From the linear model to incremental innovation: Science and Industry in India

Tyabji, Nasir (2012): From the linear model to incremental innovation: Science and Industry in India.

Abstract

In the course of the first 45 years of India’s post Independence development, the focus of scientific activity was changed: from that of a science of raw material extraction, oblivious of any industrial imperative, to a science of material production, aimed at inducing technological awareness within industry. This change in focus, requiring original thought and practical experimentation, achieved with some difficulty, was accompanied by policy hesitation, and faced reverses. The most notable conceptual development was the recognition of the complementary nature of twin processes of industrial innovation: the laboratory to industry, or linear innovation chain, and the incremental or evolutionary innovation process. This intellectual advance was reflected in the creation of both relevant institutional structures, and of inter-institutional linkages. The result was a diversified industrial base together with considerable, albeit highly uneven, levels of technological competence. The subsequent 20 year period is characterised by a reliance on the market mechanism as the channel directing scientific activity and industrial energy. Market fundamentalism is dismissive of the necessity of creative thought on the contemporary dialectics of the science and industry relationship. This, let alone providing the basis for further advance, has led to the degradation of achieved capabilities in comprehension of this relationship.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Linear model of innovation;incremental innovation; CSIR; science and industry
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N7 - Transport, Trade, Energy, Technology, and Other Services > N75 - Asia including Middle East; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O31 - Innovation and Invention: Processes and Incentives; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O32 - Management of Technological Innovation and R&D; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O38 - Government Policy

References

Abrol, Dinesh (1995) “‘Colonised Minds’ or Progressive Nationalist Scientists: The Science and Culture Group” in MacLeod, Roy and Kumar, Deepak (eds.) Technology and the Raj: Western Technology and Technical Transfers to India, 1700-1947 (New Delhi, Sage Publications): 265-288

Abrol, Dinesh (2004) “Post-TRIPs Technological Behaviour of the Pharmaceutical Industry in India” Science Technology and Society 9 (2): 243-271

Abrol, Dinesh (2007) “Publicly Funded Research and Policy Reforms in India: Lessons from the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR)” History and Sociology of South Asia 1(2): 58-88

Abrol, Dinesh (2010) “Policies for Self Reliant Development: Lessons from India” History and Sociology of South Asia 4(1): 41-73

Aggarwal, Aradhna (2000) “Deregulation, technology imports and in-house R&D efforts: an analysis of the Indian experience” Research Policy 29: 1081–1093

Alagh, Yoginder (1997) “Technological Change in Indian Industry” Economic and Political Weekly 33(4): 181-4

Alam, Ghayur (1993) “Research and Development by Indian Industry: A study of the Determinants of its Size and Scope” (mimeo) Study undertaken by the Centre for Technology Studies, New Delhi on behalf of the Department of Science and Technology, Government of India

Alam, Ghayur and Langrish, J. (1984)"Government Research and its Utilisation by Industry: The Case of Industrial Civil Research in India," Research Policy, January

Arnold, David (2000) Science, Technology and Medicine in Colonial India (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press)

Aurora, G. S. and Morehouse, Ward (1972) “Dilemma of Technological Choice: The Case of the Small Tractor” Economic and Political Weekly 7 (31/33): 1633-1644

Bagchi, Amiya Kumar et al (1984) “Indian Patents Act and Its Relation to Technological Development in India: A Preliminary Investigation” Economic and Political Weekly 19 (7): 287-304

Bernal, J.D. (1971a) Science in History Volume 2: The Scientific and Industrial Revolutions (Cambridge, Mass, MIT Press)

Bernal, J.D. (1971b) Science in History Volume 3: The Natural Sciences in Our Time (Cambridge, Mass, MIT Press)

Bagchi-Sen, Sharmista and Lawton-Smith, Helen (2008) “Science, Institutions, and Markets: Developments in the Indian Biotechnology Sector” Regional Studies 42 (7): 961–975

Bhagavan, M. R. (1995) “Technological Implications of Structural Adjustment” Economic and Political Weekly 30: M2-M12

Bhagavan, M.R. (ed.) (1997) New Generic Technologies in Developing Countries (London, Macmillan)

Bhaneja, Balwant (1976) “India's Science and Technology Plan, 1974-79” Social Studies of Science 6: 99-104

Bhatt, V. V. (1978) “Decision Making in the Public Sector: Case Study of Swaraj Tractor” Economic and Political Weekly 13 (21): M30-M45

Bhatt, V. V. (1980) “Financial Institutions and Technology Policy” Economic and Political Weekly 15 (22): M45-M52

