Testing the hockey-stick hypothesis by statistical analyses of a large dataset of proxy records.

Travaglini, Guido (2014): Testing the hockey-stick hypothesis by statistical analyses of a large dataset of proxy records. Published in: Pattern Recognition in Physics , Vol. 2, No. 2 (March 2014): pp. 36-63.

Abstract

This paper is a statistical time-series investigation addressed at testing the anthropogenic climate change hypothesis known as the “hockey-stick”. The time-series components of a select batch of 258 long-term yearly Climate Change Proxies (CCP) included in 19 paleoclimate datasets, all of which running back as far as the year 2192 B.C., are reconstructed by means of univariate Bayesian Calibration. The instrumental temperature record utilized is the Global Best Estimated Anomaly (BEA) of the HADCRUT4 time series readings available yearly for the period 1850-2010. After performing appropriate data transformations, Ordinary Least Squares parameter estimates are obtained, and subsequently simulated by means of multi-draw Gibbs sampling for each year of the pre-1850 period. The ensuing Time-Varying Parameter sequence is utilized to produce high-resolution calibrated estimates of the CCP series, merged with BEA to yield Millennial-scale Time Series (MTS). Finally, the MTS are individually tested for temperature single break date and multiple peak dates. As a result, the estimated temperature breaks and peaks suggest widespread rejection of the hockey-stick hypothesis since they are mostly centered in the Medieval Warm Period.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Bayesian Calibration; climate change; Gibbs sampling; hockey-stick hypothesis.
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General > C11 - Bayesian Analysis: General; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General > C14 - Semiparametric and Nonparametric Methods: General; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C5 - Econometric Modeling; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C5 - Econometric Modeling > C51 - Model Construction and Estimation

References

1. Abdussamatov H.: About the long-term coordinated variations of the activity, radius, total irradiance of the sun and the Earth’s climate, In Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union, 223, 541-542, 2004.

2. Alanko-Huotari K., Usoskin I.G., Mursula, K., and Kovaltsov, G.A.: Global heliospheric parameters and cosmic ray modulation: an empirical relation for the last decades, Solar Phys., 238, 391–404, 2006.

3. Ansari A.R. and Bradley R.A.: Rank-sum tests for dispersion, Ann. Math. Stat., 31, 1174–1189, 1960.

4. Appenzeller C., Stocker T.F., and Anktin M.: North Atlantic oscillation dynamics recorded in Greenland ice cores, Science, 282, 446–449, 1998.

5. Baliunas, S., Soon, W.: Lessons and limits of climate history: was the 20th. century climate unusual? The George C. Marshall Institute: Washington, D.C., 1-25, 2003.

6. Banerjee A., Marcellino M., and Masten I.: Leading indicators for Euro-area inflation and GDP growth, Oxf. Bull. Econ. Stat., 67, 785–813, 2005.

7. Bard, E. and Frank, M.: Climate change and solar variability: What’s new under the sun?, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 248, 1–14, 2006.

8. Bradley R.S.: Paleoclimatology: Reconstructing climates of the Quaternary, Harcourt Academic Press: San Diego, CA, pp. 613, 1999.

9. Bradley R.S., Briffa K.R., Crowley T.J., Hughes M.K., Jones P.D., and Mann M.E.: Scope of medieval warming, Science, 292, 2011–2012, 2001.

10. Broecker W.S.: Was the Medieval Warm Period global?, Science, 291, 1497–1499, 2001.

11. Büntgen U., Tegel W., Nicolussi K., McCormick M., Frank D., Trouet V., Kaplan J.O., Herzig F., Heussner K.U., and Wanner H.: 2500 Years of European climate variability and human susceptibility, Science, 331, 578–583, 2011.

12. Büntgen U., Trouet V., Frank D.C., Leuschner H.H., Friederichs D., Luterbacher J., and Esper, J.: Tree-ring indicators of German summer drought over the last millennium, Quat. Sci. Rev., 29, 1005–1016, 2010.

13. Büntgen U., Frank D.C., Nievergelt D., and Esper J.: Summer temperature variations in the European Alps, A.D. 755–2004, J. Clim., 19, 5606–5623, 2006.

