Assessing the Mumbai metropolitan region: a governance perspective

Pethe, Abhay and Gandhi, Sahil and Tandel, Vaidehi (2011): Assessing the Mumbai metropolitan region: a governance perspective. Published in: Economic and Political Weekly , Vol. 46, No. 26&27 (25 May 2011): pp. 187-195.

Abstract

The paper written from a governance perspective takes the position that a useful governance perspective must be informed by the socio-economic-cultural milieu and in the specific Indian context must sit on a tripod of ‘political reality’, ‘state of decentralization’ and ‘basic economic principles’. Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) is one of the most important growth engines for India as it accrues tremendous revenues to the central and the Maharashtra (State) governments. It is thus crucial to ensure that the governance system in MMR is efficient for it to continue on its growth trajectory. We assess the performance of the governance system in MMR which resembles a polycentric governance system- a system that has been heralded as being greatly suited to metropolitan regions by several scholars. We recognize that Metropolitan governance is a concept since in reality it comprises a loose bundle of multiple actors and organizations. For sharper focus, we study the interactions between only two (dominant) public organizations- Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (an Urban Local Body of Greater Mumbai) and the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (a parastatal of the State Government). Our assessment reveals that the institutions – rules of the game – which are essential for the efficient functioning of polycentric governance system are missing in the region. Our findings emphasize the need to bring about micro reforms in the institutional framework for polycentric governance to be successful in MMR.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Intergovernmental Relations; Federalism; Administrative Processes in Public Organizations; Conflict Resolution
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D73 - Bureaucracy ; Administrative Processes in Public Organizations ; Corruption; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession; D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D74 - Conflict ; Conflict Resolution ; Alliances ; Revolutions; H - Public Economics > H8 - Miscellaneous Issues > H83 - Public Administration ; Public Sector Accounting and Audits

References

Andersson, K.P. and E. Ostrom (2008) Analyzing decentralized resource regimes from a polycentric perspective. Policy Science 41.1, 71‐93.

Batley, R. and G. Larbi (2004) The changing role of government: The reform of public services in developing countries. Palgrave/Macmillan, London.

Batley, R. (2004) The politics of service delivery reform. Development and Change 35.1, 31– 56.

Carlsson, L. and A. Sandström (2008) Performance of Policy Networks: The Relation between Network Structure and Network Performance. Policy Studies Journal 36 .4, 497-524.

Chhotray, V. and G. Stoker (2009) Governance theory and practice: A cross disciplinary approach. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke.

DNA (2007) MMRDA asks BMC to foot rehab bill. DNA, June 11.

DNA (2010) BMC on collision path with MMRDA over profit sharing. DNA, July 22.

Denhardt, J. V. and R. B. Denhardt (2007) The new public service: Serving, not steering. M.E. Sharpe, Armonk, NY.

Dixit, A. (2004) Lawlessness and Economics: Alternative Models of Governance. Princeton University Press, Princeton.

Express India (2005) Finally, CM tells BMC, MMRDA and others to start talking to each other. Express India, May 22.

Express India (2007) MMRDA skips monsoon meeting. Express India, May 29.

Express India (2006) Shiv Sena starts sticker campaign against the MMRDA. Express India, June 13.

Express India (2009) Burst pipeline brings out BMC-MMRDA war out in open. Express India, May 6.

Feiock, R. C. and J. T. Scholz, eds. (2010) Self- Organizing Federalism: Collaborative Mechanisms to Mitigate Institutional Collective Action Dilemmas. Cambridge University Press, New York.

Ferlie, E., L. Ashburner, L. Fitzgerald and A. Pettigrew (1996) The New Public Management in Action. Oxford University Press, New York.

Heinelt, H. And D. Kübler (eds.) (2005) Metropolitan governance: Capacity, democracy and the dynamics of place. Routledge, London.

Hindustan Times (2010a) Court raps civic body, MHADA over inaction. Hindustan Times, January 28.

Hindustan Times (2010b) BMC No drinking water for MHADA flats at Mankhurd. Hindustan Times, February 7.

Hindustan Times (2010c) It’s time for a patch up: Calling a truce. Hindustan Times, August 24.

Hindustan Times (2010d) Little comes out of first BMC MMRDA meet. Hindustan Times, August 24.

Hindustan Times (2010e) Planning agency washes hands of infra projects. Hindustan Times, November 25.

Hood, C. (1991) A public management for all seasons? Public Administration 69.1, 3-19.

Indian Express (1997) MMRDA bails out BMC with Rs. 165 cr loan. Indian Express, May 14.

Indian Express (1998) Hot Property: Defaulters owe BMC 75 cr. Indian Express, November 25. Indian Express (1999) MMRDA to fund 3 BMC projects. Indian Express, Nov 17.

Indian Express (2009) Civic officials at war with development body over bills. Indian Express, May 31.

