Religion, Clubs, and Emergent Social Divides

Makowsky, Michael (2009): Religion, Clubs, and Emergent Social Divides.

Abstract

Arguments for and against the existence of an American cultural divide are frequently placed in a religious context. This paper seeks to establish that, all politics aside, the American religious divide is real, that modern religious polarization is not a uniquely American phenomenon, and that religious divides can be understood as naturally emergent within the club theory of religion. Analysis of the 2005 Baylor Religion reveals a bimodal distribution of religious commitment in the US. International survey data reveals bimodal distributions in twenty-eight of thirty surveyed countries. The club theory of religion, when applied in a multi-agent model, generates bimodal distributions of religious commitment whose emergence correlates to substitutability of club goods for standard goods and the mean population wage rate. Ramifications of religious bimodality include potential instability of majority rule electoral outcomes. Median estimators, such as majority rule democracy, are non-robust with bimodal distributions. When religion is politically salient and polarized, small errors can disproportionately shift the election result from the preferences of the median voter.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Culture Divide, Religious Divide, Club Theory, Multi-Agent Model, Sacrifice
• Subjects: Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology > Z12 - Religion; D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D71 - Social Choice ; Clubs ; Committees ; Associations; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C6 - Mathematical Methods ; Programming Models ; Mathematical and Simulation Modeling > C63 - Computational Techniques ; Simulation Modeling

References

Abramowitz, Alan, and Kyle L. Saunders. 2005. "Why Can't We all Just Get Along? The Reality of a Polarized America." Working Paper.

Ansolabehere, Stephen, Jonathan Rodden, and James M. Snyder. 2006. "Purple America." Journal of Economic Perspectives 20 (2):97-118.

Bader, Christopher, Kevin Dougherty, Paul Frose, Byron Johnson, F. Carson Mencken, Jerry Z. Park, and Rodney Stark. 2006. "American Piety in the 21st Century: New Insights into the Depth and Complexity of Religion in the U.S." The Baylor Institute for Studies of Religion.

Becker, Gary S. 1965. "A Theory of the Allocation of Time." The Economic Journal 75 (299):493-517.

Berman, Eli. 2000. "Sect, Subsidy, and Sacrifice: An Economist's View of Ultra-Orthodox Jews." Quarterly Journal of Economics 65 (3):905-53.

Black, Duncan. 1948. "On the Rationale of Group Decision-making." Journal of Political Economy 56:23-34.

Buchanan, James M. 1965. "An Economic Theory of Clubs." Economica 32 (125):1-14.

Clark, Christopher, and Wolfram Kaiser. 2003. Culture wars : secular-Catholic conflict in nineteenth-century Europe. Cambridge ; New York: Cambridge University Press.

Clementi, F., and M. Gallegati. 2005. "Power law tails in the Italian personal income distribution." Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications 350 (2-4):427-38.

Cornes, Richard, and Todd Sandler. 1986. The Theory of Externalities, Public Goods, and Club Goods. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Darlingotn, Richard B. 1970. "Is Kurtosis Really "Peakedness?"" The American Statistician 24 (2):19-22.

DiMaggio, Paul, John Evans, and Bethany Bryson. 1996. "Have American's Social Attitudes Become More Polarized?" The American Journal of Sociology 102 (3):690-755.

Dragulescu, A. A., and V. M. Yakovenko. 2001. "Evidence for the exponential distribution of income in the USA." The European Physical Journal 20:585-9. Efron, Bradley, and Robert Tibshirani. 1993. An Introduction to the Bootstrap. London: Chapman and hall.

Ellision, Aaron M. 1987. "Effect of Seed Dimorphism on the Density-Dependent Dynamics of Experimental Populations of Atriplex triangularis (Chenopodiaceae)." American Journal of Botany 74 (8):1280-8.

Enyedi, Zsolt. 2000. "Clerical and religious polarization in Hungary." In Religion and Mass Electoral Behaviour, ed. D. Broughton and H.-M. T. Napel. London: Routledge.

Evans, John H., Bethany Bryson, and Paul DiMaggio. 2001. "Opinion Polarization: Important Contributions, Necessary Limitations." The American Journal of Sociology 106 (4):944-59.

Fiorina, Morris P., Samuel J. Abrams, and Jeremy Pope. 2005. Culture war? : the myth of a polarized America. New York: Pearson Longman.

