Labor in a Planned Economy: F. A. Hayek and John Jewkes on the Impossibility of Democratic Socialism

Makovi, Michael (2016): Labor in a Planned Economy: F. A. Hayek and John Jewkes on the Impossibility of Democratic Socialism.

Abstract

Milton Friedman (1962) is associated with the claim that political freedom presupposes economic freedom (cf. Lawson and Clark 2010). Friedman's famous example is that there cannot be freedom of speech where the government owns the printing presses. Less well-known is F. A. Hayek's and John Jewkes's illustrations of the same principle, both drawing from labor economics. Absent a freely operating price system, economic planning cannot function without resorting to compulsory assignment of labor. Similarly, no state may simultaneously fix “fair” wages and demand a given pattern of productive output and employment. It is impossible to both achieve income equality and accomplish an economic plan. This counters Farrant and McPhail (2009)'s claim that Hayek was incorrect in applying his thesis to the modern welfare state. Labor economics helps demonstrate why democratic socialism is impossible, in the sense that it cannot accomplish what its advocates desire.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Hayek; Road to Serfdom; democratic socialism; market socialism; economic democracy; totalitarianism; public choice; government failure; impossibility; corvee; corvée; serfdom; slavery; involuntary; coercive; compulsion; compulsory; labor; servitude
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B24 - Socialist ; Marxist ; Sraffian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B25 - Historical ; Institutional ; Evolutionary ; Austrian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B51 - Socialist ; Marxian ; Sraffian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B53 - Austrian; D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J0 - General; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J0 - General > J00 - General; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J20 - General; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J3 - Wages, Compensation, and Labor Costs > J30 - General; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J4 - Particular Labor Markets > J47 - Coercive Labor Markets; P - Economic Systems > P1 - Capitalist Systems > P10 - General; P - Economic Systems > P2 - Socialist Systems and Transitional Economies > P20 - General; P - Economic Systems > P3 - Socialist Institutions and Their Transitions > P30 - General; P - Economic Systems > P5 - Comparative Economic Systems > P50 - General

References

Aldcraft, Derek H. (1968). “The New Ordeal by Planning: The Experience of the Forties and Sixties by John Jewkes” (book review). Journal of Developing Areas 3:1 (October):91-92.

Ashford, Nigel. (2001). Principles for a Free Society. Stockholm: Jarl Hjalmarson Foundation

Boaz, David. (2005). “The Man Who Told the Truth: Robert Heilbroner fessed up to the failure of socialism.” Reason. 21 Sept. <http://reason.com/archives/2005/01/21/the-man-who-told-the-truth> [accessed:17 Feb. 2016]

Boaz, David. (2016). “What Socialism Requires.” Huffington Post. 22 Sept. <http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-boaz/bernie-sanders-democratic-socialism_b_9055290.html> [accessed:17 Feb. 2016]

Boettke, Peter J. (2012). Living Economics: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow. Oakland, CA: Independent Institute / Guatemala City: Universidad Francisco Marroquín.

Boettke, Peter J. (1998). “Economic Calculation: The Austrian Contribution to Political Economy.” Advances in Austrian Economics vol. 5:131-158.

Boettke, Peter J. (1995). “Hayek's The Road to Serfdom Revisited: Government Failure in the Argument Against Socialism.” Eastern Economic Journal 21:1 (Winter):7-26. Rpt. in Boettke, Calculation and Coordination, London/NY: Routledge:47-65.

Boettke, Peter J. and Peter T. Leeson. (2002). “Hayek, Arrow, and the Problems of Democratic Decision-Making.” Journal of Public Finance and Public Choice (PFPC) 20(1):9-21.

Boettke, Peter J. and Edward J. López (2002). “Austrian Economics and Public Choice.” Review of Austrian Economics 15(2/3):111-119.

Brewin, F. A. (1950). “Ordeal by Planning by John Jewkes” (book review). International Journal 5:4 (Autumn):367-369.

Brown, A. J. (1948). “Ordeal by Planning. by John Jewkes” (book review). International Affairs 24:4 (October):580-581.

Brutzkus, Boris. (1935). Economic Planning in Soviet Russia. Ed. F. A. Hayek. London: Routledge.