Blackett, P.M.S. (1968) “Science and Technology in an Unequal World” (New Delhi, Jawaharlal Nehru Memorial Fund)

Bowonder, B. and Satish, N.G. (2003) “Is economic liberalisation stimulating innovation in India?” Interdisciplinary Science Reviews 28(1): 44-53

Chaudhuri, Sudip (1984) “Manufacturing Drugs without TNCs: Status of Indigenous Sector in India” Economic and Political Weekly 19: 1341-83

Chaudhuri, Sudip (2005) The WTO and India’s Pharmaceuticals Industry: Patent Protection, TRIPS, and Developing Countries (New Delhi, Oxford University Press)

Chowdhry, Kamla (1969) “Organization and Administration of Scientific Institutions: A Case Study of Atira” Management International Review 9 (6): 97-104

Dahlman, Carl and Utz, Anuja (2005) India and the Knowledge Economy: Leveraging Strengths and Opportunities (Washington, DC, World Bank)

Dasgupta, Uma (ed.) (2011) Science and Modern India: An Institutional History, c.1784-1947 (Delhi, Pearson Longman)

Desai, Ashok V.(1980)"The Origin and Direction of Industrial R&D in India," Research Policy 9: 85

Dhar, Biswajit (2003) “A Case Study of the Pharmaceutical Industry in India” in United Nations Transfer of Technology for Successful Integration into the Global Economy UNCTAD/ITE/IPC/2003/6 (Geneva and New York, United Nations): 87-140

Faley, Timothy L. and Sharer, Michael (2005) “Technology Transfer and Innovation: Reexamining and Broadening the Perspective of the Transfer of Discoveries resulting from Government Sponsored Research” Comparative Technology Transfer and Society 3(2):109-128

Fontes, Margarida and Coombs, Rod (2001) “Contribution of new technology-based firms to the strengthening of technological capabilities in intermediate economies” Research Policy 30: 79–97

Forbes, Naushad and Wield, David (2000) “Managing R&D in technology-followers” Research Policy 29: 1095–1109

Forbes, Naushad and Wield, David (2004) “R&D in follower nations: What is R&D? Why does it matter?” Science and Public Policy 31(4): 267–277

Forero-Pineda, Clemente (2006) “The impact of stronger intellectual property rights on science and technology in developing countries” Research Policy 35: 808–824

Fransman, Martin and King, Kenneth (Eds.) (1984) Technological Capability in the Third World (London, Macmillan)

Furmana, Jeffrey L. and Hayes, Richard (2004) “Catching up or standing still? National innovative productivity among ‘follower’ countries, 1978–1999” Research Policy 33: 1329–1354

Ganapathy, R. S. (1971) “R and D: Emerging Identity Crisis” Economic and Political Weekly 6(1): 51-54

George, Gerard and Prabhu, Ganesh N. (2003) “Developmental financial institutions as technology policy instruments: implications for innovation and entrepreneurship in emerging economies” Research Policy 32: 89–108

Gibbons, Michael et al (Eds.) (1984) Science and Technology Policies in the 1980s and Beyond (London, Longmans)

Godin, Benoît (2006) “The Linear Model of Innovation: The Historical Construction of an Analytical Framework” Science Technology Human Values 31(6): 639-667

Godin, Benoît (2009) “National Innovation System: The System Approach in Historical Perspective” Science Technology Human Values 34(4):476-501

Golinski, Jan (2011) “Science in the Enlightenment, Revisited” History of Science 64(2): 217-23

Greene, William (2007) The Emergence of India’s Pharmaceutical Industry and Implications for the U.S. Generic Drug Market, U.S. International Trade Commission Office of Economics Working Paper No. 2007-05-A www.usitc.gov/publications/332/working_papers/EC200705A.pdf (accessed 5 May 2010)

Heeks, Richard (1996) India’s Software Industry: State Policy, Liberalisation and Industrial Development (New Delhi, Sage Publications)

Heinman, S.A. (1981) Scientific and Technical Revolution: Economic Aspects (Moacow, progress Publishers)

Hill, A.V. (1945) Scientific Research in India (New Delhi)

India (1945) Council of Scientific and Industrial Research Report of the Industrial Research Planning Committee (New Delhi)

India (1949) Council of Scientific and Industrial Research Reviewing Committee Report (New Delhi)

India (1954) Council of Scientific and Industrial Research Report of the Second Reviewing Committee of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (New Delhi)

India (1958) Ministry of Scientific Research and Cultural Affairs Minutes of the Conference held in...New Delhi on the 18th and 19th July, 1958, to consider implementation of the Scientific Policy Resolution (mimeo)

