Student exposure to socio-economic diversity and students’ university outcomes – Evidence from English administrative data

Braakmann, Nils and McDonald, Stephen (2018): Student exposure to socio-economic diversity and students’ university outcomes – Evidence from English administrative data.

Abstract

Many countries encourage universities to increase the ethnic and socio-economic diversity of their student bodies, for example, through affirmative action policies. We use unique administrative data for all undergraduate degree students entering English universities between 2008 and 2010 to investigate the role of a more diverse environment for students’ degree outcomes. We find a complex picture – a more diverse environment is beneficial for students, but so is meeting some students from the same background. These effects are different for good and top degrees, interact with each other and vary across institutions, subjects and student subgroups.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Diversity; affirmative action; widening participation; university; student outcomes
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I23 - Higher Education ; Research Institutions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I24 - Education and Inequality; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I26 - Returns to Education; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I28 - Government Policy; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J15 - Economics of Minorities, Races, Indigenous Peoples, and Immigrants ; Non-labor Discrimination

References

Alesina, Alberto and Eliana La Ferrara (2005). Ethnic diversity and economic performance. Journal of Economic Literature 43(3), pp. 207-234.

Alon, Sigal (2011). The diversity dividends of a need-blind and color-blind affirmative action policy. Social Science Research 40, pp. 1494-1505.

Alon, Sigal and Marta Tienda (2007). Diversity, opportunity, and the shifting meritocracy in higher education. American Sociological Review 72(4), pp. 487-511.

Ammermueller, Andreas and Joern-Steffen Pischke (2012). Peer effects in European Primary Schools: Evidence from the Progress in International Reading Literacy Study. Journal of Labor Economics 27(3), pp. 315-348.

Anelli, Massimo and Giovanni Peri (2017). The long run effects of high-school class gender composition. Economic Journal, forthcoming.

Angrist, Joshua and Guido Imbens (1994). Identification and estimation of local average treatment effects. Econometrica 62(2), pp. 467-475.

Angrist, Joshua, Guido Imbens and Donald Rubin (1996). Identification of causal effects using instrumental variables. Journal of the American Statistical Association 91(434), pp. 444-455.

Backes, Ben (2012). Do affirmative action bans lower minority college enrolment and attainment? Evidence from statewide bans. Journal of Human Resources 47(2), pp. 435-455.

Bertoni, Marco, Giorgio Brunello and Lorenzo Cappellari (2017). Parents, siblings and schoolmates: The effects of family-school interactions on educational achievement and long-term labour market outcomes. IZA Discussion Paper 11200.

Bianchi, Milo, Paolo Buonanno and Paola Pinotti, P. (2012). Do immigrants cause crime? Journal of the European Economic Association 10(6), pp. 1318-1347.

Booij, Adam, Edwin Leuven and Hessel Oosterbeek (2017). Ability peer effects in university: Evidence from a randomized experiment. The Review of Economic Studies 84(2), pp. 547- 578.

Black, Sandra, Paul Devereux, and Kjell Salvanes (2013). Under Pressure? The Effect of Peers on Outcomes of Young Adults. Journal of Labor Economics 31(1), pp. 119-153.

Braakmann, Nils (2016). Immigration and the property market: Evidence from England and Wales. Forthcoming: Real Estate Economics.

Burgess, Simon and Lucinda Platt (2018). Inter-ethnic relations of teenagers in England’s schools: the role of school and neighbourhood ethnic composition. Centre for Research & Analysis of Migration Discussion Paper 07/18.

Byrne, Donn (1971). The attraction paradigm. New York: Academic Press.

Card, David (2001). Immigrant inflows, native outflows, and the local labor market impacts of higher immigration. Journal of Labor Economics 19(1), pp. 22-63.

Card, David (2009). Immigration and Inequality. American Economic Review 99(2), pp. 1-21.

