Flipping in the Housing Market

Leung, Charles Ka Yui and Tse, Chung-Yi (2017): Flipping in the Housing Market.

Abstract

We add arbitraging middlemen -- investors who attempt to profit from buying low and selling high -- to a canonical housing market search model. Flipping tends to take place in sluggish and tight, but not in moderate, markets. To follow is the possibility of multiple equilibria. In one equilibrium, most, if not all, transactions are intermediated, resulting in rapid turnover, a high vacancy rate, and high housing prices. In another equilibrium, few houses are bought and sold by middlemen. Turnover is slow, few houses are vacant, and prices are moderate. Moreover, flippers can enter and exit en masse in response to the smallest interest rate shock. The housing market can then be intrinsically unstable even when all flippers are akin to the arbitraging middlemen in classical finance theory. In speeding up turnover, the flipping that takes place in a sluggish and illiquid market tends to be socially beneficial. The flipping that takes place in a tight and liquid market can be wasteful as the efficiency gain from any faster turnover is unlikely to be large enough to offset the loss from more houses being left vacant in the hands of flippers. Based on our calibrated model, which matches several stylized facts of the U.S. housing market, we show that the housing price response to interest rate change is very non-linear, suggesting cautions to policy attempt to “stabilize” the housing market through monetary policy.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Search and matching, housing market, liquidity, flippers and speculators, financing and bargaining advantage.
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D83 - Search ; Learning ; Information and Knowledge ; Communication ; Belief ; Unawareness; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G12 - Asset Pricing ; Trading Volume ; Bond Interest Rates; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R3 - Real Estate Markets, Spatial Production Analysis, and Firm Location > R30 - General

References

Albrecht, James, Axel Anderson, Eric Smith, and Susan Vroman, 2007, "Opportunistic Matching in the Housing Market," International Economic Review 42, 641-664.

Amormin, Gene, Jennifer Huang, Clemens Sialm, and Edward Zhong, 2012, "Complex Mortgages," memo.

Anenberg, Elliot and Patrick Bayer, 2013, "Endogenous Sources of Volatility in Housing Markets: The Joint Buyer-Seller Problem," NBER working paper 18980.

Anglin, Paul and Yanmin Gao, 2011, "Integrating Illiquid Assets into the Portfolio Decision Process," Real Estate Economics 39, 277-311.

Arnott, Richard, 1989, "Housing Vacancies, Thin Markets and Idiosyncratic Tastes," Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 2, 5-30.

Bayer, Patrick, Christopher Geissler, and James W. Roberts, 2011, "Speculators and Middlemen: The Role of Flippers in the Housing Market," NBER working paper 16784.

Corbae, Dean and Erwan Quintin, 2013, Leverage and the Foreclosure Crisis, University of Wisconsin-Madison, mimeo.

Diaz, Antonia and Belen Jerez, 2013, "House Prices, Sales and Time on the Market: A Search-Theortical Framework," International Economic Review 54, 837-872.

Depken, Craig A. II, Haris Hollans, and Steve Swidler, 2009, "An Empirical Analysis of Residential Property Flipping," Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 39, 248-263.

Ferreira, Fernando, Joseph Gyourko and Joseph Tracy, 2010, "Housing Busts and Household Mobility," Journal of Urban Economics 68, 34-45.

Foote, Christopher L., Kristopher S. Gerardi, and Paul S. Willen, 2012, "Why Did So Many People Make So Many Ex Post Bad Decisions? The Causes of the Foreclosure Crisis," Federal Reserve Bank of Altanta Working Paper 2012-7.

Gavazza, Alessandro, 2012, "An Empirical Model of a Decentralized Asset Market," memo.

Genesove, David and Lu Han, 2012, "Search and Matching in the Housing Market," Journal of Urban Economics 72, 31-45.

Genesove, David and Christopher J. Mayer, 1997, "Equity and Time to Sale in the Real Estate Market," American Economic Review 87, 255-269.

Haughwout, Andrew, Donghoon Lee, Joseph Tracy, and Wilbert van der Klaauw, 2011, "Real Estate Investors, the Leverage Cycle, and the Housing Market Crisis," Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Staff Reports no. 514.

Head, Allen and Huw Lloyd-Ellis, 2012, "Housing Liquidity, Mobility and the Labour Market," Review of Economic Studies 79, 1559-1589.

Head, Allen, Huw Lloyd-Ellis, and Hongfei Sun, 2014, "Search, Liquidity, and the Dynamics of House Prices," American Economic Review 104, 1172-1210.

Herbert, Christopher E., Irene Lew, and Rocio Sanchez-Moyano, 2013, "The Role of Investors in Acquiring Foreclosed Properties in Low- and Moderate-Income Neighborhoods: A Review of Findings from Four Case Studies," WhatWorks Collaborative Report.