India (1963) Ministry of Scientific Research and Cultural Affairs, Proceedings of the Second Conference of Scientists and Educationists held at New Delhi on 4th and 5th August 1963 (New Delhi)

India (1964) Council of Scientific and Industrial Research Report of the Third Reviewing Committee of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (New Delhi)

India (1966) Council of Scientific and Industrial Research First Get-Together of Research and Industry (New Delhi)

India (1968) Ministry of Industrial Development and Corporate Affairs Report of the Committee on Foreign Collaboration May 1967 (New Delhi)

India (1969) Directorate General of Technical Development Import Substitution and its Impacts (A Review by the Directorate General of Technical Development for 1960-1967) (New Delhi)

India (1970) Council of Scientific and Industrial Research Report of Committee of Enquiry (New Delhi)

India (1971) Committee on Science and Technology Proceedings of the Third National Conference of Scientists, Technologists & Educationists: New Delhi, Nov. 1970 (New Delhi)

India (1986) Council of Scientific and Industrial Research Report of the CSIR Review Committee: Towards a New Perspective (New Delhi)

India (1996) Council of Scientific and Industrial Research CSIR 2001: Vision and Strategy (New Delhi)

Katrak, Homi (2002) “Does economic liberalisation endanger indigenous technological developments? An analysis of the Indian experience” Research Policy 31: 19–30

Kolontayev, A. (1981) “The Scientific and Technological Revolution and the Machine Stage of Production in the Developing Countries” in “Social Sciences Today” Editorial Board, India: Problems of Development, Oriental Studies in the USSR No.4 (Moscow, USSR Academy of Sciences): 35-56

Krishna, V.V. (1995) “Organisation of Industrial Research: The Early History of CSIR, 1934-47” in MacLeod, Roy and Kumar, Deepak (eds.) Technology and the Raj: Western Technology and Technical Transfers to India, 1700-1947 (New Delhi, Sage Publications): 289-323

Krishnan, Rishikesha T. (2003) “The Evolution of a Developing Country Innovation System during Economic Liberalization: The Case of India” Paper presented at The First Globelics Conference, November 3-6, 2003 at http://www.iimb.ernet.in/~rishi/evolution.pdf accessed on July 14, 2011

Krishnan, Rishikesha T. (2010) From Jugaad to Systematic Innovation: The Challenge for India (Bengaluru, Utprereka Foundation)

Krishnan, Rishikesha T. and Jha, Srivardhini K. (2011) “Innovation Strategies in Emerging Markets: What Can We Learn from Indian Market Leaders?” ASCI Journal of Management 41(1): 21–45

Kuchhal, R.D., ed. 1995. Vision of Science in India–R&D and CSIR (A Historical Perspective) (New Delhi: World Science News)

Kumar, Deepak (1995) Science and the Raj (Delhi, Oxford University Press)

Kumar, Nagesh (1985) “Cost of Technology Imports: The Indian Experience” Economic and Political Weekly 20(35): M103-M114

Kumar, Nagesh (1987) “Technology Imports and Local Research and Development in Indian Manufacturing” The Developing Economies 25 (3): 220-233

Kumar, Nagesh (1987) “Technology Policy in India: An Overview of its Evolution and an Assessment” in Brahmananda, P.R. and Panchamukhi, V.R. eds., The Development Process of Indian Economy, (Mumbai, Himalaya): 461-92

Kumar, Nagesh (1990) “Cost of Imported and Local Technologies: Implications for Technology Policy” Economic and Political Weekly 103-106

Kumar, Nagesh and Aggarwal, Aradhna (2005) “Liberalization, outward orientation and in-house R&D activity of multinational and local firms: A quantitative exploration for Indian manufacturing” Research Policy 34: 441–460

Lall, Sanjaya (1981) “Indian Technology Exports and Technological Development” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 458, Technology Transfer: New Issues, New Analysis: 151-162

Lall, Sanjaya (1987) Learning to Industrialise: the Acquisition of Technological Capability by India (Basingstoke, Macmillan)

Mahmooda, Ishtiaq P. and Singh, Jasjit (2003) “Technological dynamism in Asia” Research Policy 32: 1031–1054

Mallick, Sambit and Ejnavarzala, Haribabu (2010) “The Intellectual Property Rights Regime and Emerging Institutional Framework of Scientific Research: Responses from Plant Molecular Biologists in India” Asian Journal of Social Science 38: 79–106

Mani, Sunil (2007) “Government Support for Sustaining a Knowledge-based Economy: An Examination of India’s Technology Policy Initiatives, 1990-2005” in Vaidyanathan, A and Krishna, K.L. (Eds.) Institutions and Markets in India’s Development: Essays for K.N. Raj (Delhi, Oxford University Press)