Card, David and John DiNardo (2000). Do Immigrant Inflows Lead to Native Outflows? American Economic Review 90(2), pp. 360-367.

Card, David and Alan B. Krueger (2005). Would the elimination of Affirmative Action affects highly qualified minority applicants? Evidence from California and Texas. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 58(3), pp. 416-434.

Card, David, Alexandre Mas and Jesse Rothstein (2008). Tipping and the dynamics of segregation. Quarterly Journal of Economics 123(1), pp. 177-218.

Cox, Taylor (1993). Cultural diversity on organizations: Theory, research, and practice. San Francisco, CA: Berret-Koehler.

Cox, Taylor (2001). Creating the multicultural organization: A strategy for capturing the power of diversity. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Cox, Taylor and Ruby L. Beale (1997). Developing competency to manage diversity. San Francisco, CA: Berret-Koehler.

Carrell, Scott, Richard Fullerton and James West (2009). Does your cohort matter? Measuring peer effects in college achievement. Journal of Labor Economics 27(3), pp. 439-464.

Cortes, Patricia (2008). The effect of low-skilled immigration on US prices: Evidence from CPI data. Journal of Political Economy 116, pp. 381-422.

Dickson, Lisa M. (2006). Does ending affirmative action if college admissions lower the percent of minority students applying to college? Economics of Education Review 25, pp. 109-119.

Duflo, Esther, Pascaline Dupas and Michael Kremer (2011). Peer effects, teacher incentives, and the impact of tracking: Evidence from a randomized evaluation in Kenya. American Economic Review 101(5), pp. 1739-1774.

Dustmann, Christian, Patrick A. Puhani and Uta Schoenberg (2017). The long-term effects if early track choice. Economic Journal 127(603), pp. 1348-1380.

Eisenkopf, Gerald, Zohal Hessami, Urs Fischbacher and Heinrich Ursprung (2015). Academic performance and single-sex schooling: Evidence from a natural experiment in Switzerland. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 115, pp. 123-143.

Francis, Andrew M. and Maria Tannuri-Pianto (2012a). Using Brazil’s racial continuum to examine the short-run effects of affirmative action in higher education. Journal of Human Resources 47(3), pp. 754-784.

Francis, Andrew M. and Maria Tannuri-Pianto (2012b). The redistributive equity of affirmatice action: Exploring the role of race, socioecononomic status and gender in college admissions. Economics of Education Review 31, pp. 45-55.

Garnero, Andrea, Stephan Kampelmann and François Rycx (2014). The heterogenous effects of workforce diversity on productivity, wages, and profits. Industrial Relations 53(3), pp. 430-477.

Geay, Charlotte, Sandra McNally and Shqiponja Telhaj (2013). Non-native speakers of English in the classroom: What are the effects on pupil performance? Economic Journal 123(570), pp. F281-F307.

Goldsmith-Pinkham, Paul, Isaac Sorkin and Henry Swift (2018). Bartik Instruments: What, when, why, and how. NBER Working Paper 24408.

Gonzalez, Libertad and Francesc Ortega (2013). Immigration and housing booms: Evidence from Spain. Journal of Regional Science 53(1), pp. 37-59.

Gurin, Patricia, Biren (Ratnesh) A. Nagda, and Gretchen E. Lopez. 2004. The benefits of diversity in education for democratic citizenship.” Journal of Social Issues 60(1), pp. 17–34.

Guyon, Nina, Eirc Maruin and Sandra McNally (2012). The effect of tracking students by ability into different schools: A natural experiment. Journal of Human Resources 47(3), pp. 684-721.

Hall, Caroline (2012). The effects of reducing tracking in upper secondary school: Evidence from a large-scale pilot scheme. Journal of Human Resources 47(1), pp. 237-269.

Hanushek, Eric A. and Ludger Woessmann (2006). Does educational tracking affect performance and inequality? Difference-in-differences evidence across countries. Economic Journal 116(510), pp. C63-C76.

