From overhang to hangover: consequences of protectionist responses to the global crisis for low-income countries

Willenbockel, Dirk (2009): From overhang to hangover: consequences of protectionist responses to the global crisis for low-income countries.

Abstract

As the global economic crisis unfolds, policymakers around the world are faced with increasing pressures to resort to protectionist measures in support of domestic producers. While observable recent protectionist trends are certainly a far cry from the spiralling protectionism of the 1930s, and the trade restrictions implemented so far are limited in scope, it is widely expected that pressures on policymakers to adopt protectionist measures will intensify as the crisis deepens. Inspired by the approach proposed in Bouet and Laborde Debucquet (2009), this paper employs a global computable general equilibrium (CGE) trade model to contrast the outcomes of a successful Doha agreement with the consequences of a scenario in which countries raise their import duties to the maximum levels compatible with current WTO obligations. The study complements the earlier CGE analysis of Bouet and Laborde Debucquet by using a more differentiated regional disaggregation with a particular focus on low-income regions in Asia and sub-Saharan Africa, by adopting alternative factor market closures that allow for unemployment and underutilization of capital in the short run, and by incorporating the most recent (December 2008) Doha Round draft modality revisions in the analysis. The illustrative simulation results presented hereconfirm that a widespread resort to WTO-rule-consistent protectionism in response to the crisis would have drastic adverse implications for developing country trade and welfare, especially if factor market imperfections are taken into account. A swift successful completion of a meaningful Doha Round – i.e. a Doha Round that is not hollowed out by a plethora of exemptions - would gradually reduce existing binding overhangs considerably and would thus reduce the threat of a WTO-compliant rise in global protection that is bound to impede a global economic recovery.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Doha round; protectionism; global financial crisis; binding overhang; developing countries; least developed countries
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C6 - Mathematical Methods ; Programming Models ; Mathematical and Simulation Modeling > C68 - Computable General Equilibrium Models; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F13 - Trade Policy ; International Trade Organizations; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F17 - Trade Forecasting and Simulation

References

Amiti, Mary and John Romalis (2006) Will the Doha Round Lead to Preference Erosion? IMF Working Paper 06/10.

Baldwin, Richard E. and Simon Evenett (eds)(2009) The Collapse of Global Trade, Murky Protectionism, and the Crisis: Recommendations for the G20. London: Centre for Economic Policy Research.

Bouet, Antoine and David Laborde Debocquet (2009) The Potential Cost of a Failed Doha Round. 12th Annual Conference on Global Economic Analysis, Santiago.

Bown, Chad P. (2009) Protectionism Increases and Spreads: Global Use of Trade Remedies Rises by 18.8% in First Quarter 2009. Brookings Institute (May).

Dadush, Uri (2009) Resurgent Protectionism: Risks and Possible Remedies. In: New Ideas for the London Summit: Recommendations to the G20. Royal Institute of International Affairs: London, 60-64.

Dimaranan, Betina V., Robert A. McDougall and Thomas W. Hertel (2006) Behavioral Parameters. In B.V. Dimaranan (ed) Global Trade, Assistance, and Production: The GTAP 6 Data Base. Center for Global Trade Analysis, Purdue University: West Lafayette, Ch.20.

Elliott, Kimberly Ann (2007) Trade Policies for Development: Reforming U.S. Trade Preferences. CGD Brief August 2007, Center for Global Development: Washington, DC.

Erixon, Fredrik (2009) Mounting Protectionist Dangers and G20 Responses. In: New Ideas for the London Summit: Recommendations to the G20. Royal Institute of International Affairs: London, 57-59.

Gamberoni, Elisa and Richard Newfarmer (2009) Trade Protection: Incipient but Worrisome Trends. In: Baldwin and Evenett (eds), 49-53.

Hertel, Thomas W., David Hummels, Maros Ivanic, and Roman Keeney. (2007) How Confident Can We Be in CGE Based Assessments of Free Trade Agreements? Economic Modelling 24(4), 611-35.

Hufbauer, Gary and Sherry Stephenson (2009) Trade Policy in a Time of Crisis: Suggestions for Developing Countries. CEPR Policy Insight No.33 (May).

Lamy, Pascal (2009) Report to the TPRB from the Director-General on the Financial and Economic Crisis and Trade Related Developments. JOB(09)/30, 26 March 2009.

Liu, Jing, Channing Arndt and Thomas W. Hertel (2004) Parameter Estimation and Measures of Fit in a General Equilibrium Model. Journal of Economic Integration 19(3), 626-49.

Mattoo, Aaditya and Arvind Subramanian (2009) From Doha to the Next Bretton Woods: A New Multilateral Trade Agenda. Foreign Affairs 88(1), 15-26.

McDonald, Scott, Thierfelder, Karen and Robinson, Sherman (2007) Globe: A SAM Based Global CGE Model using GTAP Data’, USNA Working Paper No.14. Annapolis: US Naval Academy

Narayanan, Badri and Terrie L. Walmsley (eds) (2008) Global Trade, Assistance, and Production: The GTAP 7 Data Base. Center for Global Trade Analysis, Purdue University: West Lafayette.

PPI (2007) America’s Tariffs Hit Cambodia and Bangladesh Hardest. PPI Trade Fact of the Week, 21 February 2007, Progressive Policy Institute: Washington, DC.

Robinson, Sherman and Dirk Willenbockel (2009) The Impact on Developing Countries of an OECD Recession. IDS In Focus Policy Briefing No.7.7.

Rollo, Jim and Peter Holmes (2009) Trade and the Global Financial Crisis: Immediate Challenges and Long-Term Threats. Chatham House International Economics Programme Briefing Paper 2009/01.

Willenbockel, Dirk and Sherman Robinson (2009) The OECD Recession and Developing Country Trade: A Global Simulation Analysis. IDS Bulletin 40(4), in press.

WTO (2008a) Revised Draft Modalities for Agriculture. TN/AG/W/4/Rev.4, 6 December 2008.

WTO (2008b) Fourth Revision of Draft Modalities for Non-Agricultural Market Access. TN/MA/W/103/Rev.4, 6 December 2008.

Yang, Yongzhen (2005) Africa in the Doha Round: Dealing with Preference Erosion and Beyond. IMF Policy Discussion Paper 05/8.