Understanding Financial Instability: Minsky Versus the Austrians

Van den Hauwe, Ludwig (2014): Understanding Financial Instability: Minsky Versus the Austrians.

Abstract

Although Minsky’s interpretation of Keynes’s work and essential message clashes with authoritative alternative interpretations, it has become increasingly influential in the years following the GFC and further research along the lines suggested by Minsky can be expected to be forthcoming in coming years. Some of the analogies and/or similarities of his theoretical analysis with the analysis provided by the Austrian School suggest a more than merely superficial affinity between both theoretical approaches and there may be found some scope for cross-fertilization between both research traditions that may be further evidenced by forthcoming work relating to business cycle theory and to the role of financial regulation. Nevertheless, both in terms of fundamental causality and in terms of policy conclusions and prescriptions, both approaches remain incompatible at a fundamental level and difficult if not impossible to reconcile. Much of the disagreement on policy issues between post-Keynesians and Austrians hinges on the answer to the underlying question of whether the actions and interventions of Big Players in mixed economies are stabilizing or destabilizing. Post-Keynesians believe they can and, if conducted appropriately, often will indeed be stabilizing; Austrians to the contrary believe that mostly they will tend to be destabilizing. Minsky’s policy conclusions manifest a lack of familiarity with the conclusions of the Austrian analysis of the problems of central planning by Big Players such as Big Bank and Big Government. Even if the two theoretical frameworks do not directly contradict each other since they are actually non-commensurable, the Austro-Wicksellian paradigm arguably provides superior insights that can complement and correct Minskyan analyses of the historical experience of the Global Financial Crisis and Great Recession.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Financial Instability, Business Cycle, Minsky, Austrian School
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B50 - General; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B53 - Austrian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B59 - Other; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E0 - General; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E0 - General > E02 - Institutions and the Macroeconomy; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E30 - General; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E32 - Business Fluctuations ; Cycles

References

Acharya, V.V. and M. Richardson. 2011. “How Securitization Concentrated Risk in the Financial Sector”, in: Friedman. 2011: Chapter 7, 183-199.

Altmiks, P. (Hg.). 2010. Im Schatten der Finanzkrise—Muss das staatliche Zentralbankwesen abgeschafft werden?. München: Olzog Verlag.

Arnold, L.G. 2002. Business Cycle Theory. New York: Oxford University Press.

Assenza, Tiziana, Domenico Delli Gatti and Mauro Gallegati. 2010. “Financial instability and agents’ heterogeneity: a post Minskyan research agenda”, in: Papadimitriou, D.B. and Wray L.R. 2010: 182-205.

Backhaus J. 2005. The Elgar Companion to Law end Economics. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Backhouse, R.E. 2014. “Hayek and Keynes.” in: R. Garrison and N. Barry. 2014: 94-115.

Bhattacharya, S., C.A.E. Goodhart, D. Tsomocos and A. Vardoulakis. 2011. “Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis and the Leverage Cycle”, LSE Financial Markets Group Paper Series, Special paper 202.

Beckworth, D. 2012. Boom and Bust Banking—The Causes and Cures of the Great Recession. Oakland: The Independent Institute.

Bellofiore, R. and Piero Ferri. 2001a. Financial Keynesianism and Market Instability—The Economic Legacy of Hyman Minsky. Volume I. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Bellofiore, R and Piero Ferri. 2001b. “Introduction: ‘Things fall apart, the centre cannot hold””, in: Bellofiore and Ferri. 2001a: 1-29 and in: Bellofiore and Ferri. 2001c: 1-29.

Bellofiore, R. and Piero Ferri. 2001c. Financial Fragility and Investment in the Capitalist Economy—The Economic Legacy of Hyman Minsky. Volume II. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Bilo S. and R. E. Wagner. 2015. “Neutral money: Historical fact or analytical artifact?” Review of Austrian Economics. 28: 139-150.

Bohm-Bawerk E. von. 1959. Capital and Interest. Illinois: Libertarian Press.

Booth, P. (ed.) 2009. Verdict on the Crash: Causes and Policy Implications, London: The Institute of Economic Affairs.

Buchanan, J.M. and R.E. Wagner. 1977 [2000]. Demovracy in Deficit—The Political Legacy of Lord Keynes. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.

Butos, W.N. 1985. “Hayek and General Equilibrium Analysis.” Southern Economic Journal. Vol. 52, No. 2: 332-343.

