What Drives the Choice of Third Party Logistics Provider?

Anderson, Edward and Coltman, Tim and Devinney, Timothy M. and Keating, Byron W. (2010): What Drives the Choice of Third Party Logistics Provider? Published in: Journal of Supply Chain Management , Vol. 47, No. 2 (2011): pp. 97-115.

Abstract

It is generally believed that companies choose supply chain partners on the basis of their distinctive value propositions; a fact one would also expect holds true when companies choose a logistics service provider. However, faced with the complexities of varied customer demands, it can be difficult for logistics service companies to obtain an effective understanding of how customers differentially value the service components they offer. In this paper, we address this by identifying the factors that are important in a customer’s choice of a logistics service provider. Using stated choice methods we explore the relative importance of seven service attributes using a sample of 309 managers with a central role in purchasing logistics services across a range of industries and countries. The results reveal that three distinct decision models populate our data where the preferences for different logistics service attributes – such as price and delivery performance –vary greatly between customer groups represented by these models. Strategically, our findings provide the management of a third party logistics provider with a logical starting point from which to determine the goals that are set for their operations, particularly in choosing the customer segments to service.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: third party logistics; survey methods; discrete choice modeling
• Subjects: M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M3 - Marketing and Advertising > M31 - Marketing; N - Economic History > N7 - Transport, Trade, Energy, Technology, and Other Services; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C2 - Single Equation Models ; Single Variables > C25 - Discrete Regression and Qualitative Choice Models ; Discrete Regressors ; Proportions ; Probabilities

References

Anderson, E., C. Fornell and D.R. Lehman. “Customer Satisfaction, Market Share, and Profitability,” Journal of Marketing, (58:7), 1994, pp. 53-66.

Armstrong and Associates “3PL Customers Report Identifies Service Trends, 3PL Market Segment Sizes and Growth Rates,” The Press Room, http://blog.logisticstoday.com/press-room, Accessed May19, 2010.

Bensmail, H., G. Celeux and A.E. Raftery. "Inference in Model Based Clustering," Statistics and Computing, (7), 1993, pp. 1-10.

Bowersox, D.J., D.J. Closs and T.P. Stank. 21st Century Logistics: Making Supply Chain Integration a Reality. Council of Logistics Management, Oak Brook IL, 1999.

Buckley, P.J., T.M. Devinney and J.J. Louviere. "Do Managers Behave the Way Theory Suggests? A Choice Theoretic Examination of Foreign Direct Investment Location Decision Making," Journal of International Business, (38:7), 2007, pp. 1069-1095.

Cahill, D.L. Customer Loyalty in Third Party Logistics Relationships: Findings from Studies in Germany and the USA, Physica, Heidelburg, Germany, 2006.

Carter, C.R. and L.M. Ellram. "Thirty-Five Years of The Journal of Supply Chain Management: Where Have We Been and Where are We Going?" Journal of Supply Chain Management, (39:2), 2003, pp. 299-318.

Coase, R.H. "The Nature of the Firm," Econometrica, (4:16), 1937, pp. 386-405.

Coltman, T., T.M. Devinney and B. Keating. (2010) "Best-Worst Scaling Approach to Predict Customer Choice for 3PL Services," Journal Business Logistics, forthcoming.

Dibb, S. and R. Wensley. "Segmentation Analysis in Industrial Markets: Problems of Integrating Customer Requirements into Operations Strategy," European Journal of Marketing, (36:1/2), 2002, pp. 231-251.

Dwyer, F.R., P.H. Schurr and S. Oh. "Developing Buyer-Seller Relationships," Journal of Marketing, (51:2), 1987, pp. 11-27.

Erevelles, S. and T.H. Stevenson. "Enhancing the Business-to-Business Supply Chain," Industrial Marketing Management, (35), 2006, pp. 481-492.

Fisher, M.L. "What is the Right Supply Chain for Your Product?," Harvard Business Review, (36:4), 1997, pp. 105-116.

Flint, D.J., E. Larsson, B. Gammelgaard. "Logistics Innovation: A Customer Value-Oriented Social Process" Journal of Business Logistics, (26:1), 2005, pp. 113-147.

Gattorna, J. Living Supply Chains, Prentice Hall, London, England, 2006.

Godsell, J., A. Harrison,C. Emberson and J. Storey. "Customer Responsive Supply Chain Strategy: An Unnatural Act?," International Journal of Logistics: Research and Applications, (9:1), 2006, pp. 47-56.

