School-Based Mentoring Programs: Using Volunteers to Improve the Academic Outcomes of Underserved Students

Bayer, Amanda and Grossman, Jean and DuBois, David (2013): School-Based Mentoring Programs: Using Volunteers to Improve the Academic Outcomes of Underserved Students. Published in: MDRC Working Paper

Abstract

Previous research suggests that school-based mentoring programs, such as those offered by Big Brothers Big Sisters of America (BBBSA), yield statistically significant, but generally small improvements in the academic performance and scholastic efficacy beliefs of mentored students. The present study uses randomized control trial data, involving over 1000 students from 71 schools across the country, to investigate further the academic benefits of school-based mentoring and to enrich understanding of how schools can use volunteers to support students. We employ instrumental variables and other approaches to provide insight into why the BBBSA school-based mentoring program is effective, finding that the relationship between mentor and youth appears to play a key role. The evidence suggests that developing a close relationship with a mentor led to better academic outcomes for youth; by contrast, youth who were mentored but did not experience a close relationship showed no improvement in academic outcomes relative to the control group. This pattern is evident in mentoring matches of various lengths. In addition, there is no evidence that mentoring programs with an academic focus produced better youth academic outcomes than did relationship-only programs. Findings do reveal, however, that programs structured with weekly meetings and with opportunities for pairs to interact outside of a large-group setting were more likely to generate close mentor-youth relationships. Beyond reporting new empirical findings, this paper contributes a theoretical structure with which to understand the results of randomized evaluations of mentoring programs.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: School-based mentoring, Academic, Volunteers
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I20 - General; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I24 - Education and Inequality; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J13 - Fertility ; Family Planning ; Child Care ; Children ; Youth

References

Angrist, J. D. (1991). Grouped-data estimation and testing in simple labor-supply models. Journal of Econometrics, 47, 243-66.

Angrist, J. D., Imbens, G. W., & Rubin, D. B. (1996). Identification of causal effects using instrumental variables. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 91, 444-455.

Benjamini, Y., & Hochberg, Y. (1995). Controlling for the false discovery rate: A practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 57, 289-300.

Bernstein, L., Dun Rappaport, C., Olsho, L., Hunt, D., & Levin, M. (2009). Impact evaluation of the U.S. Department of Education’s Student Mentoring Program (NCEE 2009-4047). Washington, DC: National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education.

Bloom, H. (1984). Accounting for no-shows in experimental evaluation designs. Evaluation Review, 8, 225-246.

Cavell, T. A., & Elledge, L.C. (2014). Mentoring and prevention science. In D.L. DuBois & M.J. Karcher (Eds.), Handbook of youth mentoring (2nd ed., pp. 29-42). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

DuBois, D. L., & Karcher, M. J. (Eds.). (2014). Handbook of youth mentoring (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

DuBois, D. L., & Neville, H. A. (1997). Youth mentoring: Investigation of relationship characteristics and perceived benefits. Journal of Community Psychology, 25, 227-234.

DuBois, D. L., Portillo, N., Rhodes, J. E., Silverthorn, N., & Valentine, J. C. (2011). How effective are mentoring programs for youth? A systematic assessment of the evidence. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 12, 57–91.

Ferguson, R. F., & Snipes, J. (1994). Outcomes of mentoring: Healthy identities for youth. Reclaiming Children and Youth, 3, 19-22.

Grossman, J. B., Chan, C. S., Schwartz, S. E., & Rhodes, J. E. (2012). The test of time in school-based mentoring: The role of relationship duration and re-matching on academic outcomes. American Journal of Community Psychology, 49, 43-54.

Grossman, J. B., & Rhodes, J. E. (2002). The test of time: Predictors and effects of duration in youth mentoring relationships. American Journal of Community Psychology, 30, 199-219.

Harter, S. (1985). Manual for the Self Perception Profile for Children. Denver, CO: University of Denver.