Butos, W.N. and R. Koppl. 1993. “Hayekian Expectations: Theory and Empirical Expectations.” Constitutional Political Economy, Vol. 4 N° 3: 303-29.

Cachanosky, Nicolas and Salter, Alexander William. 2013. “The View from Vienna: An Analysis of the Renewed Interest in the Mises-Hayek Theory of the Business Cycle.” Available at SSRN:http://ssrn.com/abstract=2363560 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2363560

Caldwell, B. 1995. Contra Keynes and Cambridge, The Collected Works of F.A. Hayek Volume 9, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Cantillon, R. 1755 [2001]. Essay on the Nature of Commerce in General. London: Transaction Publishers.

Cochran, J.P. and F.R. Glahe. 1992. “The Use and Abuse of Equilibrium in Business Cycle Theory—A Praxeological Approach.” Cultural Dynamics, 5: 356-70.

Cochran, J.P. and F.R. Glahe. 1999. The Hayek-Keynes Debate—Lessons for Current Business Cycle Research. Lewiston: The Edwin Mellen Press.

Colander D., M. Goldberg, A. Haas, K. Juselius, A. Kirman, T. Lux and B. Sloth. 2011. “The Financial Crisis and the Systemic Failure of the Economics Profession.” In: J. Friedman 2011, Chapter 12: 262-278.

D’Apice V. and G. Ferri. 2010. Financial Instability. New York: Palgrave.

De Antoni, E. 2010. “Minsly’s ‘financial instability hypothesis’: the not-too-Keynesian optimism of a financial Cassandra.” in: Zambelli. 2010: 462-84.

De Grauwe, P. 2012. Lectures in Behavioral Macroeconomics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Dejuán, Ó, Febrero E. and Marcuzzo, M.C. 2011. The First Great Recession of the 21st Century. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Detzer D. and H. Herr 2015. “Theories of Financial Crises as Cumulative Processes.” in: Hein et al. 2015, Chapter 3: 115-161.

Eggertsson G.B. and P. Krugman. 2012. “Debt, Deleveraging, and the Liquidity Trap: A Fisher-Minsky-Koo Approach.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1469-1513.

Fazzari, S. and Dimitri B. Papadimitriou (eds.). 1992. Financial Conditions and Macroeconomic Performance. New York: Sharpe.

Fillieule, R. 2010. L’école autrichienne d’économie—Une autre hétérodoxie. France: Septentrion.

Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission. 2011. Final Report of the National Commission on the Causes of the Financial and Economic Crises in the United States, New York: PublicAffairs.

Fisher, I. Oct. 1933. “The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depressions.” Econometrica 1, 337-357.

Flanders, J. 2015. “It’s Not a Minsky Moment, It’s a Minsky Era, Or: Inevitable Instability.” Econ Journal Watch 12(1): 84-105.

Friedman J. (ed.). 2011. What Caused the Financial Crisis?, Oxford: University of Pennsylvania Press.

Friedman, J. and Wladimir Kraus. 2011. Engineering the Financial Crisis—Systemic Risk and the Failure of Regulation. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

Garrison, R.W. 1978. “Austrian Macroeconomics: A Diagrammatical Exposition.” In: Spadaro L.M. (ed.). 1978.

Garrison, R.W. 1992. “Is Milton Friedman a Keynesian? In: Skousen. 1992: 131-47.

Garrison, R.W. 2001. Time and Money—The Macroeconomics of Capital Structure. London: Routledge.

Garrison, R.W. 2005. “The Austrian School.” in: Snowdon B. and Vane H.R. 2005: 474-516.

Garrison, R.W. and N. Barry. 2014. Elgar Companion to Hayekian Economics. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Gjerstad, S.D. and V.L. Smith. 2014. Rethinking Housing Bubbles—The Role of Household and Bank Balance Sheets in Modeling Economic Cycles. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Gloria-Palermo, S. 1999. The Evolution of Austrian Economics. London : Routledge.

Godley, W. and M. Lavoie. 2012. Monetary Economics—An Integrated Approach to Credit, Money, Income, Production and Wealth. New York : Palgrave Macmillan.

Goodspeed, T. B. 2012. Rethinking the Keynesian Revolution. New York: Oxford University Press.

Gordon, R.J. .2012. Macroeconomics. New York: Pearson.

