Are the best jobs created in largest cities? Evidence from Italy 1993-2016

Croce, Giuseppe and Piselli, Paolo (2024): Are the best jobs created in largest cities? Evidence from Italy 1993-2016.

Abstract

The gap in the employment dynamics between larger urban areas and other areas has widened dramatically in recent decades in advanced economies. A proposed explanation for this trend argues that the technological change occurs with greater intensity in larger urban areas than in medium and small cities, since it interacts with the urban agglomeration forces. In particular, more qualified, better paid jobs are expected to grow more in larger cities. This work focuses on the dynamics of most paying jobs and their spatial distribution across different-size cities in Italy in the period between 1993 and 2016. We investigate whether their share has grown and whether its growth has actually been concentrated in the larger cities. Using Bank of Italy’s Survey of Household Income and Wealth (SHIW), we find that the share of most paying jobs has increased in aggregate but its growth in large cities was much weaker than in medium and small cities and even negative after 2008. We also estimate a probit IV model of the worker’s probability of being employed in a most paying job across cities. The results show that being in a bigger city does not increase the chances of getting a better paid job. Furthermore, a shift-share decomposition reveals that the weak growth of most paying jobs in larger cities is only partly explained by the sectoral shifts. Our evidence can be explained by the slow diffusion of new technologies in the Italian economy. Moreover, it is consistent with studies showing the poor performance of the largest urban economies in Italy.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: employment change, technological change, most paying jobs, cities, local labour markets, agglomeration
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J24 - Human Capital ; Skills ; Occupational Choice ; Labor Productivity; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J3 - Wages, Compensation, and Labor Costs > J31 - Wage Level and Structure ; Wage Differentials; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O14 - Industrialization ; Manufacturing and Service Industries ; Choice of Technology; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O18 - Urban, Rural, Regional, and Transportation Analysis ; Housing ; Infrastructure; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O33 - Technological Change: Choices and Consequences ; Diffusion Processes; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R11 - Regional Economic Activity: Growth, Development, Environmental Issues, and Changes

References

Accetturo A., Lamorgese A., Mocetti S., Sestito P., 2019, Sviluppo locale, economie urbane e crescita aggregate, Questioni di Economia e Finanza, 490, Banca d’Italia.

Acemoglu D., 2002, Technical change, inequality and the labor market, Journal of Economic Literature, 40(1), 7-72.

Aimone Gigio L., Camussi S., Maccarrone V., 2021, Changes in the employment structure and in job quality in Italy: a national and regional analysis, Occasional Papers 603, Banca d’Italia.

Autor D.H., 2015, Why Are There Still So Many Jobs? The History and Future of Workplace Automation, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 29(3), 3–30.

Autor D.H., 2019, Work of the past, work of the future, AEA Papers and Proceedings, 109, 1-32.

Autor D.H., Katz L.F., Krueger A.B., 1998, Computing Inequality: Have Computers Changed the Labor Market?, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 113(4), 1169–1213.

Autor, D.H., Dorn D., 2013, The Growth of Low-Skill Service Jobs in the United States, American Economic Review, 103(5), 1553-1597.

Autor, D.H., Levy F., Murname R.J., 2003, The skill content of recent technological change: an empirical exploration, Quarterly journal of Economics, 118(4), 1279-1334.

Bárány Z.L., Siegel C., 2018, Job Polarization and Structural Change, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 10(1), 57–89.

Barbiellini Amidei, F., Gomellini M. and Piselli P., 2018, Il contributo della demografia alla crescita economica: duecento anni di “storia” italiana, Questioni di Economia e Finanza (Occasional Papers), 431, Banca d’Italia.

Barone G., Mocetti S., 2011, With a little help from abroad: The effect of low-skilled immigration on the female labour supply, Labour Economics, 18, 664-675.

Basso G., 2020, The evolution of the occupational structure in Italy 2007-2017, Social Indicators Research, 152, 673–704.

Berman E., Bound J., Machin S., 1998, Implications of skill-biased technological change: international evidence, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 113(4), 1245–1279.

