Better to be in the same boat: Positional envy in the workplace

Distefano, Rosaria (2022): Better to be in the same boat: Positional envy in the workplace.

Abstract

In a simple agency model of the labor market, we examine how fairness concerns affect the structure of optimal contracts when workers have different and unobservable abilities. In the framework, we assume that low-ability workers are envious and incur a utility cost whenever the more talented earn a surplus from their contracts. We focus on the equilibrium payoff of the envied and show that, when the ability gap is relatively small, it is first increasing and then decreasing in the level of envy cost borne by the envious. In contrast, when the gap is large, the payoff is monotonically decreasing. We also find that the utility loss of the envious is higher the lower the skill heterogeneity between types. Finally, we validate our theoretical results through GSOEP data.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: asymmetric information; envy; fairness; other-regarding preferences; principal-agent model.
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D03 - Behavioral Microeconomics: Underlying Principles; D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D82 - Asymmetric and Private Information ; Mechanism Design; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M5 - Personnel Economics > M54 - Labor Management

References

Ball, S., Eckel, C., Grossman, P., and Zame, W. (2001). Status in markets. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116:161-188.

Barigozzi, F. and Manna, E. (2020). Envy in mission-oriented organisations. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 179:395- 424.

Bartling, B. and Von Siemens, F. (2010). The intensity of incentives in firms and markets: Moral hazard with envious agents. Labour Economics, 17:598-607.

Becker, G. (1973). A theory of marriage: Part I. Journal of Political Economy, 81:813-846.

Ben-Ze'ev, A. (1992). Envy and inequality. Journal of Philosophy, 89:551-581.

Bolton, G. and Ockenfels, A. (2000). ERC: A theory of equity, reciprocity, and competition. American Economic Review, 90:166-193.

Breza, E., Kaur, S., and Shamdasani, Y. (2018). The morale effects of pay inequality. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 133:611-663.

Card, D., Mas, A., Moretti, E., and Saez, E. (2012). Inequality at work: The effect of peer salaries on job satisfaction. American Economic Review, 102:2981-3003.

Caserta, M., Ferrante, L., and Reito, F. (2021). Envy manipulation at work. The B.E. Journal of Theoretical Economics, 1:287-314.

Clark, A., Frijters, P., and Shields, M. (2008). Relative income, happiness, and utility: An explanation for the Easterlin paradox and other puzzles. Journal of Economic Literature, 46:95-144.

Cohen-Charash, Y. and Mueller, J. (2007). Does perceived unfairness exacerbate or mitigate interpersonal counterproductive work behaviors related to envy? Journal of Applied Psychology, 92:666-680.

Cohn, A., Fehr, E., Herrmann, B., and Schneider, F. (2014). Social comparison and effort provision: Evidence from a field experiment. Journal of the European Economic Association, 12:877-898.

Cornelissen, T., Himmler, O., and Koenig, T. (2011). Perceived unfairness in CEO compensation and work morale. Economics Letters, 110:45-48.

Crusius, J. and Lange, J. (2014). What catches the envious eye? Attentional biases within malicious and benign envy. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 55:1-11.

Desiraju, R. and Sappington, D. (2007). Equity and adverse selection. Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, 16:285-318.

Duesenberry, J. (1952). Income, saving, and the theory of consumer behavior. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.

Duffy, M., Scott, K., Shaw, J., Tepper, B., and Aquino, K. (2012). A social context model of envy and social undermining. Academy of Management Journal, 55:643-666.

Dur, R. and Glazer, A. (2008). Optimal contracts when a worker envies his boss. Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization, 24:120-137.

Fehr, E., Goette, L., and Zehnder, C. (2009). A behavioral account of the labor market: The role of fairness concerns. Annual Review of Economics, 1:355-384.

Fehr, E. and Schmidt, K. (1999). A theory of fairness, competition, and cooperation. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 114:817-868.

Ferrer-i Carbonell, A. (2005). Income and well-being: An empirical analysis of the comparison income effect. Journal of Public Economics, 89:997-1019.

