Measuring the inadequacy of IRR in PFI schemes using profitability index and AIRR

Cuthbert, James R. and Magni, Carlo Alberto (2016): Measuring the inadequacy of IRR in PFI schemes using profitability index and AIRR. Published in: International Journal of Production Economics No. 179 (2016): pp. 130-140.

Abstract

The internal rate of return (IRR) is widely used in Private Finance Initiative (PFI) schemes in the UK for measuring performance. However, it is well-known that the IRR may be a misleading indicator of economic profitability. Treasury Guidance (2004) recognises that the the IRR should not be used and net present value (NPV) should be calculated instead, unless the cash flow pattern is even. The distortion generated by the IRR can be quantified by the notion of scheduling effect, introduced in Cuthbert and Cuthbert (2012). We combine this notion with the notion of average IRR (AIRR), introduced in Magni (2010, 2013) and show that a positive scheduling effect arises if the AIRR, relative to a flat payment stream, exceeds the project’s IRR. The scheduling component can be measured in two separate ways, in terms of specific AIRRs, one of which enables the scheduling component to be decomposed into relative capital and relative rate components. We also highlight the role of average capital, whose quotation in the market, in association with IRRs or AIRRs, would deepen the economic analysis of the project.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: PFI, AIRR, profitability index, scheduling effect, internal rate of return.
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G0 - General > G00 - General; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G11 - Portfolio Choice ; Investment Decisions; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G12 - Asset Pricing ; Trading Volume ; Bond Interest Rates; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G31 - Capital Budgeting ; Fixed Investment and Inventory Studies ; Capacity; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M2 - Business Economics; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M40 - General

References

Biondi, Y. 2006. The double emergence of the modified internal rate of return: The neglected financial work of Duvillard (1755–1832) in a comparative perspective. The European Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 13(3), 311–335.

Brealey, R. A., Myers, S., Allen, F. 2011. Principles of corporate finance (Global Ed.). Singapore: McGraw-Hill Irwin.

Cuthbert, J.R., Cuthbert, M. 2012. Why IRR is an inadequate indicator of costs and returns in relation to PFI schemes. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 23(6) (September), 420‒433.

Graham, J.R., Harvey, C.H. 2001. The theory and practice of corporate finance: evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 60, 187‒243.

Gronchi, S. 1986. On investment criteria based on the internal rate of return. Oxford Economic Papers, 38(1) (March), 174‒180.

Kierulff, H. 2008. MIRR: A better measure. Business Horizons, 51, 321–329.

Lefley, F. 1996. The payback method of investment appraisal: A review and synthesis. International Journal of Production Economics, 44(3) (July), 207‒224].

Lefley, F. 2015. The FAP Model and its application in the appraisal of ICT projects. London: Palgrave Macmillan. Lin, S.A.Y. 1976, The modified internal rate of return and investment criterion, The Engineering Economist, 21 (4), Summer, 237‒247.

Lindblom, T., Sjӧgren, S. 2009. Increasing goal congruence in project evaluation by introducing a strict market depreciation schedule. International Journal of Production Economics, 121, 519‒532.

Magni, C.A. 2009. Splitting up value: A critical review of residual income theories. European Journal of Operational Research, 198(1) (October), 1–22.

Magni, C.A. 2010. Average Internal Rate of Return and Investment Decisions: A new perspective. The Engineering Economist, 55(2), 150‒181.

Magni, C.A. 2013. The Internal-Rate-of-Return approach and the AIRR paradigm: A refutation and a corroboration. The Engineering Economist, 58(2), 73‒111.

Magni, C.A. 2015. Aggregate Return On Investment for Investments under Uncertainty. International Journal of Production Economics, 165 (July), 29–37.

Pasqual, J., Padilla, E., Jadotte, E. 2013. Technical note: Equivalence of different profitability criteria with the net present value. International Journal of Production Economics, 142, 205‒210.

Peasnell, K.V. 1982. Some formal connections between economic values and yields and accounting numbers. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 9(3), 361–381.

Percoco, M., Borgonovo, E., 2012. A note on the sensitivity analysis of the internal rate of return. International Journal of Production Economics, 135, 526–529.

Remer, D.S., Nieto, A.P., 1995a. A compendium and comparison of 25 project evaluation techniques. Part 1: Net present value and rate of return methods. International Journal of Production Economics, 42, 79–96.

Remer, D.S., Nieto, A.P., 1995b. A compendium and comparison of 25 project evaluation techniques. Part 2: Ratio, payback, and accounting methods. International Journal of Production Economics, 42, 101–129.

Remer, D.S., Stokdyk, S.B., Van Driel, M., 1993. Survey of project evaluation techniques currently used in industry. International Journal of Production Economics, 32, 103–115.

Ross, S.A., Westerfield, R.W., and Jordan, B.D. 2011. Essentials of corporate finance (7th ed.). NewYork: McGraw-Hill/Irwin.

Rubinstein, M.E. 2003. Great moments in financial economics: I. Present value. Journal of Investment Management. 1(1) (First Quarter), 45–54.

Slagmulder, R., Bruggeman, W., van Wassenhove , L., 1995. An empirical study of capital budgeting practices for strategic investments in CIM technologies. International Journal of Production Economics, 2-3 (August), 121–152.

Soper, C.S. 1959. The Marginal Efficiency of Capital: A Further Note. The Economic Journal, 69(273), 174‒177.

Treasury, H. M. 2004. Guidance Note: The use of internal rates of return in PFI projects.