 2001, “La réduction des taux d’activité aux âges extrêmes, une spécificité française ? ”, Documents de travail de la Direction des Etudes et Synthèses Economiques, G 2001 / 16, INSEE.

GERLACH S. and F. SMETS (1999), “Output Gaps and the Monetary Policy in the EMU area”, European Economic Review, 43, 205-244.

GHAHRAMANI Z. and E. HINTON, 1996, “Parameter estimation for linear dynamical systems”, working paper, University of Toronto.

GORDON R. J., 1997, “The Time-varying NAIRU and its Implications for Economic Policy”, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 11(1), 11-32.

GIORNO C., P. RICHARDSON, D. ROSEVEARE and P. VAN DEN NOORD, 1995, "Estimating potential output, output gaps and structural budget balances", OECD Economic Department Working Paper, No 152.

HARVEY A.C., 1985, “Trend and cycles in macroeconomic time series”, Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, No 3.

HARVEY D., S. LEYBOURNE and P. NEWBOLD, 1997, “Testing the equality of prediction mean errors”, International Journal of Forecasting, No 13, 281-291.

HEYER E., F. REYNES and H. STERDYNIAK, 2004, “Variables observables et inobservables dans la théorie du taux de chômage d’équilibre, Une comparaison France / Etats-Unis ”, OFCE Working Paper 2004-03.

HEYER E., F. REYNÈS and H. STERDYNIAK, 2007, “Structural and reduced approaches of the equilibrium rate of unemployment, a comparison between France and the United States”, Economic Modelling 24, pp. 42-65.

HEYER E. and X. TIMBEAU (2002), « Le chômage structurel à 5% en France ? », Revue de l’OFCE n°80, January.

HODRICK, R. and E.C. PRESCOTT, 1980, "Post-War U.S. Business Cycles: An Empirical Investigation", Discussion Paper No 451, Carnegie-Mellon University, Pittsburgh, P.A.

JACQUOT, A., 1997, “Les flexions des taux d’activité sont-elles seulement conjoncturelles”, Economie et Prévisions, 127 :137–155, january.

JAEGER, A. and M. PARKINSON, , 1994, “Some evidence in Hysteresis in Unemployment Rates”, European Economic Review 38(2), 329-342.

KING, R. G., J. H. STOCK and M. WATSON, 1995, “Temporal instability of the unemployment-inflation relationship”, Economic Perspectives of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago 19, 2-12.

IRAC D., 2000, “Estimation of a time varying NAIRU for France”, Note d’études et de recherche de la Banque de France 75.

KICHIAN M., 1999, "Measuring Potential Output within a State-Space Framework", Working Paper No. 99-9, Bank Of Canada.

KUTTNER K.N. (1994), “Estimating Potential Output Gap as a Latent Variable”, Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 12, 361-367.

LAUBACH, T., 2001, “Measuring the NAIRU: evidence from seven economies”, Review of Economics and Statistics 83(2), 218-231.

LAXTON D. and R. TETLOW, 1992, “A Simple Multivariate Filter for the Measurement of Potential Output”, Technical Report No. 59. Bank of Canada.

LE BIHAN H., H. STERDYNIAK and P. COUR, 1997, “La notion de croissance potentielle a-t-elle un sens?”, Economie internationale 69.

LEMOINE M., P. MONPERRUS-VERONI and F. REYNES, 2006, “Potentiels moins freinés”, Revue de l’OFCE 99, october.

LEMOINE M., P. MONPERRUS-VERONI and F. REYNES, 2007a, “L’Europe moins vieille que prévue. La démographie favorable à une politique de croissance”, Lettre de l’OFCE 281, March.

LEMOINE M., P. MONPERRUS-VERONI and F. REYNES, F., 2007b, “Nairu en zone heureuse”, Revue de l’OFCE 101, April.

LOGEAY C. and S. TOBER, 2003, “Time-varying Nairu and real interest rates in the Euro Area”, DIW Discussion Papers 351.

MC MORROW K. and W. ROEGER, 2000, “Time-Varying Nairu / Nawru Estimates for the EU’s Member States”, European Commission Economic Paper 145.

ONGENA H. and W. ROGER, 1997, “Les estimations de l’écart de production de la Commission Européenne ”, Economie internationale 69, 1er trimestre.

ORLANDI F. and K. PICHELMANN, 2000, "Disentangling Trend and Cycle in the EUR-11 Unemployment Series", Economic Paper No. 140, DG ECFIN.

ORPHANIDES A. and S. VAN NORDEN, 2002, “The Unreliability of Output Gap Estimates in Real Time”, Review of Economics and Statistics, 84, 569-583.

ORPHANIDES A. and S. VAN NORDEN, 2004, “The Reliability of Inflation Forecasts Based on Output Gap Estimates in Real Time”, FEDS Working Paper No. 2004-68.

PASSET, O., C. RIFFLART and H. STERDYNIAK, 1997, “Ralentissement de la croissance potentielle et hausse du chômage”, Revue de l’OFCE 60, 147-186.

PROIETTI T., A. MUSSO and T. WESTERMANN, 2002, ''Estimating Potential Output and the Output Gap for the euro area : a Model-Based Production Function Approach'', ECB Working paper.

RICHARDSON P., L., BOONE, C. GIORNO, M. MEACCI, D. RAE and D. TURNER, 2000 : “The concept, policy use and measurement of structural unemployment : estimating a time varying NAIRU across 21 OECD countries'', OECD Economic Department Working Paper No 250.

RÜNSTLER G., 2002, ''The information content of real-time output gap estimates. An application to the euro area'', ECB Working Paper.

SCOTT A., 2000, "A multivariate unobserved components model of cyclical activity", Discussion Paper 2000/04, Reserve Bank of New Zealand.

SHAPIRO M. D., M. W. WATSON, 1988, “Sources of Business Cycle Fluctuations”, NBER Working Paper 2589, May 1988.

SIMS C.A., 1980, “Comparison of Interwar and Postwar Cycles: Monetarism Reconsidered”, NBER Working Paper 430, January 1980.

STRAND K. and T. DERNBURG, 1964, “Cyclical Variation in Civilian Labor Force Participation”, Review of Economics and Statistics 46(4), 378-391.

TURNER D., L. BOONE, C. GIORNO, M. MEACCI, D. RAE, P. RICHARDSON, 2001, Estimating the structural rate of unemployment for the OECD countries, OECD Economic Studies, No.33, 2001/2.