Trade contraction and economic regression: the Paraguayan economy under Francia, 1814-1840

Pastore, Mario H. (1994): Trade contraction and economic regression: the Paraguayan economy under Francia, 1814-1840. Published in: Journal of Latin American Studies , Vol. 26, No. 3 (October 1994): pp. 539-595.

Abstract

I argue here that economic activity fell considerably in the first three decades of Paraguay's early national period, below levels it had attained in the late colonial period and would attain again only after the mid-nineteenth century. I attribute this economic depression primarily to regional political fragmentation and the institutional regression it triggered. In the 1810s, the United Provinces of the River Plate sought to keep the former Viceroyalty of the River Plate under a single federal government, but failed to prevent Paraguay's early secession. Their subsequent trade blockades and military threats had profound economic and political effects on Paraguay: revenues from foreign trade taxation fell, scale economies in defence and justice provision vanished, a standing army emerged, government budget deficits worsened, mercantilist regulations heightened, the fiscal burden increased, and transactions costs generally rose. Proponents of federation, more representative governments, and freer trade progressively declined, while supporters of secession, political absolutism, and government regulation became ever more prominent. In the 1820s, blockade relaxations exacerbated economic intervention by the state, which substantially redistributed property rights in land towards itself. In the 1830s, renewed blockading had more than proportional negative effects on economic activity, which remained below late colonial levels at least until international waterways became freely navigable shortly after mid-century. Colonial absolutism and mercantilism may be said to have been restored with a vengeance. Long-run economic performance worsened.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: autarky, economic contraction, institutional regression; trade exposure, political cleavages; "autonomous' development; financing of public spending, state land ownership, taxation of peasantry.
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F16 - Trade and Labor Market Interactions; D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D62 - Externalities; D - Microeconomics > D3 - Distribution > D33 - Factor Income Distribution; D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D02 - Institutions: Design, Formation, Operations, and Impact; N - Economic History > N5 - Agriculture, Natural Resources, Environment, and Extractive Industries > N56 - Latin America ; Caribbean

References

References

Abente, Diego (1989). "Foreign Capital, Economic Elites, and the State in Paraguay during the Liberal Republic (1870-1936) ," Journal of Latin American Studies Vol. 21 (February).

Abente, Diego (1989) "The Liberal Republic and the Failure of Democracy," Journal of Latin American Studies Vol 21 (February).

Aguirre, Juan Francisco de (1949-51). Diario.. Revista de la Biblioteca Nacional de Buenos Aires ns. 17-20

AI'perovich, M.S (1979). "La dictadura del Dr. Francia en la historiografia del siglo XX," Estudios Latinoamericanos Vol 5:87-96.

Assadourian, Carlos Sempat (1982). El sistema de la economia colonial: mercado interno, regiones, y espacio economico (Lima).

Azara, Felix de (1847, 1962) Descripci6n e historia del Paraguay y del Rio de la Plata in Biblioteca Indiana. Viajes por la America del Sur Vol. 2 (Madrid).

Báez, Cecilio (1910). Ensayo sobre el Doctor Francia y la dictadura en Sud-America (Asunción).

Bagú, Sergio (1966). EI plan económico del grupo rivadaviano, 1811-1827 (Rosario, Argentina), pp.49-53 and 84-94)

Batou, Jean (1989) Cent ans de resistance au sous-developpment: l'industrialisation du Moyen Orient et de l'Amerigue latine face au defi europeen (Geneve).

Baysinger, Barry, Robert Ekelund, and Robert Tollison, "Mercantilism as a Rent-Seeking Society," in Buchanan, James, et.al., Towards a Theory of the Rent-Seeking Society (College Station, Texas, 1981),

Heckscher, Eli (1935). Mercantilism 2 vols. (London).

Batchelder, Ronald and Herman Freudenberger (1983). "On the Rational Origins of the Modern Centralized State," Explorations in Economic History Vol. 20, pp. 1-13,

Burgin, Miron (1946). The Economic Aspects of Argentine Federalism, 1820¬1852 (New York).

Cardozo, Efraim (1967) Efemerides de la historia del Paraguay (Asuncion).

Cardozo, Efraim (1959). EI Paraguay colonial: las raices de la nacionalidad (Buenos Aires)

Cardozo, Efraim (1941). EI Plan Federal del Dr. Francia. (Buenos Aires,).