Harter, S. (1990). Identity and self development. In S. Feldman 
and G. Elliott (Eds.), At the Threshold: The Developing Adolescent. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Hausman, J. A. (1978). Specification tests in econometrics. Econometrica, 46, 1251-1271.

Herrera, C. (2004). School-based mentoring: A closer look. Philadelphia, PA: Public/Private Ventures.

Herrera, C., DuBois, D. L., & Grossman, J. B. (2013). The role of risk: Mentoring experiences and outcomes for youth with varying risk profiles. New York, NY: Public/Private Ventures and MDRC.

Herrera, C., Grossman, J. B., Kauh, T. J., Feldman, A. F., & McMaken, J. (2007). Making a difference in schools: The Big Brothers Big Sisters school-based mentoring impact study. Philadelphia, PA: Public/Private Ventures.

Herrera, C., Grossman, J. B., Kauh, T. J., & McMaken, J. (2011). Mentoring in schools: An impact study of Big Brothers Big Sisters school-based mentoring. Child Development, 82, 346-361.

Imbens, G., & Angrist, J. (1994). Identification and estimation of local average treatment effects. Econometrica, 62, 467-75.

Institute of Education Sciences. (2011). WWC Procedures and Standards Handbook (Version 2.1). Washington, DC: Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education.

Karcher, M. J. (2003). The Hemingway: Measure of adolescent connectedness.

Krueger, A. B. (1999). Experimental estimates of education production functions. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 114, 497-532.

Lauer, P. A., Akiba, M., Wilkerson, S. B., Apthorp, H. S., Snow, D., & Martin-Glenn, M. L. (2006). Out-of-school-time programs: A meta-analysis of effects for at-risk students. Review of Educational Research, 76, 275-313.

Maldonado-Carreno, C., & Votruba-Drzal, E. (2011). Teacher-child relationships and the development of academic and behavioral skills during elementary school: A within- and between-child analysis. Child Development, 82, 601-616.

MENTOR. (2006). Mentoring in America 2005: A snapshot of the current state of mentoring.

Parra, G. R., DuBois, D. L., Neville, H. A., Pugh-Lilly, A. O., & Povinelli, N. (2002). Mentoring relationships for youth: Investigation of a process-oriented model. Journal of Community Psychology, 30, 367-388.

Pierce K. M., Bolt D. M., & Vandell D. (2010). Specific features of after-school program quality: Associations with children’s functioning in middle childhood. American Journal of Community Psychology, 45, 381–393.

Pierce, K. M., Hamm, J. V., & Vandell, D. L. (1999). Experiences in after-school programs and children’s adjustment in first-grade classrooms. Child Development, 70, 756-767.

Pryce, J., & Keller, T. E. (2012). An investigation of volunteer-student relationship trajectories within school-based youth mentoring programs. Journal of Community Psychology, 40, 228-248.

Rhodes, J. E. (2005). A model of youth mentoring. In D.L. DuBois, & M.J. Karcher (Eds.), Handbook of youth mentoring (pp. 30-43). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

Schwartz, S., Rhodes, J., Chan, C. & Herrera, C. (2011). The impact of school-based mentoring on youth with different relational profiles. Developmental Psychology, 47, 450-462.

Schwartz, S., Rhodes, J., & Herrera, C. (2012). The influence of meeting time on academic outcomes in school-based mentoring. Children and Youth Services Review, 34, 2319-2326.

Thomson, N. R., & Zand, D. H. (2010). Mentees’ perceptions of their interpersonal relationships: the role of the mentor-youth bond. Youth & Society, 41, 434-445.

Wheeler, M. E., Keller, T. E., & DuBois, D. L. (2010). Review of three recent randomized trials of school-based mentoring: Making sense of mixed findings. SRCD Social Policy Report, 24.

Zand, D., Thomson, N. R., Cervantes, R., Espiritu, R., Klagholz, D., LaBlanc, L., & Taylor, A. (2009). The mentor-youth alliance: the role of mentoring relationships in promoting youth competence. Journal of Adolescence, 32, 1-17.