HOW to Facilitate or Stifle Economic Development: The Role of Agriculture in Indonesia and the Philippines

James, William and Roumasset, James (1992): HOW to Facilitate or Stifle Economic Development: The Role of Agriculture in Indonesia and the Philippines. Published in: SOUTHEAST ASIAN JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS , Vol. 1, No. 2 (1992): pp. 125-136.

Abstract

Strikingly different patterns of agricultural growth and widely divergent results in terlnsof rural income. poverty. and employment have cmcrged in Southeast Asia. In the Philippiies, with someregional variations, a patterns of declining red farm wages,increasing landlessness in worsening poverty and diminishing employmctlt relative to demand for jobs has emerged despite some brief periods of improvcment since 1960. Sincc 1980, the employment and poverty situation has deteriorated sharply,particularly in areas concentrating on single traditional export crops (lkc sugar or coconuts) but also in amore general context. Indonesia (particularly in Java, which contains over 60 pcrcent of the population) succeeded in reversing a seemingly inevitable worsening of poverty and inequality in the rural economy with strong evidence indicating that rural real wages and income of small farmers rose substantially between the mid-1970sand late 1980s.

Why such divergent patterns of rural development exist and the lessons that can be extracted from thc varied cxperiences of 1ndoncsia and the Philippines are subjects of this papcr.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: agriculture, economic develoment, Indonesia, the Philippines
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N0 - General > N01 - Development of the Discipline: Historiographical; Sources and Methods; N - Economic History > N5 - Agriculture, Natural Resources, Environment, and Extractive Industries > N55 - Asia including Middle East; D - Microeconomics > D9 - Intertemporal Choice > D92 - Intertemporal Firm Choice, Investment, Capacity, and Financing

References

Afiff, Saleh, 1990. Economic adjustment: the Indonesian experience. Paper Presented during the Second Round Table on Development Strategies, 22-24 January (Manila: Asian Development Bank)

Balisacan, A.M. Agricultural growth, landlessness, off-farm employment,andrural poverty in the Philippines, Economic Development and Cultural Change, forthcoming.

Balisacan, A.M., and J. Roumasset, 1987. Public choice of economic policy: the growth of agricultural protection, Welhoirtschafrliches Archiv 123,232-248.

Bautista, R.M. 1987. Production Incentives in Philippine Agriculture: Effects of Trade and ExchangeRate Policies. Research Report 59 (Washington, D.C.: International Food Policy Research Institute).

Binswanger, H.P. and V.W. Ruttan, 1978. Induced Innovation: Technology, Institutions and Development (Baltimore, MD: JohnsHopkins University Press).

Borland, J. and X. Yang, 1992. Specialization and a new approach to economic organization and growth, American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings, May, 386-91.

Boserup, E., 1981. Population and Technological Change: A Study of Long-Term Trends (Chicago , k University of Chicago Press).

Clarete, R. and J. Roumasset, 1987. Anatomy of stagnation: economic policy and agricultural development in the Philippines, in: R. Purcell and E. Momson, eds.. U.S. Agricultural Exports and Third World Development: The Critical Linkuges (Boulder, Colorado: Lynne and Reiner Press), 115-39.

Collier, W. et al., 1974. Choice of technique of rice milling on Java : a comment, Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, March, 106- 120.

Collier, W. et al., 1982. Acceleration of rural development in Java, Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies 18.3, November, 82-101.

Coxhead, LA., 1989. Technical change, irrigation and factor demand elasticities in Philippine agriculture. Working Papers in Trade Development (Canberm Australian National University Department of Economics and National Centre for Development Studies).

David, C. C., 1987. Philippines: food policy in transition. Agricultural Economics Depariment Paper No. 87-03, January(LosBaños: International Rice Research Institute).

David, C. C. and K. Otsuka, 1989. The modem seed fertilizer technology and adoption of laborsaving technologies: the Philippine case. Agricultural Economics Department Paper No. 89-15 (Los Baños: International RiceResearch Institute).

Day. R. H., 1982. Instability in the transition from manoralism: a classical analysis, Explorations in Economic History 19, 321-28.

Dowling,J.M., 1984. Incomedistributionand poverty in selected Asian countries. Asian Development Bank Economic Staff Paper No. 22, November.

Food and AgricultureOrganization, 1989. Prodrtctio11 Yearbook (Rome: United Nations).