Mani, Sunil (2011) “National Manufacturing Policy: Making India a Powerhouse?” Economic and Political Weekly 46(53):16-19

Mazzoleni, Roberto and Nelson, Richard R. (2007) “Public research institutions and economic catch-up” Research Policy 36: 1512–1528

Mitra, Prabir (1981) “Utilisation of Indigenous Technology: Organisational and Policy Constraints” Economic and Political Weekly 16 (48): M153-M164

Morehouse, Ward (1967) “Confronting a Four-Dimensional Problem: Science, Technology, Society, and Tradition in India and Pakistan” Technology and Culture 8 (3): 363-375

Morehouse, Ward (1980) “Technology and Enterprise Performance in the Indian Tractor Industry: Does Self-Reliance Measure Up?” Economic and Political Weekly 15 (51): 2139-2152

Nath, N.C.B. and Misra, L. (Eds.) (1994) Transfer of Technology in Indian Industry: Case Studies on Utilisation of Indigenous R & D (New Delhi, Indus Publishing)

Nayar, Baldev Raj (1983) India’s Quest for Technological Independence (New Delhi, Lancer Publishers)

Nayudamma, Y. (1966) “Promoting the Industrial Application of Research in an Underdeveloped Country” Minerva 5(3): 323-339

Nayudamma, Y. (1973) “Decentralised Management of R & D in a Developing Country” Minerva 11(4): 516-536

Oldham, G. et al (1968)"The transfer of technology to developing countries, with special reference to licensing and know-how agreements" (TD/28/Supp. 1 and Corr.l TD/II/WG. 1/L.4/Rev. 1 reproduced in the appendix to the report of Working Group I, Proceedings of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, Second Session, Vol. I—Report and Annexes (United Nations publication, Sales No.E.68.H.D.14), p.357.

Parthasarathi, Ashok (1969a) “Sociology of Science in Developing Countries: The Indian Experience” 4(31): 1277-1280

Parthasarathi, Ashok (1969b) “Sociology of Science in Developing Countries: The Indian Experience- A Sequal” Economic and Political Weekly 4(34): 1387-1389

Parthasarathi, Ashok (1970) “Development Strategy for Electronics Industry: Ensuring Success of Technological Innovation” Economic and Political Weekly 5 (48): M149-M155

Parthasarathi, Ashok (1987) “Acquisition and Development of Technology: Some Issues” Economic and Political Weekly 22(48): M131-138

Parthasarathi, Ashok (2007) Technology at the Core: Science and Technology with Indira Gandhi (New Delhi, Pearson)

Parthasarathi, Ashok and Singh, Baldev (1992) “Science in India: The First Ten Years” Economic and Political Weekly 27(35): 1852-1858

Patel, Surendra J. (1982) “The Technological Transformation of the Third World” Economic and Political Weekly 17(9): M13-M22

Pillai, P. Mohanan (1978) “Foreign Collaboration in Public Sector” Economic and Political Weekly 13(21): M48-M55

Pillai, P. Mohanan (1979) “Technology Transfer, Adaptation and Assimilation” Economic and Political Weekly 14(47): M121-M126

Pillai, P. Mohanan (1990) “Technology Transformation: Role of Pricing” Economic and Political Weekly 25(17): 963-964

Rahman, A. (1971) “Indian Science: A Polite View” Economic and Political Weekly 6(29): 1431

Rahman, A. “Scientists in India: The Impact of Economic Policies and Support in Historical and Social Perspective”

Rangarao, B. V. (1971) “Cost-Benefit of an Enquiry” Economic and Political Weekly 6 (40): 2095-2096

Rao, A. (2000) “Technology Absorption: An Overview” Global Business Review 1(1): 101-111

Ray, Amit S. (2004) “The Changing Structure of R&D Incentives in India: The Pharmaceutical Sector” Science Technology & Society 9(2): 295-317.

Reddy, Amulya Kumar N (1977) “The CSIR Decision: A Serious Threat to Indian Development” Economic and Political Weekly

Richta, R. et al (1969) Civilization at the Crossroads: Social and Human Implications of the Scientific and Technological Revolution (White Plains, NY, International Arts and Sciences Press)

Sandhya, G.D. et al (1990) “S and T Planning, Policy Directions and CSIR” Economic and Political Weekly 25 (51): 2800-2805

Sengupta, Arya Kumar et al (2009) “Case Study of an Industry-Academia Interface: The FITT Story” Global Business Review 10 (2): 299-344