14. Bürger G.: Comment on the spatial extent of 20th-century warmth in the context of the past 1200 years, Science, 316/5833, 1844, 2007.

15. Carter C.K. and Cohn P.: On Gibbs sampling for state space models, Biometrika, 81, 541–553, 1994.

16. Christiansen B., Schmith T., and Thejll P.: A surrogate ensemble study of climate reconstruction methods: Stochasticity and robustness, J. Clim., 22, 951–976, 2009.

17. Christiansen B.: Reconstructing the NH mean temperature: Can underestimation of trends and variability be avoided?, J. Clim., 24, 674–692, 2011.

18. Christiansen B. and Ljungqvist F.C.: Reconstruction of the extratropical NH mean temperature over the last millennium with a method that preserves low-frequency variability, J. Clim., 24, 6013–6034, 2011.

19. Cook E.R., Palmer J.G., and D’Arrigo R.D.: Evidence for a ‘Medieval Warm Period’ in a 1,100 year tree-ring reconstruction of past austral summer temperatures in New Zealand, Geophys. Res. Lett., 29, 12-1–12-4, 2002.

20. Cook E.R., Buckley B.M., D’Arrigo R.D., and Peterson M.J.: Warm-season temperatures since 1600 B.C. reconstructed from Tasmanian tree rings and their relationship to large-scale sea surface temperature anomalies, Clim. Dyn., 16, 79–91, 2000.

21. Cook E.R., Buckley B.M., and D’Arrigo R.D.: Inter-decadal climate variability in the Southern Hemisphere: Evidence from Tasmanian tree rings over the past three millennia, In Climate variations and forcing mechanisms of the last 2,000 years. NATO ASI Series, In Jones P.D., Bradley R.S., Jouzel J., Eds., Springer-Verlag: Berlin, Germany, 41, 141–160, 1996.

22. Cooley T.F.: Calibrated models, Oxf. Rev. Econ. Policy, 13, 55–69, 1997.

23. Crowley T.J. and North G.R.: Paleoclimatology, Oxford University Press: New York, N.Y., pp. 339, 1991.

24. Crowley T.J.: Causes of climate change over the past 1000 years, Science, 289, 270–277, 2000.

25. Crowley T.J. and Lowery T.: How warm was the medieval warm period?, Ambio, 29, 51–54, 2000.

26. Cuven S., Francus P., and Lamoureux S.: Mid to Late Holocene hydroclimatic and geochemical records from the varved sediments of East Lake, Cape Bounty, Canadian High Arctic, Quat. Sci. Rev., 30, 2651–2665, 2011.

27. D’Agostino R.B., Belanger A., and D’Agostino R.B. Jr.: A suggestion for using powerful and informative tests of normality, Am. Stat., 44, 316–321, 1990.

28. D’Arrigo R., Wilson R., and Jacoby G.: On the long-term context for late twentieth century warming, J. Geophys. Res., 111, doi: 10.1029/2005JD006352, 2006.

29. Elliott G., Rothenberg T.J., and Stock J.H.: Efficient tests for an autoregressive unit root, Econometrica, 64, 813–836, 1996.

30. Esper J., Cook E.R., and Schweingruber F.H.: Low-Frequency signals in long tree-ring chronologies for reconstructing past temperature variability, Science, 295, 2250–2253, 2002.

31. Esper J. and Frank D.: The IPCC on a heterogeneous Medieval Warm Period, Clim. Change, 94, 267–273, 2009.

32. Evans M.N., Kaplan A., and Cane M.A.: Pacific sea surface temperature field reconstruction from coral data using reduced space objective analysis, Paleoceanography, 17, doi: 10.1029/2000PA000590, 2002.

33. Fan J. and Yao Q,, Nonlinear time series: Nonparametric and parametric methods, Springer-Verlag, N.Y., pp. vii+551, 2003.

34. Folland C.K., Karl T.R., Christy J.R., Clarke R.A., Gruza G.V., Jouze, J., Mann M.E., Oerlemans J., Salinger M.J., and Wang S.W.: Observed climate variability and change, In Climate change 2001: The scientific basis, Houghton J.T., Griggs D.J., Nogner M., van der Linden P.J., Dai X., Maskell K., and Johnson C.A. Eds., Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, pp. 99–181, 2001.