Caldwell, Bruce. (2011). “Hayek on Socialism and on the Welfare State: A Comment on Farrant and McPhail's 'Does FA Hayek's Road to Serfdom Deserve to Make a Comeback?'.”Challenge 54(1): 82-97.

Caldwell, Bruce. (1997). “Hayek and socialism.” Journal of Economic Literature 35(4):1856-1890.

Dalmia, Shikha. (2016). “Want to solve Europe's jihadi problem? Reform the continent's toxic labor laws.” The Week. April 5th. <http://theweek.com/articles/615462/want-solve-europes-jihadi-problem-reform-continents-toxic-labor-laws> [accessed:6 April 2016].

Farrant, Andrew. (2015). “Hayek, Orwell, and The Road to Serfdom.” Hayek: A Collaborative Biography: Part VI, Good Dictators, Sovereign Producers and Hayek's “Ruthless Consistency,” ed. Robert Leeson. New York: Palgrave Macmillan:152-182.

Farrant, Andrew and Edward McPhail. (2009). “Hayek, Samuelson, and the logic of the mixed economy?” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 69(1):5-16.

Fischer, R. J. (1949). “Ordeal by Planning by John Jewkes” (book review). Australian Quarterly 21:4 (December):118-119.

Fitz-Claridge, Liberty. (2015), “'Wilt Chamberlain Revisited' Revisited: Interpretive, Practical, and Theoretical Problems for Fried’s Left-Lockeanism,” Libertarian Papers 7:55-69. <http://libertarianpapers.org/article/4-fitz-claridge-wilt-chamberlain-revisited-revisited/> [accessed:5 April 2016].

Friedman, Milton. (1962). Capitalism and Freedom. Chicago & London: University of Chicago Press.

Grampp, William D. (1949). “Ordeal by Planning by John Jewkes” (book review). Southern Economic Journal 16:1 (July):93-94.

Harrington, Michael. (1978a). “What Socialists Would Do in America – If They Could.” Dissent 25:4 (Fall):440-452. Hyperlinked in Dissent, editors of. (2015). “What Is Democratic Socialism?” 14 Nov. <https://www.dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/what-is-democratic-socialism> [accessed:16 Feb. 2016] Harrington, Michael. (1978b). Untitled reply to Heilbroner (1978). Dissent 25:3 (Summer):355-357.

Harris, Seymour E. (1949). “Ordeal by Planning. By John Jewkes” (book review). Journal of Business of the University of Chicago 22:1 (Jan.):60-63. Hayek, F. A. (2011 [1960]). The Constitution of Liberty. Chicago / London: University of Chicago Press.

Hayek, F. A. (2007 [1944]). The Road to Serfdom. Chicago: Chicago University Press.

Hayek, F. A. (1978). New Studies in Philosophy, Politics, Economics, and the History of Ideas. London: Routledge.

Hayek, F. A. (1978 [1976]). “Socialism and Science.” Lecture of 19 Oct. 1976, in: Hayek (1978:295-308).

Hayek, F. A. (1977). Law, Legislation and Liberty, Volume 2: The Mirage of Social Justice. Chicago / London: Chicago University Press.

Hayek, F. A. (1967). Studies in Philosophy, Politics, and Economics. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Hayek, F. A. (1966). “The Principles of a Liberal Social Order.” In: Hayek (1967:160-177). Rpt. from Il Politico 31:4 (Dec.):601-618.

Hayek, F. A. (1948). Individualism and the Economic Order. Chicago & London: University of Chicago Press.

Hayek, F. A. (ed.) (1935). Collectivist Economic Planning. London: Routledge.

Hazlitt, Henry. (1966 [1951]). Time Will Run Back: A Novel about the Discovery of Capitalism. New Rochelle: Arlington. (Orig. The Great Idea. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1951.)

Heilbroner, Robert L. (1978). “What is Socialism?” Dissent 25:3 (Summer):341-348. Hyperlinked in Dissent (2015).

Heilbroner, Robert L. (1986). The Nature and Logic of Capitalism. NY & London: W. W. Norton & Company.