Goodale, J.C., R. Verma and M.E. Pullman. "A Market Utility-Based Model for Capacity Scheduling in Mass Services," Production & Operations Management, (12:2), 2003, pp. 165-195.

Griffiths, J., R. James and J. Kempson. "Focusing Customer Demand Through Manufacturing Supply Chains by the Use of Customer Focused Cells: An Appraisal," International Journal of Production Economics, (65), 2000, pp. 111-120.

Hatten, K.J., D.E. Schendel, and A.C. Cooper. "A Strategic Model of the U.S. Brewing Industry: 1952–1971," Academy of Management Journal, (21:4), 1978, pp. 592–610.

Hensher, D.A. and S.M. Puckett. "Refocusing the Modelling of Freight Distribution: Development of an Economic-Based Framework to Evaluate Supply Chain Behaviour in Response to Congestion Charging," Transportation, (32:6), 2005, pp. 573-602.

Hill, T. Manufacturing Strategy: Text and Cases. 3rd ed. Boston: Irwin McGraw-Hill, 2000

Hoetker, G. "How Much You Know Versus How Well I Know You: Selecting a Supplier for a Technically Innovative Component," Strategic Management Journal. (26:1), 2005, 75-97.

Holcomb, T.R. and M.A. Hitt. "Toward a Model of Strategic Outsourcing," Journal of Operations Management, (25: 3), 2006, 464-481.

Hunt, S.D. and D.F. Davis. "Grounding Supply Chain Management in Resource-Advantage Theory," Journal of Supply Chain Management, (44: 1), 2008, pp.10-21.

Iqbal, Z., R. Verma and R. Baran. "Understanding Consumer Choices and Preferences in Transaction-Based e-Services," Journal of Service Research, (6:1), 2003, pp. 51-65.

Jackson, B.B. "Build Customer Relationships That Last," Harvard Business Review, (63:6), 1985, pp. 120-128.

Jacobides, M.G. "Industry Change Through Vertical Disintegration: How and Why Markets Emerged in Mortgage Banking," Academy of Management Journal (48: 3), 2005, pp. 465–498.

Jacobides, M.G. and S.G. Winter. "The Co-evolution of Capabilities and Transaction Costs: Explaining the Institutional Structure of Production," Strategic Management Journal. (26: 5), 2005, 395-414.

Knemeyer, M.A. and P.R. Murphy. "Is the Glass Half Full or Half Empty?," International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, (35:30), 2005, pp. 708-727.

Lai, F., D. Li, Q. Wang and X. Zhao. "The Information Technology Capability of Third-Party Logistics Providers: A Resource-Based View and Empirical Evidence from China," Journal of Supply Chain Management, (44:3), 2008, pp. 22-38.

La Londe, B.J. and M.C. Cooper. Partnerships in Providing Customer Service: A Third Party Perspective, The Council of Logistics Management, Cincinatti, OH, 1989.

Louviere, J.J., D.A. Hensher and J.D. Swait. Stated Choice Methods: Analysis and Application, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2000.

Madhok, A. "Reassessing the Fundamentals and Beyond: Ronald Coase, the Transaction Cost and Resource-based Theories of the Firm and the Institutional Structure of Production," Strategic Management Journal, (23:10), 2002, pp. 535-550.

Marasco, A. "Third-party Logistics: A Literature Review," International Journal of Production Economics, (113:1), 2008, pp. 127-147.

McGinnis, M.A. "The Relative Importance of Cost and Service in Freight Transportation Choice: Before and After Deregulation," Transportation Journal, (29: 4), 1990, pp. 12-19.

McGinnis, M.A. and J.W. Kohn, "A Factor Analytic Study of Logistics Strategy," Journal of Business Logistics, (11, 2), 1990, pp.41-63.

McFadden, D. Conditional Logit Analysis of Qualitative Choice Behavior, In: Zarembka, P. (Eds.), Frontiers In Econometrics. Academic Press, New York, 1974.

McIvor, R. The Outsourcing Process: Strategies for Evaluation and Management, New York, N.Y., Cambridge University Press, 2005.

Mc Lachlan, G.J. and K.E. Basford. Mixture Models: Inference and Application to Clustering, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1988.

Melnyk, S.A., E.W. Davis, R.E. Spekman and J. Sandor. "Outcome-Driven Supply Chains," MIT Sloan Management Review, (51: 2), 2010, pp. 33-38.

Mentzer, J.T., D.J. Flint and T.M. Hult. "Logistics Serive Quality and a Segment-Customized Process," Journal of Marketing, (65:4), 2001, pp. 82-104.