Gardner, B., 1987. The Economics of Agricultural Policies (New York, NY: Macmillan).

Geertz, C., 1966. Agricultural Involution (Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press).

Hart, G., 1986. Power. Labor and Livelihood: Processes of Change in Rural Java (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press).

Hayami, Y., 1978. Anatomy of a Peasant Economy: A Rice Village in the Philippines (Los Baños: IRRI).

Hayami, Y., L. S. Adriano and M. R. Quisumbing, 1988. Agribusiness and agrarian reform: a view from the banana and the pineapple plantations. Agricultural Policy Research Program Working Paper No. 88-01 (Los Baños:U niversity of the Philippines). Hayami, Y. and J. Kikuchi, 1981. Asian Village Economy at the Crossroads: An Economic Approach to Insritutional Change (Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press).

Hayami, Y. and V. W. Ruttan, 1985. Agricultural Development: An International Perspective (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press).

Intemational Rice R e s k h Institute (TRRI), 1987. WorldRiceStatistics (Los Baños,Philippines: 1RRI).

Huke, R. E., 1963. Shadows or1 the Land: An Economic Geography of the Philippines (Manila: Bookmark Publishers).

International Rice Research Institute (IRRI), 1987. WorldRiceStatistics (Los Ballos,Philippines: IRRI).

James, W.E.,and J. Roumasset, 1984. Migration and I the evolution of tenure contracts in newly settled regions, Journal of Development ! Economics 14, 147-62. Johnston, B. and P. Kilby, 1975. Agricutural and ! Structural Transformation (London: Oxford University Press).

Jorgenson, D. W., 1x1. The development of a dual economy, Economic Journal. June.

Kikuchi,M.,A.Hafid,andY.Hayami. 198 4.Changes in rice harvesting contracts and wages in Java, I in: H.P. Binswangerand M.Rosenzweig,eds., Contractual Arrangements, Employment, and i Wages in Rural Labor Markets in Asia (New Haven, Connecticut: Yale University Press), 117-30.

Lande. C. H.. 1987. Rebuilding a Nation: Philippine Challenges and American Policy (Washington, D. C.: Washington Institute Press).

Manning, C., 1988. Rural employment creation in Java: lessons fmm the green revolution and oil boom, Population and Development ReTew, March, 47-80. Mears,L., 1981. The New Rice Economy in Indonesia (J ogjalrarta: Gadjah Madah University Press).

Montes, M.. 1991. The Philippines: in search of internal dynamism in the development proocess, Journal of International Economic Studies 5, 97-118.

Naylor, R., 1990. Wage trends in rice production on Java: 1976-1988, Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, August, 133-54.

Palmer, I., 1977. Rural poverty in Indonesia with special reference to Java, Poverty and Landlessness in Rural Asia (Geneva: International Labour Office).

Pelzer, K. J., 1945. Pioneer Settlement in Asiatic Tropics (New York. NY: American Geographical Society).

Power, J.H., and G.P. Sicat, 1971. The Philippines: Industrialization and Trade Policies (London: Oxford University Press).

Ranis, G., 1991. The political economy of development policy change, in: G.M. Meier, ed.,Politics and Policy Making in Developing Countries: Perspectives on the New Political Economy (San Francisco: InternationalCenter for Economic Growth), 69-122.

Roumasset, J. and J. Smith, 1981. Population, technological change, and landless workers, Population and Development Review 7,401 - 20.

Shepherd, G. and F. Alburo, 1991. The Philippines, in: D. Papageorgiu, M. Michaely, and A.M. Choski,eds., Liberalizing Foreign Trade, Vol. II (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Basil Blackwell), 133-308.

Timmer, C. P., 1984. Energy and structural change in the Asia-Pacific region: the agricultural sector, in: R.M. Bautista and S. Naya, eds., Energy and Strucrural Change in the Asia- Pacific Region (Manila: Asian Development Bank), 51-72.

World Bank, 1985. Employment trends and outlook, Indonesia: Policies for Growth and Employment, Part 11, Report No. 5597-IND, 23 April, (Washington, D.C.), 86-171.

World Bank, 1990. WorldDevelopmentReporr (New York: Oxford University Press).

Young.A.A.. 1928. Purrhasing returns and economic progress, Economic Journal 38: 152, December, 527-42.