Affirmative Action in the Presence of a Creamy Layer: Identity or Class Based?

Guha, Brishti and Roy Chowdhury, Prabal (2017): Affirmative Action in the Presence of a Creamy Layer: Identity or Class Based?

Abstract

We analyze affirmative action in the presence of income heterogeneity, with the target group containing a creamy layer, as well as poorer members. We find that a move from identity to class-based affirmative action would affect the creamy layer and the poorer members of the target group differently. While it would help the poorer members of the target group, it would hurt the creamy layer, as well as the non-target group. Further, temporary affirmative action need not have a permanent effect, since removing identity-based affirmative action may harm the poorer members of the target group. Thus either removing identity-based affirmative action, or switching to a class-based affirmative action is likely to be politically difficult.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Affirmative action; creamy layer; class-based affirmative action.
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D78 - Positive Analysis of Policy Formulation and Implementation; D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D82 - Asymmetric and Private Information ; Mechanism Design; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J7 - Labor Discrimination > J71 - Discrimination; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J7 - Labor Discrimination > J78 - Public Policy

References

1.Allen, L. (1995) : The role model argument and faculty diversity, in S. M. Cahn, ed., The affirmative action debate. New York: Routledge, pp. 121-34.

2.Alon, S. (2011) : The diversity dividends of a need-blind and color-blind affirmative action policy. Social Science Research, 40(6): 1494-1505.

3.Arrow, K.J (1972) : Some models of racial discrimination in the labour market. In Racial Discrimination in Economic Life, Lexington Books.

4.Banerjee, A., Bertrand, M., Datta, S. and Mullainathan, S. (2009) : Labour market discrimination in Delhi: Evidence from a field experiment. Journal of Comparative Economics 37, 14-27.

5.Becker, G.S. (1957) : The Economics of Discrimination. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

6.Bertrand, M. and Mullainathan, S. (2004) : Are Emily and Greg more emplyable than Lakisha and Jamal? A field experiment on labour market discrimination. American Economic Review 94, 991-101.

7.Carter, M.R and Lybbert, T.J. (2012) : Consumption versus asset smoothing: testing the implications of poverty trap theory in Burkina Faso. Journal of Development Economics 99, 255-264.

8.Chung, K.S (2000) : Role models and arguments for affirmative action. American Economic Review, 90(3): 640-648.

9.Coate, S. and Loury, G. (1993) : Will affirmative action policies eliminate negative stereotypes? American Economic Review, 83(5): 1220-1240.

10.Deshpande, A. and Ramachandran, R. (2014) : How backward are the other backward classes? Changing contours of caste disadvantage in India. Mimeo, Delhi School of Economics.

11.Fang, H. and Norman, P. (2006) : Government-mandated discriminatory policies: Theory and evidence. International Economic Review 47, 361-389.

12.Feagin, J.R., and Porter, A (1995) : Affirmative action and African Americans: rhetoric and practice. Humboldt Journal of Social Relations, 21(2): 81-103.

13.Fryer, R.G. (2007) : Belief flipping in a dynamic model of statistical discrimination. Journal of Public Economics 91, 1151-1166.

14.Fryer, R.G. and Loury, G.C. (2013) : Valuing Diversity. Journal of Political Economy 121, 747-774.

15.Hnatkovska, V., Lahiri, A. and Paul, S. (2012) : Castes and Labor Mobility. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, American Economic Association 4(2), 274-307.

16.Jackson, B.O (1987) : The effects of racial group consciousness on political mobilization in American cities. Western Political Quarterly, 40(4): 631-646.

17.Leonard, J.S. (1984) : The impact of affirmative action on employment. Journal of Labour Economics 2, 439-464.

18.Lundberg, S.J. (1991) : The enforcement of equal opportunity laws under imperfect information: Affirmative action and alternatives. Quarterly Journal of Economics 106, 309-206.

19.Moro, A. and Norman, P. (2003) : Affirmative action in a competitive economy. Journal of Public Economics 87, 567-594.

20.Nelson, W. and Meranto, P.J (1977) : Electing black mayors: political action in the black community. Columbus: Ohio State University Press.

21.Phelps, E.S. (1972) : The statistical theory of racism and sexism. American Economic Review 62, 659-61.

22.Reece, J. (2011) : Revisiting class-based affirmative action in government contracting. Washington University Law Review 88, 1309-1352.

23.Sander, R.H (1997) : Experimenting with class-based affirmative action. Journal of Legal Education, 47(4): 472-503.

24.Smith, J.P. and Welch, F. (1984) : Affirmative action and labour markets. Journal of Labour Economics 2, 269-301.

25.Welch, F. (1976) : Employment quotas for minorities. Journal of Political Economy 84, 8105-39.

26.Welch, F. (1989) : Affirmative action and discrimination. In S. Shulman and W. Darrity, Jr., eds., The Question of Discrimination. Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, pp. 153-189.

27.Wilson, W.J (1978) : The declining significance of race. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.