Festinger, L. (1954). A theory of social comparison processes. Human Relations, 7:117-140.

Fiske, S. (2010). Envy up, scorn down: How comparison divides us. American Psychologist, 65:698-706.

Frank, R. (1984). Interdependent preferences and the competitive wage structure. RAND Journal of Economics, 65:510-520.

Ghatak, M. (1999). Group lending, local information and peer selection. Journal of Development Economics, 60:27-50.

Grant, A. and Mayer, D. (2009). Good soldiers and good actors: Prosocial and impression management motives as interactive predictors of affiliative citizenship behaviors. Journal of Applied Psychology, 94:900-912.

Grund, C. and Sliwka, D. (2005). Envy and compassion in tournaments. Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, 14:187-207.

Itoh, H. (2004). Moral hazard and other-regarding preferences. Japanese Economic Review, 55:18-45.

Khan, A., Quratulain, S., and Bell, C. (2014). Episodic envy and counterproductive work behaviors: Is more justice always good? Journal of Organizational Behavior, 35:128-144.

Loewenstein, G., Thompson, L., and Bazerman, M. (1989). Social utility and decision making in interpersonal contexts. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 57:426-441.

Manna, E. (2016). Envy in the workplace. Economics Letters, 142:18-21.

Mas, A. (2006). Pay, reference points, and police performance. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 121:783-821.

Neilson, W. and Stowe, J. (2010). Piece-rate contracts for other-regarding workers. Economic Inquiry, 48:575-586.

Nickerson, J. and Zenger, T. (2008). Envy, comparison costs, and the economic theory of the firm. Strategic Management Journal, 29:1429-1449.

Obloj, T. and Zenger, T. (2017). Organization design, proximity, and productivity responses to upward social comparison. Organization Science, 28:1-18.

Ockenfels, A., Sliwka, D., and Werner, P. (2015). Bonus payments and reference point violations. Management Science, 61:1496-1513.

Ostell, A. (1996). Managing dysfunctional emotions in organizations. Journal of Management Studies, 33:525-557.

Postlewaite, A. (1998). The social basis of interdependent preferences. European Economic Review, 42:779-800.

Rustemeyer, R. and Wilbert, C. (2001). Jealousy within the perspective of a self-evaluation maintenance theory. Psychological Reports, 88:799-804.

Silver, M. and Sabini, J. (1978). The perception of envy. Social Psychology, 41:105-117.

Smith, R. and Kim, S. (2007). Comprehending envy. Psychological Bulletin, 133:46-64.

Smith, R., Parrott, W., Diener, E., Hoyle, R., and Kim, S. (1999). Dispositional envy. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 25:1007-1020.

Solnick, S. and Hemenway, D. (2005). Are positional concerns stronger in some domains than in others? American Economic Review, 95:147-151.

Song, J., Price, D., Guvenen, F., Bloom, N., and Von Wachter, T. (2019). Firming up inequality. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134:1-50.

Tai, K., Narayanan, J., and McAllister, D. (2012). Envy as pain: Rethinking the nature of envy and its implications for employees and organizations. Academy of Management Review, 37:107-129.

van de Ven, N. and Zeelenberg, M. (2015). On the counterfactual nature of envy: "It could have been me". Cognition and Emotion, 29:954-971.

van de Ven, N., Zeelenberg, M., and Pieters, R. (2009). Leveling up and down: The experiences of benign and malicious envy. Emotion, 9:419-429.

Vecchio, R. (2000). Negative emotion in the workplace: Employee jealousy and envy. International Journal of Stress Management, 7:161-179.

Vendrik, M. and Woltjer, G. (2007). Happiness and loss aversion: Is utility concave or convex in relative income? Journal of Public Economics, 91:1423-1448.

Wagner, G., Frick, J., and Schupp, J. (2007). The German Socio-Economic Panel study (SOEP)-evolution, scope and enhancements. Schmollers Jahrbuch, 127:139-169.