Keeping it off the Books: An Empirical Investigation of Firms that Engage in Tax Evasion

Tedds, Lindsay (2007): Keeping it off the Books: An Empirical Investigation of Firms that Engage in Tax Evasion.

Abstract

This paper uses a unique and recently available dataset that contains detailed information on firms from around the world to investigate factors that affect under-reporting behaviour by firms. The empirical strategy employed exploits the nature of the dependent variable, which is interval coded, and uses interval regression which provides an asymptotically more efficient estimator than the ordered probit, provided that the classical linear model assumptions hold. These assumptions are investigated using standard diagnostic tests that have been modified for the interval regression model. Evidence is presented that shows that firms in all regions around the world engage in under-reporting. Regression results indicate that government corruption has the single largest causal effect on under-reporting, resulting in the percentage of sales not reported to the tax authority being 53.4 percent higher. Taxes have the second single largest causal effect on under-reporting, resulting in the percentage of sales not reported to the tax authority being 20.2 percent higher. Access to financing, organized crime, political instability and the fairness of the legal system were found to have no effect on under-reporting. It is also found that there is a significant correlation between under-reporting and the legal organization of the business, size, age, ownership, competition and audit controls.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: University of Victoria
• Language: English
• Keywords: Underground Economy; Tax Non-compliance; Firm Characteristics; Interval Regression
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C2 - Single Equation Models ; Single Variables > C24 - Truncated and Censored Models ; Switching Regression Models ; Threshold Regression Models; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O17 - Formal and Informal Sectors ; Shadow Economy ; Institutional Arrangements; D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D21 - Firm Behavior: Theory

References

Allingham, M. and A. Sandmo. 1972. Income Tax Evasion: A Theoretical Analysis. Journal of Public Economics 1:323-338.

Andreoni, James. 1992. IRS as Loan Shark: Tax Compliance with Borrowing Constraints. Journal of Public Economics 49:35-46.

______. Brian Erard, and Jonathan Feinstein. 1998. Tax Compliance. Journal of Economic Literature 36:818-860.

Apel, Mikael. 1994. An Expenditure-Based Estimate of Tax Evasion in Sweden. Working Paper, Department of Economics, Uppsala University.

Bajada, Christopher. 1999. Estimates of the Underground Economy in Australia. The Economic Record 75: 369-84

Batra, Geeta, Daniel Kaufmann and Andrew H.W. Stone. 2003. Investment Climate Around the World: Voices of the Firms from the World Business Environment Survey. Washington, D.C.: The World Bank.

Border, Kim C. and Joel Sobel. 1987. Samurai Accountant: A Theory of Audit and Plunder. Review of Economic Studies 54:525-540.

Chan, K. Hung and Phyllis Lai Lan Mo. 2000. Tax Holidays and Tax Non-compliance: An Empirical Study of Corporate Tax Audits in China’s Developing Economy. The Accounting Review 75:469-484.

Chen, Kong-Pin and C. Y. Cyrus Chu. 2005. Internal Control and External Manipulation: A Model of Corporate Income Tax Evasion. RAND Journal of Economics 26:151-164.

Chesher, A. and M. Irish. 1987. Residual Analysis in the Grouped and Censored Normal Regression Model. Journal of Econometrics 34:33–61. Christian, Charles W. 1994. Voluntary Compliance with Individual Income Tax: Results from the 1988 TCMP study. The IRS Research Bulletin Publication 1500 9:35-42.

Cowell, Frank. 2004. Sticks and Carrots. In The Crises in Tax Administration , eds. Henry Aaron and Joel Slemrod, 230-258. Washington, D.C.: The Brookings Institution Press.

Cremer, Helmuth, Maurice Marchand and Pierre Pestieau. 1990. Evading, Auditing and Taxing: the Equity-Compliance Tradeoff. Journal of Public Economics 43:67-92.

Crocker, Joel and Joel Slemrod. 2005. Corporate Tax Evasion with Agency Costs. Journal of Public Economics 89: 1593-1610.

Dell’Anno, Roberto, Miguel Gómez-Antonio, and Angel Pardo. 2007. The Shadow Economy in Three Mediterranean Countries: France, Spain and Greece. A MIMIC approach. Empirical Economics 33: 51-84.

Deregulation Commission (1991) Opening of Markets and Competition, Report Presented to German Federal Government, Bonn.

Draeseke, Robert and David .E.A. Giles. 2002. Modelling the New Zealand Underground Economy Using Fuzzy Logic Techniques. Mathematics and Computers in Simulation 59: 115-123.

Engström, Per and Bertil Holmlund. 2006. Tax Evasion and Self-Employment in a High-Tax Country: Evidence from Sweden. Working Paper, Department of Economics, Uppsala University.

Erard, Brian. 1992. The Influence of Tax Auditing on Reporting Behaviour. In Why People Pay Taxes, ed. Joel Slemrod. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan.

______ and Chih-Chin Ho. 2001. Searching for Ghosts: Who are the Nonfilers and How Much Tax do they Owe? Journal of Public Economics 81:25-50.

Feldman, Naomi and Joel Slemrod. 2007. Estimating Tax Noncompliance with Evidence from Unaudited Tax Returns. Economic Journal 117: 327-352.

Giles, David E.A.. 1999. The Hidden Economy and the Tax-Gap in New Zealand: A Latent Variable Analysis. Empirical Economics 24: 621-640.