Greenberger, M. 2013. “Derivatives in the Crisis and Financial Reform.” Chapter 23, in: Wolfson and Epstein. 2013: 467-490.

Hayek, F.A. 1931-2. “Reflections on the Pure Theory of Money of Mr. J. M. Keynes.” in: Caldwell. 1995: 121-146 and 174-197.

Hayek, F.A. 1937 [1939]. “Investment that Raises the Demand for Capital.” in: Hayek 1939: 73- 82.

Hayek, F.A. 1939. Profits, Interest and Investment. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Hayek, F.A. 1945. “The use of knowledge in society.” American Economic Review, 35 (4): 519-30, reprinted in: Hayek F.A. 1948 [1980]: 77-91.

Hayek, F.A. 1948 [1980]. Individualism and Economic Order. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Hayek, F.A. 1933 [2008]. Monetary Theory and the Trade Cycle, in: Salerno J. T. 2008. Prices and Production and Other Works F. A. Hayek On Money, the Business Cycle, and the Gold Standard. Auburn: Ludwig von Mises Institute.

Hayek, F.A. 1969 [1978]. “Three Elucidations of the Ricardo Effect.” in: Hayek 1978: 165-178.

Hayek, F.A. 1978. New Studies in Philosophy, Politics, Economics and the History of Ideas. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Hayek, F.A. 1979. Unemployment and Monetary Policy—Government as Generator of the “Business Cycle.” Cato Paper N° 3, San Francisco: Cato Institute.

Hein, E., D. Detzer and N. Dodig (eds.). 2015. The Demise of Finance-Dominated Capitalism—Explaining the Financial and Economic Crises. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Higgs, R. 1997. “Regime uncertainty: why the Great Depression lasted so long and why prosperity resumed after the war.” Independent Review, Volume I N°4: 561-90.

Horwitz, S. 2000. Microfoundations and Macroeconomics—An Austrian Perspective, London: Routledge.

Howden, D. 2011. Institutions in Crisis—European Perspectives on the Recession. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Huerta de Soto, J. 2010. Socialism, Economic Calculation and Entrepreneurship.Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Huerta de Soto, J. 2011. “A brief note on economic recessions, banking reform, and the future of capitalism.” in: Dejuán et al. 2011: 33-41.

Huerta de Soto, J. 2012. Money, Bank Credit and Economic Cycles. Auburn : Ludwig von Mises Institute.

Ikeda, S. 1997. Dynamics of the Mixed Economy. London: Routledge.

Jablecki, J. and Mateusz Machaj 2001. “A Regulated Meltdown: The Basel Rules and Banks’ Leverage.” in: Friedman 2011. Chapter 8: 200-227.

Kalecki 1965 [2009]. Theory of Economic Dynamics. New York: George Allen & Unwin.

Kates, S. (ed.). 2010. Macroeconomic Theory and its Failings. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. Kates, S. (ed.). 2011. The Global Financial Crisis—What Have We Learnt? Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Keynes, J.M. 1930 [2011]. A Treatise on Money. Mansfield: Martino Publishing.

Keynes, J.M. 1936 [1997]. The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money. New York: Prometheus Books.

Koo, R.C. 2015. The Escape from Balance Sheet Recession and the QE Trap. Singapore: Wiley.

Koppl, R. 2002. Big Players and the Economic Theory of Expectations. New York: Palgrave.

Koppl, R. and W.J. Luther 2012. “Hayek, Keynes and modern macroeconomics.” Review of Austrian Economics, 25: 223-241.

Koppl, R. 2014. From Crisis to Confidence: Macroeconomics after the Crash. London: IEA.

Kregel, J.A. 1992. “Minsky’s “Two-Price” Theory of Financial Instability and Monetary Policy: Discounting versus Open Market Intervention.” in: Fazzari and Papadimitriou 1992: 85-103.

Kregel, J.A. 2008. “Using Minsky’s Cushions of Safety to Analyze the Crisis in the U.S. Subprime Mortgage Market.” International Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 37, no. 1: 3-23.

Kregel, J.A. 2013. “Political Economy Approaches to Financial Crisis: Hyman Minsky’s Financial Fragility Hypothesis.” Chapter 8 in: Wolfson and Epstein 2013: 159-171.

Lachmann L. 1937 [1994]. “Uncertainty and Liquidity-Preference.” In: Lavoie (ed.). 1994: 29-41.