Glaeser, Edward L., and Bryce Ward. 2006. "Myths and Realities of American Political Geography." Journal of Economic Perspectives 20 (2):119-44.

Gruber, Jonathan, and Daniel M. Hungerman. 2006. "The Church vs. The Mall: What Happens When Religion Faces Increased Secular Competition." Quarterly Journal of Economics 123 (2):831-62.

Hungerman, Dan. 2003. "Are Church and State Substitutes? Evidence from the 1996 Welfare Reform." Working Paper. Hunter, James Davison. 1991. Culture Wars: The Struggle to Define America. New York: BasicBooks.

Iannaccone, Laurence, and Michael Makowsky. 2007. "Accidental Atheists?Agent-Based Explanations for the Persistence of Religious Regionalism." Journal for the Scientific of Study of Religion 46 (1):1-19.

Iannaccone, Laurence R. 1992. "Sacrifice and Stigma: Reducing Free-riding in Cults, Communes, and Other Collectives." Journal of Political Economy 100 (2):271-91.

Imbert, Eric, Jose Escarre, and Jacques Lepart. 1996. "Achene Dimorphism and Among-Population Variation in Crepis sancta (Asteraceae)." International Journal of Plant Sciences 157 (3):309-15.

Jones, Arthur F., and Daniel H. Weinberg. 2000. "The Changing Shape of the Nation's Income Distribution." ed. E. a. S. Administration. Washington, D.C.: U.S Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census.

Kollman, Ken, J. H. Miller, and Scott E. Page. 2003. Computational models in political economy. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.

Levy, D. 1989. "The Statistical Basis of Athenian-American Constitutional Theory." The Journal of Legal Studies 18 (1):79-103.

Levy, D. M., and S. Peart. 2002. "Galton's Two Papers on Voting as Robust Estimation." Public Choice 113 (3):357-65.

Luke, S., C. Cioffi-Revilla, L. Panait, K. Sullivan, and G. Balan. 2005. "MASON: A Multiagent Simulation Environment." SIMULATION 81 (7):517.

Majumder, Amita, and Satya Ranjan Chakravarty. 1990. "Distribution of Personal Income: Development of a new Model and its Application to U. S. Income Data." Journal of Applied Econometrics 5 (2):189-96.

McBride, Michael. 2007. "Club Mormon: Free-riders, Monitoring, and Exclusion in the LDS Church." Rationality and Society 19 (4):395-424.

McDonald, James B., and Michael R. Ransom. 1979. "Functional Forms, Estimation Techniques and the Distribution of Income." Econometrica 47 (6):1513-26.

Mosteller, Frederick, and John Wilder Tukey. 1977. Data Analysis and Regression: a Second Course in Statistics. Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley Pub. Co. Press, William H. 2002. Numerical recipes in C++ : the art of scientific computing. 2nd ed. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Reynal-Querol, Marta. 2002. "Ethnicity, Political Systems, and Civil Wars." SAS/STAT User's Guide. 1989. Version 6, 4th ed. ed. 2 vols vols. Cary, N.C.: SAS Institute.

Shapiro, Jesse M., Edward L. Glaeser, and Giacomo Ponzetto. 2005. "Strategic Extremism: Why Republicans and Democrats Divide on Religious Values." Quarterly Journal of Economics 120 (No. 4):1283-330.

Smith, Christian S., David Sikkink, and J. Baily. 1998. "Devotion in Dixie and Beyond: A Test of the 'Shibley thesis' on the Rffects of Regional Origin and Migration on Individual Religiosity." Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 37 (3):495-506.

Stark, Rodney, William Sims Bainbridge, and The Seymour Martin Lipset collection. 1985. The future of religion : secularization, revival, and cult formation. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Stigler, George J., and Gary S. Becker. 1977. "De Gustibus Non Est Disputandum." The American Economic Review 67 (2):76-90.

Sunstein, C. R. 2002. "The Law of Group Polarization." Journal of Political Philosophy 10 (2):175-95.

Wand, J. N., K. W. Shotts, J. S. Sekhon, W. R. Mebane Jr, M. C. Herron, and H. E. Brady. 2002. "The Butterfly Did It: The Aberrant Vote for Buchanan in Palm Beach County, Florida." American Political Science Review 95 (04):793-810.

Wolfe, Alan. 1998. One Nation After All: What Middle-Class Americans Really Think About: God, Country, Family, Racism, Welfare, Immigration, Homosexuality, Work, the Right, the Left, and Each Other. New York: Viking Penguin.