Hoff, Trygve J. B. (1981). Economic Calculation in the Socialist Society. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund. (Rpt. from London / Edinburgh / Glasgow: William Hodge, 1949. Trans. M. A. Michael from the orig. Økonomisk Kalkulasjon i Socialistiske Samfund. Oslo: H. Aschehoug, 1938.)

Ikeda, Sanford. (2015). “Dynamics of Interventionism.” in: Peter J. Boettke and Christopher J. Coyne, eds. The Oxford Handbook of Austrian Economics. Oxford / NY: Oxford University Press:393-416.

Ikeda, Sanford. (2003). “How compatible are public choice and Austrian political economy?.” The Review of Austrian Economics 16(1):63-75.

Jewkes, John. (1968 [1948]). The New Ordeal By Planning: The Experience of the Forties and Sixties. London/Melbourne/Toronto: Macmillan & New York: St. Martin's. (Updated from The Ordeal by Planning. New York: Macmillan, 1948.)

Jewkes, John. (1978). A return to free market economics?: critical essays on government intervention. London, Basingstoke: Macmillan.

Lange, Oskar. (1938). On the Economic Theory of Socialism. B. Lippincott (ed.). University of Minnesota Press.

Lawson, Robert A. and Jeff R. Clark. (2010). “Examining the Hayek–Friedman hypothesis on economic and political freedom.” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 74(3):230-239.

Lavoie, Don. (1985a.) National Economic Planning: What is Left?. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.

Lavoie, Don. (1985b). Rivalry and Central Planning: The Socialist Calculation Debate Reconsidered. Cambridge / London / NY / New Rochelle / Melbourne / Sydney: Cambridge University Press.

Leoni, Bruno. (2009 [1965]). “The Problem of Economic Calculation in a Planned Economy,” in Carlo Lottieri (ed.), Law, Liberty and the Competitive Market. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction, pp. 39-82. (Orig. “Il problema del calcolo economico in un'economica di piano.” Il Politico 30(3) (1965):415-460.)

Levitan, Sar A. (1949). “Ordeal by Planning by John Jewkes” (book review). Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 263 (May):235-236.

Lewis, Ben W. (1969). “The New Ordeal by Planning: The Experience of the Forties and Sixties by John Jewkes” (book review). Journal of Economic History 29:2 (June):361-362.

Lipson, Leslie. (1949). “Ordeal by Planning by John Jewkes” (book review). American Political Science Review 43:2 (April):383-385.

Mackintosh, W. A. (1949). “Ordeal by Planning by John Jewkes” (book review). Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science 15:2 (May):261-263.

Makovi, Michael. (2016a). “Two Opposing Literary Critiques of Socialism: George Orwell Versus Eugen Richter and Henry Hazlitt.” Forthcoming in the International Journal of Pluralism and Economics Education (IJPEE).

Makovi, Michael. (2016b). “The Impossibility of Democratic Socialism: Two Conceptions of Democracy.” Unpublished working paper. <https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/id/eprint/70172> [accessed:20 March 2016].

Makovi, Michael. (2016c). “Interest Groups and the Impossibility of Democratic Socialism: Hayek, Jewkes, and the Arrow Theorem.” Unpublished working paper. <https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/id/eprint/70173> [accessed:20 March 2016].

Makovi, Michael. (2015a). “George Orwell as a Public Choice Economist.” The American Economist 60(2):183-208.

Makovi, Michael. (2015b). “The 'Self-Defeating Morality' of the Lockean Proviso.” Homo Oeconomicus 32(2):235-274.

Mises, Ludwig von. (1996 [1929]). A Critique of Interventionism. Irvington-on-Hudson, NY: Foundation for Economic Education. (Orig. Kritik des Interventionismus: Untersuchungen zur Wirtschaftspolitik und Wirtschaftsideologie der Gegenwart. Jena: Gustav Fischer, 1929).

Mises, Ludwig von. (1998). Interventionism: An Economic Analysis. Irvington-on-Hudson, NY: Foundation for Economic Education. (Trans. from unpublished German manuscript written in 1940.)

Mises, Ludwig von. (1981 [1922]). Socialism. Indianapolis, Indiana: Liberty Classics. Rpt. from previous editions of London: Jonathan Cape (1936), Yale University Press (1951), and London: Jonathan Cape (1969). All English editions translated by J. Kahane from the orig. De Gemeinwirtschaft (1922).

