Managing the Impossible Trinity: Volatile Capital Flows and Indian Monetary Policy

Mohan, Rakesh and Kapur, Muneesh (2009): Managing the Impossible Trinity: Volatile Capital Flows and Indian Monetary Policy. Published in:

Abstract

Large capital inflows are often followed by credit and investment booms, inflation, real exchange rate misalignments, current account imbalances and financial sector weaknesses culminating in financial crisis and long-term output losses. While India has received large capital flows since 1993-94, macroeconomic price and financial stability has been maintained in a high growth environment. What explains this desirable outcome? This paper assesses external sector and monetary management policies and finds the outcome can be attributed to judicious use of a menu of options such as management of the capital account; restrictions on access of financial intermediaries to external borrowings vis-à-vis non-financial corporate entities; flexibility in exchange rate movements with capacity to intervene in times of excessive volatility; building up of reserves; strengthening of the financial sector; pre-emptive tightening of norms in sectors with high credit growth; and refinements in the institutional framework for monetary policy. As a result of this approach, growth in monetary/credit aggregates was contained amid growth in the real economy, structural transformation and financial deepening. Inflation was contained even as growth accelerated; financial stability was maintained even as the global economic environment experienced a series of financial crises. The impossible trinity was achieved by maintaining an open but managed capital account and a flexible exchange rate with management of volatility. Rather than relying on a single instrument, many instruments were used in coordination since the Reserve Bank’s jurisdiction over both monetary policy and the regulation of financial institutions permitted the use of various policy instruments. Key lessons from the Indian experience are that monetary policy needs to move away from price stability/inflation targeting objective, central banks need multiple instruments and capital account management has to be countercyclical.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Capital flows; capital account management; Indian monetary policy
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E4 - Money and Interest Rates > E44 - Financial Markets and the Macroeconomy; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E52 - Monetary Policy; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E58 - Central Banks and Their Policies

References

Aghion, Philippe, Philippe Bacchetta, Romain Ranciere and Kenneth Rogoff, 2009, “Exchange Rate Volatility and Productivity Growth: The Role of Financial Development”, Journal of Monetary Economics, 56, pages 494-513.

Asian Development Bank (2009), Asian Development Outlook 2009.

Cecchetti, Stephen, Marion Kohler and Christian Upper, 2009, “Financial Crisis and Economic Activity”, Paper Presented at Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City’s Symposium at Jackson Hole.

Chinn, Menzie and Hiro Ito, 2008, “A New Measure of Financial Openness”, Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis, Vol. 10, Issue 3 September, pp. 309 - 322.

Committee on the Global Financial System, 2009, Report of the Working Group on Capital flows to Emerging Market Economies (Chairman: Rakesh Mohan), Bank for International Settlements, Basel.

Goodhart, Charles, 2009, “Liquidity Management”, Remarks at Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City’s Symposium at Jackson Hole.

Gordon, James and Poonam Gupta, 2004, “Nonresident Deposits in India: In Search of Return?”, Working Paper WP/049/48, International Monetary Fund.

Government of India, 2007, Report of the High Powered Expert Committee on Making Mumbai an International Financial Centre (Chairman: Percy Mistry), New Delhi: Sage India, 2007

Government of India, 2008, Report of the Committee on Financial Sector Reforms (Chairman: Raghuram Rajan), New Delhi:

Grenville, Stephen, 2008, “Central Banks and Capital Flows”, Discussion Paper 87, Asian Development Bank Institute.

Hammond, Gill, 2009, “State of the Art of Inflation Targeting”, Handbook No. 29, Centre for Central Banking Studies, Bank of England.

International Monetary Fund, 2009a, “India: Staff Report for the 2008 Article IV Consultation”, January.

----- ,2009b, World Economic Outlook Database, April.

---- (2009c) “What’s the Damage? Medium-term Output Dynamics After Financial Crises”, World Economic Outlook (Chapter 4), October 2009.

Krugman, Paul, 2009, “How did Economists Get it so Wrong?”, The New York Times, September 6, 2009.