______. 2000. Modeling the Tax Compliance Profiles of New Zealand Firms. In Taxation and the Limits of Government, eds. Gerald W. Scully and Patrick J. Caragata, 243-270. Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

______ and P.J. Caragata. 2001. The Learning Path of the Hidden Economy: Tax and Growth Effects in New Zealand. Applied Economics 33: 1857-1867.

Giles, David E.A. and B.J. Johnson. 2002. Taxes, Risk-Aversion, and the Size of the Underground Economy: A Nonparametric Analysis With New Zealand Data. Pacific Economic Review 7: 97-113.

Giles, David E.A. and Lindsay M. Tedds. 2002. Taxes and the Canadian Underground Economy. Toronto: The Canadian Tax Foundation.

Hanlon, Michelle, Lillian Mills, and Joel Slemrod. 2005. An Empirical Examination of Corporate Tax Non-compliance. Working Paper, University of Michigan.

Harvey, Andrew. 1976. Estimating Regression Models with Multiplicative Heterocedasticity. Econometrica 44: 461-65.

Huber, P.J. 1967. The Behaviour of Maximum Likelihood Estimates under Non-standard Conditions. In Proceedings of the Fifth Berkeley Symposium on Mathematical Statistics and Probability, 221-223. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Internal Revenue Service. 2004. Interactive Tax Gap Map. National Headquarters Office of Research.

Johnson, Simon, Daniel Kaufmann, John McMillan, and Christopher Woodruff. 2000. Why do firms hide? Bribes and Unofficial Activity After Communism. Journal of Public Economics 76:495-520.

Joulfaian, David. 2000. Corporate Tax Evasion and Managerial Preferences. Review of Economics and Statistics 82:698-701.

______ and Mark Rider. 1998. Differential Taxation and Tax Evasion by Small Business. National Tax Journal 51:676-87.

Kennedy, P. 1981. Estimation with Correctly Interpreted Dummy Variables in Semilogarithmic Equations. American Economic Review 71: 801.

Lyssiotou, Panayiota, Panos Pashardes and Thanasis Stengos. 2004. Estimates of the Black Economy Based on Consumer Demand Approaches. Economic Journal 114:622-640.

McElvey, W. and Zavoina, R. 1975. A Statistical Model for the Analysis of Ordinal Level Dependent Variables. Journal of Mathematical Sociology 4:103-120.

Mookherjee, Dilip and Ivan P.L. P’ng. 1989. Optimal Auditing, Insurance and Redistribution. Quarterly Journal of Economics 104:399-415.

Orme, C. 1990. The Small-Sample Performance of the Information Matrix Test. Journal of Econometrics 46:309–331. Pissarides, Christopher A., and Guglielmo Weber. 1989. An Expenditure-based Estimate of Britain’s Black Economy. Journal of Public Economics 39:17-32.

Ramsey, J.B. 1969. Tests for Specification Errors in Classical Linear Least-Squares Regression Analysis. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society 31:350 – 71.

Rice, Eric M. 1992. The Corporate Tax Gap: Evidence on Tax Compliance by Small Corporations. In Why People Pay Taxes, ed. Joel Slemrod, 125-166. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press: Ann Arbor.

Sanchez, Isabel and Joel Sobel. 1993. Hierarchical Design and Enforcement of Income Tax Policies. Journal of Public Economics 50:345-369. Schuetze, Herb J. 2002. Profiles of Tax Non-compliance Among the Self-Employed in Canada, 1969-1992. Canadian Public Policy XXVIII: 219-237. Schnieder, Friedrich. 2006. Shadow Economies of 145 Countries all over the World: What do we Know? Working Paper, University of Linz, Austria.

______ and Dominik Enste (2000) “Increasing Shadow Economies All Over the World – Fiction or Reality? A Survey of the Global Evidence of Their Size and Their Impact From 1970 to 1995.” 38 Journal of Economic Literature 77-114.

Scotchmer, Suzanne. 1987. Audit Classes and Tax Enforcement Policy. American Economic Review 77:229-233.

______ and Shlomo Yitzhaki. 1996. The Cost of Taxation and the Marginal Efficiency Cost of Funds. International Monetary Fund Staff Papers 43:25-34.

Smith, J. and T. Adams. 1987. The Measurement of Selected Income Flows in Informal Markets, 1981 and 1985-1986. Working Paper, University of Michigan Survey Research Centre.

Stewart, M. 1983. On Least Squares Estimation when the Dependent Variable is Grouped. Review of Economic Studies 50:737-753.

Tannenbaum, Robert. 1993. Corporate Tax Disclosure: Good or Bad for the Commonwealth? Working Paper, Massachusetts Special Commission on Business Tax Policy.

Tedds, Lindsay M., 2005, “The Underground Economy in Canada,” in Chris Bajada and Friedrich Schneider (eds.) Size, Causes and Consequences of the Underground Economy (Ashgate Publishing, UK).

Tedds, Lindsay M. 2007. Estimating the Income Report Function for the Self-Employed. Working Paper, School of Public Administration, University of Victoria.

Trandel, Greg and Arthur Snow. 1999. Progressive Income Taxation and the Underground Economy. Economics Letters 62:217-222.

Veall, Michael R. and Kurt F. Zimmermann. 1996. Pseudo-R2 Measures for Some Common Limited Dependent Variable Models. Journal of Economic Surveys 10:241-259.

Watson, Harry. 1985. Tax Evasion and Labor Markets. Journal of Public Economics 27:231-246.

World Bank. 1997. World Development Report 1997: The State in a Changing World. Washington, D.C.: World Bank Group.