Brandolini A. and Bugamelli M. (eds.), 2009, Rapporto sulle tendenze nel sistema produttivo italiano, Questioni di Economia e Finanza, (Occasional Papers), 45.

Brunetti I., Cirillo V., Intraligi V., Ricci A., 2020, Low-skill jobs and routine tasks specialization: New insights from Italian provinces, Papers in regional science, 99.

Buciuni G., Corò G., 2023, Periferie competitive. Lo sviluppo dei territori nell’economia della conoscenza, il Mulino, Bologna.

Bugamelli M., Cannari L., Lotti F., Magri S., 2012, Il gap innovativo del Sistema produttivo italiano: radici e possibili rimedi, Questioni di economia e finanza, 121, Banca d’Italia.

Bugamelli M., Lotti F., Amici M., Ciapanna E., Colonna F., D'Amuri F., Giacomelli S., Linarello A., Manaresi F., Palumbo G., Scoccianti F., Sette E., 2018, Productivity growth in Italy: a tale of a slow-motion change, 422, Banca d’Italia.

Card D., DiNardo J.E., 2002, Skill biased technological change and rising wage inequality: come problems and puzzles, Journal of labor economics, 20(4), 733-783.

Cerina F., Dienesch E., Moro A., Rendall M., 2022, Spatial polarization, The Economic Journal: 1–40.

Ciani E., David F., de Blasio G., 2017, Local labour market heterogeneity in Italy: estimates and simulations using responses to labour demand shocks, Temi di discussione, 1112, Banca d’Italia.

Cirillo V., 2018, Job polarisation in European industries, International Labour Review, 157 (1).

Davis D.R., Dingel J.I., 2020, The comparative advantage of cities, Journal of International Economics, 123.

Davis D.R., Mengus E., Michalski T.K., 2020, Labor market polarization and the great divergence: theory and evidence, NBER Working Paper 26955.

De Philippis M., 2017, The dynamics of the Italian labour force participation rate: determinants and implications for the employment and unemployment rate, Questioni di Economia e finanza, Banca d’Italia, Roma.

Di Giacinto V., Gomellini M., Micucci G., Pagnini M., 2012, Mapping local productivity advantages in Italy: industrial districts, cities or both?, Temi di discussion 850, Banca d’Italia.

Duranton G., Kerr W.R., 2015, The logic of agglomeration, NBER w.p. 21452.

Duranton G., Puga D., 2004, Handbook of Regional and Urban Economics, in: J. V. Henderson & J. F. Thisse (ed.), Handbook of Regional and Urban Economics, vol. 4, ch. 48, 2063-2117, Elsevier.

Eeckhout J., Hedtrich C., Pinheiro R., 2021, IT and Urban Polarization, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, wp 21-18.

Cohen J., Small E.C., 1998, Hypsographic demography: The distribution of human population by altitude, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 95, 14009–14014.

Eurofound, 2014, Drivers of recent job polarisation and upgrading in Europe: European Jobs Monitor 2014, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg.

Eurofound, 2017, Occupational change and wage inequality: European Jobs Monitor 2017, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg.

Federico S., 2014, Industry Dynamics and Competition from Low-Wage Countries: Evidence on Italy, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 76(3), 389–410.

Fernández-Macías E., 2012, Job Polarization in Europe? Changes in the Employment Structure and Job Quality, 1995-2007, Work and Occupations, 39(2), 157-182.

Fernández-Macías E., Hurley J., 2016, Routine-biased technical change and job polarization in Europe, Socio-Economic Review, Vol. 15(3), 563-585.

Fiorentino S., Glasmeier A.K., Lobao L., Martin R., Tyler P., 2024, ‘Left behind places’: what are they and why do they matter?, Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 17, 1–16. Florida R. L., 2002, The Rise of the Creative Class. New York: Basic Books.

Goos M., Manning A., 2007, Lousy and lovely jobs: the rising polarization of work in Britain, Review of Economics and Statistics, 89(1), pp. 118–133.

Goos M., Manning A., Salomons A., 2009, Job polarization in Europe, American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings, 99(2), 58-63.

