Are banks’ below-par own debt repurchases a cause for prudential concern?

Lubberink, Martien and Renders, Annelies (2016): Are banks’ below-par own debt repurchases a cause for prudential concern?

Abstract

Leading up to the implementation of Basel III, European banks repurchased below-par debt securities. Banks are subjected to a prudential filter that excludes unrealized gains on liabilities from changes in own credit standing from the calculation of capital ratios. By repurchasing securities, unrealized gains become realized and increase Core Tier 1 capital. We show that poorly capitalized banks repurchased securities and lost about e9.1bn in premiums to compensate debt holders. Banks also repurchased the most loss-absorbing securities, for which they paid the highest premiums. These premiums increase with leverage and in times of stress. Hence debt repurchases are a cause for prudential concern.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Banking, repurchases, subordinated debt.
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E58 - Central Banks and Their Policies; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G21 - Banks ; Depository Institutions ; Micro Finance Institutions ; Mortgages; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G28 - Government Policy and Regulation; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G32 - Financing Policy ; Financial Risk and Risk Management ; Capital and Ownership Structure ; Value of Firms ; Goodwill; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G35 - Payout Policy; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M41 - Accounting

References

Admati, A. R.; P. M. DeMarzo; M. F. Hellwig; and P. C. Pfleiderer. “Debt Overhang and Capital Regulation.” SSRN eLibrary, (2012), 1–42.

Admati, A. R.; P. M. DeMarzo; M. F. Hellwig; and P. C. Pfleiderer. “Fallacies, Irrelevant Facts, and Myths in the Discussion of Capital Regulation: Why Bank Equity is not Expensive.” SSRN eLibrary, (2013), 1–72.

Admati, A. R.; P. M. DeMarzo; M. F. Hellwig; and P. C. Pfleiderer. “The Leverage Ratchet Effect.” SSRN eLibrary, (2015), 1–58.

Alloway, T. “Own credit conundrum at the IASB.” Financial Times. June 23, 2009.

Barth, M. E.; L. D. Hodder; and S. R. Stubben. “Fair Value Accounting for Liabilities and Own Credit Risk.” The Accounting Review, 83, (2008), 629–664.

BCBS. International convergence of capital measurement and capital standards. Basel: Bank for International Settlements (1988). www.bis.org/publ/bcbs04a.pdf.

BCBS. Instruments eligible for inclusion in Tier 1 capital. Basel: Bank for International Settlements (1998). BIS Press Release 27th October 1998, www.bis.org/press/p981027.htm.

BCBS. International convergence of capital measurement and capital standards: a revised framework, comprehensive version. Basel: Bank for International Settlements (2006a). www.bis.org/publ/bcbs128. pdf.

BCBS. Supervisory guidance on the use of the fair value option for financial instruments by banks. Basel:

Bank for International Settlements (2006b). www.bis.org/publ/bcbs127.pdf.

BCBS. Strengthening the resilience of the banking sector. Basel: Bank for International Settlements (2009). www.bis.org/publ/bcbs164.pdf.

BCBS. Basel III: a global regulatory framework for more resilient banks and banking systems. Basel: Bank for International Settlements (2010). www.bis.org/publ/bcbs189.htm.

BCBS. Final elements of the reforms to raise the quality of regulatory capital issued by the Basel Committee.

Basel: Bank for International Settlements (2011). www.bis.org/press/p110113.htm.

BCBS. The interplay of accounting and regulation and its impact on bank behaviour: Literature review. Basel: Bank for International Settlements (2015). http://www.bis.org/bcbs/publ/wp28.htm.

Beatty, A. and S. Liao. “Financial accounting in the banking industry: A review of the empirical literature.” Journal of Accounting and Economics, 58, (2014), 339–383.

Beltratti, A. and R. Stulz. “The credit crisis around the globe: Why did some banks perform better?” Journal of Financial Economics, 105, (2012), 1–17.

Benninga, S. Z. Financial Modeling. Boston: MIT Press, 4th edition (2014).

Berger, A. N. and C. H. Bouwman. “How does capital affect bank performance during financial crises?” Journal of Financial Economics, 109, (2013), 146–176.

Bischof, J.; U. Bruggemann; and H. Daske. “Fair Value Reclassifications of Financial Assets During the¨ Financial Crisis.” SSRN eLibrary, (2014), 1–65.

Black, F. and M. Scholes. “The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities.” Journal of Political Economy, 81, (1973), 637–654.

Bulow, J. and K. Rogoff. “The Buyback Boondoggle.” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 2, (1988), 675–698.

Bulow, J. and K. Rogoff. “Sovereign Debt: Is to Forgive to Forget?” American Economic Review, 79, (1989), 43–50.

Bulow, J. and K. Rogoff. “Cleaning Up Third World Debt without Getting Taken to the Cleaners.” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 4, (1990), 31–42.

CEBS. CEBS Guidelines on Prudential Filters for Regulatory Capital. London: European Banking Authority (2004).