Herring, Cedric (2009). Does diversity pay?: Race, gender and the business case for diversity. American Sociological Review 74(2), pp. 208-224.

Hinrichs, Peter (2012). The effects of affirmative action bans on college enrolment, educational attainment, and the demographic composition of universities. Review of Economics and Statistics 94(3), pp. 712-722.

Hoogendorn, Sander, Hessel Oosterbeek and Mirjam van Praag (2013). The impact of gender diversity on the performance of business teams: Evidence from a field experiment”. Management Science 59(7), pp. 1514-1528.

Hoxby, Caroline (2000). Peer effects in the classroom: Learning from gender and race variation. NBER Working Paper 7867.

Hubbard, Edward E. (2004). The diversity scorecard: Evaluating the impact of diversity on organizational performance. Burlington, MA: Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann.

Hunt, Jennifer (2012). The impact of immigration on the educational attainment of natives. IZA Discussion Paper no. 6904.

Jaeger, David A., Theodore J. Joyce and Robert Kaestner (2018). A cautionary tale of evaluating identifying assumptions: Did reality TV really cause a decline in teenage childbearing? Forthcoming: Journal of Business and Economic Statistrics.

Jaeger, David A., Joakim Ruist and Jan Stuhler (2018). Shift-share instruments and the impact of immigration. NBER Working Paper 24285.

Jehn, Karen, Gregory Northcraft and Margaret Neale (1999). Why differences make a difference: A field study of diversity, conflict and performance in workgroups. Administrative Science Quarterly 44(4), pp. 741-763.

Kerr, Sari P., Tuomas Pekkarinen and Roope Ussitalo (2013). School tracking and development of cognitive skills. Journal of Labor Economics 31(3), pp. 577-602.

Lang, Levin (1986). A language theory of discrimination. Quarterly Journal of Economics 101(2), pp. 363-382.

Lavy, Victor and Analia Schlosser (2011). Mechanisms and impacts of gender peer effects at school. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 3(2), pp. 1-33.

Lavy, Victor, Olmo Silva and Felix Weinhardt (2012). The good, the bad, and the average: Evidence on ability peer effects in schools. Journal of Labor Economics 30(2), pp. 367- 414.

Lavy, Victor, Daniele Paserman, and Analia Schlosser (2012). Inside the black box of ability peer effects: Evidence from variation in the proportion of low achievers in the classroom. The Economic Journal 122(559), pp. 208-237.

Leonard, Jonathan and David Levine (2006). The effects of diversity on turnover: A large case study. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 59(4), pp. 547-572.

Lyle, David (2009). The Effects of Peer Group Heterogeneity on the Production of Human Capital at West Point. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 1(4), pp. 69-84

Malamud, Ofer and Christian Pop-Eleches (2011). School tracking and access to higher education among disadvantaged groups. Journal of Public Economics 95(11-12), pp. 1538-1549.

Manski, Charles F. (1993). Identification of endogenous social effects: The reflection problem. Review of Economic Studies 60(3), pp. 531-542.

Merlino, Luca Paolo, Max F. Steinhardt and Liam Wren-Lewis (2018). More than just friends? School peers and adult interracial relationships. Forthcoming: Journal of Labor Economics.

Mouw, Ted and Barbara Entwisle (2006). Residential segregation and interraxcial friendship in schools. American Journal of Sociology 112(2), pp. 394-441.

Ohinata, Asako and Jan van Ours (2013). How immigrant children affect the academic achievement of native Dutch children. Economic Journal 123(570), pp. F281-F307.

Ohinata, Asako and Jan van Ours (2016). Quantile peer effects of immigrant children at primary school. Labour 30(2), pp. 135-157.

Oosterbeek , Hessel and Reyn Van Ewijk (2014). Gender peer effects in university: Evidence from a randomized experiment. Economics of Education Review 38(C), pp. 51-63

Ottaviano, Gianmarco and Peri, Giovanni. (2005). Cities and cultures. Journal of Urban Economics 58(2), pp. 304-337.