Lavoie, D. (ed.). 1994. Expectations and the Meaning of Institutions, London: Routledge.

Lavoie M. and M. Seccareccia. 2001. “Minsky’s financial fragility hyothesis : a missing macroeconomic link?” in: R. Bellofiore ans P. Ferri. 2001b: 76-96.

Leijonhufvud, A. 1981a. Information and Coordination—Essays in Macroeconomic Theory. New York: Oxford University Press.

Leijonhufvud, A. 1981b. “The Wicksell Connection: Variations on a Theme.” in: Leijonhufvud 1981a: 131-202.

Leijonhufvud A. 2009. “Out of the corridor: Keynes and the crisis.” Cambridge Journal of Economics, 33: 741-757.

Machlup, F. 1976. “Hayek's Contribution to Economics.” in: Machlup. (ed.). Essays on Hayek, Hillsdale, Mich.: Hillsdale College Press: 13-59.

Mansharamani V. 2011. Boombustology—Spotting Financial Bubbles Before They Burst, Hoboken: Wiley.

Mehrling, P. 1999. “The vision of Hyman P. Minsky.” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 39: 129-58.

Meltzer, A.H. 1988. Keynes’s Monetary Theory—A Different Interpretation, New York: Cambridge University Press.

Menger, C. 1871 [1994]. Principles of Economics, Grove City: Libertarian Press.

Minsky, H.P. 1975 [2008]. John Maynard Keynes, New York: McGraw Hill.

Minsky, H.P. 1982. Can “It” Happen Again—Essays on Instability and Finance. New York: Sharpe.

Minsky, H.P. 1986 [2008]. Stabilizing an Unstable Economy. New York: McGraw Hill.

Minsky, H.P. 1993. “On the non-neutrality of money.” FRBNY Quarterly Review (Spring), 77-82.

Minsky, H.P.1994 [2012]. “Financial Instability Hypothesis.” in Wray 2012 543-48. Minsky, H.P. 2004. Induced Investment and Business Cycles. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Mises, L. von. 1949 [1966]. Human Action—A Treatise on Economics. Fourth Revised Edition, New York: FEE.

Mishkin, F.S. 2013. The Economics of Money, Banking, and Financial Markets. New York: Pearson.

Murphy, D. 2009. Unravelling the Credit Crunch. London: CRC Press.

O’Driscoll G. P. and Rizzo M.J. 1996. The Economics of Time and Ignorance. London: Routledge.

O’Driscoll, G. P. 2011. “Hayek and Keynes: What Have We Learned?” The Journal of Private Enterprise, 27(1): 29-38.

Page West III G. and Robert M. Whaples (eds.). 2013. The Economic Crisis in Retrospect— Explanations by Great Economists, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Papadimitriou, D.B. 2004. “Introduction.” in: Minsky 2004: ix-xvi.

Papadimitriou, D.B. and L. Randall Wray. 2010. The Elgar Companion to Hyman Minsky. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Polleit, T. and M. von Prollius. 2010. Geldreform—Vom schlechten Staatsgeld zum guten Marktgeld. Grevenbroich: Lichtschlag Medien.

Posner, R.A. 2011. “The Causes of the Financial Crisis.” in: Friedman 2011: 279-94.

Prychitko, D.L. 2010. “Competing explanations of the Minsky moment: The financial instability hypothesis in light of Austrian theory.” Review of Austrian Economics, 23: 199-221.

Rabin, A.A. 2004. Monetary Theory. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Ravier, A.O. 2013. “Dynamic Monetary Theory and the Phillips Curve with a Positive Slope.” Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics, Vol. 16, N° 2: 165-86.

Rodriguez, A., Turmo J. and O. Vara. 2014. Financial Crisis and the Failure of Economic Theory. London: Pickering & Chatto.

Rosser J.B., M.V. Rosser and M. Gallegati. 2012. “A Minsky-Kindleberger Perspective on the Financial Crisis.” Journal of Economic Issues. Vol. XLVI, N° 2: 449-458.

Rothbard, M.N. 1962 [2004]. Man, Economy, State. Auburn: Ludwig von Mises Institute. Selgin G.A. 1988. The Theory of Free Banking—Money Supply under Competitive Note Issue. Rowman & Littlefield.