Castedo Franco, Eliana (1978). "El proceso social de la revolucion del 14 de mayo de 1811. Un estudio socio-historico, " Estudios Paraquayos Vol 6 n2, pp.141-195.

Caves, Richard (1965). "Vent for Surplus Models of Trade and Growth," in R.E. Baldwin et al (eds.) Trade, Growth and the Balance of Payments (Chicago).

Caves, R. J., Frankel, and R. Jones (1991). World Trade and Payments, 5th edition (Glennview, Illinois).

Chaves, Julio César (1958). El Supremo Dictador 3a. edición (Buenos Aires).

Chaves, Julio César (1961). La revolucion paraguaya de la independencia. Relato y biografia de los proceres (Buenos Aires).

Coatsworth, John (1978)"Obstacles to Change in Nineteenth Century Mexico," American Historical Review.

Coni, Emilio (1927). La verdad sabre la enfiteusis de Rivadavia (Buenos Aires).

Cooney, Jerry W. (1992). "La Direcci6n General de la Renta de Tabacos and the Decline of the Royal Trade Monopoly in Paraguay. 1779-1800," Colonial Latin American Historical Review (Vol 1, n1):101-116.

_______(1990). Economia y sociedad en la Intendencia del Paraguay (Asunción).

_______(1988). "The Carrera del Paraguay, 1770¬1810: Lifeline of the Platine Littoral " paper presented at the Southern Historical Association Meetings.

________(1988). “The Yerba Mate and Cattle Frontier of Paraguay 1776-1811: Social, Economic, and Political Impact .” Paper presented at the XIV Int'l Congress of the Latin American Studies Association, New Orleans, LA, 17-19 March.

(1987). "Foreigners in the Intendencia of Paraguay", The Americas vol XXXIX (1982-83) :333-358.

¬_______(1979). "The Destruction of the Religious Orders in Paraguay," The Americas Vol. 36, n02 (October):177-198,

________(1979) "A Colonial Naval Industry: The Fabricas de Cables of Paraguay", Revista de Historia de America vol. 87, (Enero –Junio).

_______(1979)"Forest Industries and Trade in Late Colonial Paraguay," Journal of Forest Industries vo1.23 1 n04 (October):186¬-97.

_______ ( n.d.). "Criollos and Peninsulares in the Intendencia of Paraguay: Elite Accomodation in Place of Conflict." Dpt. of History, University of Louisville.

"Serving the Hinterland: The Commercial Rise of Asuncion, 1776-1810," SECOLAS Annals vol. XVIII (March).

(1985)"The Rival of Dr. Francia: Fernando de la Mora and the Paraguayan Revolution," Revista de Historia de America n° 100 (Julio-Diciembre) :201-229.

(1980) "Paraguayan Astilleros and the Platine Merchant Marine, 1796-1806," pp. 55-74:

(1979). "A Colonial Naval Industry: The Fabricas de Cables of Paraguay", Revista de Historia de America vol. 87, (Enero -Junio;

"An Ignored Aspect of the Viceroyalty of the River Plate," Intercambio Internacional / Vol. 2, n01 (January 1977) :10-13.

"The Paraguayan Independence Movement, 1806-1814," (Ph.D. dissertation, The University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM, 1971).

Coria, Luis A. "Determinacion del P.B.I de Mendoza para 1807," in Anales del A.A.E.P, XXIII Reunion Anual Vol. 1., 1988.

David, Paul "The Growth of Real Product in the United States Before 1840: New Evidence, Controlled Conjectures," Journal of Economic History vol. XXVI, n° 2, (June 1967).

David, Paul A. (1985). "Clio and the Economics of QWERTY," American Economic Review Vol 75 (May).

Duran Estragó, Margarita (1987). Presencia Franciscana en e1 Paraguay (1538-1824) (Asunción).

Eggertsson, Thrainn (1989). Economic Behavior and Institutions (New York).

Feeney, David (1989)."The Development of Property Rights in Land: A Comparative Study," in Robert H. Bates (editor) Toward a Political Economy of Development, a Rational Choice Perspective (Berkeley,

Ferrer de Arréllaga, Rene (85)Un siglo de expansión colonizadora: los origenes de Concepción (Asunción).