Mises, Ludwig von. (1974 [1950]). “Middle-of-the-Road Policy Leads to Socialism.” In Mises, Planning for Freedom (South Holland, IL: Libertarian Press):18-35.

Mitchell, Daniel. (2016). “Sweden Isn't a Good Role Model for Bernie Sanders.” Blog. <https://danieljmitchell.wordpress.com/2016/04/08/sweden-isnt-a-good-role-model-for-bernie-sanders/> [accessed: 8 April 2016].

Newsinger, John. (1999). Orwell's Politics. Houndsmills, Basingstroke, New Hampshire and New York: Palgrave.

Richman, Sheldon. (2011). “From 1944 to Nineteen Eighty-Four: A Tale of Two Books.” The Freeman. The Foundation for Economic Education, 16 Dec. (rpt. from vol. 59, December 2009). <http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/from-1944-to-nineteen-eighty-four> [accessed:2 February 2014]

Richter, Eugen. (2010 [1891]). Pictures of the Socialistic Future (Freely adapted from Bebel). Auburn: Mises Institute. (Orig. Sozialdemokratische Zukunftsbilder: Frei nach Bebel, 1891. Trans. Henry Wright. London: Swan Sonnenschein, 1893.)

Röpke (Roepke), Wilhelm. (1987 [1951]). 2 Essays by Wilhelm Roepke. Lanham, MD: University Press of America.

Röpke (Roepke), Wilhelm. (1992 [1942]). The Social Crisis of Our Time. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.

Rothbard, Murray. (1977). “The Myth of Democratic Socialism.” Libertarian Review. September: pp. 24-27, 45. <http://www.paulbogdanor.com/left/rothbard.pdf> [accessed:17 March 2016].

Sanandaji, Nima. (2011). “The Swedish Model Reassessed: Affluence Despite the Welfare State.” Helsinki, Finland: Libera Foundation. <https://web.archive.org/web/20150105192615/http://www.libera.fi/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/Libera_The-Swedish-model.pdf> [accessed:2 Feb. 2015]

Schweickart, David. (1992). “Economic democracy: A worthy socialism that would really work.” Science & Society 56(1):9-38.

Shleifer, Andrei and Robert W. Vishny. (1994).“The Politics of Market Socialism.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 8:2 (Spring):165-176.

de Soto, Jesús Huerta. (2010). Socialism, Economic Calculation and Entrepreneurship. Cheltenham, UK / Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.

Steele, David Ramsay. (1992). From Marx to Mises: Post-Capitalist Society and the Challenge of Economic Calculation. La Salle: Open Court.

Stein, Peter. (1991). “Sweden: From Capitalist Success to Welfare-State Sclerosis.” Cato Institute Policy Analysis no. 160. <http://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/sweden-capitalist-success-welfarestate-sclerosis> [accessed:25 Feb. 2015]

Sutherland, Alistair. (1968). “The New Ordeal by Planning: The Experience of the Forties and Sixties by John Jewkes” (book review). Economica 35:139 (August):330.

Szasz, Thomas. (1977). The Theology of Medicine: The Politico-Philosophical Foundations of Medical Ethics. Baton Rouge: Lousiana State University Press.

Tabarrok, Alex. (2016). “Labor Market Rigidity and the Disaffection of European Muslim Youth.” Marginal Revolution (blog). March 29th. <http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/03/crime-immigration-and-labor-market-assimilation.html> [accessed:6 April 2016].

Talmon, Jacob. (1960). The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy. NY: Praeger.

Tupy, Marian. (2016). “Bernie Is Not a Socialist and America Is Not Capitalist: Scandinavia is, by one measure, a freer market than the United States.” The Atlantic. <http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2016/03/bernie-sanders-democratic-socialism/471630/> [accessed:21 March 2016]

Witt, Ulrich. (1992). “The endogenous public choice theorist.” Public choice 73(1):117-129.

Worcester, Jr., Dean A. (1978). “A Return to Free Market Economics? Critical Essays on Government Intervention. by John Jewkes; Frank McFadzean” (book review). Journal of Economic Literature 16:4 (December):1435-1436.