Selgin, G. 1997. Less Than Zero—The Case for a Falling Price Level in a Growing Economy. London : IEA.

Sinn, Hans-Werner. 2010. Casino Capitalism, New York: Oxford University Press.

Simpson, D. 2013. The Rediscovery of Classical Economics. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Skousen, M. (ed.). 1992. Dissent on Keynes—A Critical Appraisal of Keynesian Economics. New York: Praeger.

Skousen, M. 2015. “Linking Austrian and Keynesian Economics: A Variation on a Theme.” The Journal of Private Enterprise, 30(4): 97-112.

Smith, V.L. 1991. Papers in Experimental Economics. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Smith, V.L., Suchanek, G.L. and Williams, A.W. 1988. “Bubbles, crashes, and endogenous expectations in experimental spot asset markets.” in: Smith, V.L. 1991: 339-371.

Smithin, J. 2013. Essays in the Fundamental Theory of Monetary Economics and Macroeconomics. Singapore: World Scientific.

Snowdon B. and Vane H.R. 2005. Modern Macroeconomics—Its Origins, Development and Current State. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Sorensen, P.B. and H.J. Whitta-Jacobsen. 2010. Introducing Advanced Macroeconomics—Growth and Business Cycles. London: McGraw-Hill.

Spadaro , L.M. 1978. New Directions in Austrian Economics. San Francisco: Institute for Humane Studies.

Sraffa, P. 1932 [1995]. “Dr. Hayek on Money and Capital.” in: Caldwell. 1995: 198-209.

Taylor, J.B. 2009. Getting Off Track—How Governme nt Actions and Interventions Caused, Prolonged, and Worsened the Financial Crisis. Stanford: Hoover Institution Press.

Taylor, J.B. 2011. “Monetary Policy, Economic Policy and the Financial Crisis: An Empirical Analysis of What Went Wrong.” in: Friedman 2011: 150-171.

Tymoigne, E. and L. Randall Wray. 2014. The Rise and Fall of Money Manager Capitalism. London: Routledge.

Van den Hauwe, L. 2005. “Constitutional economics II.” in Backhaus. 2005: 223-238.

Van den Hauwe, L. 2009a. Foundations of Business Cycle Research Volume I, Saarbrücken: VDM Verlag.

Van den Hauwe, L. 2009b. Three Essays in Monetary Theory. Norderstedt: BoD.

Van den Hauwe, L. 2011a. “John Maynard Keynes and Ludwig von Mises on Probability.”.Journal of Libertarian Studies 22, No. 1: 471–507.

Van den Hauwe, L. 2011b. “Hayek, Gödel, and the case for methodological dualism.” Journal of Economic Methodology, Vol. 18, N° 4: 387-407.

Wallison, P.J. 2011. “Credit-Default Swaps and the Crisis.” in: Friedman 2011, Chapter 10: 238- 248.

White, L.H. 2011. “The Credit-Rating Agencies and the Subprime Debacle.” in: Friedman 2011. Chapter 9: 228-237.

White, L.H. 2015. “Skepticism About Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis: A Comment on Flanders.” Econ Journal Watch 12(1): 106-113.

White, L.H., Vanberg, V. and E. Köhler. 2015. Renewing the Search for a Monetary Constitution—Reforming Government’s Role in the Monetary System. Washington: The Cato Institue.

Wicksell, K. 1936 [1965]. Interest and Prices. New York: Augustus M. Kelley.

Wolf, M. 2014. The Shifts and the Shocks. London: Allen Lane.

Wolfson, M.H. and G.A. Epstein. 2013. The Handbook of The Political Economy of Financial Crises. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Wray, L.R. 1992. “Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis and the Endogeneity of Money.” in: Fazzari and Papadimitriou 1992: 161-180.

Wray, L.R. 2012. Theories of Money and Banking Volume II. Cheltenham: Elgar Research Collection.

Wray, L.R. 2013. “A Minskyan Road to Financial Reform.” Chapter 35 in: Wolfson and Epstein. 2013: 696-710.

Wray, L.R. 2016. Why Minsky Matters—An Introduction to the Work of a Maverick Economist. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Yeager, L. 1988. “The Austrian School on Money and Gold.” Journal of Economic Studies. 15(3/4): 92-105.

Zambelli, S. (ed.).. 2010. Computable, Constructive and Behavioural Economic Dynamics. London: Routledge.