Friedman, David (1977) "A Theory of the Size and Shape of Nations," Journal of Political Economy Vol. 85, n° 1 (February) :59-77.

Héctor Lindo Fuentes, "Nineteenth Century Economomic History of EI Salvador," (Ph.D. dissertation, University of Chicago, 1984).

Luis Armando Galeano Romero "Unidades productivas agropecuarias y estructura de poder en Paraguay (1811-1870)/" Revista Paraguaya de Sociologia Vol. 9, n° 23 (Enero-Abril) :91-105,

Gallman, Robert (1972). "The Pace and Pattern of American Economic Growth," in Lance Davis and et al (editors), American Economic Growth:33--39;

Garavaglia, Juan Carlos (1983). Mercado interno y economia colonial (Mexico)

Garavaglia, Juan Carlos "Economic Growth and Regional Differentiation: The River Plate Region at the End of the Eighteenth Century," Hispanic American Historical Review.

Garavaglia, Juan Carlos Economia, Sociedad y Regiones (Buenos Aires: 1987).

Gordon, "The Economic Theory of a Common Pool Resource: The Fishery," Journal of Political Economy Vol. LXII (1954).

Halperin Donghi, Tulio (1982). Guerra y finanzas en los origenes del estado argentino (Buenos Aires).

Halperin Donghi, Tulio (1971). El revisionismo histórico argentino (Mexico).

Hartwick, John, and Nancy D. Olewiler(1986). The Economics of Natural Resource Use (New York).

Heyn Schupp, Carlos Antonio (1991). Iglesia y Estado en el proceso de emancipacion politica del Paraguay (1811-1853) (Asuncion:

Huston, Richard (1993). "Folk and State in Paraguay: Political Order and Social Disorder." (Ph.D. dissertation, University of California at Los Angeles,

Isard, Walter (1982). Methods of Regional Analysis. An Introduction to Regional Science (Ithaca, NY).

Klein, Herbert (1992) Bolivia. The Evolution of a Multi-ethnic Society 2nd. ed (New York).

Krugman, Paul (1991). Geography and Trade (Cambridge, MA).

Lynch, John (19580. Spanish Colonial Administration 1782-1810; The Intendent in the Viceroyalty of the Rio de la Plata (London, 1958).

John Lynch, "The Origins of Spanish American Independence," in Leslie Bethell (editor) Cambridge History of Latin America (London, 1987),

Lopez, Adalberto The Revolt of the Comuneros, 1721-1735: A Study in Colonial History of Paraguay (Cambridge, MA, 1976), Review vol 65, n° 1 (1985) :51-89.

Marx, Karl. The Eighteenth of Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte, excerpted in Robert C. Tucker (editor) The Marx-Engels Reader 2nd. edition (London, 1978),

Molas, Mariano Antonio (1866). "Descripci6n histórica de la antigua Provincia del Paraguay," Revista de Buenos Aires Tomo IX

Mariano Antonio Molas Descripci6n hist6rica de la antigua provincia del Paraguay 3a. edici6n (Buenos Aires, 1957).

Mariano Antonio Molas, "Clamor de un Paraguayo,1I Revista del Paraguay n 07 @ 8 (1828, 1893) :240-262,

Mora Merida, Jose Luis "La demografia colonial paraguaya," Jahrbuch fur Geschichte von Staat. Wirtschaft, und Gessellschaft Lateinamerikas, Band II (1974). M¨orner, Magnus (1959). "Panorama de la sociedad del Rio de la Plata durante la primera mitad del siglo XVIII," Estudios Americanos Revista de la Escuela de Estudios Hispanoamericanos, Sevilla. Vol. XVII, n° 92-93 (Mayo-Junio 1959):203-216.

Alberto Nogués La Iglesia en la epoca del Dr. Francia (Asuncion, 1960), p.s,

North, Douglass (1955) "Location Theory and Regional Economic Growth," Journal of Political Economy LXIII, n.3 (June):243-258.

North, Douglass C. The Economic Growth of the United States, 1790-1860 (Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey);

North D.C., and R.P.Thomas, "An Economic Theory of the Growth of the Western World," The Economic History Review 2nd series, Vol 23, n° 1

North, Douglass, and Robert Thomas (1971)."The Rise and Fall of the Manorial Economy: A Theoretical Model," Journal of Economic History vol 31 n.4 (December):777-80.