Goos M., Manning A., Salomons A., 2014, Explaining Job Polarization: Routine-Biased Technological Change and Offshoring, The American Economic Review, 104 (8), 2509-2526.

Henderson, J. V., Squires, T., Storeygard, A., Weil, D., 2017. The global distribution of economic activity: Nature, history, and the role of trade. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 133 (1), 357–406.

Herrero D., Pérez-Ortíz L., 2023, Occupational change in Europe after the Great Recession, w.p. 1, Instituto Complutense de Estudios Internacionales, Madrid.

Hoffman E.B., Malacrino D., Pistaferri L., 2022, Earnings dynamics and labor market reforms: The Italian case, Quantitative Economics, 13, 1637–1667.

Hurley J., Fernández-Macías E., Bisello M., Vacas C., Fana M., 2019, European Jobs Monitor 2019: Shifts in the employment structure at regional level, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg.

Intraligi V., Vittori C., Ricci A., 2024, Job polarisation in Italy: routinisation and structural change?, Spatial Economic Analysis, DOI: 10.1080/17421772.2023.2298965.

Kemeny T., Storper M., 2023, The Changing Shape of Spatial Inequality in the United States, Economic Geography, 99, 1–30.

Koster H.R.A., Ozgen C., 2021, Cities and tasks, Journal of Urban Economics, 126.

Krugman, P., 1991. Increasing returns and economic geography. Journal of Political Economy, 99 (3), 483–499.

Lamorgese A., Petrella A., 2016, An anatomy of Italian cities: evidence from firm-level data, QEF 362, Banca d’Italia.

Lamorgese, A., Olivieri E., Paccagnella M., 2019, Spillovers in the Urban Wage Premium, Banca d’Italia, mimeo.

Lin J., 2011, Technological adaptation, cities, and new work, The review of economics and statistics, 93 (2), 554-574.

Mazzolari F., Ragusa G., 2013, Spillovers from High-Skill Consumption to Low-Skill Labor Markets, Review of Economics and Statistics, 95 (1), 74–86.

Michaels G., Ashwini N., Van Reenen J., 2014, Has ICT Polarized Skill Demand? Evidence from Eleven Countries over 25 Years, Review of Economics and Statistics, 96(1), 60-77.

Mitsch F., Lee N., Morrow E.R., 2021, Faith no more? The divergence of political trust between urban and rural Europe, Political geography, 89.

Moretti E., 2012, The new geography of jobs, Mariner Books.

Muzzicato S., Sabbatini R. and Zollino F., (2008). Prices of residential property in Italy: constructing a new indicator, Questioni di Economia e Finanza, 17, Banca d’Italia.

Odendhal C., Springford J., Johnson S., Murray J., 2019, The big European sort? The diverging fortunes of Europe’s regions, Centre for European reform.

OECD, 2020, Regions and cities at a glance 2020, OECD Publishing, Paris.

Olivieri E., 2012, Il cambiamento delle opportunità lavorative, Quaderni di Economia e Finanza, Questioni di Economia e Finanza 117, Banca d’Italia.

Olney W., Thompson O., 2024, The Determinants Of Declining Internal Migration, NBER wp 32123, February.

Petrella A., Torrini R. (eds.), 2019, Turismo in Italia: numeri e potenziali di sviluppo, Questioni di economia e finanza, Questioni di Economia e Finanza 505, Banca d’Italia.

Rhodes M., 1996, Southern European Welfare States: Identity, Problems and Prospects for Reform, South European Society and Politics, 1(3), 1-22.

Rodriguez-Pose A., 2018; The revenge of the places that don’t matter (and what to do about it), Cambridge Journal of regions, economy and society, 11(1), 189-209.

Rosés J.R., Wolf N., 2021, Regional Growth and Inequality in the Long-run: Europe, 1900–2015, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 37, 17–48.

Torrejòn Pérez S., Hurley J., Fernández-Macías E., Staffa E., 2023, Employment shifts in Europe from 1997 to 2021: from job upgrading to polarisation, JRC w.p. on Labour, Education and Technology, 5, European Commission, Seville.