CEBS. Implementation Guidelines regarding Instruments referred to in Article 57(a) of Directive 2006/48/EC recast. London: European Banking Authority (2010).

Chassany, A.-S.; K. Crowley; and C. Penty. “EU Banks Selling ‘Crown Jewels’ Risks Undermining Growth.” Bloomberg. December 13, 2011.

Chatterjee, S.; U. S. Dhillon; and G. G. Ramırez. “Coercive tender and exchange offers in distressed high yield debt restructurings An empirical analysis.” Journal of Financial Economics, 38, (1995), 333–360.

Couch, R. B.; N. Thibodeau; and W. Wu. “Are Fair Value Options Created Equal? A Study of SFAS 159 and Earnings Volatility.” SSRN eLibrary, (2014), 1–74.

Credit Agricole. “Cr´ edit Agricole S.A. Announces the Successful Outcome of its Offer to Repurchase up´ to £750 million of its Outstanding Upper Tier 2 Notes.” (2011a). www.info-financiere.fr/upload/CNS/ 2009/04/FCCNS018292 20090408.pdf.

Credit Agricole. “Cr´ edit Agricole to seek to repurchase up to 750 million of its £1,050 million outstanding´ Upper Tier 2 Notes.” (2011b). www.credit-agricole.com/en/content/download/5103/35439/version/2/ file/Comm UT 2 EN 0309.pdf.

De Jong, A.; P. Roosenboom; and W. Schramade. “Who benefits from bond tender offers in Europe?” Journal of Multinational Financial Management, 19, (2009), 355–369.

Dunkley, E. “High court rules against Lloyds in investor challenge over bonds.” Financial Times. June 4, 2015.

Dunkley, E. “Investors hit as Lloyds wins appeal to call in bonds.” Financial Times. December 10, 2015.

EBA. EU Capital exercise. London: European Banking Authority (2011a).

EBA. European Banking Authority - EU Capital exercise 2011 - Press release. London: European Banking Authority (2011b).

EBA. EU Capital exercise final results. London: European Banking Authority (2012).

EBA. The EBA publishes a Recommendation on the preservation of capital. London: European Banking Authority (2013).

EC. Regulation (EC) No 1606/2002 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 July 2002 on the application of international accounting standards. Brussels: European Commission (2002).

EC. EU Accounting Regulatory Committee supports Commission proposal to endorse IAS 39 Fair Value Option. Brussels: European Commission (2005). European Commission Press Release IP/05/884, Brussels, 8th July 2005; http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release IP-05--884 en.htm.

EC. “Directive 2006/48/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 June 2006 relating to the taking up and pursuit of the business of credit institutions (recast).” Official Journal of the European Union.

EC. Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 on prudential requirements for credit institutions and investment firms and amending Regulation (EU) No 648/2012. Brussels: European Commission (2013a).

EC. Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 on prudential requirements for credit institutions and investment firms and amending Regulation (EU) No 648/2012. Brussels: European Commission (2013b).

EC. Directive 2014/59/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 May 2014 establishing a framework for the recovery and resolution of credit institutions and investment firms and amending Council Directive 82/891/EEC, and Directives 2001/24/EC, 2002/47/EC, 2004/25/EC, 2005/56/EC, 2007/36/EC, 2011/35/EU, 2012/30/EU and 2013/36/EU, and Regulations (EU) No 1093/2010 and (EU) No 648/2012, of the European Parliament and of the Council. Brussels: European Commission (2014).

ECB. Fair Value Accounting in the Banking Sector. Frankfurt: European Central Bank (2001).

ECB. Note on the comprehensive assessment, October 2013. Frankfurt: European Central Bank (2013).

ECB. Aggregate report on the comprehensive assessment, October 2014. Frankfurt: European Central Bank (2014).

FASB. Extinguishment of Debt. Norwalk, CT: Financial Accounting Standards Board (1983). FASB Statement No. 76.

FASB. The Fair Value Option for Financial Assets and Financial Liabilities, Including an Amendment of FASB Statement No. 115. Norwalk, CT: Financial Accounting Standards Board (2007). FASB Summary of Statement No. 159.

FFIEC. Quarterly Call Report Supplemental Instructions. Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council (2007). www.ffiec.gov/pdf/ffiec forms/ffiec031 041 suppinst 200712.pdf.

G20. Global Plan for Recovery and Reform. G20 Information Centre, London (2009). www.g20.utoronto. ca/2009/2009communique0402.html#supervision.

GHOS. G20 Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors Communique´. G20 Information Centre (2009). www.g20.utoronto.ca/2009/2009communique0314.html.

Glover, J. “Rabobank Pays to Sell First Basel III-Compliant Tier 1 Debt.” Bloomberg. November 3, 2011.

Glover, J. “Barclays Contingent Capital Securities Risk Shareholder Conflict.” Bloomberg. November 12, 2012.