North, Douglass (1981). Structure and Change in Economic History (New York: Norton)

North, D.C., and R.P.Thomas, "An Economic Theory of the Growth of the Western World," The Economic History Review 2nd series, Vol 23, n° 1

North, Douglass, and Barry Weingast, "Constitutions and Commitment: The Evolution of Public Choice Institutions Governing Public Choice in Seventeenth Century England," Journal of Economic History 49 n° 4 (December 1989) :203-832.

Olson, Mancur (1965) The Logic of Collective Action. Public Goods and the Theory of Groups (Cambridge, MA).

_____(1982. The Rise and Decline of Nations (New Haven, CT).

Pastore, Carlos (1978), "Introduccion a una Historia Economica del Paraguay en el Siglo XIX," Historia Paraguaya vol. XVI pp.103-126.

Pastore, Carlos (1972). La lucha por la tierra en el Paraguay (Montevideo).

Pastore, Mario(1994) "State and Industrialization in Nineteenth Century Latin America: the Evidence on Paraguay Reconsidered," Journal of Latin American Studies (May).

Pastore, Mario "Trabalho forc;ado indigena e campesinato mestic;o livre no Paraguai colonial: uma visao de suas causas baseada na teoria da procura de rendas economicas, " Revista Brasileira de Historia Vol. 11, n021 (set/fev. 1990/91) :147-185; English version in J.Brewer and S.Staves (eds.) Early Modern Conceptions of Property (London, forthcoming).

PIa, Josefina (1972). Hermano Negro. La Esclavitud en el Paraguay (Madrid).

Barbara Potthast-Jutkeit (1991). "The Ass of a Mare and Other Scandals: Marriage and Extramarital Relations in Nineteenth Century Paraguay," Journal of Family History, Vol 16 n.3,

Prados de la Escosura, Leandro, and Samuel Amaral (editores) La independencia americana: sus consecuencias economicas (Madrid, 1993) :164-200.

Ramos, R. Antonio. La política del Brasil en el Paraguay bajo la dictadura del Dr. Francia (Buenos Aires, 1957).

Ransom, Roger L., and Kerry Ann Odell (1986). "Land and Credit: Some Historical Parallels Between Mexico and the American South," Agricultural History Vol 60 n.l (Winter :4-31

Rengger, J.R. and M. Longchamps, The Reign of Doctor Joseph Gaspard Roderick de Francia in Paraguay; Being an Account of a Six Year's Residence in that Republic, from July, 1819-to May 1825 (London, 1827),

Rivarola Paoli Juan Bautista "La Administracion de Temporalidades en la Provincia del Paraguay," Historia Paraguaya Vol. 25 (1988)

Rivarola Paoli, Juan Bautista (1986)La economía colonial (Asunci6n).

Reber, Vera Blinn (1988). "The Demographics of the Paraguay: A Reinterpretation of the Great War, 1864-70," Hispanic American Historical Review vol 68, n02,:289-319.

_____ (1985). "Commerce and Industry in Nineteenth Century Paraguay: The Example of Yerba Mate", The Americas, vol. XLII, (July, n. 1;

_____, (ms).Modernization from Within. Trade and Development in Paraguay, 1810 to 1870

Riquelme Garcia, Benigno "El Colegio Seminario Conciliar de San Carlos, de Asuncion, 1783-1822," Cuadernos Republicanos nOl0 1

Rock, David (1985). Argentina. 1516-1980: From Colonization to the Falklands' War (Berkeley,);

Rogowski, Ronald "Political Cleavages and Changing Exposure to Trade," American Political Science Review Vol. 81, n° 4 (December 1987)

__________(1989) Commerce and Coalitions. How Trade Affects Domestic Political Alignments (Princeton, NJ).

Saeger, James Schofield "Survival and Abolition: The Eighteenth Century Paraguayan Encomienda." The Americas Vol 28, (July), pp.59-85;

Saeger, James Schofield "Origins of the Rebellion of Paraguay," Hispanic American Historical Review Vol. 52 (May 1972) :215-229;

Salvucci, Richard J., and Linda K. Salvucci, "Las consecuencias económicas de la independencia mexicana," in Prados and Amaral, La independencia americana, pp. 31-53.