35. Fouka P., Fröhlich C., Spruit H., and Wigley T.M.: Variations in solar luminosity and their effect on the Earth's climate, Nature, 443, 161–166, 2006.

36. Fritts H.C., Blasing T.J., Hayden B.P., and Kutzbach J.E.: Multivariate techniques for specifying tree-growth and climate relationships and for reconstructing anomalies in paleoclimate, J. Appl. Meteorol. 10, 845–864, 1971.

37. Fritts H.C.: Reconstructing large-scale climatic patterns from tree-ring data, The University of Arizona Press: Tucson, AZ., pp. 286, 1991.

38. Gagen M., McCarroll D., Loader N.J., Robertson I., Jalkanen R., and Anchukaitis K.J.: Exorcising the ‘segment length curse’: Summer temperature reconstruction since A.D. 1640 using non-detrended stable carbon isotope ratios from pine trees in northern Finland, Holocene, 17, 435–446, 2007.

39. Goodman L.: On the exact variance of products, J. Am. Stat. Assoc., 55, 708–713, 1960.

40. Goodman L.: The variance of the product of K random variables, J. Am. Stat. Assoc., 57, 54–60, 1962.

41. Graham N.E., Ammann C.M., Fleitmann D., Cobb K.M., and Luterbacher J.: Support for global climate reorganization during the “Medieval Climate Anomaly”, Clim. Dyn., doi:10.1007/s00382-010-0914-z, 2010.

42. Granger C.W.J. and Newbold P.: Spurious regression in econometrics, J. Econom., 2, 111-120, 1974.

43. Gray W.M., Sheaffer J.D., and Landsea C.W.: Climate trends associated with multidecadal variability of Atlantic hurricane activity, In Hurricanes: Climate and Socioeconomic Impacts, Diaz H.F.and Pulwarty R.S., Eds., Springer-Verlag: New York, NY, USA, pp. 15–53, 1997.

44. Guiot J., Corona C., and ESCARSEL members: Growing season temperatures in Europe and climate forcings over the past 1400 years, PLoS ONE, 5, e9972, 2010.

45. Hamilton J.D.: Time Series Analysis, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, USA, pp. 799, 1994.

46. Hantemirov R.M. and Shiyatov S.G.: A continuous multimillennial ring-width chronology in Yamal, Northwestern Siberia, Holocene, 12, 717–726, 2002.

47. Hendy E.J., Gagan M.K., Alibert C.A., McCulloch M.T., Lough J.M., and Isdale P.J.: Abrupt decrease in Tropical pacific sea surface salinity at end of Little Ice Age, Science, 295, 1511–1154, 2002.

48. Hollander M. and Wolfe D.A.: Nonparametric statistical methods, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.: Hoboken, N.J., pp. 816, 1999.

49. IPCC, 2001: Third Assessment Report, Available at: http://www.grida.no/publications/other/ipcc_tar/.

50. IPCC, 2007, Fourth Assessment Report, Available at: http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data//ar4/syr/en/ contents.html.

51. Jarque C.M. and Bera, A.K.: A test for normality of observations and regression residuals, Int. Stat. Rev., 55, 163–172, 1987.

52. Jones P.D., Osborn J., and Briffa K.R.: The evolution of climate over the last millennium, Science, 292, 662–667, 2001.

53. Juckes M.N., Allen M.R., Briffa K.R., Esper J., Hegerl G.C., Moberg A., Osborn T.J., and Weber S.L.: Millennial temperature reconstruction intercomparison and evaluation, Clim. Past, 3, 591–609, 2007.

54. Kalman R.E.: A new approach to linear filtering and prediction problems, Trans. ASME, 82, 35–45, 1960.

55. Kennedy M. and O’Hagan A.: Bayesian calibration of computer models (with discussion), J. R. Stat. Soc. Ser. B, 63, 425–464, 2001.

56. Kim D. and Perron P.: Unit root tests allowing for a break in the trend function at an unknown time under both the null and alternative hypotheses, J. Econom.., 148, 1–13, 2009.