Morash, E.A. "Supply Chain Strategies, Capabilities, and Performance," Transportation Journal, (41:1), 2001, pp. 37-53.

Murphy, P.R. and D.F. Wood. Contemporary Logistics, 8th Ed. Pearson Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey, 2004.

Power, D., M. Sharafali and V. Bhakoo. "Adding Value through Outsourcing," Management Research News, (30:3), 2007, pp. 228-235.

Razzaque, M.A. and C.C. Sheng. "Outsourcing of Logistics Functions: A Literature Survey," International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, (28:2), 1998, pp. 89-101.

Sarkis, J. and S. Talluri. "A Model for Strategic Supplier Selection," Journal of Supply Chain Management, (38: 1), 2002, pp. 18-28.

Sanders, N.R., A. Locke, C.B. Moore and C.W. Autry. "A Multidimensional Framework for Understanding Outsourcing Arrangements," The Journal of Supply Chain Management, (43:4), 2007, pp. 3-15.

da Silveira, G.J.C. "Market Priorities, Manufacturing Configuration, and Business Performance: An Empirical Analysis of the Order-Winners Framework," Journal of Operations Management, (23:6), 2005, pp. 662-675.

Stank, T.P., T.J. Goldsby, S. Vickery and K. Savitskie. "Logistics Service Performance: Estimating its Influence on Market Share," Journal of Business Logistics, (24:1), 2003, pp. 27-55.

Stank, T.P., S.B. Keller and D.J. Closs. "Performance Benefits of Supply Chain Logistical Integration," Transportation Journal, (41:2/3), 2001, pp. 32-47.

Street, D. and L. Burgess. The Construction of Optimal Stated Choice Experiments: Theory and Methods, Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 2007.

Terpend, R., B.B. Tyler, D.R. Krause, and R.B. Handfield. "Buyer-Supplier Relationships: Derived Value Over Two Decades," Journal of Supply Chain Management, (44: 2), 2008, pp. 28-49.

Thurstone, L.L. "A Law of Comparative Judgment," Psychological Review, (34, 1927, pp. 273-286.

Vargo, S.L. and R.F. Lusch, "Evolving to a New Dominant Logic for Marketing,". Journal of Marketing, (68: 1), 2004, 1-18.

van Laarhoven, P., M. Berglund and M. Peters. "Third Party Logistics in Europe: Five Years Later" International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, (20:5), 2000, pp. 425-442.

Verma, R.,G. Thompson and J. Louviere. "Configuring Service Operations in Accordance with Customers Needs and Preferences," Journal of Service Research, (1:3), 1999, pp. 262-274.

Verma, R., G. Plaschka, and J. Louviere. "Understanding Customer Choices: A Key to Successful Management of Hospitality Services," Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, (43: 6), 2002, pp. 15-24

Verma, R., J.J. Louviere, and P. Burke. "Using a Market Utility Based Approach to Designing Public Services: A Case Illustration from United States Forest Service," Journal of Operations Management, (24:4), 2006, pp. 407-416.

Vermunt, J.K. and J. Magidson. "Latent Class Cluster Analysis," In: Hagenaars, J. A. and A.L. McCutcheon, (Eds.), Advances in Latent Class Analysis, University Press, Cambridge, 2002.

Voss, D.M., T.J. Page, S. Keller and J. Ozment. "Determining Important Carrier Attributes: A Fresh Perspective Using the Theory of Reasoned Action," Transportation Journal, (45:3), 2006, pp. 7-19.

Wagner, S.M., "Innovation Management in the German Transportation System," Journal of Business Logistics, (29:2), 2008, pp. 215-231.

Walker, G. and D., Weber. "Supplier Competition, Uncertainty, and Make-or-Buy Decisions," Academy of Management Journal, 30, 1987, pp.589-596.

Wallenburg, C.M., "Innovation in Logistics Outsourcing Relationships: Proactive Improvements by Logistics Service Providers as a Driver of Customer Loyalty," Journal of Supply Chain Management, (45:2), 2009, pp.75-93.

Wedel, M. and W. Kamakura. Market Segmentation. Kluwer, London, 2000.

Williamson O.E., "Outsourcing: Transaction Cost Economics and Supply Chain Management" Journal of Supply Chain Management, (44:2), 2008, pp.5-16.

Yankelovich, D.M. "Rediscovering Market Segmentation," Harvard Business Review, (84: 2), 2006, p. 122.