Salvucci, Richard and Linda (1993) "Las consecuencias economicas de la independencia mexicana," in Prados and Amaral, La independencia americana (Madrid, :31-53;

Sanchez Quell H. (1984). Pedro Juan Caballero y otros ensayos (Asuncion,;

Smith, Adam (1910). The Wealth of Nations Everyman ed. (London).

Stolper, Wolfang, and Paul Samuelson (1942). "Protection and Real Wages," Review of Economic Studies

Susnik Branislava (1991). Una visión socio-antropológica del Paraguay del siglo XVIII (Asunción)

Vargas Peña, Benjamin (1985). Secreta Politica del Dictador Francia (República Argentina).

Velazquez Rafael Eladio (1977) "Organización militar de la Gobernaci6n y Capitanía General del Paraguay, " Estudios Paraguayos Vol. V, n.1 (Junio) :25-¬68

Velazquez, Rafael Eladio (1973). "Navegación paraguaya de los siglos XVII Y XVIII," Estudios Paraguayos Vol. I (November): 45-84.

Velazquez, Rafael Eladio (1965). EI Paraguay en 1811 (Asunción).

Véliz, Claudio (1980) The Centralist Tradition in Latin America (Princeton).

Viola, Alfredo (1986)Origen de Pueblos del Paraguay (Asunción).

(1990) Cartas y Decretos del Dictator Francia, tomo III (Asuncion).

(1983)."El Dr. Francia y la Hacienda Publica," Anuario del Instituto de Investigaciones Historicas Dr. Jose Gaspar Rodriguez de Francia Vol V, n° 5 (October,

"Moneda y control de cambio durante el gobierno del Dr. Francia," Anuario del Instituto de Investigaciones Historicas José Gaspar Rodriguez de Francia Vol III, n° 3 (Setiembre),

"La tenencia de la tierra durante el gobierno del Dr. Francia," Anuario del Instituto de Investigaciones Historicas Jose Gaspar Rodriguez de Francia Vol. II, n° 2 (November) :80-89.

Watkins, Melville (1983)."A Staple Theory of Economic Growth," The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, Vol. XIX, n° 2 (May) :141-158;

Whigham, Thomas L. (1991). The Politics of River Trade: Tradition and Development in the Upper Plata (1780-1870) (Albuquerque).

Whigham, Thomas L. "The Backdoor Approach: The Alto Uruguay and Paraguayan Trade, 1810-1852" Revista de Historia de America n° 109 (Enero-Junio 1990) :45-68.

(1988)"Cattle Raising in the Argentine Northeast: Corrientes, 1750-1870," Journal of Latin American Studies Vol. 20 (November :313-335.

______(1986),Whigham, Thomas L. "The Politics of River Commerce in the Upper Plata, 1760-1865," (Ph.D. Dissertation, Stanford University).

White, Richard Alan (1978). Paraguay's Autonomous Revolution (Albuquerque).

Williams, John Hoyt (1979). The Rise and Fall of the Paraguayan Republic, 1800-1870. (Austin, Texas)

(1975) "From the Barrel of a Gun: Some Notes on Dr. Francia and Paraguayan Militarism," Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society Vol. 119, n° 1 (February):73-86.

(1973). "The Conspiracy of 1820 and the Destruction of the Paraguayan Aristocracy." Revista de Historia de America nos. 75-76 (Jan-Dec) :141-156.

Velazquez, Rafael Eladio (1987)."Los Cabildos en 1a historia del Paraguay," Historia Paraguaya Vol. XXVI

(1981)"Los Yegros en la historia del Paraguay," Historia Paraguaya Vol. XVIII, pp.215-283. Also in "Fulgencio Yegros, bicentenerio de nacimiento," Proceedings of a commemorative symposium (Asunción, 1980)

Williams, John Hoyt "La guerra no-declarada entre el Paraguay y Corrientes," Estudios Paraguayos vol 1, n01 (Noviembre 1973) :35-43

Williams, John Hoyt "Dictatorship and the Church: Dr. Francia in Paraguay." Journal of Church and State Vol. 15, n03 (Fall 1973),

Williams, John Hoyt "Paraguay/s Nineteenth Century Estancias de la Republica," Agricultural History Vol. 47 (July) :206-215).

Wisner de Morgenstern, Francisco (1923, 1957). EI Dictador del Paraguay. Jose Gaspar de Francia (Buenos Aires)