Public Private Partnerships: The Swiss Specificity

Athias, Laure and Macina, Moudo and Wicht, Pascal (2017): Public Private Partnerships: The Swiss Specificity.

Abstract

While most countries have adopted public private partnerships, the prevalence of such arrangements differs widely across countries and the differences have been persistent. In particular, while around 722 PPP projects have been launched in the United Kingdom between 1994 and 2016, Switzerland has experienced only 2 of such arrangements over the same period of time, and exhibits one of the lowest number of PPPs within European countries. What could explain this low number of PPPs in Switzerland? Is it a good or a bad thing? What is the right number of PPPs? The goal of this chapter is to answer these questions. To this aim, we first define precisely what PPPs are, and what they are not (Section 1). We then develop the theoretical framework that points out the conditions under which PPP arrangements are optimal, or relatively more optimal than the other possible modes of provision (Section 2). This normative analysis highlights that the choice to resort to PPPs should be driven by the characteristics of the public service considered. As we expect public services to be quite similar across countries of similar level of economic development, we can infer that only cultural and institutional differences that could help explain the differences in actually implemented PPPs. We then consider the bad reasons to resort and not to resort to PPPs that might differ across countries and we point out that, while there are probably too few PPPs in Switzerland, there are clearly too many of them in some other countries (Section 3). Finally, we conclude with some policy recommendations.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Public private partnerships, Transaction costs, Switzerland, Culture, Institutions
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D23 - Organizational Behavior ; Transaction Costs ; Property Rights; H - Public Economics > H1 - Structure and Scope of Government > H11 - Structure, Scope, and Performance of Government; H - Public Economics > H4 - Publicly Provided Goods > H44 - Publicly Provided Goods: Mixed Markets

References

Afonso, António, Ludger Schuknecht, and Vito Tanzi, “Public Sector Efficiency, an International Comparison”, Public Choice, 123, pp. 321-347, 2005.

Athias, Laure, "Local Public-Services Provision under Public Private Partnerships: Contractual Design and Contracting Parties Incentives", Local Government Studies, 39(3), 312-331, 2013a.

Athias, Laure, “La contractualisation de service public : une analyse économique" in Ladner, Andreas, Jean-Loup Chappelet, Yves Emery, Peter Knoepfel, Luzuis Mader, Nils Soguel, Frédéric Varone (eds.), Manuel d'administration publique suisse, Lausanne: Presses Polytechniques et Universitaires Romandes, 2013b.

Athias, Laure and Lisa Chever, “The Relative Efficiency of Competitive Tendering”, in Saussier and De Brux (eds.), The Economics of Public-Private Partnerships: Theoretical and Empirical Developments, Springer, pp. 113-133, 2018.

Athias, Laure, Julie Le Gallo and Thierry Madiès, “Do More Fiscal Accountable Governments Resort More to Public Private Partnerships?”, Working paper, 2018.

Athias, Laure, and Antonio Nuñez, “Winner’s curse in toll road concessions”, Economics Letters, 101(3), pp. 172-174, 2008.

Athias, Laure, and Antonio Nuñez, “Effects of Uncertainty and Opportunistic Renegotiations on Bidding Behaviour: Evidence from Toll Road Concessions”, in A.Picot, M.Florio, N.Grove and L.Kranz (eds) The Economics of Infrastructure Provisioning: The Changing Role of the State, MIT Press, pp. 285-314, 2015.

Athias, Laure, and Stéphane Saussier, “Are Public Private Partnerships that Rigid? And Why? Evidence from Price Provisions in French Toll Road Concession Contracts”, Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, forthcoming, 2018.

Athias, Laure, and Pascal Wicht, “Institutional Environment and Organizational Choices: the Impact of State-level Norms within Switzerland on the Prevalence of For-Profit Nursing Homes”, Working paper, 2018a.

Athias, Laure, and Pascal Wicht, “Using Differences in the Salience of Public Sector's Mission-Orientation across Neighbor Cultures to Uncover its Impacts on Public Service Delivery Productivity”, Working paper, 2018b.

Besley, Timothy, and Maitreesh Ghatak, “Competition and incentives with motivated agents”, The American Economic Review, 95(3), pp. 616-636, 2005.

Brahier, Jean-Michel, “Partenariat public-privé et concession de travaux – Proposition de systématisation et réflexions sur la soumission au droit des marchés publics des partenariats publics-privés et des concessions de travaux" in Journées suisses du droit de la construction, 2017.

Coase, Ronald H., “The nature of the firm”, Economica, 4(16), pp. 386-405, 1937.

Ellman, Matthew, “Does Privatising Public Service Provision Reduce Accountability?”, Universitat Pompeu Fabra Economics Working Paper 997, 2006.

Geser, Hans, Urs Meuli, Kathia Horber-Papazian, Andreas Ladner, and Reto Steiner, “Les membres des exécutifs dans les communes suisses”, Glarus/Chur: Éditions Rüegger, 2012.

Gregg, Paul, Paul A. Grout, Anita Ratcliffe, Sarah Smith, and Frank Windmeijer, “How important is pro-social behaviour in the delivery of public services?”, Journal of public economics, 95(7), pp. 758-766, 2011.

Hart, Oliver, Andrei Shleifer, and Robert W. Vishny, "The Proper Scope of Government: Theory and an Application to Prisons", The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112(4), pp. 1127-1161, 1997.

HM Treasury, “PFI: Meeting the Investment Challenge”, HM Treasury, London, 2003.

Ladner, Andreas, “Die Schweizer Gemeinden im Wandel: Politische Institutionen und lokale Politik”, Cahiers de l’IDHEAP, 237, Lausanne, 2011.

Maskin, Eric and Jean Tirole, “Public-private partnerships and government spending limits”, International Journal of Industrial Organization, 26, pp. 412-420, 2008.

Meinhardt, Marcel, Fadri Lenggenhager and Oliver Labhart, “Switzerland“, in Pickworth, Jonathan, and Deborah Williams (eds), Bribery & Corruption, 2nd edition, Global Legal Group Ltd, 2014.

NAO, “Private Finance Projects”, Technical report, National Audit Office, London, 2009.

Neue Zürcher Zeitung, “Wenn Private den Staat zu mittelfristigem Denken zwingen”, pp. 13, September 9th, 2013.

The Economist, “Singing the blues: Recession is heaping problems on a controversial form of public investment”, July 2nd, 2009.

Williamson Oliver E., “Markets and Hierarchies : Analysis and Antitrust Implications”, Free Press, 1975

Williamson Oliver E., “The Economic Institutions of Capitalism”, Free Press, 1985.