Game of Thrones or Game of Class Struggle? Revisiting the Demise of Feudalism and the Dobb-Sweezy Debate

Lambert, Thomas (2019): Game of Thrones or Game of Class Struggle? Revisiting the Demise of Feudalism and the Dobb-Sweezy Debate.

Abstract

In 1947, the Marxist economist Maurice Dobb published a book that attempted to outline and explain how the feudalistic economic system of medieval times gave way to capitalism. Dobb’s Studies in the Development of Capitalism (1947) started a debate among economists and historians over the following decades that has continued until this day. One of his most prominent and earliest critics was Paul M. Sweezy who, although he commended Dobb on raising the question of why feudalism gave way to capitalism, disagreed with Dobb’s conclusions on why the transition from feudalism to capitalism occurred. In general, Dobb thought that feudalism went into decline and was replaced by capitalism because of endogenous causes rooted in the class struggles between serfs and noblemen. Sweezy and others, on the other hand, thought that the factors which led to the decline of feudalism and rise of capitalism were exogenous, and these factors included the development and growth of international trade, production for markets and money, the growth and importance of cities, and the need for European monarchies to finance their wars and overseas empires. Other economists and historians, both mainstream and Marxian, also joined the debate, and a long list of articles and books have been generated on the “transition debate” since the late 1940s. In doing research for this paper, no statistical work on the Dobb-Sweezy debate and its competing hypotheses was found, and so this paper attempts to do some empirical testing of these hypotheses using data from England from the middle ages up to the late nineteenth century. The findings of this note are informative in trying to better understand the transition and provide some food for thought on how capitalism may change in the future.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: capitalism, feudalism, Dobb-Sweezy debate, econometrics, productivity, surplus value, and transition debate
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B20 - General; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B24 - Socialist ; Marxist ; Sraffian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B25 - Historical ; Institutional ; Evolutionary ; Austrian; N - Economic History > N3 - Labor and Consumers, Demography, Education, Health, Welfare, Income, Wealth, Religion, and Philanthropy; N - Economic History > N3 - Labor and Consumers, Demography, Education, Health, Welfare, Income, Wealth, Religion, and Philanthropy > N33 - Europe: Pre-1913

References

Anderson, Perry. 2013. Passages from Antiquity to Feudalism. London, UK: Verso Press. First published by NLB, 1974.

Ashton, T. H., and C. H. E. Philpin (editors).. 1985. The Brenner Debate: Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-industrial Europe. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pages 213-327.

Bairoch, Paul, and Goertz, Gary. 1986. “Factors of Urbanisation in the Nineteenth Century Developed Countries: A Descriptive and Econometric Analysis.” Urban Studies, 23(4), 285–305. https://doi.org/10.1080/00420988620080351 . Accessed on October 20, 2019.

Baran, Paul. 1953. Economic Progress and Economic Surplus. Science & Society, 17(4), 289-317. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/40400214 . Accessed on October 16, 2019.

Bateman, Victoria N. 2011. “The Evolution of Markets in Early Modern Europe, 1350-1800: A Study of Wheat Prices.” Economic History Review 64(2): 447-471.

Blom, Phillipp. 2019. Nature's Mutiny : How the Little Ice Age of the Long Seventeenth Century Transformed the West and Shaped the Present. New York, NY: Liveright Publishing Corporation, a division of W.W. Norton & Company.

Brenner, Robert. 1976. “Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe.” Past & Present 70(February): 30–75.

Brenner, Robert. 1985. “The Agrarian Roots of European Capitalism.” In The Brenner Debate: Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-industrial Europe, edited by Ashton, T. H., and C. H. E. Philpin. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pages 213-327.

Broadberry, S., Campbell, B., Klein, A., Overton, M., & Van Leeuwen, B. 2015. British Economic Growth, 1270–1870. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. doi:10.1017/CBO9781107707603 .

Clark, Gregory. 2006. ”Interpreting English Economic History 1200-1800:Malthusian Stasis or Early Dynamism?” XIV International Economic History Congress, Helsinki 2006, Session 122. http://www.helsinki.fi/iehc2006/papers3/Clark.pdf . Accessed on October 18, 2019.