Ottaviano, Gianmarco and Peri, Giovanni. (2006). The economic value of cultural diversity: evidence from US cities. Journal of Economic Geography 6(1), pp. 9-44.

Richard, Orlando C. (2000). Racial diversity, business strategy, and firm performance: A resource-based view. Academy of Management Journal 43(2), pp. 164-177.

Sá, Filipa (2015). Immigration and house prices in the UK. Economic Journal 125(587): 1393-1424.

Sacerdote, Bruce (2001). Peer effects with random assignment: Results for Dartmouth roommates. Quarterly Journal of Economics 116(2), pp. 681-704.

Saiz, Albert (2006). Immigration and housing rents in American cities. Journal of Urban Economics 61(2), pp. 345-371.

Schneeweis, Nicole (2015). Immigrant concentration in schools: Consequences for native and migrant students. Labour Economics 35, pp. 63-76.

Schøne, Pål, Kristine von Simson and Marte Strøm (2016). Girls Helping Girls-The Impact of Female Peers on Grades and Educational Choices. IZA Discussion Paper 10586.

Scott, Kristyn, Joanna Hearthcote and Jamie Gruman (2011). The diverse organization: Finding gold at the end of the rainbow. Human Resource Management 50(6), pp. 735-755.

Shore, Lynne, Beth Chung-Herrera, Michelle Dean, Karen Halcombe Ehrhardt, Don Jung, Amy Randel and Gangaram Singh (2009). Diversity in organizations: Where are we now and where are we going? Human Resource Management Review 19(2), pp. 117-133.

Skerry, Peter. 2002. “Beyond Sushiology: Does diversity work?” Brookings Review 20, pp. 20–23.

Smedley, Brian D., Adrienne Stith Butler, and Lonnie R. Bristow, eds. (2004). In the nation’s compelling interest: Ensuring diversity in the health-care workforce. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.

Smith, Sanne, Daniel A. McFarland, Frank Van Tubergen, and Ineke Maas (2016). Ethnic Composition and Friendship Segregation: Differential Effects for Adolescent Natives and Immigrants. American Journal of Sociology 121(4), pp. 1223-1272.

Sparber, Chad (2010). Racial diversity and macroeconomic productivity across US states and cities. Regional Studies 44(1), pp. 71-85.

Strully, Kate (2014). Racially and ethnically diverse schools and adolescent romantic relationships. American Journal of Sociology 120(3), pp. 750-797.

Suedekum, Jens, Katja Wolf and Uwe Blien (2014). Cultural diversity and local labour markets. Regional Studies 48(1), pp. 173-191.

Tajfel, Henri and John Turner (1986). The Social Identity Theory of Intergroup Behavior. In S. Worschel and W. G. Austin, eds., Psychology of Intergroup Relations, 2nd ed. Chicago: Nelson-Hall, pp. 7-24.

Tannen, Deborah (1990). You just don’t understand: Women and men in conversation. New York: Morrow.

Tsui, Ann S., T. D. Egan, and Charles A. O’Reilly. 1992. “Being Different: Relational Demography and Organizational Attachment.” Administrative Science Quarterly 37, pp. 549–79.

Turner, John (1985). Social Categorization and the Self-Concept: A Social Cognitive Theory of Group Behavior. In Edward J. Lawler, ed., Advances in Group Processes: Theory and Research, Vol. 2. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press, pp. 77–121.

Waldinger, Fabian, 2010. Quality matters: The expulsion of professor and the consequences for Ph.D. student outcomes in Nazi Germany. Journal of Political Economy 118(4), pp. 787-831.

Waldinger, Fabian, 2012. Peer effects in science – Evidence from the dismissal of scientists in Nazi Germany. Review of Economic Studies 79(2), pp. 838-861.