57. Koop G. and Korobilis D.: Manual to accompany Matlab package for Bayesian VAR models, Mimeo, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, UK, 1-27, 2009.

58. Kruskal W.H. and Wallis W.A.: Use of ranks in one-criterion variance analysis, J. Am. Stat. Assoc., 47, 583–621.

59. Kwiatkowski D., Phillips P.C.B., Schmidt P., and Shin Y.: Testing the null hypothesis of stationarity against the alternative of a unit root, J. Econom., 54, 159–178, 1992.

60. Li J., Xie S.P., Cook E.R., Huang G., D’Arrigo R., Liu F., Ma J., and Zheng X.-T.: Interdecadal modulation of El Niño amplitude during the past millennium, Nat. Clim. Change, 1, 114–118, 2011.

61. Lindholm M., Jalkanen R., Salminen H., Aalto T., and Ogurtsov M.: The height-increment record of summer temperature extended over the last millennium in Fennoscandia, Holocene, doi:10.1177/0959683610378875, 2010.

62. Ljungqvist F.C.: Temperature proxy records covering the last two millennia: a tabular and visual overview, Geogr. Ann., 91, 11–29, 2009.

63. Loehle C.: A 2000-year global temperature reconstruction based on non-tree ring proxies, Energy Environ. 18, 1049–1058, 2007.

64. Loehle C., McCulloch J.H.: Correction to: A 2000-year global temperature reconstruction based on non-tree ring proxies, Energy Environ., 19, 93–100, 2008.

65. Loso M.G.: Summer temperatures during the Medieval Warm Period and Little Ice Age inferred from varved proglacial lake sediments in Southern Alaska, J. Paleolimnol., 41, 117–128, 2008.

66. Mann M.E., Bradley R.S., and Hughes M.K.: Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcing over the past six centuries, Nature, 392, 779–787, 1998.

67. Mann M.E., Bradley R.S., and Hughes M.K.: Northern Hemisphere temperature during the past millennium: inferences, uncertainties and limitations, Geophys. Res. Lett., 26, 759–762, 1999.

68. Mann M.E., Zhang Z., Hughes M.K., Bradley R.S., Miller S.K., Rutherford S., and Ni F.: Proxy-based reconstructions of hemispheric and global surface temperature variations over the past two millennia, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 105, 13252–13257, 2008.

69. Mann M.E., Zhang Z., Rutherford S., Bradley R.S., Hughes M.K., Shindell D., Ammann C., Faluvegi G., and Ni F.: Global signatures and dynamical origins of the Little Ice Age and Medieval Climate Anomaly, Science, 326, 1256–1260, 2009.

70. McIntyre S. and McKitrick R.: The M&M critique of the MBH98 Northern Hemisphere climate index: update and implications, Energy Environ., 16, 69–100, 2005.

71. McIntyre S. and McKitrick R.: Proxy inconsistency and other problems in millennial paleoclimate reconstructions, Lett. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 106, E10, 2009.

72. McKitrick, R.: The Mann et al. Northern Hemisphere “Hockey- Stick” climate index: A Tale of due diligence, In Shattered consensus: the true state of global warming, Michaels P., Ed., Rowman and Littlefield: Washington D.C., pp. 20–48, 2006.

73. McShane B.B. and Wyner A.J.: A statistical analysis of multiple temperature proxies: Are reconstructions of surface temperatures over the last 1000 years reliable?, The Annals of Appl. Stat., 5, 5-44, 2011.

74. Moberg A., Sonechkin D.M., Holmgren K., Datsenko N.M., and Karlén W.: Highly variable Northern Hemisphere temperatures reconstructed from low- and high-resolution proxy data, Nature, 433, 613–617, 2005.

75. Montford A.W.: The hockey-stick illusion, climategate and the corruption of science, Stacey International, London, UK, pp. 482, 2010.

76. Moore J.J., Hughen K.A., Miller G.H., and Overpeck J.T.: Little Ice Age recorded in summer temperatures from varved sediments of Donard Lake, Baffin Island, Canada, J. Paleolimnol., 25, 503–517, 2001.