Cohn, Samuel. 2007. “After the Black Death: Labour Legislation and Attitudes Towards Labour in Late-Medieval Western Europe.” The Economic History Review New Series, 60(3): 457-485. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4502106 . Accessed on October 19, 2019.

Demographia. No Date. Greater London, Inner London & Outer London Population & Density History. http://www.demographia.com/dm-lon31.htm . Accessed on October 20, 2019.

Dobb, Maurice. 1947. Studies in the Development of Capitalism. New York, NY: International Publishers.

Engels, Friedrich. 1935. Socialism: Utopian and Scientific. New York, NY: International Publishers. Originally published in 1880.

Engels, Friedrich. 1957. “The Decline of Feudalism and the Rise of the Bourgeoisie.” Monthly Review April 1957, pp. 445-454. Originally written in 1884 and from an unfinished manuscript discovered amongst Engels posthumous papers: "Ueber den Verfall des Feudalismus and das Aufkommen der Bourgeoisie", Berlin DDR, 1953. https://marxists.catbull.com/archive/marx/works/1884/decline/index.htm . Accessed on October 29, 2019.

Epstein, Stephan R. 2007. Rodney Hilton, Marxism and the Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism. Past and Present, 195 (Suppl. 2). pp. 248-269.

Fagan, Brian M. 2000. The Little Ice Age: How Climate Made History, 1300-1850. New York: Basic Books.

Foster, John Bellamy, and McChesney, Robert W. 2012. The Endless Crisis: How Monopoly-Finance Capital Produces Stagnation and Upheaval from the U.S.A. to China. New York, NY: Monthly Review Press.

Harvey, David. 2014. Seventeen Contradictions and the End of Capitalism. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press USA.

Heller, Henry. 2011. The Birth of Capitalism: A Twenty-First Century Perspective. London, UK: Pluto Press.

Hilton, Rodney. 1976a (1953). “A Comment.” In The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism, edited by Hilton, Rodney, London, UK: NLB, pages 109-117. Originally published in Science and Society, Fall 1953.

Hilton, Rodney. 1976b (1952). “Capitalism—What’s in a Name?” In The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism, edited by Hilton, Rodney, London, UK: NLB, pages 145-158. Originally published in Past and Present, February 1952.

History.com Editors. 2017. Silk Road. Published online November 3, 2017. https://www.history.com/topics/ancient-middle-east/silk-road . Accessed on October 17, 2019.

Hobsbawm, Eric. 1976 (1962). “From Feudalism to Capitalism.” In The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism, edited by Hilton, Rodney, London, UK: NLB, pages 159-164. Originally published in Marxism Today, September 1962.

Law, C. 1967. The Growth of Urban Population in England and Wales, 1801-1911. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, (41), 125-143. doi:10.2307/621331 .

Lee, Ronald. 1973. “Population in Preindustrial England: An Econometric Analysis.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 87(4), 581-607. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/1882026 . Accessed on October 20, 2019.

Lispson, E. 1959. The Economic History of England, Volume 1, The Middle Ages. London: Adam and Charles Black Publishers.

Marx, Karl. 1990. Capital: A Critique of Political Economy, Volume I. London, UK: Penguin Books. Originally published in 1867.

Marx, Karl, and Friedrich Engels. 1974 (1845). The German Ideology. C. J. Arthur, editor. London, UK: Lawrence & Wishart. Originally published in 1845.

Mason, Paul. 2015. PostCapitalism: A Guide to Our Future. London, UK: Allen Lane.

McCloskey, Donald N. 1972. "The Enclosure of Open Fields: Preface to a Study of Its Impact on the Efficiency of English Agriculture in the Eighteenth Century," Journal of Economic History 32 (1, Mar 1972): 15-35.

Mielants, Eric H. 2007. The Origins of Capitalism and the Rise of the West. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

Nell, Edward. 1967. “Economic Relationships in the Decline of Feudalism: An Examination of Economic Interdependence and Social Change.” History and Theory, 6(3), 313-350. doi:10.2307/2504421 . Accessed on October 20, 2019.