Hort, Katinka, 2000, "Prices and Turnover in the Market for Owner-Occupied Homes," Regional Science and Urban Economics 30, 99-119.

Hosios, Arthur, 1990, "On the Efficiency of Matching and Related Models of Search and Unemployment," Review of Economic Studies 57, 279-298.

Johri, Alok and John Leach, 2002, "Middlemen and the Allocation of Heterogeneous Goods," International Economic Review 43, 347-361.

Kashiwagi, M., 2014, "Sunspots and Self-Fulfilling Beliefs in the U.S. Housing Market," Review of Economic Dynamics, forthcoming.

Krainer, John, 2001, "A Theory of Liquidity in Residential Real Estate Markets," Journal of Urban Economics 49, 32-53.

Kwok, Hon Ho and Chung-Yi Tse, 2006, "Estimating the Liquidity Premium in the Housing Market," mimeo.

Lagos, Ricardo, Guillaume Rocheteau, and Pierre-Olivier Weill, 2011, "Crises and Liquidity in Over-The-Counter Markets," Journal of Economic Theory 146, 2169-2205.

Leung, Charles K. Y.; Dandan Feng, 2005, "What Drives the Property Price-Trading Volume Correlation: Evidence from a Commercial Real Estate Market," Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 31(2), 241-255.

Leung, Charles K.Y., Garion C.K. Lau, and Youngman C.F. Leong, 2003, "Testing Alternative Theories of the Property Price-Trading Volume Correlation," Journal of Real Estate Research 23, 253-265.

Leung, Charles K.Y., Youngman C. F. Leong, and Ida Y. S. Chan, 2002, "TOM: Why Isn't Price Enough?" International Real Estate Review 5, 91-115.

Leung, Charles K. Y.; Youngman C. F. Leong and Kelvin S. K. Wong, 2006, "Housing Price Dispersion: an Empirical Investigation," Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 32(3), 357-385.

Leung, Charles K. Y. and Chung-Yi Tse, 2016a, "Flipping in the Housing Market -- Extensions and Robustness," memo.

Leung, Charles K. Y. and Chung-Yi Tse, 2016b, "Flipping in the Housing Market -- The Dynamics," memo.

Leung, Charles K. Y. and Jun Zhang, 2011, "Fire Sales in Housing Market: Is the House-Search Process similar to a Theme Park visit?," International Real Estate Review, 14, 311-329.

Li, Yiting, 1998, "Middlemen and Private Information," Journal of Monetary Economics 42, 131-159.

Masters, Adrian, 2007, "Middlemen in Search Equilibrium," International Economic Review 48, 343-362.

Merlo, Antonio and Francois Ortalo-Magne, 2004, "Bargaining over Residential Real Estate: Evidence from England," Journal of Urban Economics 56, 192-216.

Moen, Espen R. and Plamen T. Nenov, 2014, "Buying First or Selling First? Buyer-Seller Decisions and Housing Market Volatility," memo.

Mortensen, Dale T. and Randall Wright, 2002, "Competitive Pricing and Efficiency in Search Equilibrium," International Economic Review 43, 1-20.

Ngai, L. Rachel and Silvana Tenreyro, 2014, "Hot and Cold Seasons in the Housing Market", American Economic Review 104, 3991-4026.

Rubinstein, Ariel and Asher Wolinsky, 1987, "Middlemen," Quarterly Journal of Economics 102, 581-593.

Shevchenko, Andrei, 2004, "Middlemen," International Economic Review 45, 1-24.

Smith, Eric, 2004, "Intermediated Search," Economica 71, 619-636.

Stein, Jeremy, 1995, "Prices and Trading Volume in the Housing Market: A Model with Down-Payment Effects," Quarterly Journal of Economics 110, 379-406.

Tse, Chung-Yi, 2011, "The Spatial Origin of Commerce," International Economic Review 52, 349-377.

Watanabe, Makoto, 2010, "A Model of Merchants," Journal of Economic Theory 145, 1865-1889.

Wheaton, William C., 1990, "Vacancy, Search, and Prices in a Housing Market Matching Model," Journal of Political Economy 98, 1270-1292.

Wright, Randall and Yuet-Yee Wong, 2014, "Buyers, Sellers, and Middlemen: Variations on Search-Theoretic Themes," International Economic Review 55, 375-391.

Yavas, Abdullah, 1992a, "Marketmakers versus Matchmakers," Journal of Financial Intermediation 2, 33-58.

Yavas, Abdullah, 1992b, "A Simple Search and Bargaining Model of Real Estate Markets," American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association Journal (now Real Estate Economics) 20, 533-548.