Guthrie, K.; J. H. Irving; and J. Sokolowsky. “Accounting Choice and the Fair Value Option.” SSRN eLibrary, (2011), 1–42.

Hand, J. R.; P. J. Hughes; and S. E. Sefcik. “Insubstance Defeasances: Security Price Reactions and Motivations.” Journal of Accounting and Economics, 13, (1990), 47–89.

Henry, E. “Early Adoption of SFAS 159: Lessons from Games (almost) Played.” SSRN eLibrary, (2008), 1–32.

Ioannidou, V. P. “Does monetary policy affect the central bank’s role in bank supervision?” Journal of Financial Intermediation, 14, (2005), 58–85.

Johnson, J. M.; R. A. Pari; and L. Rosenthal. “The Impact of In-Substance Defeasance on Bondholder and Shareholder Wealth.” The Journal of Finance, 44, (1989), 1049–1057.

Jonghe, O. D. and O.¨ Oztekin. “Bank capital management: International evidence.”¨ Journal of Financial Intermediation, 24, (2015), 154–177.

Kothari, S. P. and J. B. Warner. “Econometrics of Event Studies.” In Handbook of Empirical Corporate Finance, B. Espen Eckbo, ed., Handbooks in Finance. San Diego: Elsevier (2007), 3–36.

Kruse, T.; T. Nohel; and S. K. Todd. “The Decision to Repurchase Debt.” Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 26, (2014), 85–93.

Lintner, J. “Distribution of Incomes of Corporations Among Dividends, Retained Earnings, and Taxes.” American Economic Review, 46, (1956), 97–113.

Liu, C.-C.; Y.-L. Chang; and S. G. Ryan. “Why Banks Elected SFAS No. 159’s Fair Value Option: Opportunism versus Compliance with the Standard’s Intent.” SSRN eLibrary, (2011), 1–46.

Mann, S. V. and E. A. Powers. “Determinants of bond tender premiums and the percentage tendered.” Journal of Banking & Finance, 31, (2007), 547–566.

Marinova, K. and S. van Veldhuizen. “Bank recapitalization.” CPB Background Document, (2014), 1–36. 11–07–2014.

Mehran, H. and A. Thakor. “Bank Capital and Value in the Cross-Section.” Review of Financial Studies, 24, (2011), 1019–1067.

Merler, S. “Deferred tax credits may soon become deferred troubles for some European banks - what are deferred tax assets, and why are they important?” Bruegel.

http://www.bruegel.org/nc/blog/detail/article/1606-deferred-tax-credits-may-soon-become-deferredtroubles-for-some-european-banks/.

Merton, R. C. “On the Pricing of Corporate Debt: The Risk Structure of Interest Rates.” The Journal of Finance, 29, (1974), 449–470.

Mesonnier, J.-S. and A. Monks. “Did the EBA Capital Exercise Cause a Credit Crunch in the Euro Area?”´ SSRN eLibrary.

Miller, M. H. “Do the M&M propositions apply to banks?” Journal of Banking & Finance, 19, (1995), 483–489.

Myers, S. C. “Determinants of corporate borrowing.” Journal of Financial Economics, 5, (1977), 147–176.

OCC. Regulatory Capital Rules: Regulatory Capital, Implementation of Basel III, Capital Adequacy, Transition Provisions, Prompt Corrective Action, Standardized Approach for Risk - weighted Assets, Market Discipline and Disclosure Requirements, Advanced Approaches Risk - Based Capital Rule, and Market Risk Capital Rule. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Department Of The Treasury, Washington (2013). www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2013-10-11/pdf/2013-21653.pdf.

Opschoor, A.; D. J. C. van Dijk; and M. van der Wel. “Predicting Volatility and Correlations with Financial Conditions Indexes .” SSRN eLibrary, (2014), 1–26.

Petersen, M. A. “Estimating Standard Errors in Finance Panel Data Sets: Comparing Approaches.” Review of Financial Studies, 22, (2009), 435–480.

Pignal, S. and P. Jenkins. “Dexia poses setback for EBA stress tests.” Financial Times. October 5, 2011.

Roengpitya, R.; N. Tarashev; and K. Tsatsaronis. “Bank business models.” BIS Quarterly Review, December 2014, (2014), 55–65.

Schwert, G. W. “Stock Volatility during the Recent Financial Crisis.” European Financial Management, 17, (2011), 789–805.

Sebag, G. and J. Brunsden. “Bank Tax Credits Face Scrutiny From EU State-Aid Watchdog.” Bloomberg. April 8, 2015.

Shotter, J.; P. Jenkins; and G. Jackson. “Deutsche Bank considers multibillion bond buyback.” Financial Times. February 9, 2016.

Song, C. J. “An Evaluation of FAS 159 Fair Value Option: Evidence from the Banking Industry.” SSRN eLibrary, (2008), 1–35.

Wingler, T. R. and G. D. Jud. “Premium Debt Tenders: Analysis and Evidence.” Financial Management, 19, (1990), 58–67.