North, Douglas and Robert Paul Thomas. 1971. “The Rise and Fall of the Manorial System: A Theoretical Model.” The Journal of Economic History 31(4): 777-803.

North, Douglas and Robert Paul Thomas. 1973. The Rise of the Western World: A New Economic History. Cambridge, UK/New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

O’Brien, Patrick K. and Phillip A. Hunt. 1993. “The Rise of a Fiscal State in England, 1485–1815.” Historical Research, 66: 129-176. doi:10.1111/j.1468-2281.1993.tb01806.x . Accessed on October 24, 2019/

O’Brien, Patrick K. and Philip A. Hunt. 1999. “Chapter 2: England: 1485-1815,” in The Rise of the Fiscal State in Europe, c. 1200 – 1815. Pages 53-100. Richard Bonney, editor. Oxford, UK: Oxford University.

O’Connor. James. 1979. The Fiscal Crisis of the State. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers. Omrod, W. M. 1999. “Chapter1: England in the Middle Ages,” in The Rise of the Fiscal State in Europe, c. 1200 – 1815. Pages 19-52. Richard Bonney, editor. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

Pamuk, Sevket. 2007. “The Black Death and the origins of the 'Great Divergence' across Europe, 1300-1600.” European Review of Economic History, 11(3), 289-317. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/41378468 . Accessed on October 20, 2019.

Pirenne, Henri. 1956 (1925). Medieval Cities: Their Origins and the Revival of Trade. Garden City, NY: Doubleday Anchor Books. Originally published in 1925.

Resnick, Stephen., & Wolff, Richard. 1979. “The Theory of Transitional Conjunctures and the Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism in Western Europe.” Review of Radical Political Economics 11(3), 3–22. https://doi.org/10.1177/048661347901100302 .

Rigby, Stephen H. 2004. “Historical Materialism: Social Structure and Social Change in the Middle Ages.” Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies 34(3): 473-522.

Rigby, Stephen H. 2010. “Urban Population in Late Medieval England: The Evidence of the Lay Subsidies.” Economic History Review, 63(2): 393-417.

Snooks, Graeme Donald. 1993. Economics Without Time: A Science Blind to the Forces of Historical Change. Ann Arbor, MI: The University of Michigan Press.

Sweezy, Paul M. 1976 (1950). “A Critique,” in The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism, edited by Hilton, Rodney, London, UK: NLB, pages 33-56. Originally published with Dobb in Science and Society, Spring 1950: Sweezy, Paul M., and Maurice Dobb. "The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism." Science & Society 14, no. 2 (1950): 134-67.

Sharman, Frank A,, 1989. “An Introduction to the Enclosure Acts.” Journal of Legal History, 10(10:45-70.

Strayer, Joseph R., Hans W. Gatzke, and E. Harris Harbison. 1974. The Mainstream of Civilization to 1500, 2nd Edition. New York, NY: Harcourt-Brace-Jovanovich, Inc.

Takahashi, Kohachiro. 1976 (1952). “A Contribution to the Discussion.” In The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism, edited by Hilton, Rodney, London, UK: NLB, pages 68-97. Originally published in Science and Society, Fall 1952.

Tawney, R. H. 1962. Religion and the Rise of Capitalism. Gloucester, MA: Peter Smith. Originally published by Harcourt, Brace, and Company, 1926.

The European State Finance Database. No Date. https://www.esfdb.org/Default.aspx. Last accessed on October 17, 2019.

Wallerstein, Immanuel. 1974. The Modern World-System: Capitalist Agriculture and the Origins of the European World-Economy in the Sixteenth Century. New York, NY: Academic Press.

Weber, Max. 1958 (1905). The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. New York, NY: Charles Scribner’s Sons. Originally published in 1905.

Wrigley, E. 1985 . Urban Growth and Agricultural Change: England and the Continent in the Early Modern Period. The Journal of Interdisciplinary History, 15(4), 683-728. doi:10.2307/204276 .