77. Morice C.P., Kennedy J.J., Rayner N.A., and Jones P.D.: Quantifying uncertainties in global and regional temperature change using an ensemble of observational estimates: The HadCRUT4 data set, J. Geophys. Res., doi: 10.1029/2011JD017187, 2012.

78. Neukom R., Luterbacher J., Villalba R., Küttel M., Frank D., Jones P.D., Grosjean M., Wanner H., Aravena J.-C., Black, D.E., Christie D.A, D’Arrigo R., Lara A., Morales M., Soliz-Gamboa C., Srur A., Urrrutia R., and von Gunten L.: Multiproxy summer and winter surface air temperature field reconstructions for Southern South America covering the past centuries, Clim. Dyn., doi:10.1007/s00382-010-0793-3, 2010.

79. O’Keefe W. and Kueter J.: Climate models: A primer, The George C. Marshall Institute, Washington D.C., 1-22, 2004.

80. Orfanidis S.J.: Introduction to signal processing, Sophocles J. Orfanidis, Rutgers University, pp. xiii+795, 2010.

81. Pederson G.T., Gray S.T., Woodhouse C.A., Betancourt J.L., Fagre D.B., Littell J.S., Watson E., Luckman B.H., and Graumlich L.J.: The unusual nature of recent snowpack declines in the North American Cordillera, Science, 333, 332–335, 2011.

82. Perron P. and Zhu X.: Structural breaks with deterministic and stochastic trends, J. Econom.129, 65–119, 2005.

83. Rougier J.: Discussion of “A statistical analysis of multiple temperature proxies: are reconstructions of surface temperatures over the last 1000 years reliable?” by Mcshane and Wyner, The Annals of Appl. Stat., 5, 1-3, 2011.

84. Royston P.: Algorithm AS R94, Appl. Stat., 44, 547-550, 1995.

85. Said E. and Dickey D.A.: Testing for unit roots in autoregressive moving average models of unknown order, Biometrika, 71, 599–607, 1984.

86. Salzer M.W. and Kipfmueller K.F.: Reconstructed temperature and precipitation on a millennial timescale from tree-rings in the Southern Colorado Plateau, U.S.A., Clim. Change, 70, 465-487, 2005.

87. Sansó B. and Forest C.: Statistical calibration of climate system properties, J. R. Stat. Soc., 58, 485–503, 2009.

88. Savitzky A. and Golay M.J.E., Smoothing and differentiation of data by simplified least squares procedures, Anal. Chem., 36, 1627–1639, 1964.

89. Scafetta N.: Discussion on common errors in analyzing sea level accelerations, solar trends and global warming, Pattern Recogn. Phys.1, 37–57, 2013.

90. Shaviv N.: On climate response to changes in the cosmic ray flux and radiative budget,J. Geophys. Res., 110, 1–15, 2005.

91. Shindell D.T., Schmidt G.A., Mann E.M., and Faluvegi G.: Dynamic winter climate response to large tropical volcanic eruptions since 1600, J. Geophys. Res., 109, 1-12, 2004.

92. Sinha A., Berkelhammer M., Stott L., Mudelsee M., Cheng H., and Biswas J.: The leading mode of Indian summer monsoon precipitation variability during the last millennium, Geophys. Res. Lett., 38, doi: 10.1029/2011GL047713, 2011.

93. Smerdon J., Kaplan A., and Chang D.: On the origin of the standardization sensitivity in RegEM climate field reconstructions, J. Clim, 21, 6710–6723, 2008.

94. Stahle D.W., Diaz J.V., Burnette D.J., Paredes J.C., Heim R.R. Jr., Fye F.K., Acuna Soto R., Therrell M.D., Cleaveland M.K., and Stahl D.K.: Major Mesoamerican droughts of the past millennium, Geophys. Res. Lett., 38, doi: 10.1029/2010GL046472, 2011.

95. Stambaugh M.C., Guyette R.P., McMurry E.R., Cook E.R., Meko D.M., and Lupo A.R.: Drought duration and frequency in the U.S. Corn Belt during the last millennium (A.D. 992–2004), Agric. For. Meteorol., 151, 154–162, 2011.