Sinha, Jagdish N. (1995) “Technology for National Reconstruction: The National Planning Committee, 1938-49” in MacLeod, Roy and Kumar, Deepak (eds.) Technology and the Raj: Western Technology and Technical Transfers to India, 1700-1947 (New Delhi, Sage Publications): 250-264

Sharma, Dinesh C. (2009) The Long Revolution: The Birth and Growth of India's IT Industry (Delhi, Harper Collins)

Singh, Baldev (1971) “Foreign Technology: Role and Control” Economic and Political Weekly 6(47): 2353-2356

Singh, Baldev (1986) “Reviewing the CSIR” Economic and Political Weekly 21 (34): 1511-1517

Singh, Baldev (1987a) “Perspectives before the CSIR” Economic and Political Weekly 22(17): 752-756

Singh, Baldev (1987b) “Research and Development in Industry” Economic and Political Weekly 22(34): 1431-1434

Singh, Kishore (Ed.) (1986) Choice of Technology for Endogenous Development (New Delhi, NISTADS)

Subrahmanian, K. K. (1966) “Do Collaboration Agreements Hamper Exports?” Economic and Political Weekly 1(7): 273-276

Subrahmanian, K. K. (1968) “Policy on Foreign Collaboration-Need for Change” Economic and Political Weekly 3(41): 1591-1593

Subrahmanian, K. K. (1971) “Determinants of Corporative R and D” Economic and Political Weekly 6(48): M169-M171

Subrahmanian, K.K. (1972) Import of Capital and Technology: A Study of Foreign Collaboration in Indian Industry (New Delhi, People’s Publishing House)

Subrahmanian, K. K. (1978) “Approach to Foreign Collaboration-A Critique of New Industrial Policy” Economic and Political Weekly 13(14): 613-617

Subrahmanian, K. K. (1986) “Technology Import: Regulation Reduces Cost” Economic and Political Weekly 21(32): 1412-1416

Subrahmanian, K. K. (1987) “Towards Technological Self-Reliance: An assessment of Indian Strategy and Achievement in Industry” in P.R.Brahmananda and V.R. Panchamukhi The Development Process of the Indian Economy (Bombay, Himalaya Publishing House): 420-46

Subrahmanian, K. K. (1991) “Technological Capability under Economic Liberalism-Experience of Indian Industry in Eighties” Economic and Political Weekly 26(35): M87-M91

Subrahmanian, K. K. and Pillai, P Mohanan (1976) “Implications of Technology-Transfer in Export-Led Growth Strategy” Economic and Political Weekly 11(44): 1729-1735

Subrahmanian, K.K. et al (1996) Foreign Collaboration under Liberalisation Policy: Patterns of FDI and Technology-Transfer in Indian Industry since 1991 Development Research Group Study No. 14 (Mumbai, Department of Economic Analysis and Policy, Reserve Bank of India)

Suri, M.M. (1968) “Impact of Foreign Collaboration on Indian Research and Development” in Rehman, A. and Sharma, K.D. (eds.) Science Policy Studies (Mumbai, Somaiya Publications): 395-406

Technology Analysis & Strategic Management (2007) Special issue “The Indian Pharmaceutical Industry before and after TRIPS,” 19 (5): 559–708

Teich, Mikulas (2008) “J. D. Bernal the historian and the Scientific-Technical Revolution” Interdisciplinary Science Reviews 33(2): 135-139

Tripathi, Dwijendra (1996) “Colonialism and Technology Choices in India: A Historical Overview” The Developing Economies 34(1): 80-97

Tyabji, Nasir (1995) Colonialism, Chemical Technology and Industry in Southern India, 1880-1937 (Delhi, Oxford University Press)

Tyabji, Nasir (2000) Industrialisation and Innovation: The Indian Experience (New Delhi, Sage Publications)

Tyabji, Nasir (2005) “Globalisation and Chemistry within the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research, 1945-2005” (typescript) paper presented at the 22nd International Congress of History of Science, Globalisation and Diversity: Modern Chemistry and Chemical Technology, ICHS Symposium SC16, 24–30 July 2005 Beijing,

Tyabji, Nasir (2007) “Jawaharlal Nehru and Science and Technology” History and Sociology of South Asia 1(1): 130-136

Valluri, S. R. (1989) “CSIR: Reorganisation or Dismantling?” Economic and Political Weekly 24(38): 2115-2120

Valluri, S. R. (1990) “Management of R and D Institutions and Self-Reliance” Economic and Political Weekly 25(34): M111-M114

Valluri, S. R. (1993) “CSIR and Technological Self-Reliance” Economic and Political Weekly 28(14): 565-568

Valluri, S. R. (1997) “Industrial Research and Scientific Workers” Economic and Political Weekly 32(8): 392-395