Being in the Right Place: A Natural Field Experiment on the Causes of Position Effects in Individual Choice

Harris, Mark and Novarese, Marco and Wilson, Chris (2019): Being in the Right Place: A Natural Field Experiment on the Causes of Position Effects in Individual Choice.

Abstract

This paper uses a natural field experiment to better understand why individuals tend to select items at the top of lists. After randomizing the order in which new economics research papers are presented in email alerts and measuring the subsequent downloads, we provide robust evidence of position effects. Moreover, our novel user-level data offers two key findings: i) most users exhibit both top and bottom position effects, and ii) distinct groups of users consider the listed items in different orders. These results allow us to conclude that the causes of top position effects are complex and heterogeneous across individuals, but are most consistent with a version of choice fatigue where users consider the listed items in a non-monotonic order.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Position Effects; Order Effects; Choice Fatigue; Prominence; Lists
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D01 - Microeconomic Behavior: Underlying Principles; D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D83 - Search ; Learning ; Information and Knowledge ; Communication ; Belief ; Unawareness; L - Industrial Organization > L0 - General > L00 - General

References

Ansari A. and Mela C.F. (2003) "E-customization” Journal of Marketing Research vol.40 p.131-145

Armstrong M. (2017) “Ordered Consumer Search” Journal of the European Economic Association vol.15 p.989-1024

Asch S.E. (1946) “Forming Impressions of Personality” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology vol.41 p.258-290

Athey S. and Ellison G. (2011) “Position Auctions with Consumer Search” Quarterly Journal of Economics vol.126 p.1213-1270

Augenblick N. and Nicholson S. (2016) “Ballot Position, Choice Fatigue, and Voter Behavior” Review of Economics Studies vol.83 p.460-480

Baye M.R., De los Santos B. and Wildenbeest M.R. (2016a) “Search Engine Optimization: What Drives Organic Traffic to Retail Sites?” Journal of Economics and Management Strategy vol.25 p.6-31

Baye M.R., De los Santos B. and Wildenbeest M.R. (2016b) “What's in a Name? Measuring Prominence, and Its Impact on Organic Traffic from Search Engines” Information Economics and Policy vol.34 p.44-57

Biswas D., Grewal D. and Roggeveen A. (2010) “How the Order of Sampled Experiential Products Affects Choice” Journal of Marketing Research vol.47 p.508-519

Caplin A., Dean M., and Martin, D. (2011) “Search and Satisficing” American Economic Review vol.101 p.2899-2922

Coupe T., Ginsburgh V. and Noury A. (2010) “Are Leading Papers of Better Quality? Evidence from a Natural Field Experiment” Oxford Economic Papers vol.61 p.1-11

Dayan E. and Bar-Hillel M. (2011) “Nudge to Nobesity II: Menu Positions Influence Food Orders” Judgement and Decision Making vol.6 p.333-342

de Corniere A. and Taylor G. (2014) “Integration and Search Engine Bias” RAND Journal of Economics vol.45 p.576-597

De los Santos B., Hortacsu A. and Wildenbeest M.R. (2012) “Testing Models of Consumer Search Using Data on Web Browsing and Purchasing Behavior” American Economic Review vol.102 p.2955-2980

De los Santos B. and Koulayev S. (2017) “Optimizing Click-Through in Online Rankings with Endogenous Search Refinement” Marketing Science vol.36 p.542-564

Ellison G. and Wolitzky A. (2012) “A Search Cost Model of Obfuscation” RAND Journal of Economics vol.43 p.417-441

Fedyk A. (2019) “Front Page News: The Effect of News Positioning on Financial Markets”, working paper

Feenberg D., Ganguli I., Gaule P., and Gruber, J. (2017) “It's Good to be First: Order Bias in Reading and Citing NBER Working Papers” Review of Economics and Statistics vol.99 p.32-39

Fishman A. and Lubensky D. (2018) “Search Prominence and Return Costs” International Journal of Industrial Organization, vol.58 p.136-161

Greene W. (2010) “Testing Hypotheses about Interaction Effects in Nonlinear Models” Economics Letters vol.107 p.291-296

Haan M.A., Dijkstra S.G. and Dijkstra P.T. (2005) “Expert Judgement Versus Public Opinion - Evidence from the Eurovision Song Contest” Journal of Cultural Economics vol.29 p.59-78

Ho D.E. and Imai K. (2008) “Estimating Causal Effects of Ballot Order from a Randomized Natural Experiment: California Alphabet Lottery 1978-2002” Public Opinion Quarterly vol.72 p.216-240

Itzkowitz J., Itzkowitz J., and Rothbort S. (2016) “ABCs of Trading: Behavioral Biases Affect Stock Turnover and Value “Review of Finance vol.20 p.663-692

Jacobs H. and Hillert A. (2015) “Alphabetic Bias, Investor Recognition, and Trading Behavior” Review of Finance vol.20 p.693-723

Janssen M.C. and Parakhonyak A. (2014) “Consumer Search Markets with Costly Revisits” Journal of Economic Theory vol.55 p.481-514

Jeziorski P. and Segal I. (2015) “What Makes Them Click: Empirical Analysis of Consumer Demand for Search Advertising” American Economic Journal: Microeconomics vol.7 p.24-53

Koppell K. G. S. and Steen J.A. (2004) “The Effects of Ballot Position on Election Outcomes” Journal of Politics vol.66 p.267-281

McDevitt, R.C. (2014) “Business by Any Other Name: Firm Name Choice as a Signal of Firm Quality” Journal of Political Economy vol.122 p.909-944

Meredith M. and Salant Y. (2013) “On the Causes and Consequences of Ballot Order Effects” Political Behavior vol.35 p.175-197

Miller J.M. and Krosnick J.A. (1998) “The Impact of Candidate Name Order on Election Outcomes” Public Opinion Quarterly vol.62 p.291-330

Murphy J., Hofacker C. and Mizerski R. (2006) “Primacy and Recency Effects on Clicking Behavior” Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication vol.11 p.522-535

Narayanan S. and Kalyanam K. (2015) “Position Effects in Search Advertising and their Moderators: A Regression Discontinuity Approach” Marketing Science vol.34 p.388-407

Petrikaite V. (2018) “Consumer Obfuscation by a Multiproduct Firm” RAND Journal of Economics vol.49 p.206-223

Pinkowitz L. (2002) “Research Dissemination and Impact: Evidence from Website Downloads” Journal of Finance vol.57 p.485-499

Salant Y. (2011) “Procedural Analysis of Choice Rules with Applications to Bounded Rationality” American Economic Review vol.101 p.724-48

Schwarz N., Hippler H.-J. and Noelle-Neumann E. (1992) “A Cognitive Model of Response Order Effects in Survey Measurement” in “Context Effects in Social and Psychological Research” (Eds) Schwarz N. and Sudman S., New York: Springer

Simon H. A. (1955) “A Behavioral Model of Rational Choice” Quarterly Journal of Economics vol.69 p.99-118

Tan L. and Ward G. (2000) “A Recency-Based Account of Primacy Effects in Free Recall” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition vol.26 p.1589-1625

Train K.E. (2003) “Discrete Choice Methods with Simulation”, New York: Cambridge University Press

Ursu R. M. (2018) “The Power of Rankings: Quantifying the Effect of Rankings on Online Consumer Search and Purchase Decisions” Marketing Science vol. 37 p.530-552