96. Stock J.H. and Watson M.W.: New indexes of coincident and leading economic indicators, In NBER Macroeconomics Annual,, Blanchard O.J. and Fischer S. Eds., NBER, Cambridge, MA, 351–409, 1989.

97. Svensmark H. and Frijs-Christensen E.: Reply to Lockwood and Fröhlich. The persistent role of the sun in climate forcing, Danish National Space Center Scientific Report , 3, 1-6, 2007.

98. Tand M., Liu T.S., Hou J., Qin X., Zhang H., and Li T.: Cyclic rapid warming on centennial-scale revealed by a 2650-year stalagmite record of warm season temperature, Geophys. Res. Lett., 30, doi: 10.1029/2003GL017352, 2003.

99. Tellinghuisen J.: Inverse vs. classical calibration for small data sets, Fresenius J. Anal. Chem., 368, 585–588, 2000.

100. Tingley M.P.: BARCAST and the Kalman smoother, Manuscript, 2010a.

101. Tingley M.P.: and Huybers P.: A Bayesian algorithm for reconstructing climate anomalies in space and time. Part I: Development and applications to paleoclimate reconstruction problems, J. Clim, 23, 23, 2759–2781, 2010b.

102. Tingley M.P.: Spurious predictions with random time series: The LASSO in the context of paleoclimatic reconstructions. A Discussion of “A statistical analysis of multiple temperature proxies: Are reconstructions of surface temperatures over the last 1000 years reliable?” by Blakeley B. McShane and Abraham J. Wyner, The Annals of Appl. Stat., 5, 83-87, 2011.

103. Tingley M.P. and Li B.: Comments on “Reconstructing the NH mean temperature: Can underestimation of trends and variability be avoided?”, J. Clim. 2012, 25, 3441–3446, 2012.

104. Trouet V., Esper J., Graham N.E., Baker A., Scourse J.D., and Frank D.C.: Persistent positive North Atlantic oscillation mode dominated the medieval climate anomaly, Science, 324, 78-80, 2009.

105. Usoskin I.G., Mursula K., Solanki S.K., Schüssler M., and Alanko-Huotari K.: Reconstruction of solar activity for the last millennium using data, Astron. Astrophys.,413, 745–751, 2004a.

106. Usoskin I.G., Mursula K., Solanki S.K., Schüssler M., and Alanko-Huotari K.: Millennium-scale sunspot number reconstruction: Evidence for an unusually active sun since the 1940s, Phys. Rev. Lett., 91, 211101:1–211101:4, 2004b.

107. Usoskin I.G., Solanki S.K., and Korte M.: Solar activity reconstructed over the last 7000 years: The influence of geomagnetic field changes, Geophys. Res. Lett., 33, L08103:1–L08103:4, 2006.

108. Ventosa-Santaulària D.: Spurious regression, J. Probab. Stat., 2009, 1–27, 2009.

109. Von Storch H., Zorita E., Jones J.M., Dimitriev Y., González-Rouco F., and Tett S.F.B.: Reconstructing past climate from noisy data, Science, 306, doi:10.1126/science.1096109, 2004.

110. Wahl E.R., Anderson D.M., Bauer B.A., Buckner R., Gille E.P., Gross W.S., Hartman M., and Shah A.: An archive of high-resolution temperature reconstructions over the past 2+ millennia, Geochem. Geophys. Geosyst., 11, doi:10.1029/2009GC002817, 2010.

111. Wilson R., Wiles G., D’Arrigo R., and Zweck C.: Cycles and shifts: 1,300 years of multi-decadal temperature variability in the Gulf of Alaska, Clim. Dyn., 28, 425–440, 2006.

112. Yan H., Sun L., Wang Y., Huang W., Qiu S., and Yang C.: A record of the Southern Oscillation Index for the past 2,000 years from precipitation proxies, Nat. Geosci., 4, 611–614, 2013.

113. Zunli L., Rickaby R.E.M., Kennedy H., Kennedy P., Pancost R.D., Shaw S., Lennie A., Wellner J., and Anderson J.B.: An Ikaite record of late Holocene climate at the Antarctic Peninsula, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 325-326, 108–115, 2012.