Mohan, Rakesh, 2004, "Challenges to Monetary Policy in a Globalising Context", Reserve Bank of India Bulletin, January [Published in Mohan, Rakesh (2009), “Monetary Policy in a Globalised World: A Practitioner’s View”, Oxford University Press, New Delhi].

--- , 2007a, “Capital Account Liberalisation and Conduct of Monetary Policy: The Indian Experience", Reserve Bank of India Bulletin, July.

--- , 2007b, “India's Financial Sector Reforms: Fostering Growth While Containing Risk", Reserve Bank of India Bulletin, December.

--- , 2008a, “Capital Flows to India", Reserve Bank of India Bulletin, December.

---- 2008b, “The Growth Record of the Indian Economy 1950-2008 : A Story of Sustained Savings and Investment”, Reserve Bank of India Bulletin, March.

----, 2008c, “The Role of Fiscal and Monetary Policies in Sustaining Growth With Stability in India”, Asian Economic Policy Review, Vol. 3, pages 209–236

--- , 2009a, “Monetary Policy in a Globalised World: A Practitioner’s View”, Oxford University Press, New Delhi.

--- ,2009b, “Global Financial Crisis: Causes, Impact, Policy Responses and Lessons”, Reserve Bank of India Bulletin, May

--- ,2009c, “Emerging Contours of Financial Regulation: Challenges and Dynamics”, Financial Stability Review, September 2009, Banque de France, pp.103-116.

Mohan, Rakesh and Muneesh Kapur, 2009, Capital Account Liberalisation and Regulation: Lessons for Emerging Market Economies, Working Paper, Asian Development Bank Institute (forthcoming).

Obstfeld, Maurice, 2009, “International Finance and Growth in Developing Countries: What Have We Learned?”, Staff Papers 56(1), International Monetary Fund.

Reddy, Y.V., 2008, “Management of the Capital Account in India: Some Perspectives”, Reserve Bank of India Bulletin, February.

-----, 2009, “India and the Global Financial Crisis: Managing Money and Finance”, Orient BlackSwan, New Delhi.

Reinhart, Carmen M. and Kenneth S. Rogoff, 2008, “This Time is Different: A Panoramic View of Eight Centuries of Financial Crises”, Working Paper 13882, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Reserve Bank of India, 2008, Report on Currency and Finance 2006-08.

Seelig, Steven and Alicia Novoa (2009), “Governance Practices at Financial Regulatory and Supervisory Agencies”, Working Paper WP/09/135, July, International Monetary Fund.

Shah, Ajay and Ila Patnaik, 2008, “Managing Capital Flows: The Case of India”, Discussion Paper 98, Asian Development Bank Institute.

Shirakawa, Masaaki, 2009, “International Policy Response to Financial Crisis”, Remarks at Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City’s Symposium at Jackson Hole.

Singh, Bhupal, 2007, “Corporate Choice for Overseas Borrowings: The Indian Evidence”, Reserve Bank of India Occasional Papers, Vol.28, No.3, Winter, pp.1-33.

Stiglitz, Joseph E., 2003, “Globalization and Its Discontents”, Norton: New York.

Subbarao, D., 2009, “Global Financial Crisis: Questioning the Questions”, Reserve Bank of India Bulletin, July.

-----“Financial Stability: Issues and Challenges”, Reserve Bank of India Bulletin, October.

Taylor, John, 2008, “The Impacts of Globalisation on Monetary Policy” in “International Symposium: Globalisation, Inflation and Monetary Policy”, Banque de France, March.

Thorat, Usha, 2009, “Global Agenda for Regulatory and Supervisory Reforms: The Stock Taking and Way Forward”, Reserve Bank of India Bulletin, October.

Turner Review (2009), The Turner Review: A Regulatory Response to the Global Banking Crisis, by Lord Turner, Chairman, Financial Services Authority, UK.

United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, 2009, “Trade and Development Report, 2009”, United Nations.