Jessop, B (1998) The rise of governance and the risks of failure: the case of economic development. International Social Science Journal 50.155, 29–45.

Joardar, S. (2008) Urban Governance in India: the case of Metropolitan Planning Committee. The SPA Journal of Planning and Architecture 13.1, 69-85.

Jones, C., W. Hesterly and S. Borgatti (1997) A general theory of network governance: exchange conditions and social mechanisms. Academy of Management Review 22.4, 911–45.

Laffont, J.-J. (2000) Incentives and Political Economy. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Le Galès, P. (1998) Regulation and governance in European cities. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 22.3, 482–506.

Lefèvre, C. (1998) Metropolitan government and governance in Western countries. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 22.1, 9-25.

McGinnis, M. (ed.) (1999a) Polycentric Governance and Development: Readings from the Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis. University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor.

McGinnis, M. (ed.) (1999b) Polycentricity and Local Public Economies: Readings from the Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis. University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor.

McGinnis, M. (ed.) (2000) Polycentric Games and Institutions: Readings from the Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis. University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor.

Meuleman, L. (2008) Public Management and the Metagovernance of Hierarchies, Networks and Markets. Physica-Verlag, Heidelberg.

Mumbai Mirror (2009) Bad news for MHADA house seekers no BMC water till 2011. Mumbai Mirror, December 9.

Mumbai Mirror (2010a) BMC seeks cut in Metro Revenue from MMRDA. Mumbai Mirror, March 4.

Mumbai Mirror (2010b) BMC, MMRDA chiefs to thrash out city problems. Mumbai Mirror, August 22.

North, D. (1990) Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK.

Ostrom, E. (1990) Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.

Ostrom, E. (2010) Organizational Economics: Applications to Metropolitan Governance. Journal of Institutional Economics 6.1, 109-15.

Ostrom, V. (1999) Polycentricity (Part I). In M. McGinnis (ed.), Polycentricity and Local Public Economies. Readings from the Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis. University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, 52-74.

Ostrom, V. and E. Ostrom (1999) Public Goods and Public Choices. In Polycentricity and Local Public Economies. Readings from the Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis,edited by M. McGinnis. University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. Press, 75-105 [originally published in 1977].

Ostrom, V., C. Tiebout, and R. Warren (1961) The Organization of Government in Metropolitan Areas: A Theoretical Inquiry. American Political Science Review 55.4, 831-42.

Pethe, A (2010) Collusion, Conflicts, Informal Systems & Rent Seeking: The Great Prototype Indian Story Of Urban Land Management in Mumbai. Synthesis report of a study undertaken for World Bank presented at Urban Design and Research Institute, Mumbai on 10th December 2010.

Pethe, A. and M. Lalvani (2007) A Report On The Local Government Finances In MMR Region, Study commissioned by MTSU on advice of the World Bank. Podolny, J. M., and K.L. Page (1998) Network forms of organization. Annual Review of Sociology 24, 57-76.

Powell, W. W. (1990) Neither market nor hierarchy: Network forms of organization. In B. M. Staw and L. L. Cummings (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior. JAI Press, Greenwich, CT. 12, 295–33.

Rhodes, R. A. W. (1996) The New Governance: Governing Without Governance. Political Studies 44 .4, 652–67.

Sanyal, B. and V. Mukhija (2001) Institutional pluralism and housing delivery: a case of unforeseen conflicts in Mumbai, India. World Development 29.12, 2043-57.

Schedler, K. and I. Proeller (2002) The New Public Management: A Perspective from Mainland Europe. In K. McLaughlin, S. P. Osborne, and E. Ferlie (eds.), New Public Management: Current Trends and Future Prospects, Routledge, London. 164– 80.

Sørensen, E. and J. Torfing (2005) The democratic anchorage of governance networks. Scandinavian Political Studies 28.3, 195–218.

Stoker, G. (1998) Governance as theory: five propositions. International Social Science Journal 50 .155, 17-28.

Times of India (2005) Court orders repair of potholes. Times of India, October 19.

Times of India (2006a) Sainiks ask MMRDA to ‘mind their language’. Times of India, April 21.

Times of India (2006b) Fill Potholes: HC. Times of India, August 17.

Times of India (2009) CM steps in to mediate in BMC MMRDA slugfest. Times of India, May 9.

Times of India (2010) BMC blames MMRDA for jams on Link Road. Times of India, September 27.

Tirole, J. (1986) Hierarchies and bureaucracies: on the role of collusion in organizations. Journal of Law, Economics and Organization 2.2, 181−214.

Weikart , L.A . (2001) The Giuliani Administration and the New Public Management in New York City. Urban Affairs Review 36.3, 359 – 81.

Williamson, O. E. (1996) The Mechanisms of Governance. Oxford University Press, New York.