Developing Composite Indicators for Fiscal Decentralization: Which Is The Best Measure For Whom?

Gu, Gyun Cheol (2012): Developing Composite Indicators for Fiscal Decentralization: Which Is The Best Measure For Whom?

Abstract

The right way to measure the degree and extent of the different aspects of fiscal decentralization has been a long-debated, yet underdeveloped issue. There has been little consensus on the right approach to developing a single indicator which is sometimes needed to show a general trend in fiscal decentralization and reveal relationship to other variables in empirical studies. In particular, several composite indicators of fiscal decentralization have been proposed, but there are very few attempts to evaluate and compare these measures in terms of implicit biases and different weights between revenue and expenditure decentralization. Critically reviewing and comparing various types of fiscal-relation indicators in a systematic way, this paper proposes two criteria to classify similar-looking composite indicators for fiscal decentralization while it also presents two new composite measures. The new fiscal decentralization indicators are symmetric in terms of the relative effects of revenue and expenditure decentralization on the value of the composite indicators at the same time that they are weighted for/against fiscal gaps and imbalances. It is argued that different composite indicators reflect different perspectives on which aspect of fiscal decentralization is more important and whether a growing fiscal gap means less fiscal decentralization or not.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: fiscal federalism; fiscal decentralization; decentralization measurement
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession; H - Public Economics > H1 - Structure and Scope of Government > H11 - Structure, Scope, and Performance of Government; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H72 - State and Local Budget and Expenditures; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H71 - State and Local Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue

References

Anderson, G. (2010) Fiscal federalism: A comparative introduction, Oxford

Akai, N. and M. Sakata (2002) Fiscal decentralization contributes to economic growth: evidence from state-level cross-section data for the United States, Journal of Urban Economics, 52:93-108

Bahl, R., and S. Wallace (2007) Intergovernmental transfers: the vertical sharing dimension, in Fiscal Equalization: Challenges in the Design of Intergovernmental Transfer, ed. by J. Martinez-Vazques and B. Searle (New York: Springer)

Baskaran, T. (2010) On the link between fiscal decentralization and public debt in OECD countries, Public Choice, 145: 351-378

Bird, R. (2012) Are there trends in local finance? A comparative look at data and normative models of local government finance, International Center for Public Policy Working Paper 12-05

Bird, R. and A. Tarasov (2004) Closing the gap: fiscal imbalances and intergovernmental transfers in developed federations, Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 22: 77-102

Dziobek, C., C. Mangas, and P. Kufa (2011) Measuring Fiscal Decentralization – Exploring the IMF’s Databases, IMF working paper 11/126

Escolano, J., L. Eyraud, M. Moreno Badia, J. Sarnes, and A. Tuladhar (2012) Fiscal performance, institutional design and decentralization in European Union countries, IMF working paper 45

Eyraud, L. and L. Lusinyan (2011) Decentralizing spending more than revenue: Does it hurt fiscal performance?, IMF working paper 11/226

Feld and Schnellenbach (2008) Fiscal federalism, decentralization and economic growth: A meta-analysis, working paper

Jin, J. and H. Zou (2002) How does fiscal decentralization affect aggregate, national, and subnational government size?, Journal of Urban Economics, 52: 270-293

Martinez-Vazquez, J. and A. Timofeev (2009)Decentralization Measures Revisited,International Studies Program Working Paper 09-13

OECD (1999) Taxing powers of state and local government, Tax policy studies No 1. Paris

Rao, M. and N. Singh (2002) The political economy of center-state fiscal transfers in India, in J. McLaren (ed.), Institutional Elements of Tax Design and Reform, Washington, DC: World Bank, pp. 69-123

Rodden, J. (2002) The dilemma of fiscal federalism: Grants and fiscal performance around the world, American Journal of Political Science, 46(3): 670-687

Sharma, C. (2011) Beyond gaps and imbalances: re-structuring the debate on intergovernmental fiscal relations, Public Administration, 90(1): 99-128

Stegarescu, D. (2005) Public sector decentralization: Measurement concepts and recent international trends, Fiscal Studies, 26(3): 301-333

Stegarescu, D. (2009) The effects of economic and political integration on fiscal decentralization: evidence from OECD countries, Canadian Journal of Economics,42(2): 694-718

Vo, D. (2008) The economics of measuring fiscal decentralization, PhD Dissertation, The University of Western Australia